Upload
iiserpune
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Project ReportOn
EMERGING HR TRENDS IN INDIAN IT SECTOR
Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirement
for the award of the Degree of
Master of Business Administration
To
Maharishi Dayanand University, Rohtak
University Institute of Technology
and Management
Sec 40, Gurgaon
(2012-14)
DECLARATION
I Rashmi hereby declares that the project work entitled
“EMERGING HR TRENDS IN INDIAN IT INDUSTRY ” done under the
guidance of Dr.Vijay Rathi faculty of GITM for the award of
the degree of Master of Business Administration & and is
submitted to MAHARISHI DAYANAND UNIVERSITY, Rohtak and this
work has not been submitted elsewhere.
Submitted by
Rashmi
n
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This project is outcome of an effort, time and skills. I would
like to take this opportunity to thank all those who have
helped me towards completion of this project formulation.
I am grateful to the God Almighty to provide me strength and
health to complete this project work. I am also thankful for
the inspiration and unconditional support of my parents. Along
with above all, I would like to express my sincere gratitude
to Prof. (Dr.) R.K. Yadav, Director GITM, Prof. Sujata
Chaturvedi, HOD- Management, my project mentor Ms. Shweta
Sharma faculty of GITM. Without their valuable advices &
Supervision this project would not has been completed so
successfully. I would also like to thank my seniors who were
ready with a positive comment all the time, whether it was an
off-hand comment to encourage us or a constructive piece of
criticism. Last but not the least; I would like to thanks
other faculty members of GITM for extending a helping hand at
every juncture of need.
PREFACE
In order to correlate theoretical aspect of management studies
with practical aspect of real business world, the students of
management are required to do project work on a particular
sector and to study the various players.
Infect the project can be treated as telescope through which
we, tomorrow’s manager ‘s can peep into the world and can
observe the activities of Real business world before crossing
the “Door” that leads us the wonder world of real business
management.
Understanding and managing people in the organisation is quite
challenging job for managers in the present context because
complexities involved in every sector, so my efforts in this
project to know about HR trends in Indian IT sector like HR
manager behavior towards its employee ,employee retention in
this sector, employee payable in Indian IT sector etc.
Since my area of interest is Human Resource. This project is
the outcome of detailed study of Emerging HR trends in Indian
IT Industry.
SUMMARY
The era of skill-based workers has arrived but if India wants
to truly move to the global arena, it has to spruce up its
workforce. Small may be beautiful, but not in the IT industry.
In the knowledge era and a skill-based economy, it has become
imperative that human resources become one of the most
essential ingredients of success. The growth of IT companies
worldwide depends on its people and the intellectual capital
it possesses.
‘Knowledge workers’ has become a buzzword in today’s IT
scenario. And if we look at the top software exporters, they
have been growing phenomenally in workforce strength. To make
it big in the global software market, India needs to increase
its mass of knowledge workers. The establishment of Indian
Institutes of Information Technology is definitely a step
ahead in the right direction, but what the industry needs is
experts in niche areas, in other words, persons with domain
expertise. In the era of cutting-edge technologies, it is this
skilled workforce that will make all the difference.
The total human resource strength of the IT industry as a
whole stands at 425,609. A company-wise break-up of this
figure reveals that nearly 525 companies constituting 35% of
the IT industry employ an average of 58 persons each, 750
companies constituting 50% of the industry employ an average
of 275 persons each, and 150 companies constituting 10% of the
industry employ an average of 726 persons each. At least 40
companies have more than 1,000 employees, while some very big
companies like TCS, Wipro, HCL and Infosys have staffs above
5,000 each. Despite having abundant English-speaking skilled
workforce, an acute shortage of skilled workforce will affect
the country’s software exports in the long run, if remedial
actions are not taken immediately.
Geometrical growth of Information Technology in the world as
well as India has created lot of revenues for government and
number of avenues for employees. The introduction of computers
has changed the way of life everywhere, including work places
and our homes.
The life has become quite fast and speed of provisioning of
different services has also increased. But all this activities
are being managed by number of well qualified professionals.
They may be from computer hardware developers, software
engineers or marketing managers. As the things are running
fast, so they have to be managed fast.
This fastness of services and higher level of
education/training standards are not easy to manage by the
organizations concerned. As we already know that Human
Resource Management of the organization deals with the
individuals putting their hard work to meet the organizations
goals. Managing people is the toughest element of any
organization than land, machinery or finances. Every human
being has its own degree of preferences, likings and attitude.
So, an HR manager has to take care of all these things in mind
while dealing with the number of people working in the
organization.
Different type of employees/workers recruited for different
level of working has to be managed in different styles. The
hundreds years of organizational, management experience has
been converted into a standard personnel management and
industry and service organizations are following these HR
techniques for their organizational management.
Due to availability of written down procedures and rules by
the learned managers, it was felt that HR managing was not so
typical. But, emerging HR trends of Information Technology
industry can not be managed properly by the old traditional HR
techniques. As it is commonly known that man learns by
experience. 50 years of introduction of computers has provided
us the areas to be additionally addressed by the HR managers
in IT sector. Indian IT industry is not an exception.
Moreover, due to existence of old conservative .and protective
labour laws it is not possible to meet the ever-growing
international competition in the IT services.
Hence, the IT industry has been devising newer Personnel
Management/ HR techniques, which specifically meet the needs
of IT industry. The main reason for this is high standards of
education and professional training required for this
industry. Secondly, there is an excessive job demand for
developed countries in this sector and high wage standards.
So, HR managers mainly in developing countries like India find
it very difficult to retain and recruit their manpower. An HR
manager worldwide has devised handsome compensation methods
like Profit Sharing, Employee Stock Option Schemes ESOP etc.
Though over the period few schemes has flopped like ESOP due
to heavy fall in company share prices.
TABLE OF CONTENT
TOPIC PAGE NO.
DECLARATION
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
PREFACE
SUMMARY
I
II
III
IV-V
Chapter -1 INTRODUCTION 1-30
Chapter -2 REVIEW OF LITERATURE 31-33
Chapter -3 OBJECTIVE,SCOPE,SIGNIFICANCE OF STUDY & RESEARCH PROBLEB STATEMENT
34-37
Chapter -4 RESERCH DESIGN AND METHODOGOLY 38
Chapter -5 DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION 39-51
Chapter - 6 FINDINGS AND CONCLUSION 52-53
Chapter -7 SUGGESTIONS AND LIMITATIONS 54-55
APPENDICES AND ANNXEURE 56-60
BIBLIOGRAPHY 61-62
CHAPTER-1
INTRODUCTION
Success of every business enterprise depends on its human
resource. Money, material and machines are inert factors; but
man with his ability to feel, think, conscience and plan is
the most valuable resource. At the same time, human elements
are most difficult to be inspired, controlled and motivated.
