[Attachment to GEC’s Demonstration/Feasibility Study Report JFY2012]
I-7
MRV Methodology Title: “Replacement of boiler by heat pump in country Mongolia” (Draft Ver. 3.0)
1. Title of the Methodology
“Replacement of boiler by heat pump in country Mongolia”
2. Summary of the Methodology
This methodology can be applied to projects that intend to reduce GHG emission from
reference scenario by replacing existing heating boilers with heat pump system in Mongolia.
3. Eligibility Criteria
This methodology is applicable to projects that fully satisfy the following cases.
Check
Case 1 The existing heating boilers that supply hot water for heating shall be
replaced by heat pumps that supply hot water for heating.
Case 2 All the fuel of the existing boiler(s) before the project is fossil fuel.
Case 3 The existing secondary heating system shall continue to be used after the
project without any modification.
Case 4 The project shall pass the below “check list”.
Case 5 The project shall satisfy the following formula.
Average annual COP of heat pump > efficiency of boiler / emission factor of
fuel of boiler / 3.6 * emission factor of grid
In order to satisfy the above formula, efficiency of boiler, emission factor of
fuel of boiler, and emission factor of grid shall be known.
Case 6 Rooms are heated.
Case 7 In case that the project applies geothermal heat pumps, a know-how support
on designing and construction shall be provided by developed countries.
Note: This methodology is drafted as the result of the GEC’s JCM Demonstration/Feasibility Study in JFY2012. Therefore, this draft methodology is not officially approved by any governments involved in JCM, and is subject to change in the future.
[Attachment to GEC’s Demonstration/Feasibility Study Report JFY2012]
I-8
Check list for determining the reference scenario
No. Check list Conclusion that can be made from checking
1
Is it possible to improve the efficiency of the existing boilers?(1) Yes. (2) No, because there is no regulation that forces to improve the
efficiency of the existing boilers and its project IRR for 15years will be lower than loan interest.
(3) Others.
If (2) is satisfied, improving the efficiency of the existing boilers is not the reference scenario. Go to check No.2.
2
Is it possible to switch from the existing boilers to other heating service?(1) Yes. (2) No, because there is no regulation that forces to switch from the
existing boilers to other heating service and there is no heating service available.
(3) No, because there is no regulation that forces switch from the existing boilers to other heating service and its project IRR for 15years will be lower than loan interest.
(4) Others.
If (2) or (3) are satisfied, switching from the existing boilers to other heating service is not the reference scenario. Go to check No.3.
3
Is it possible to replace the existing boilers with electric heaters?(1) Yes. (2) No, because there is no regulation that forces to replace the existing
boilers with electric heaters and replacing will result in increase of energy cost.
(3) No, because there is no regulation that forces replace the existing boilers with electric heaters and its project IRR for 15years will be lower than loan interest.
(4) No, because power source for the electric heater can’t be secured. (5) Others.
If (2) or (3) or (4) are satisfied, replacing the existing boilers with electric heaters is not the reference scenario. Go to check No.4.
4
Is it possible to switch from the existing boilers to other boilers which fuel has lower emission factor? (1) Yes. (2) No, because there is no regulation that forces to switch from the
existing boilers to other boilers which fuel has lower emission factor and switching will result in increase of energy cost.
(3) No, because there is no regulation that forces to switch from the existing boilers to other boilers which fuel has lower emission factor and its project IRR for 15years will be lower than loan interest.
(4) No, because there is no regulation that forces to switch from the existing boilers to other boilers which fuel has lower emission factor and there is no other fuel available.
(5) Others.
If (2) or (3) or (4) are satisfied, switching from the existing boilers to other boilers which fuel has lower emission factor is not the reference scenario. Go to check No.5.
5
Is it possible to replace the existing boilers with biomass boilers or solar powered heaters? (1) Yes. (2) No, because there is no regulation that forces to replace the existing
boilers with biomass boilers or solar powered heaters and replacing will result in increase of energy cost.
(3) No, because there is no regulation that forces to replace the existing boilers with biomass boilers or solar powered heaters and its project IRR for 15years will be lower than loan interest.
(4) No, because there is no regulation that forces to replace the existing boilers with biomass boilers or solar powered heaters and there is no biomass available.
(5) No, because there is not enough solar energy. (6) Others.
If (2) or (3) or (4) or (5) are satisfied, replacing the existing boilers with biomass boilers or solar powered heaters is not the reference scenario. Go to check No.6.
[Attachment to GEC’s Demonstration/Feasibility Study Report JFY2012]
I-9
No. Check list Conclusion that can be made from checking
6
Is it possible to replace the existing boilers with heat pumps?(1) Yes. (2) No, because there is no regulation that forces to replace the existing
boilers with heat pumps and replacing will result in increase of energy cost.
(3) No, because there is no regulation that forces to replace the existing boilers with heat pumps and its project IRR for 15years will be lower than loan interest.
(4) Others.
If (2) or (3) are satisfied, replacing the existing boilers with heat pumps is not the reference scenario, this methodology is applicable, and it is specified that the reference scenario is continuation of the existing boilers.
