10

Click here to load reader

A New Arrow for The Pension Practitioners Quiver: Pension Risk Transfer

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Webinar Presentation Slides Gone are the days of group annuity contracts only being able to satisfy the plan termination objectives of a pension plan sponsor. Today, there are a wide variety of useful applications for guaranteed institutional annuity contract structures to provide an alternative to traditional fixed income investments. Are you or your pension clients: •Struggling with cost and volatility issues surrounding a defined benefit pension plan? •Considering a liability driven investment strategy that will de-risk the plan investment and allow for stable, predictable funding? •Limited by fixed income funds that only allow for simple duration matching, and expose the plan to cash flow mismatch risks? •Unaware of the variety of customized institutional insurance contract structures available? •Lacking a fiduciary process for evaluating and monitoring the attractiveness of insured pension solutions?

Citation preview

Page 1: A New Arrow for The Pension Practitioners Quiver: Pension Risk Transfer

A New Arrow For The Pension Practitioners Quiver Pension Risk Transfer

Jay Dinunzio Senior 

Consultant

©2012 Dietrich & Associates, Inc.. All Rights Reserved. 

Page 2: A New Arrow for The Pension Practitioners Quiver: Pension Risk Transfer

The Typical Pension Plan

50%private sector DB plans frozen

78% funded Asset Liability Mismatch

50%private sector DB plans frozen

17Employer Contributions

17 years liability duration60/40 equity/debt

30% retiree obligations

©2012 Dietrich & Associates, Inc.. All Rights Reserved. 

Funded Status Volatility2

Page 3: A New Arrow for The Pension Practitioners Quiver: Pension Risk Transfer

Insured Pension Risk Transfer Solutions are an Attractive Fixed Income Alternative

Guaranteed insurance contracts

Customizable to sponsor objectives Reduce plan sizeImmunize plan liabilitiesPlan terminations

V i t f diff t t tVariety of different structures

Provide certainty to risk focused pension sponsors

Backed by the largest and most well capitalized US life insurance carriers who meet Department of Labor I.B. 95‐1 criteria

©2012 Dietrich & Associates, Inc.. All Rights Reserved.  3

Page 4: A New Arrow for The Pension Practitioners Quiver: Pension Risk Transfer

Pension Risk Transfer Solution Spectrum

Higher Cost

Buy‐out Annuity

Buy‐in Annuity

More Risks Transferred

Less  Risks Transferred

Fixed Crediting Rate

Lower Cost

Insured Guaranteed LDI

©2012 Dietrich & Associates, Inc.. All Rights Reserved.  4

Page 5: A New Arrow for The Pension Practitioners Quiver: Pension Risk Transfer

Retiree Benefit Payments Create Significant Challenges for Pension Plans

Largest plan  Negative cash  Near zero cash g pexpense

gflow returns

ConsistentMortality improvements

Consistent investment income

What approaches can be used to insure against these risks?

The typical pension plan has  20‐50% of its pension obligations owed to currently retired participants

Annual benefit payments can total 5‐10% of  plan assets

©2012 Dietrich & Associates, Inc.. All Rights Reserved.  5

Page 6: A New Arrow for The Pension Practitioners Quiver: Pension Risk Transfer

Pension Risk Transfer ‐ Retiree AnnuitizationDifferent Structures for Different Client Circumstances

Buy‐out vs. Buy‐in Group Annuities

Sponsor Circumstances•Well funded plan•Shorter termination horizon

Sponsor Circumstances•Plan is less well funded•Longer termination horizonShorter termination horizon

•Access to cash for full funding•Pension plan small part of P&L•Exit strategy is objective

Longer termination horizon•Company  cash not available to fund•Pension plan large part of P&L•Immunization strategy is objective

Retiree Buy‐in AnnuityRetiree Buy‐out Annuity

• Plan Size Permanently Reduced• P&L Impact• Participants Paid Directly By Insurer

• Liabilities hedged with guaranteed annuity contract

• No P&L impact• Participants paid by Plan TrustParticipants paid by Plan Trust

Removes Plan’s largest ongoing expenseReduces plan’s negative cash flow One time payment includes embedded costs

©2012 Dietrich & Associates, Inc.. All Rights Reserved. 

costs5‐10% premium over GAAP Liability ValueMortality guarantee

6

Page 7: A New Arrow for The Pension Practitioners Quiver: Pension Risk Transfer

Pension Risk Transfer ‐ Indexed Guaranteed Investment ContractUnable or Unwilling to Lock‐in Annuity Costs ‐ Insured LDI

Insured LDI• Insurance contract guarantees 

same pension discount curve used to value liability

• No financial penalties to exit

• Fee Based (pay as you go)• Plan retains risks of actual flows 

vs. expected cash flowsNo financial penalties to exit 

Tailored specifically to plan liability cash flowsTailored specifically to plan liability cash flowsInsurance contract alternative to market valued bond fundsPrecise hedge against asset/liability movementsFully transparent with no embedded costs

Guarantee Solves Key Challenges Associates With Investing to 

©2012 Dietrich & Associates, Inc.. All Rights Reserved. 

Match Pension Liability Indexes

7

Page 8: A New Arrow for The Pension Practitioners Quiver: Pension Risk Transfer

5 Important Questions To Consider

1.  1.  Is your pension program  frozen?

22. . Is plan termination the ultimate pension objective?

3. 3. Are you concerned with pension funding volatility?

44. . Are you looking to de‐risk the plan investments via liability driven investing?

55. . Are you unfamiliar with insured pension risk transfer solutions?

If the answer to one or more of the questions above is “YES” then a Pension Risk Transfer specialist

©2012 Dietrich & Associates, Inc.. All Rights Reserved. 

Pension Risk Transfer specialist     may be able to help you 

8

Page 9: A New Arrow for The Pension Practitioners Quiver: Pension Risk Transfer

Question and Answer Session

*Any questions not answered during the Q & A session will be answered individually after the webinar concludes.

©2012 Dietrich & Associates, Inc.. All Rights Reserved.  9

Page 10: A New Arrow for The Pension Practitioners Quiver: Pension Risk Transfer

Thank you for attending

Visit www.dietrichassociates.com for more information.

Connect with Mr. Annuity and Connect with Jay

Follow Mr Annuity's Tweets

©2012 Dietrich & Associates, Inc.. All Rights Reserved. 

Stay tuned for our upcoming webinar on The Dietrich (k) Annuity™. 

10