The upcoming competition in India will demand high
motivational level of its employees.
Growth of an enterprise is vital for the economic development
of the country. This is possible only by maintaining the
enthusiasm and motivation of the employees, which is vital for
carrying out the operations in most efficient manner. The most
successful companies, all over the world have designed their
business policies to achieve higher productivity by using
potentiality and strength of people.
The basic aim of human policies is the genuine concern for the
people. Proper design of human policies is based on the higher
responsibilities, personal and positive approach in the total
perspective of organizational interest. The world's best
companies have established their strength with their people.
The employees identify themselves with the company they are
working for. This also helps in building up their spirit,
morale and espirit-de-cops that becomes strength of the
company.
Finding the right man for the job and developing him into a
valuable resource is an indispensable requirement of every
organization. Human resources are capable of enlargement i.e.
capable of providing an output that is greater than the sum of
the inputs. Proper recruitment helps the line managers to work
most effectively in accomplishing the primary objective of the
enterprise. In order to harness the human energies in the
service or organizational goals, every manager is expected to
pay proper attention to recruitment, selection, training,
development activities in an organization. Thus, personnel
functions such as manpower planning recruitment, selection and
training, when carried out properly, would enable the
organization to hire and retain the services of the best
brains in the market.
The human resource management is very crucial in respect of
information technology services than other manufacturing or
marketing enterprises. The IT services are technical in nature
and at every stage, the human touch is involved. Hence, it is
well-motivated and devoted manpower which is very much
essential for the success of IT industry.
ROLE OF HR MANAGERS
Traditionally, the role of the Human Resource professional in
many organizations has been to serve as the systematizing,
policing arm of executive management. In this role, the HR
professional served executive agendas well, but was frequently
viewed as a road block by much of the rest of the
organization. While some need for this role occasionally
remains you would no want every manager putting his own spin
on a sexual harassment policy, as an example—much of the HR
role is transforming itself. The role of the HR manager must
parallel the needs of his changing organization.
Strategic Partner:-In today’s organizations, to guarantee
their viability and ability to contribute, HR managers need to
think of themselves as strategic partners. In this role, the
HR person contributes to the development of and the
accomplishment of the organization-wide business plan and
objectives. The HR business objectives are established to
support the attainment of the overall plan and objectives.
This strategic partnership impacts HR services such as the
design of work positions, hiring; reward, recognition, and
strategic pay; performance development and appraisal systems;
career and succession planning; and employee development.
Employee Advocate:-As an employee sponsor or advocate, the HR
manager plays an integral role in organizational success via
his knowledge about and advocacy of people. In this role, the
HR manager provides employee development opportunities,
employee assistance programs, gain sharing and profit-sharing
strategies, organization development interventions, due
process approaches to problem solving, and regularly scheduled
communication opportunities.
LEADERSHIP AND EMPLOYEE INVOLVEMENT.
The main role of leadership was seen as creating a
participatory process for employee involvement, to build
collective wisdom this is a marked shift to build effective
teams. Research shows that six out of every 10 employees like
to work in teams. 87 per cent of all Fortune 500 companies use
parallel teams and about 100 per cent of all companies use
project teams.
Storytelling and appreciative enquiry are emerging as a new
dimension in positive motivation. Finding out what is wrong
seems to be the trend. In Walt Disney, telling success stories
is one of the important methods used to remind people of
greatness and goodness of the organization. Leaders in Disney
concentrate on quality, values and involvement. Speaking in
the plenary sessions, Tom Peters said, “We have transitioned
from an asset-based economy to a talent-based economy. The new
definition of lay-off is untalented go talented stay. Leaders
must realize that talent is equal to brand". His new theory is
EVP which means "Employee Value Proposition".
E-Learning: - Organizations’ like Ford Motor, Hewlett Packard,
Intel and IBM are using e-learning to increase the knowledge
of their people. Companies like Fordstar even manage time
differences between countries while conducting virtual class
rooms, chats, demos, presentations to communicate new
concepts, product details, core values, issues of governance
and corporate communities.
INNOVATIVE PRACTICES IN HR
The Innovative Practices in Human Resources study uncovered 12
practices that are reducing HR costs and improving service
quality to employees. Key findings from this research included
the need for HR managers to streamline processes, lower
overhead costs, and enable their departments to advance from
transactional organizations to strategic partners in the
business.
Practices and technologies include:
Internet and intranet employee services
Strategic human resources
Centralized HR departments and call centers
360-degree performance appraisals
HRIS systems
Employee self-service
Voice response systems (VRUs)
Resume scanning and Internet recruitment
Kiosks
Automated time and attendance systems
Team policies and development
Outsourcing
Business process reengineering (BPR)
LINKING PAY TO PERFORMANCE
Most Human Resource professionals are familiar with the
concept of strategy. There is much more concentration and
focus today on the strategic outcomes of human resource
activity than ever before. The area of compensation is no
exception.
Pay for performance systems are becoming more and more popular
as senior managers reach beyond the use of compensation
systems to deliver pay.
In experience, most organizations will profess to a "pay-for-
performance" philosophy as a keystone of their compensation
system. Such a system requires solid grounding in a clear and
documented link between performance and salary increases.
First, the annual salary change is usually a small
percentage. Giving the better performer 2% more than the cost
of living has little motivation or recognition attached to it.
Similarly giving the poor performers 2% less than the cost of
living increase is not that much of a penalty.
Second, most performance appraisal systems are after-the-fact
appraisals. In other words, at appraisal time, which is
usually toward the end of the year, managers are required to
evaluate the performance of their staff.
The result is usually a lot of avoidance behavior. Managers
avoid the appraisal process like the plague. Although
employees profess to want to "know where they stand”, they
often take issue with the appraisal. Besides, they do not
listen to the evaluation, they wait until the penny literally
"drops". "What is my rating and how much do I get?" is a
constant theme in merit systems where salary decisions are
tied so closely with the appraisal process.
Why Is This Transition Occurring? :-Well, there are many
challenges facing businesses today and these challenges are
driving them to find better ways of linking pay and
performance to the achievement of corporate results.
CHANGING JOB DESIGN IN IT COMMUNITY
The California State University (CSU) system is being
challenged to meet increasing demands for educational and
administrative services through the innovative use of
technology and human resource systems. Even though funding
levels for higher education have been cut in recent years,
public/taxpayer expectations and the demands for quality
education, access, service, and accountability have grown.
Technology initiatives within the CSU have resulted in
significant advances and improved technical capabilities and
efficiency. Human resource and organizational systems are also
needed to capitalize on and thrive in this rapidly changing
work environment.
In 1991, the CSU began a study to look at alternative work
and job design approaches to meet these challenges.