Remark: If existing regulation does not work and/or is not conformed to at all, and if project participants can
demonstrate such situation, project participants can construe that there is no such regulation.
4. Selection of Calculation Method
To calculate the reference emission, the project developer must refer to the calculation method
best-suited for his/her project using the flow chart below.
Does the project has at least one of the below characteristics?
It includes installation of air source heat pumps.
It includes installation of water source heat pumps.
Heat pump system includes electric heaters.
Heat pump system includes solar powered heaters.
Yes
No
Yes
No
Calculation
method 2
(simple method)
Calculation
method 1
(precise method)
Are there any “reference projects”
that belong to the same climate zone
as the project?
[Attachment to GEC’s Demonstration/Feasibility Study Report JFY2012]
I-10
5. Necessary Data for Calculation
The data that requires presetting in the planning stage of the project or monitoring after the
start of the project is determined below based on the calculation method selected in section 4.
If the data shown below is imported, a calculation tool is provided in this methodology that
will allow you to measure emission reductions.
5.1 Calculation method 1: …
Data necessary at ex-ante calculation at the stage of registration Item Description of data Symbol Value Unit
Data indispensable to this project
Efficiency of boilers in the reference scenario EF - Emission factor of fuel for boilers in the reference scenario
FEF tCO2/GJ
Data necessary when this project becomes a reference project to other projects
Standard climate data (outdoor temperature) SOTi degree C Heating load of the building under the standard climate data
SQ GJ
Average COP of heat pumps under the standard climate data
SCOP -
Data necessary to be monitored after implementation of the project Item Description of data Symbol Value Unit
Data indispensable to this project
Calorie of hot water supplied by heat pumps Q GJ Watt hour consumed by heat pumps (including watt hour consumed by pump for anti-freezing liquid)
W MWh
Emission factor of grid GEF tCO2/MWhData necessary when this project becomes a reference project to other projects
Climate data (outdoor temperature) OTi degree C Conservativeness factor C -
5.2 Calculation method 2:…
Data necessary at ex-ante calculation at the stage of registration Item Description of data Symbol Value Unit
Data that should be received from this project
Efficiency of boilers in the reference scenario
EF -
Emission factor of fuel for boilers in the reference scenario
FEF tCO2/GJ
Standard climate data (outdoor temperature) SOTi degree C Heating load of the building under the standard climate data
SQ GJ
Average COP of heat pump under the standard climate data
SCOP -
Data necessary to be monitored after implementation of the project Item Description of data Symbol Value Unit
Data that should be received from this project
Emission factor of grid GEF tCO2/MWhClimate data (outdoor temperature) OTi ℃
Data that should be received from the reference project
Conservativeness factor C -
[Attachment to GEC’s Demonstration/Feasibility Study Report JFY2012]
I-11
5.3 Common to both calculation method 1 and 2
Data necessary at ex-ante calculation at the stage of registration Item Description of data Symbol Value Unit
Data that should be received from this project
Lower heating value of fuel of the existing boilers
HV GJ/ton or
GJ/Nm3
Data necessary to be monitored after implementation of the project (In case of coal) Item Description of data Symbol Value Unit
Data that should be received from this project
Fuel consumption of the existing boilers FQ ton or
Nm3
Data necessary to be monitored after implementation of the project (In case of all types of fuel) Item Description of data Symbol Value Unit
Data that should be received from this project
Calorie of hot water supplied by the existing boilers
BQ GJ
6. Terms and Definitions Term Definition
Climate data (outdoor temperature)
Outdoor temperature that is monitored every hour on the hour or at fixed time every day by meteorological agency or its alternative public organization.
Standard climate data (outdoor temperature)
Outdoor temperature that is averaged every hour on the hour or at fixed time every day among certain years by meteorological agency or its alternative public organization.
Heating load of a building Characteristics of heating load of a building that are calculated for certain period based on the building’s insulation characteristics, indoor preset temperature, and operating hour of heating. The unit should be GJ.
Conservativeness factor The value equals to emission reduction applying calculation method 1 (based on calorie meter and watt hour meter) divided by emission reduction applying calculation method 2 (based on degree day) in the reference project. If this value is calculated as more than 1, then this value should be 1.
Degree day Annually integrated product of time and difference between indoor temperature and outdoor temperature.
Standard degree day Degree day calculated using standard climate data. COP Efficiency of heat pump. Energy output divided by energy input. For more
specific, calorie of supplied hot water divided by watt hour consumed. Climate zone Zone in which climate is generally regarded as same in the host country. Reference project A project that can provide conservativeness factors to other projects located in
the same climate zone. In accordance with the calculation method 1, it should have a calorie meter and a watt hour meter.
Pump for anti-freezing liquid A circulation pump for anti-freezing liquid located at the heat source side of a heat pump.
secondary heating system Facilities such as hot water circulation pump, hot water piping, and radiators located at the heat dissipation side of a heat pump.
Positive list A list that includes projects eligible for BOCM. Calorie meter Monitoring equipment that consists of a flow meter, a pair of thermo meters, a
computing unit, and connecting wires, which can calculate integrated calorie of supplied heating medium and can show the calculation result. All the equipment has to show is integrated calorie. It doesn’t need to show instantaneous calorie.
Watt hour meter Equipment that can monitor watt hour consumed both by heat pumps that replaces boilers and by pumps for anti-freezing liquid. All the equipment has to show is integrated watt hour. It doesn’t need to show instantaneous watt hour.
[Attachment to GEC’s Demonstration/Feasibility Study Report JFY2012]
I-12
7. Project Boundaries
The project boundary shall include the following GHG emission sources and GHG emissions.
CO2 emitted when fuel is combusted at the boilers in the reference scenario.
CO2 emitted at the time of generating power to the heat pump in the project scenario.
8. Reference Scenario
In the reference scenario, boilers that consume fossil fuel only continue to be used, and heat
pumps are not used during the project period envisaged. This shall be demonstrated by using
“Check list for determining the reference scenario”.
9. Reference Emissions and Calculation
9.1 Calculation method 1:
REy=Q/EF*FEF (1-1)
Where,
REy Reference CO2 emission (tCO2)
Q Calorie of hot water supplied by heat pumps (GJ)
EF Efficiency of boilers in the reference scenario (-)
FEF Emission factor of fuel for boilers in the reference scenario (tCO2/GJ)
9.2 Calculation method 2:
REy=DD*SRE/SDD (2-1)
Where,
REy Reference CO2 emission (tCO2)
DD Degree day (degree Cday)
SRE Standard reference CO2 emission (tCO2)
SDD Standard degree day (degree Cday)
DD=Σ(RT-OTi) (2-2)
Where,
DD Degree day (degree Cday)
RT Indoor temperature (degree C)
OTi Outdoor temperature (degree C)
[Attachment to GEC’s Demonstration/Feasibility Study Report JFY2012]
I-13
SRE=SQ/EF*FEF (2-3)
Where,
SRE Standard reference CO2 emission (tCO2)
SQ Heating load of the building under the standard climate data (GJ)
EF Efficiency of boilers in the reference scenario (-)
FEF Emission factor of fuel for boilers in the reference scenario (tCO2/GJ)
SDD=Σ(RT-SOTi) (2-4)
Where,
SDD Standard degree day (degree Cday)
RT Indoor temperature (degree C)
SOTi Standard outdoor temperature (degree C)
10. Project Emissions and Calculation
10.1 Calculation method 1:
PEy=W*GEF+PEB (1-2)
Where,
PEy Project CO2 emission (tCO2)
W Watt hour consumed by heat pumps (MWh)
GEF Emission factor of grid (tCO2/MWh)
PEB Emission from the existing boilers (tCO2)
10.2 Calculation method 2:
PEy=DD*SPE/SDD+PEB (2-5)
Where,
PEy Project CO2 emission (tCO2)
DD Degree day (degree Cday)
SPE Standard project CO2 emission (tCO2)
SDD Standard degree day (degree Cday)
PEB Emission from the existing boilers (tCO2)
SPE=SQ/3.6/SCOP*GEF (2-6)
[Attachment to GEC’s Demonstration/Feasibility Study Report JFY2012]
I-14
Where,
SPE Standard project CO2 emission (tCO2)
SQ Heating load of the building under the standard climate data (GJ)
3.6 Unit conversion factor (GJ/MWh)
SCOP Average COP of heat pump under the standard climate data (-)
GEF Emission factor of grid (tCO2/MWh)
10.3 Calculation of PEB (Common to both calculation method 1 and 2):
PEB=FQ*HV*FEF (2-7-1)
or
PEB=BQ/EF*FEF (2-7-2)
Where,
PEB Emission from the existing boilers (tCO2)
FQ Fuel consumption of the existing boilers (ton or Nm3)
HV Lower heating value of fuel of the existing boiler (GJ/ton or GJ/Nm3)
FEF Emission factor of fuel for the existing boilers (tCO2/GJ)
BQ Calorie of hot water supplied by the existing boilers (GJ)
EF Efficiency of the existing boilers (-)
11. Leakage emissions and Calculation
Leakage is not envisaged.
12. Calculation of Emission Reduction
Emission reduction can be calculated from reference CO2 emission and project CO2 emission.
12.1 Calculation method 1:
ERy=REy-PEy (1-3)
Where,
ERy Emission reduction (tCO2)
REy Reference CO2 emission (tCO2)
PEy Project CO2 emission (tCO2)
[Attachment to GEC’s Demonstration/Feasibility Study Report JFY2012]
I-15
12.2 Calculation method 2:
ERy=C*(REy - PEy) (2-8)
Where,
ERy Emission reduction (tCO2)
C Conservativeness factor (-)
REy Reference CO2 emission (tCO2)
PEy Project CO2 emission (tCO2)
C=ER1/ER2 (2-9)
Where,
ER1 Emission reduction of the reference project calculated in accordance with calculation
method 1 (tCO2)
ER2 Emission reduction of the reference project calculated in accordance with calculation
method 2 (tCO2)
(When calculating ER2 by using formula (2-7), C=1 shall be applied.)