The studies focused on the information technology community
and how work processes and activities could be better
organized to remove artificial barriers and improve
organizational effectiveness, a process often associated with
the term "reengineering." Secondly, the study focused on
developing a job design approach that could adapt to changing
skill requirements and that would promote the continuous
acquisition of skills for knowledge-based employees in
information technology. The goal of improved organizational
effectiveness and an orientation towards reengineering and
skills guided the development of the proposed job design
approach.
This article begins by identifying several trends that led to
the study, and then describes the overall project within the
context of an organizational effectiveness equation. A new job
design approach that was proposed as a result of the study is
presented, including a new classification structure and
competency dimensions and measures for defining and evaluating
positions. Finally, other supporting systems are described for
an integrated human resources approach. The development phase
of the project has been completed, and the CSU anticipates
entering into negotiations with its employee representatives
in the near future.
Three trends have had a direct impact on the development of a
strategic job design approach for the information technology
community at the CSU: (a) diversification and convergence of
technology, increased demand for educational access and (b)
changes in instructional delivery methods; and changing work
place demands and priorities.
The technology demands within higher education lead to a
complex and dynamic computing environment. Academic and
administrative computing strategies tend to be at cross-
purposes in terms of defining systems requirements.
This has resulted in widely diverse systems and technology
within and across the CSU's twenty campuses. Increasingly,
however, campus systems are becoming more integrated, as data
are shared across multiple platforms on a network "highway"
that is linked to external information sources. Networking and
desktop computing have removed traditional boundaries for
information access, research, and decision-support purposes.
Data, voice, and video technologies continue to be combined in
more interactive and user-friendly formats.
In terms of educational trends, many institutions offer
distance learning using various transmission media and are
incorporating instructional technology into curriculum
development. Students expect guaranteed access to technology
and to research databases, and this access has become an issue
of social responsibility.
[1] Library and computing functions are becoming increasingly
interdependent in "an infrastructure of scholarly
communication" within higher education.[2] Workplace trends,
as presented in Sustaining Excellence in the 21st Century: A
Vision and Strategies for College and University
Administration, well represent the outlook for the CSU. Two
key issues are identified:
(1) Economics. There is increasing pressure to constrain
administrative costs within the "labor intensive cost
structure" that exists in higher education. Reductions in
staff are occurring at the same time as transaction volume and
service expectations are growing.
(2) Decentralization of responsibility. With fewer people and
greater access to information, organizations are moving
responsibility for decision-making downward to the point of
service. Work organization is shifting away from job
specialization and a task/procedure orientation, to more
generalized job responsibilities focused on outcome and
greater participation on cross-functional teams
(3) Another central workplace trend is the "earning and
learning" environment described by the U.S. Department of
Labor in its Secretary's Commission on Achieving Necessary
Skills (SCANS) report. To quote Thomas P. Foley, Secretary of
the Pennsylvania Department of Labor and Industry:"We've
changed from the idea of "one skill, one job" to the reality
of a range of skills that have to apply to a number of
different kinds of professions. More to the point, workers
must possess a skill that they continually upgrade just to
keep pace in the professions they choose."
(4) The influx of new technology and applications has created
a demand for continual learning and adaptation. Due to the
CSU's relatively stable workforce, maintaining skills to keep
pace with changing technology was identified as a critical
goal. Knowledge requirements are expanding to encompass a
greater breadth of technologies and subject expertise, as well
as including process-oriented capabilities such as
communication and negotiation skills.
The implications of these technological, educational, and
workplace trends point directly to the need to reengineer
organizational structures, work design, and processes. Based
on these trends and overall organizational goals, two key
objectives were established for a new job design approach for
the CSU: flexibility and skill development. Fundamentally,
each campus needs the flexibility to achieve its goals by
distributing work assignments in a way that optimizes its
available skill mix and promotes individual skill development
and initiative.
HR TRENDS IN IT INDUSTRY
HR IT SCENARIO
The web is altering the HRD landscape beyond recognition. The
key to corporate success in the fast changing information era
is ‘thinking on your knees’.
What is this thinking on your knees? Normally as the HR
person you know what the situation is and operate from there.
A repositioning is required in your decision process with
questions like why, how and when and not just what. At this
point you operate on your knee i.e. with far more dynamism and
with a lot more effectiveness than thinking on your feet.
The employees are like gypsies, on the move all the time.
They camp at some location, enhance their skills,
responsibility levels and move on. This is particularly true
of the professional from Software Industry. Opportunities are
plenty and the next job opening is only a mouse click away.
The question is not about what else you can do to retain an
employee but it is about making him productive, while he is
with you. The value addition will then happen for both the
employee as well as the employer resulting in a win-win
situation. This means that the new strategy calls for the
recognition that no employee is expected to be permanently
with you. Normal tenure in any organization is likely to be
between two to three years.
INNOVATION IS THE KEY
Information technology and Internet have changed several
equations. Reaching out to the world market place is no more
the challenge in achieving corporate victories. Out thinking
the competition at electronic speed is the key to winning
corporate battles. The corporate success is sum total of
entrepreneurship practiced by your staff.
The key to employee longevity :-Today’s most successful
organizations recognize that to fuel growth and sustain a
competitive advantage, they must make recruiting, hiring and
retaining top talent, as the organization’s major thrust area.
Competent people deliver the rest do not matter. Successful
business organizations have no choice but to promote the
performers and let non-performers go.
Organizations’ recognize that that their ability to gather,
manage, analyze, distribute information and transform
themselves into a learning organization will provide
continuity and ensure for them their leadership role.
Systematic organizational learning should be central corporate
philosophy. Learning must be obviously followed by changes,
which may not necessarily be welcomed by veterans in the
organization. But ‘change is the only constant’ for guaranteed
success.
Points to note: The following points are important and must
be properly understood.
People have a great deal of informational knowledge to
contribute to the organization.
People are responsible
People desire opportunities to effect change, not just being
expected to change. Organizations’ need to create
awareness amongst their employees about their vision and then
empower them to act on that vision.
Establishing a sense of urgency well ahead of the
problem surfacing.
Form inter-functional core group. Encourage the
group to work together as a team.
Plan and create short-term win targets – reward
employees and recognize achievers.
Consolidate improvements through a knowledge base
driven system and institutionalize proven new
methodologies.
New Paradigms in HR Business plans must consider HR issues, focus and
adapt.
Corporate goals must factor in individual career
growth and personal growth must be tied to corporate
growth and vice versa
Job responsibilities must facilitate personal
development and learning should be institutionalized with
well-established knowledge bases. Capturing experience and
making it available ‘corporate wide’ should be a permanent
feature of an organization.