13. Monitoring
The project developers must monitor the parameters described in the table below based on the
calculation method of the selected GHG emission reductions.
13.1 Calculation method 1:
Data necessary at ex-ante calculation at the stage of registration Item Description of data Symbol Source Frequency
Data indispensable to this project
Efficiency of boilers in the reference scenario
EF Specialist in this field such as boiler man
When registration
Emission factor of fuel for boilers in the reference scenario
FEF Host government (Ministry of
Environment and Green Development)
When registration
Data necessary when this project becomes a reference project to other projects
Standard climate data (outdoor temperature)
SOTi Host government (meteorological
observatory)
When registration, data for every hour
on the hour or at fixed time every
day (*1) Heating load of the building under the standard climate data
SQ Utilization of simulation (*2)
When registration
Average COP of heat pumps under the standard climate data
SCOP Utilization of simulation (*3)
When registration
[Attachment to GEC’s Demonstration/Feasibility Study Report JFY2012]
I-16
Data necessary to be monitored after implementation of the project Item Description of data Symbol Source Frequency
Data indispensable to this project
Calorie of hot water supplied by heat pumps
Q Calorie meter At the start and the end of each
monitoring periodWatt hour consumed by heat pumps (including watt hour consumed by pump for anti-freezing liquid)
W Watt hour meter At the start and the end of each
monitoring period
Emission factor of grid GEF Host government (Ministry of
Environment and Green Development)
After monitoring period ends
Data necessary when this project becomes a reference project to other projects
Climate data (outdoor temperature) OTi Host government (meteorological
observatory)
At the end of each monitoring period, data for every hour
on the hour or at fixed time every
day (*1) Conservativeness factor C Calculation After monitoring
period ends
13.2 Calculation method 2:
Data necessary at ex-ante calculation at the stage of registration Item Description of data Symbol Source Frequency
Data that should be received from this project
Efficiency of boilers in the reference scenario
EF Specialist in this field such as boiler man
When registration
Emission factor of fuel for boilers in the reference scenario
FEF Host government (Ministry of
Environment and Green Development)
When registration
Standard climate data (outdoor temperature)
SOTi Host government (meteorological
observatory)
When registration, data for every hour
on the hour or at fixed time every
day (*1) Heating load of the building under the standard climate data
SQ Utilization of simulation (*2)
When registration
Average COP of heat pump under the standard climate data
SCOP Utilization of simulation (*3)
When registration
[Attachment to GEC’s Demonstration/Feasibility Study Report JFY2012]
I-17
Data necessary to be monitored after implementation of the project Item Description of data Symbol Source Frequency
Data that should be received from this project
Emission factor of grid GEF Host government (Ministry of
Environment and Green Development)
After monitoring period ends
Climate data (outdoor temperature) OTi Host government (meteorological
observatory)
At the end of each monitoring period, data for every hour
on the hour or at fixed time every
day (*1) Data that should be received from the reference project
Conservativeness factor C Reference project After monitoring period ends
Remarks (13.1 and 13.2) *1: It is preferable to collect hourly data, but if it is impossible, data at fixed time is acceptable. *2: Hand calculation is possible, but an example of the simulation software is “LOAD2000”. *3: An example of the simulation software available is “Ground Club”. Hand calculation is not feasible.
13.3 Common to both calculation method 1 and 2
Data necessary at ex-ante calculation at the stage of registration Item Description of data Symbol Source Frequency
Data that should be received from this project
Lower heating value of fuel of the existing boilers
HV Host government (Ministry of
Environment and Green Development)
When registration
Data necessary to be monitored after implementation of the project (In case of coal) Item Description of data Symbol Source Frequency
Data that should be received from this project
Emission factor of grid FQ Fuel transaction document
At the start and the end of each
monitoring period
Data necessary to be monitored after implementation of the project (In case of all types of fuel) Item Description of data Symbol Source Frequency
Data that should be received from this project
Emission factor of grid BQ Calorie meter At the start and the end of each
monitoring period
[Attachment to GEC’s Demonstration/Feasibility Study Report JFY2012]
I-18
Annex: Information on the calculation tool
The calculation tools consist of the following 3 tools. (1) Calculation tool 1
This provides emission reduction calculation tool for calculation method 1.
Name of worksheet
Function How to use
1 Plan Calculating emission reduction at the stage of project registration
Input necessary data into the yellow cells.
2 Ex-ante cal Calculating emission reduction at the stage of project registration
Input necessary data into the yellow cells.
3 Climate data Calculating degree day Input necessary data into the yellow cells. If necessary, sum degree day during monitoring period.
4 Report Calculating real emission reduction after each monitoring period
Input necessary data into the yellow cells.
5 Ex-post cal Calculating real emission reduction after each monitoring period
Input necessary data into the yellow cells.