WAR FOR TALENT
The world’s most popular people resource base seems to be
falling short of numbers to meet its own demands. With added
pressures of migration and attrition, can India’s IT industry
achieve its software and services revenue target of $87
billion by 2008?
Country: India. Population: 1 billion-plus. If that sounds like
too many people, think again. Plug in English-speaking and low
labor costs, and suddenly we can envision $50-billion software
exports target by the end of this decade. Not impossible, if
we consider the scarcity of IT manpower across the world. Take
a look at the US, already with a 10- million-strong IT
workforce, which needs to fill 1.6 million new jobs in the next
one year.
Japan is no different and estimates close to a million new
jobs. Germany is looking for 20,000 IT specialists and Italy
is seeking 15,000 additional manpower. Their choice
destination—India.
Ironically, the country which has been such a popular people
resource for the IT industry the world over, is struggling
with numbers to meet its own demand. To meet the overall
software and services (domestic and export) target of $87
billion by 2008, according to the Nasscom-McKinsey report, the
country will require a minimum of 2.2 million knowledge
workers for its domestic needs. This implies that the present
strength, which stands at 12,00,000 (December 2004), has to
increase about twice, not just in quantity but in quality as
well.
According to industry estimates, majority of the demand for
manpower will be in the area of IT-enabled services.
While Nasscom puts the requirement at 11, 00,000, MIT says IT-
enabled services and e-business will need 12, 70,000 workers
by 2007. Experts insist that since this sector does not
require very highly skilled manpower, we can easily meet this
demand. "IT-enabled services are a wonderful opportunity for
India and for such services you don’t need highly skilled
professionals. You just need smart graduates who can speak
English; all you need to do is train them. For instance, in a
call center, they need to be trained on accents and customer
services,
4 R’s of HR in IT
TABLE
Recruiti
ng
Signing
bonus
Finder’s Fee
Alumni
connections
Retaining
Retention
bonus
Project pay
Reduct
FTE/same pay
Telecommuting
Retraini
ng
Job rotation
Team
assignments
Skill
inventories
Competency
Restructur
ing
Broad job
descriptions
Flexible
compensation
programs
Flexible jobs
Non-techs
Students
Interns
Externs
Job sharing
Recognition
programs
development
Certificatio
n
Positive
problem-solving
spirit
OBSTACLES
Denial (This is and long term)
Misalignment (Ramping up/Ramping down)
Timing
Treating everyone the same
Navigating the bureaucracy
Demographics
WHAT OTHERS ARE DOING
Pooling recruitment efforts
Increasing freedom at the dept level
(On-the-spot hiring, broad banding, etc.)
Recruiting/retaining students
Identifying tech skills in all jobs/people
(Skill Inventories/assessment)
Sharing staff
RETENTION FACTORS
1. Quality of boss
2. Direction of department
3. Exposure to new technologies
4. Confidence in the company
5. Job security
6. Challenging work
7. Location
8. Access to capital resources
9. Caliber of co-workers
10. Empowerment
11. Department leadership
12. Ability to influence department success.
TAKING THE LEAD
See ourselves as problem-solvers
Develop critical skills and competencies in
ourselves, then others
Build compensation around results not tasks;
competencies, not seniority
Involve everyone. Constantly align and balance
resources to meet changing needs
SEARCH FOR TOMORROW
Attract, retain and reward the best performers (Encourage
all to be the best)
Increase flexibility
Reduce fixed costs
Reduce administrative effort (Simplify, simplify,
simplify)
Utilize the full range of individual talents
THE CRISIS
Ø Shortage of IT workers
COMPETITION
Ø Compensation stock options, profit sharing,
incentives
Ø Alternatives outsourcing
ATTRACTING
Ø Recruiting sign on bonuses
Ø Relocation incentives
Ø Recruiters
Ø Reduced cycle time for hiring
Ø Campus/ job fairs / referrals/ internet
RETAINING
Ø Work environment
Ø Communication forums
Ø Telecommuting
Ø Flexible staffing
Ø Exciting projects
PRACTICES
Ø Focus on value
Ø Financial and human value
Ø Commitment to core strategy
Ø Linkage between cultures an system
Ø Multi dimension communication
Ø Stakeholders partnerships
Ø Mutual support and collaboration (teamwork)
Ø Risk and innovativeness
Ø Passion
DEVELOPING
Ø Internship programs
Ø Training programs
Ø Career development programs
LONG TERM SOLUTIONS
Ø Education, government, industry partnerships
Ø Curricula: technical skills and career skills (teamwork and communication)
KEY SUCCESS FACTORS
Understand people
What they want
Long term perspective’
Innovative
Co ordinate approach
Career development I
OUT SOURCING
In the last few years, more and more companies around the
world are looking towards India for outsourcing their software
requirements. The changing business environment is demanding
new applications. In particular, the spread of client-server
computing in decentralized organizations involves the
development of applications specific to a user's business.
Outsourcing is becoming a strategy for forward thinking IS
managers. It is no longer just a means for reducing costs, but
a tool for adding value to business. It enables organisations
to concentrate on their core business, carry out business re-
engineering and provide information that is valid, timely and
adequate to assist decision making at the management level and
quality and cost control at the middle and lower levels.
As a result, outsourcing has gradually grown beyond the
traditional idea of "having a third party running the data
centre". It has come to mean, "any use of an outside
contractor to replace or extend in-house resources".
Outsourcing is closely linked with corporate strategy, since
it must support the organization’s major initiative in using
IS. It should enhance and add value to the business. A rule of
thumb to start and gain experience is, "if IS low cost and of
high value addition, keep it within the organization, i.e. in-
source. If IS high cost and of low value addition, consider
outsourcing". In the past few years, whenever organizations’
around the world have outsourced to India, the Indian software
companies have substantially helped to cut costs in software
development projects or MIS environments, while maintaining
high quality. Moreover, all these cost and quality advantages
are coupled with the use of state-of-the-art technologies.
In 2004-05 more than US$ 2500 million worth of software
development work was outsourced to India (The total software
exports from India during the year was US$ 4085 million). This
was 56% higher than outsourcing orders in 2003-04. It is
estimated that the quantum of outsourcing may jump to US$ 5
billion and reach as high as US$ 10 billion by 2010 A.D.
HR PROBLEMS OF INDIAN IT PROFESSIONALS
OVERVIEW OF PROBLEMS
The IT revolution is sweeping the world, particularly the
western world in for nearly a decade now, creating enormous
employment opportunities in this area. India joined the
bandwagon well in time and smoothly though it is yet to
entrench itself strongly in terms of corporate identity and
significant share of global revenues in IT.
Our main contribution seems to be in the less glamorous areas
of value addition, maintenance, Y2K, quality assurance and
customization of existing packages. The sudden eruption of
opportunities in this area left no time for development of
human resources in a planned manner and also software
solutions which tended to
With the enormous opportunities for employment,
entrepreneurship with low capital investment and low gestation
period for turning profitable, higher returns per employee and
large return on investment/EPS, sustained encouragement from
government, a very large number of organizations’ - large,
medium, small - have been established. Correspondingly a large
number of training establishments and cyber cafes have come
up, most of which are in the cities and towns to cash in on
the enthusiasm of the urban middle class.
A number of higher level courses have also been started mainly
through private organizations’ besides the existing government
(State/Central), university and autonomous institutions. There
are about 500 private engineering colleges besides IITs, RECs,
universities, colleges offering courses such as MCA, M.Sc.,
M.E., and M.Tech. In view of the apparent demand that appears
to be exaggerated, most of the programmes (barring a few by
government institutions and IITs) are very expensive, almost
beyond the reach of a middle-class student. Yet candidates and
their parents strain themselves financially to pursue the
courses hoping to get an attractive job (financially) which
remains a mirage by and large. The problems are further
compounded by a lack of proper teaching faculty in most
colleges and
Except in well-established institutions, job-placements are
poor. Even those trained in reputed institutions find their
jobs monotonous, leading to depression. Jobs offered by the
software industry have demonstrated the above factors as they
are able to carry out the projects with persons of any
background and levels of attainment, but with a few months
training either prior to employment or a short training during
probation.
Despite these deficiencies, students prefer software jobs
mainly with an eye on the pay-package and urban locations. The
employee- retention period even in good companies has been
shrinking and is found to be three to six months. The
companies also try to devise methods to make their employees
almost captive with surety bonds, bank guarantees, employee's
stock option (ESOP) and housing facilities, among others. The
employees, for their part, resort to innovative methods to
wriggle out of their contracts. There does not appear to be
any respectable ethics even among companies as well as the
employees in this type of free for all market. To go abroad
and become rich has become the motive of most of the employees
even if the job does not offer any intellectual satisfaction.
The manufacturing and hard-core engineering sector has also
shrunk in terms of job opportunities and attractiveness.
Even those software professionals, who are offered good
financial packages, spend their earnings on expensive
lifestyles, vehicles, and credit card syndrome and find
themselves disenchanted on all fronts including the
intellectual front. It should also be a cause for concern to
project beyond the present software boom as to what happens to
all these if the opportunities decline. The scenario appears
to be quite fluid with a predominant western bias in all the
activities concerning software profession with scores of
Indian boys getting lured and sucked into the vortices created
by the opportunities in this area.
MAIN PROBLEM AREAS
The significant problem areas which may be contributing to the
present scenario and can be addressed can be identified as
given in the succeeding paragraphs.
Recruitment process:-Without going into the deficiencies of
the present practices, the following suggestions are made to
improve the process in terms of efficiency, availability of
manpower and equity to all the aspirants irrespective of the
fact where they got educated. The various steps of the
proposed approach are as follows:
i. Aptitude tests could be conducted by reputed institutes
like IITs/ private organizations/HR agencies for prospective
professionals preferably ``on-line'' like GRE, GMAT etc. or
physically at regular intervals and scores are given. If it is
no on-line, the periodicity can be a month or two and the
validity can be for a year or so which can also be fixed based
on general agreement.
ii Based on scores and preferences of the candidates (career
counseling), companies can ask for a video clip for subsequent
interview if required. Interviews can also be conducted
simultaneously either physically or over the phone or by video
conference and selections completed.
iii Once selected and the candidate joins the organizations,
all member organizations should adopt a code of conduct such
that the candidates stays at least for a period of one year.
iv. Small companies can form some kind of a cooperative
society wherein software professionals' services can be tapped
and steer clear and manpower shortage (less than critical mass
levels).
v. The selection can be conditional that he acquires certified
skills in the required areas either through training in house
or through approved training agencies and establishments. This
will also avoid the unnecessary expenses for (which are high)
the candidates, who are presently spending lot of money with a
hope of employment. This will also ensure that there is a
focus on proper training and optimal deployment of time,
effort and finances.
vi. The selection process can thus be continuous and
commensurate with the requirements thus avoiding idle
inventory.
Vii.There can be general norms of pay packages depending on
the reputation of the companies (classifying them as A, B, C,
D by any reputed management institute like IIM etc.) with the
ratio of maximum pay within reasonable and realistic limits.
Post employment care: - The companies/organizations shouldtake adequate interest in the career development of the
employee by suitable HRD approaches which should include the
following:
i. Opportunities for creative work in the first phase
particularly for those who are bright, and have an aptitude
and come with a good pedigree say from IITs.
ii. Opportunities to lessen the monotony and improve
interpersonal relationship and mixing and group activities.
iii. Periodic rotation of the rolls and jobs if possible.
iv. Opportunities for retraining and upgrading the skills.
v. Conducting
Effective career development programs regularly.
vi. Incentives like ESOP, lucrative assignments and
challenging projects, opportunities of higher education.
vii. Make the employee more versatile with wider perspective
and flexible for easy deployment in areas needing
strengthening.
viii. Encouraging simplicity and excellence.
Advantages:- The suggested processes in 4 and 5 above can beexpected to have the following significant advantages:
i. Cost effective and efficient process.
ii. Proper deployment of skills optimally.
iii. Idle employment can be minimized.
iv. Retention can be improved.
v. Particularly useful for small firms which can
also operate in the cooperative society mode.
vi. The candidate's skills are moulded to suit the
needs of the job and need not waste time, money and efforts.
vii. Equitable opportunities to all aspirants
irrespective of location, pedigree and background.
viii. Reduces the mushrooms of training shops with
inadequate faculty.
ix. This may also give the manufacturing and core
engineering sector jobs reasonable chance to attract willing
and bright candidates.
x. The process is ideally suited for candidates to
plan their careers with adequate preparation in core areas.
xi. The process also enables realistic assessments
of needs and demands regularly and meeting them even at short
notices.
xii. The aptitude tests can become richer and more
representative over a few years and as the question bank
becomes larger and random on-line questioning can be
introduced which is more objective like GRE, GMAT
LONG TERM PERSPECTIVE
These tests can be conducted at the end of 10+2 level or
B.Sc. level also and train the candidate with or without
stipend in courses where he could get admission for his
degree. This will help in decreasing the pressure on
engineering education as otherwise the skills acquired by the
candidate at a great cost in branches other than computer
sciences are wasted and lost for good if employed by the
software industry. It may be a good idea to have a National Testfor Software Talent similar to science talent test which can be
sponsored by NASSCOM and such other interested groups the idea of
forming a cooperative society by small firms may prove to be
beneficial as the facilities and manpower can be shared optimally.