(2) Calculation tool 2
This provides annual heating load calculation tool for calculation method 1 and 2.
Name of worksheet
Function How to use
condition 1 Calculating overall heat transfer coefficient of outer wall, roof, foundation, and window
Input necessary data into the yellow cells. If necessary, add rows.
condition 2 Setting area, volume, indoor temperature, and ventilation frequency for draft calculation
Input necessary data into the yellow cells.
condition 3 Setting standard outdoor temperature Input necessary data into the yellow cells. condition 4 Setting underground temperature Input necessary data into the yellow cells. calculation Showing calculation result If necessary, sum heating load during
monitoring period. (3) Calculation tool 3
This provides emission reduction calculation tool for calculation method 2.
Name of worksheet
Function How to use
1 Plan Calculating emission reduction at the stage of project registration
Input necessary data into the yellow cells.
2 Ex-ante cal Calculating emission reduction at the stage of project registration
Input necessary data into the yellow cells.
3 Climate data Calculating degree day Input necessary data into the yellow cells. If necessary, sum degree day during monitoring period.
4 Report Calculating real emission reduction after each monitoring period
Input necessary data into the yellow cells.
5 Ex-post cal Calculating real emission reduction after each monitoring period
Input necessary data into the yellow cells.
I-19
[Attachment to G
EC’s D
emonstration/Feasibility Study R
eport JFY2012]
Calculation method 1, Plan
Name of the project: Geothermal Heat Pump Project at a Kindergarten in Zuunmod Aimag
1. Monitoring plan and input values for ex-ante estimation
Parameters Description of dataEstimated
valuesUnits
Monitoringpattern
Source ofdata
Measurement methods andprocedures
Monitoringfrequency
QA/QC procedures Other comments
QCalorie of hot water supplied by heatpumps
1,382.5 GJ pattern Cmonitored
data
Collecting calorie data from acontroled calorie meter and inputingto an spread sheet electrically.
At the start andthe end of eachmonitoring period
A controled monitoring device is installed. Personresponsible for monitoring double check the inputdata.
N/A
WWatt hour consumed by heat pumps(including watt hour consumed bypump for anti-freezing liquid)
169.9 MWh pattern Cmonitored
data
Collecting electricity consumptiondata from a controled watt hourmeter and inputing to an spreadsheet electrically.
At the start andthe end of eachmonitoring period
A controled monitoring device is installed. Personresponsible for monitoring double check the inputdata.
N/A
GEF Emission factor of grid 1.1501 tCO2/MWh pattern ADNA's web
siteCollecting emission factor at DNA'sweb site.
At the time beforedrawing upmonitoring report
QA/QC is conducted by DNA. N/A
Oti Climate data (outdoor temperature)
(fill in the tablein the
worksheet "3Climate data")
degree C pattern A
NationalAgency for
Meteorologyand
EnvironmentMonitoring
Collecting climate data from NationalAgency for Meteorology andEnvironment Monitoring.
At the time beforedrawing upmonitoring report
QA/QC is conducted by National Agency forMeteorology and Environment Monitoring.
N/A
FQFuel consumption of the existingboilers
0.0 ton or Nm3 pattern Cmonitored
data
Collecting fuel consumption datafrom a controled meter (weight scaleor flow meter) and inputing to anspread sheet electrically.
In case of weightscale: everytimefuel is carried inand accumulatethe dataIn case of flowmeter: at the startand the end ofeach monitoringperiod
A controled monitoring device is installed. Personresponsible for monitoring double check the inputdata.
If BQ ismonitored, FQneeds not to bemonitored.
BQCalorie of hot water supplied by theexisting boilers
0.0 GJ pattern Cmonitored
data
Collecting calorie data from acontroled calorie meter and inputingto an spread sheet electrically.
At the start andthe end of eachmonitoring period
A controled monitoring device is installed. Personresponsible for monitoring double check the inputdata.
If FQ is monitored,BQ needs not tobe monitored.