While otherwise they may face the problems of lack of adequate
manpower (below the critical mass level) because of less attractive
pay and perks they are able to offer. Renowned organizations like
IITs, IIMs and MNCs, and can play a catalytic roll in streamlining
the processes for an efficient HRD in this vital area of software
manpower which is a national resource.
IT SECTOR COMPENSATION METHODS
EMPLOYEE STOCK OWNWERSHIP PLAN
Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP): is a defined contribution
employee benefit plan that allows employees to become owners
of stock in the company they work for.
How does ESOP work?
1. The ESOP operates through a trust, setup by the company
that accepts tax deductible contributions from the company to
purchase company stock
2. The contributions made by the company are distributed to
individual employee accounts within the trust.
3. The amount of stock each individual receives may vary
according to pre-established formulas based on salary,
service, or position.
4. The employees may ‘cash out’ after vesting in the
program or when they leave the company. The amount they may
cash out may depend on the vesting requirements.
STOCK OPTIONS
Stock Options: The ‘right’ to purchase stock at a given
price at some time in the future.
Stock Options come in two types:
1. Incentive stock options (ISOs) in which the employee is able
to defer taxation until the shares bought with the option is
sold. The company does not receive a tax deduction for this
type of option.
2. Nonqualified stock options (NSOs) in which the employee must
pay income tax on the 'spread' between the value of the stock
and the amount paid for the option. The company may receive a
tax deduction on the 'spread'.
How do Stock options work? An option is created that
specifies that the owner of the option may 'exercise' the
'right' to purchase a company’s stock at a certain price (the
'grant' price) by a certain (expiration) date in the future.
Usually the price of the option (the 'grant' price) is set to
the market price of the stock at the time the option was sold.
If the underlying stock increases in value, the option becomes
more valuable. If the underlying stock decreases below the
'grant' price or stays the same in value as the 'grant' price,
then the option becomes worthless.
MERIT PAY
Merit Pay is an incentive plan implemented on an
institutional wide basis to give all employees an equal
opportunity for consideration, regardless of funding source.
The merit increase program is implemented when funds are
designated for that purpose by the institution's
administration, dependent upon the availability of funds and
other constraints. .
Advantages OF Merit Pay:-
Allows the employer to differentiate pay given to
high performers.
Allows a differentiation between individual and
company performance.
Allows the employer to satisfactorily reward an
employee for accomplishing a task that might not be
repeated (such as implementation of new systems).
GAIN SHARING
Gain sharing is a technique that compensates workers based on
improvements in the company's productivity.
How does Gain sharing work? A Company shares productivity
gains with the workforce. Workers voluntarily participate in
management to accept responsibility for major reforms.
This type of pay is based on factors directly under a worker’s
control (i.e., productivity or costs). Gains are measured and
distributions are made frequently through a predetermined
formula. Because this pay is only implemented when gains are
achieved, gain sharing plans do not adversely affect company
costs.
What are the 'Gains' that are measured?
· Increases in production with equal or
less effort.
· Equal levels of production with less
effort.
What are examples of Gain sharing formulas?
· Calculate gain in hours: The actual hours worked minus
the expected hours (for the given level of output) equal the gain in
hours.
PROFIT SHARING
Profit Sharing is an incentive based compensation program to
award employees a percentage of the company's profits. How doesProfit sharing work? The company contributes a portion of its pre-
tax profits to a pool that will be distributed among eligible
employees.
The amount distributed to each employee may be weighted by the
employee's base salary so that employees with higher base salaries
receive a slightly higher amount of the shared pool of profits.
Generally this is done on an annual basis How to Choose an Employee
Stock Plan for Your Company:-Many companies we encounter have a
pretty good idea of what kind of employee ownership plan they want
to use, usually based on specific needs and goals.
However, sometimes they might be better served by another kind of
stock plan. And yet others say they'd like to have an employee
ownership plan, but they're not sure what it might be. This article
will start you down the path to choosing and implementing the plan
or plans best suited to your company.
ASSESSMENT OF PLANS FOR BROAD-BASED EMPLOYEE
OWNERSHIP
Let us begin by quickly reviewing the main possibilities for
broad-based employee ownership. A "broad-based" plan is one in
which most or all employees can participate.
An employee stock ownership plan (ESOP) is a type of tax-
qualified employee benefit plan in which most or all of the
assets are invested in stock of the employer. Like profit
sharing and 401(k) plans, which are governed by many of the
same laws, an ESOP generally must include at least all full-
time employees meeting certain age and service requirements.
Employees do not actually buy shares in an ESOP.
Instead, the company contributes its own shares to the plan,
contributes cash to buy its own stock (often from an existing
owner), or, most commonly, has the plan borrow money to buy
stock, with the company repaying the loan. All of these uses
have significant tax benefits for the company, the employees,
and the sellers. Employees gradually vest in their accounts
and receive their benefits when they leave the company
(although there may be distributions prior to that). Over 8
million employees in over 11,000 companies, mostly closely
held, participate in ESOPs.
A stock option plan grants employees the right to buy company
stock at a specified price during a specified period once the
option has vested. So if an employee gets an option on 100
shares at $10 and the stock price goes up to $20, the employee
can "exercise" the option and buy those 100 shares at $10
each, sell them on the market for $20 each, and pocket the
difference. But if the stock price never rises above the
option price, the employee will simply not exercise the
option. Stock options can be given to as few or as few
employees as you wish. Perhaps 7 to 10 million or more
employees in thousands of companies, both public and private,
presently hold stock options.
An employee stock purchase plan (ESPP) is a little like a
stock option plan. It gives employees the chance to buy stock,
usually through payroll deductions over a 3- to 27-month
"offering period." The price is usually discounted up to 15%
from the market price. Frequently, employees can choose to buy
stock at a discount from the lower of the price either at the
beginning or the end of the ESPP offering period, which can
increase the discount still further.
As with a stock option, after acquiring the stock the
employee can sell it for a quick profit or hold onto it for
awhile. Unlike stock options, the discounted price built into
most ESPPs means that employees can profit even if the stock
price has gone down since the grant date. Companies usually
set up ESPPs as tax-qualified "Section 423" plans, which means
that almost all full-time employees with 2 years or more of
service must be allowed to participate (although in practice,
many choose not to). Many millions of employees, almost always
in public companies, are in ESPPs.
Section 401(k) plan is a retirement plan that, unlike an ESOP,
is designed to provide the employee with a diversified
portfolio of investments. Like an ESOP, however, a 401(k) plan
is a tax-qualified plan that generally must include all full-
time employees meeting age and service requirements.
The employees can choose among several or more choices for
investments, and the company may make a matching contribution.