2. Ex-ante estimation of CO2 emission reductions
Units
tCO2
[Attachment to Project Designe Document] Monitoring Plan and Ex-ante Estimation of Emission Reductions -input sheet-
CO2 emission reductions
131
2012/09/6Ver1.0
[Attachment to GEC’s Demonstration/Feasibility Study Report JFY2012]
I-20
Calculation method 1, Ex-ante calculation
Name of the project: Geothermal Heat Pump Project at a Kindergarten in Zuunmod Aimag
1. Calculations for emission reductions Cell type Value Units Parameter
Emission reductionAutomaticcalculation
131.5 tCO2 ERy
2. Selected default values, etc. Cell type Value Units Parameter
Efficiency of boilers in the reference scenarioInput
manually0.40 - EF
Emission factor of fuel for boilers in the reference scenarioInput
manually0.0946 tCO2/GJ FEF
Standard climate data (outdoor temperature)Input
manually
(fill in the tablein the
worksheet "3Climate data")
degree C SOTi
Heating load of the building under the standard climate dataInput
manually1,382.5 GJ SQ
Average COP of heat pump under the standard climate dataInput
manually2.26 - SCOP
Lower heating value of fuel of the existing boilerInput
manually14.24
GJ/ton orGJ/Nm3
HV
3. Calculations for reference emissions Cell type Value Units Parameter
Reference CO2 emissionAutomaticcalculation
327.0 tCO2 REy
4. Calculations of the project emissions Cell type Value Units Parameter
Project CO2 emissionAutomaticcalculation
195.4 tCO2 PEy
5. Calculations of the conservativeness factor Cell type Value Units Parameter
Standard reference CO2 emissionAutomaticcalculation
327.0 tCO2 SRE
Standard degree dayAutomaticcalculation
6,588 degree Cday SDD
Degree dayAutomaticcalculation
6,588 degree Cday DD
Reference CO2 emission REy2Automaticcalculation
327.0 tCO2 REy2
Standard project CO2 emissionAutomaticcalculation
195.4 tCO2 SPE
Project CO2 emission REy2Automaticcalculation
195.4 tCO2 PEy2
Emission reduction in accordance with calculation method 1Automaticcalculation
131.5 tCO2 ER1
Emission reduction in accordance with calculation method 2Automaticcalculation
131.5 tCO2 ER2
Conservativeness factorAutomaticcalculation
1.00 - C
[Attachment to Project Designe Document] Ex-ante Estimation of Emission Reductions -automated calculation sheet-
I-21
[Attachment to G
EC’s D
emonstration/Feasibility Study R
eport JFY2012]
Calculation method 1, Report
Name of the project: Geothermal Heat Pump Project at a Kindergarten in Zuunmod Aimag
1. Monitoring records
Monitoringperiod
Parameters Description of dataMonitored
valuesUnits
Monitoringpattern
Source ofdata
Measurement methods andprocedures
Monitoringfrequency
QA/QC procedures takenOther
comments
2012/09/15-2012/10/31
QCalorie of hot water supplied by heatpumps
73.589 GJ pattern Cmonitored
data
Collecting calorie data from acontroled calorie meter and inputingto an spread sheet electrically.
At the start andthe end of eachmonitoring period
A controled monitoring device isinstalled. Person responsible formonitoring double check the inputdata.
N/A
2012/09/15-2012/10/31
WWatt hour consumed by heat pumps(including watt hour consumed bypump for anti-freezing liquid)
6.685 MWh pattern Cmonitored
data
Collecting electricity consumptiondata from a controled watt hourmeter and inputing to an spreadsheet electrically.
At the start andthe end of eachmonitoring period
A controled monitoring device isinstalled. Person responsible formonitoring double check the inputdata.
N/A
N/A GEF Emission factor of grid 1.1501 tCO2/MWh pattern ADNA's web
siteCollecting emission factor at DNA'sweb site.
At the time beforedrawing upmonitoring report
QA/QC is conducted by DNA. N/A
2012/09/15-2012/10/31
Oti Climate data (outdoor temperature)
(fill in the tablein the
worksheet "3Climate data")
degree C pattern A
NationalAgency for
Meteorologyand
EnvironmentMonitoring
Collecting climate data from NationalAgency for Meteorology andEnvironment Monitoring.
At the time beforedrawing upmonitoring report
QA/QC is conducted by NationalAgency for Meteorology andEnvironment Monitoring.
N/A
2012/09/15-2012/10/31
FQFuel consumption of the existingboilers
0.0 ton or Nm3 pattern Cmonitored
data
Collecting fuel consumption datafrom a controled meter (weight scaleor flow meter) and inputing to anspread sheet electrically.
In case of weightscale: everytimefuel is carried inand accumulatethe dataIn case of flowmeter: at the startand the end of
A controled monitoring device isinstalled. Person responsible formonitoring double check the inputdata.
If BQ ismonitored, FQneeds not tobe monitored.
2012/09/15-2012/10/31
BQCalorie of hot water supplied by theexisting boilers
0.0 GJ pattern Cmonitored
data
Collecting calorie data from acontroled calorie meter and inputingto an spread sheet electrically.
At the start andthe end of eachmonitoring period
A controled monitoring device isinstalled. Person responsible formonitoring double check the inputdata.
If FQ ismonitored, BQneeds not tobe monitored.