Perhaps several million employees in a few thousand companies
participate in plans with a heavy company stock component;
company stock may be an investment choice for the employees
and/or the means by which the company makes matching
contributions. 401(k) plans may be combined with ESOPs (these
are called "KSOPs"), where the company match is an ESOP
contribution.
EMPLOYEE OWNERSHIP: COMPANIES PAY LESS FOR WORKERS' COMPENSATION COSTS
A study has found that employee ownership companies have lower
workers' compensation insurance rates than comparable non-
employee ownership firms. Leslie Hakala authored the study.
She began the project as an NCEO research intern and completed
it for a thesis requirement at Harvard University. The study
was unable to ascribe a specific causal relationship between
employee ownership and lower workers' compensation costs, but
it did find that these costs declined as employee ownership
plans matured.
Background: - In 1989, the last year for which we have data,
U.S. employers spent over $48 billion on workers' compensation
costs. These costs grew at 16.9% per year in the mid-1980s.
Cost increases were partly attributable to increased benefits
mandated by state workers' compensation insurance reforms. At
the same time, as employer provided health care coverage has
declined, more employees sought to cover health problems under
workers' compensation. Many people believe there has been
increased fraud as well.
Workers' compensation programs vary from state to state, but
in most programs, insurers attempt to provide employers with
an incentive to limit safety problems by developing an
experience rating. The ratings compare an individual firm's
experience with other firms of its type. If the rating is
better than average, insurance premiums will be lower; if it
is worse, they will go up. In this study, we looked only at
California firms. In California, employers are assigned a
"manual rate," an insurance rate expressed as a percentage of
every $100 of payroll. Rates are assigned to all companies
based on their industry classification.
These rates are then adjusted for companies with a premium
above a certain level according to their actual experience.
This means smaller and less risky firms are not assigned an
experience modification rating. The experience modification
rate is set for each year based on three years of past
experience, excluding the most recent year (because data are
generally not yet available). The experience modification rate
is determined by looking at actual experience modified by a
size weighting factor. For larger firms, the adjustment may be
very small; for smaller firms, actual experience is given a
lower weight because a single incident can skew results
dramatically. This weighted experience rating now becomes the
"experience modification" figure.
Theoretically, the average experience modification factor for
any business classification should be 100%. A company with a
good record would have a rating under 100%; a bad record would
rate higher. These numbers are then multiplied by the manual
rate to set the premium. In practice, the average rating is
somewhat under 100.
IT COMPANIES WRITE NEW ESOP STORY
Will I ever get to exercise my stock options? It's the one
question haunting IT industry professionals sitting on piles
of employee stock options. All those who happily grabbed at
ESOP's issued by their companies last year, have now been left
holding pieces of paper that are, in some cases, worth a
fraction of the price at which employees brought into them.
Except for a few who have benefitted from older schemes like
Infosys 1994 scheme, the great ESOPs dream is turning out to
be a nightmare. Last year, if you were given ESOPs in an IT
company, your friends, neighbors and everyone else went up
like a blimp, companies issued ESOPs in cartloads. And
employees brought into them, even at the higher prices that
the grants came from. According to a study carried out by
Nasscom , there were more than 10,000 IT staff last year
holding around 18 million ESOPs valued at roughly Rs 12,000
crore($3 billion) at February '00 prices. But all this was
merely on paper.A year later, the situations something like
this. Employees who were given ESOPs at the prices prevailing
during the IT boom, had to sit back and watch their share
prices hit the roof while they waited out the lock-in period.
Now, they can exercise their options that are sell them, and
pocket the difference between the exercise price at the time
of the grant, and the current market price. It's resulted in a
situation where employees have been left holding NIIT options
which they would have to exercise at a price of Rs 1,593 or
Silver line options, which they would have to exercise at a
price of $25. At Visual Soft, for instance, all employees who
were granted options have returned them to the company.
Consequently, the company has terminated the ESOP scheme.
Theoretically, an employee who exercised his option now would
have to buy at the exercise price, sell at the current market
price, and pay out the difference.
ESOPs HARDLY BENEFICIAL -
At the height of the IT euphoria in the markets, those
employees saw their company's scrips scaling new heights, they
could not benefit as the ESOP's had 1-2 year lock-in periods,
and could not be sold. The lock-in period, also known as the
vesting period in industry jargon, in the period during which
the employee cannot convert his or her option into shares. To
make matters worse, some companies has specified that the
option had to be exercised, that is converted into shares,
within a specified time frame after the locking period
expired. For instance, this was one year in the case of Silver
line, and 10 in the case of Aptech.
Table ESOP IN INDIAN CONTEXT
Recent ESOPs
No of
Shares
(Lakh)
Plan Exercise
Plans
Vesting
Period
Curren
t
(Rs) (Yrs) Price
(Rs)
NIIT 18.1 Aug '04 1,593 1 162
Silver
line
10.0 Nov '04 425 1.5-3.5 41
Patni 5.5 Dec '04 245* 1 54
HCL
Infosys
30.2 Aug '04 289 NA 72
SSI 1.5 Sep '04 555 3 164
Wipro 3.5 Oct '04 2,397 1-2 1,485
Infosys 19.6 Oct '04 6,249 5 3,532
Visual
Soft
0.2 Aug '04 NA 1 116
Polaris 8.5 Aug '04 480 5 120
EMPLOYEE STOCK PURCHASE PLANS (ESPPS)
Employee stock purchase plans (ESPPs) include both tax-
qualified "423 plans," which about 2,400 companies offer, and
nonqualified plans, which about 1,500 companies offer. Our
estimates are based on data from Share Data’s Equity
Compensation Trends in America (1991), Hewitt Associates' On
Employee Stock Ownership (1996), Hewitt Associates' Survey
Findings: Employee Stock Purchase Plans (1998), and the
National Association for Stock Plan Professionals' Stock Plan
Design and Administration Survey (1998), especially the more
recent studies. To estimate the number of employees covered
under the plans, we took the total number of companies
offering plans, multiplied those numbers by the average number
of employees in the companies (13,207 for 423 plans and 17,790
for nonqualified plans), and multiplied that number by the
average percentage of participation in the plans (34% for 423
plans and 17% for nonqualified ESPPs). Almost all companies
with ESPPs are public.
Multiple Plans: Many companies offer multiple e plans, and
many employees participate in more than one plan. For example,
many ESPP participants are also in 401(k), stock option, or
other equity compensation plans. Hence, the total number of
participants in all these plans is definitely not the total of
the numbers in the "Number of participants" column.