2. Ex-post calculation of CO2 emission reductions
CO2 emission reductions Units
9 tCO2
[For Verification] Monitoring Report -input sheet-
Offseting Period
2012/09/15-2012/10/31
[Attachment to GEC’s Demonstration/Feasibility Study Report JFY2012]
I-22
Calculation method 1, Ex-post calculation
Name of the project: Geothermal Heat Pump Project at a Kindergarten in Zuunmod Aimag
1. Calculations for emission reductions Cell type Value Units Parameter
Emission reductionAutomaticcalculation
9.7 tCO2 ERy
2. Selected default values, etc. Cell type Value Units Parameter
Efficiency of boilers in the reference scenarioInput
manually0.40 - EF
Emission factor of fuel for boilers in the reference scenarioInput
manually0.0946 tCO2/GJ FEF
Standard climate data (outdoor temperature)Input
manually
(fill in the tablein the
worksheet "3Climate data")
degree C SOTi
Heating load of the building under the standard climate dataInput
manually153.5 GJ SQ
Average COP of heat pump under the standard climate dataInput
manually2.30 - SCOP
Lower heating value of fuel of the existing boilerInput
manually14.24
GJ/ton orGJ/Nm3
HV
3. Calculations for reference emissions Cell type Value Units Parameter
Reference CO2 emissionAutomaticcalculation
17.4 tCO2 REy
4. Calculations of the project emissions Cell type Value Units Parameter
Project CO2 emissionAutomaticcalculation
7.7 tCO2 PEy
5. Calculations of the conservativeness factor Cell type Value Units Parameter
Standard reference CO2 emissionAutomaticcalculation
36.3 tCO2 SRE
Standard degree dayAutomaticcalculation
743 degree Cday SDD
Degree dayAutomaticcalculation
736 degree Cday DD
Reference CO2 emission REy2Automaticcalculation
36.0 tCO2 REy2
Standard project CO2 emissionAutomaticcalculation
21.3 tCO2 SPE
Project CO2 emission REy2Automaticcalculation
21.1 tCO2 PEy2
Emission reduction in accordance with calculation method 1Automaticcalculation
9.7 tCO2 ER1
Emission reduction in accordance with calculation method 2Automaticcalculation
14.8 tCO2 ER2
Conservativeness factorAutomaticcalculation
0.6543 - C
[For Verification] Monitoring Report -automated calculation sheet-
I-23
[Attachment to G
EC’s D
emonstration/Feasibility Study R
eport JFY2012]
Calculation method 2, Plan
Name of the project: Geothermal Heat Pump Project at a Kindergarten in Zuunmod Aimag
1. Monitoring plan and input values for ex-ante estimation
Parameters Description of dataEstimated
valuesUnits
Monitoringpattern
Source ofdata
Measurement methods andprocedures
Monitoringfrequency
QA/QC procedures Other comments
C Conservativeness factor 1.00 - pattern AReference
projectCollecting conservativeness factorfrom the reference project.
At the time beforedrawing upmonitoring report
QA/QC is conducted by the reference project. N/A
GEF Emission factor of grid 1.1501 tCO2/MWh pattern ADNA's web
siteCollecting emission factor at DNA'sweb site.
At the time beforedrawing upmonitoring report
QA/QC is conducted by DNA. N/A
Oti Climate data (outdoor temperature)
(fill in the tablein the
worksheet "3Climate data")
degree C pattern A
NationalAgency for
Meteorologyand
EnvironmentMonitoring
Collecting climate data from NationalAgency for Meteorology andEnvironment Monitoring.
At the time beforedrawing upmonitoring report
QA/QC is conducted by National Agency forMeteorology and Environment Monitoring.
N/A
FQFuel consumption of the existingboilers
0.0 ton or Nm3 pattern Cmonitored
data
Collecting fuel consumption datafrom a controled meter (weight scaleor flow meter) and inputing to anspread sheet electrically.
In case of weightscale: everytimefuel is carried inand accumulatethe dataIn case of flowmeter: at the startand the end ofeach monitoringperiod
A controled monitoring device is installed. Personresponsible for monitoring double check the inputdata.
If BQ ismonitored, FQneeds not to bemonitored.
BQCalorie of hot water supplied by theexisting boilers
0.0 GJ pattern Cmonitored
data
Collecting calorie data from acontroled calorie meter and inputingto an spread sheet electrically.
At the start andthe end of eachmonitoring period
A controled monitoring device is installed. Personresponsible for monitoring double check the inputdata.
If FQ is monitored,BQ needs not tobe monitored.
2. Ex-ante estimation of CO2 emission reductions
Units
tCO2
[Attachment to Project Designe Document] Monitoring Plan and Ex-ante Estimation of Emission Reductions -input sheet-
CO2 emission reductions
131
2012/09/6Ver1.0
[Attachment to GEC’s Demonstration/Feasibility Study Report JFY2012]
I-24
Calculation method 2, Ex-ante calculation
Name of the project: Geothermal Heat Pump Project at a Kindergarten in Zuunmod Aimag
1. Calculations for emission reductions Cell type Value Units Parameter
Emission reductionAutomaticcalculation
131.5 tCO2 ERy
2. Selected default values, etc. Cell type Value Units Parameter
Efficiency of boilers in the reference scenarioInput
manually0.40 - EF
Emission factor of fuel for boilers in the reference scenarioInput
manually0.0946 tCO2/GJ FEF
Standard climate data (outdoor temperature)Input
manually
(fill in the tablein the
worksheet "3Climate data")
degree C SOTi
Heating load of the building under the standard climate dataInput
manually1,382.5 GJ SQ
Average COP of heat pump under the standard climate dataInput
manually2.26 - SCOP
Lower heating value of fuel of the existing boilerInput
manually14.24
GJ/ton orGJ/Nm3
HV
3. Calculations for reference emissions Cell type Value Units Parameter
Standard degree dayAutomaticcalculation
6,588 degree Cday SDD
Degree dayAutomaticcalculation
6,588 degree Cday DD
Standard reference CO2 emissionAutomaticcalculation
327.0 tCO2 SRE
Reference CO2 emissionAutomaticcalculation
327.0 tCO2 REy
4. Calculations of the project emissions Cell type Value Units Parameter
Standard project CO2 emissionAutomaticcalculation
195.4 tCO2 SPE
Project CO2 emissionAutomaticcalculation
195.4 tCO2 PEy
[Attachment to Project Designe Document] Ex-ante Estimation of Emission Reductions -automated calculation sheet-
I-25
[Attachment to G
EC’s D
emonstration/Feasibility Study R
eport JFY2012]
Calculation method 2, Report
Name of the project: Geothermal Heat Pump Project at a Kindergarten in Zuunmod Aimag
1. Monitoring records
Monitoringperiod
Parameters Description of dataMonitored
valuesUnits
Monitoringpattern
Source ofdata
Measurement methods andprocedures
Monitoringfrequency
QA/QC procedures takenOther
comments
N/A C Conservativeness factor 0.6543 - pattern AReference
projectCollecting conservativeness factorfrom the reference project.
At the time beforedrawing upmonitoring report
QA/QC is conducted by the reference N/A
N/A GEF Emission factor of grid 1.1501 tCO2/MWh pattern ADNA's web
siteCollecting emission factor at DNA'sweb site.
At the time beforedrawing upmonitoring report
QA/QC is conducted by DNA. N/A
2012/09/15-2012/10/31
Oti Climate data (outdoor temperature)
(fill in the tablein the
worksheet "3Climate data")
degree C pattern A
NationalAgency for
Meteorologyand
EnvironmentMonitoring
Collecting climate data from NationalAgency for Meteorology andEnvironment Monitoring.
At the time beforedrawing upmonitoring report
QA/QC is conducted by NationalAgency for Meteorology andEnvironment Monitoring.
N/A
2012/09/15-2012/10/31
FQFuel consumption of the existingboilers
0.0 ton or Nm3 pattern Cmonitored
data
Collecting fuel consumption datafrom a controled meter (weight scaleor flow meter) and inputing to anspread sheet electrically.
In case of weightscale: everytimefuel is carried inand accumulatethe dataIn case of flowmeter: at the startand the end ofeach monitoringperiod
A controled monitoring device isinstalled. Person responsible formonitoring double check the inputdata.
If BQ ismonitored, FQneeds not tobe monitored.
2012/09/15-2012/10/31
BQCalorie of hot water supplied by theexisting boilers
0.0 GJ pattern Cmonitored
data
Collecting calorie data from acontroled calorie meter and inputingto an spread sheet electrically.
At the start andthe end of eachmonitoring period
A controled monitoring device isinstalled. Person responsible formonitoring double check the inputdata.
If FQ ismonitored, BQneeds not tobe monitored.
2. Ex-post calculation of CO2 emission reductions
CO2 emission reductions Units
9 tCO2
[For Verification] Monitoring Report -input sheet-
Offseting Period
2012/09/15-2012/10/31
[Attachment to GEC’s Demonstration/Feasibility Study Report JFY2012]
I-26
Calculation method 2, Ex-post calculation
Name of the project: Geothermal Heat Pump Project at a Kindergarten in Zuunmod Aimag
1. Calculations for emission reductions Cell type Value Units Parameter
Emission reductionAutomaticcalculation
9.7 tCO2 ERy
2. Selected default values, etc. Cell type Value Units Parameter
Efficiency of boilers in the reference scenarioInput
manually0.40 - EF
Emission factor of fuel for boilers in the reference scenarioInput
manually0.0946 tCO2/GJ FEF
Standard climate data (outdoor temperature)Input
manually
(fill in the tablein the
worksheet "3Climate data")
degree C SOTi
Heating load of the building under the standard climate dataInput
manually153.5 GJ SQ
Average COP of heat pump under the standard climate dataInput
manually2.30 - SCOP
Lower heating value of fuel of the existing boilerInput
manually14.24
GJ/ton orGJ/Nm3
HV
3. Calculations for reference emissions Cell type Value Units Parameter
Standard degree dayAutomaticcalculation
743 degree Cday SDD
Degree dayAutomaticcalculation
736 degree Cday DD
Standard reference CO2 emissionAutomaticcalculation
36.3 tCO2 SRE
Reference CO2 emissionAutomaticcalculation
36.0 tCO2 REy
4. Calculations of the project emissions Cell type Value Units Parameter
Standard project CO2 emissionAutomaticcalculation
21.3 tCO2 SPE
Project CO2 emissionAutomaticcalculation
21.1 tCO2 PEy
[For Verification] Monitoring Report -automated calculation sheet-