ESOPS AND CORPORATE GROWTH
A 2000 study by Joseph Blasi and Douglas Kruse at Rutgers
University found that ESOP companies grow 2.3% to 2.4% faster
than would have been expected without an ESOP for sales,
employment, and sales per employee. The study looked at all
ESOP plans set up between 1988 and 1994 for which data was
available. A 1987 NCEO study of 45 ESOP and 225 non-ESOP
companies found that companies that combine employee ownership
with a participative management style grow 8% to 11% per year
faster than they would otherwise have been expected to grow
based on how they had performed before these plans. Subsequent
studies by the General Accounting Office and by academics in
Washington State and New York found the same relationship. A
1999 study for Hewitt Associates by Hamid Mehran of
Northwestern University found that the returns on assets for
382 publicly traded ESOP companies was 2.7% per year greater
than what a model of their predicted performance would have
been. Studies on participative management alone find a small
positive impact on performance, but not nearly, enough to
explain the synergy between ownership and participation these
other studies have found.
Chapter-2
REVIEW OF
LITERATURE
Rosabeth Moss Kanter said, “Human beings are good raw
material, they become assets when you train them to increase
their knowledge and skills". She added that only a few
organisations really train people to make them a success.
Seconding this, Mr Peters pointed out how most organisations
are not serious about developing people. They spend on an
average 26.3 hours per person per year on training. A
surgeon, a pilot or an athlete on the other hand spends 10-
15 times more on training.
Tom Peters said, “We have transitioned from an asset-based
economy to a talent-based economy. The new definition of
lay-off is untalented go talented stay. Leaders must realise
that talent is equal to brand". His new theory is EVP which
means "Employee Value Proposition".
Universities like Cornell, MIT, Stanford, etc, have started
emphasizing e-learning to attract a worldwide audience. Web-
centric universities are becoming the order of the day.
William Taylor, editor and managing partner of the Fast Pace
magazine, said, "There is no going back from back from
dotcoms". He was of the opinion that there is a merger
taking place between computers and human beings. According
to a study carried out by Nasscom , there were more than
10,000 IT staff last year holding around 18 million ESOPs
valued at roughly Rs 12,000 crore($3 billion) at February
'00 prices. PramaNath
India's growth story has drastically slowed down due to the
cascading effect of the slow global economy. Organisations
are suffering, employees are confused and HR – the
profession – has been unofficially assigned the unenviable
task of retention, higher productivity, even helping
increase of sales revenue by using a synthesis of the tools
at its disposal and innovative thought leadership
People and knowledge retention during these tough times
will propel the talent management domain in the forefront
and ensure it doesn't remain consigned to a folder in the
laptop of the talent manager after the annual talent review
ritual. From using reliable tools in hiring and assessing
employees to developing high potential talent, creating a
strong leadership bench and work on a robust succession
planning strategy, talent management will become an
empirically substantiated document for the business and HR
leaders to retain people and curb knowledge transfer outside
the organisation.
The role of the Human Resources Department has changed
dramatically over the past 30 years and will become
increasingly more strategic in nature in the future, said a
leading light of the HR community in the recent 2006 Annual
Conference and Exposition of HR practitioners in Washington,
DC.
Rita Craig, president of the Craig Group and a long-time
professional HR consultant, said the role of HR has changed
from a primarily administrative position to one that is more
strategic. Times certainly have change from those days when
the HR department was called the "smile and file" department
since in that era, the primary qualifications for HR were
simply a friendly disposition and an ability to file.
She said that the emerging trends in HR call for HR
professionals to take the lead in planning for the future
and becoming strategic business partners in their
organizations. She identified several other trends in the
industry, as follows:
(1) a shrinking talent pool,
(2) An increase in outsourcing,
(3) A more intense focus on work/life balance;
(4) Changing workplace demographics,
(5) Greater need for talent management,
(6)Ethics requirements, and
(7)Globalization
The key appears to be strategic planning. With the changing
landscape of Human Resources management in the years to
come, strategic planning will be the key for HR to meet
those needs and to succeed. The key to HR planning for the
future begins with one simple question that HR professionals
have to ask themselves, says Craig: "If we are successful in
the years to come, what will our customers and competitors
be saying about us?” With the answers to this question, HR
practitioners can formulate a clear, shared vision and a
sense of direction for the organization. As a possible
starting point in providing answers to the key question,
Craig suggested the following: Focus resources on key goals
and strategic measures, create and sustain long-term
performance, and create a living document that can change
when necessary.
In closing, Craig warned against "powerful and pervasive
barriers" that prevent HR professionals from being effective
in their roles. She pinpointed these as resistance to
change, failure to implement plans, the wounds of past
strategic planning failures, and failure to anticipate the
impact on people, process and organizational structure.
To quote Thomas P. Foley, Secretary of the Pennsylvania
Department of Labor and Industry:” We’ve changed from the
idea of "one skill, one job" to the reality of a range of
skills that have to apply to a number of different kinds of
professions. More to the point, workers must possess a skill
that they continually upgrade just to keep pace in the
professions they choose."
OBJECTIVES OF STUDY
Following were the objectives of the study:-
1. To enlist emerging HR trends in Indian IT Industry
2. To find out lacking areas regarding the HRD in IT sector.
3. To measure the perceptions of IT sector employees in
respect of application of HRD in their organization.
4. To suggest the measures to fill the gaps and improve
motivation level of employees and HR management in IT
industry.
5. The goal of improved organizational effectiveness and an
orientation towards reengineering and skills guided the
development of the proposed job design approach.
SCOPE OF STUDY
Following were the scope of the study:-
To know the emerging HR trends in Indian IT Industry.
Give information about the Indian IT Industry.
To know about the HR problems of Indian IT Professionals.
Give information that what’s wrong seems to be the trend.
SIGNIFICANCE OF STUDY
Optimum Utilization of Human Resources
Healthy work environment –Due to study of HR trends in IT
Industry we find the deficiencies and helps in creating
the healthy working environment. It helps to build good
employee, relationship so that individual goals aligns
with organizational goal.
The study focused on the information technology community
and how works processes and activities could be better
organized to remove artificial barriers and improve
organizational effectiveness, a process often associated
with the term "reengineering.
The study focused on developing a job design approach
that could adapt to changing skill requirements and that
would promote the continuous acquisition of skills for
knowledge-based employees in information technology.
RESEARCH PROBLEM STATEMENT
Significant problem areas, which may be contributing to the
present scenario and can be addressed, can be identified as
given
Post employment care - The companies/organizations should take adequate interest in the career development of the
employee by suitable HRD approaches which should include the
following:
i. Opportunities for creative work in the first
phase particularly for those who are bright, and have an
aptitude and come with a good pedigree say from IITs.
ii. Opportunities to lessen the monotony and
improve interpersonal relationship
Recruitment process - Aptitude tests could be conducted byreputed institutes like IITs/ private organizations/HR
agencies for prospective professionals preferably ``on-line''
like GRE, GMAT etc. or physically at regular intervals and
scores are given. If it is no on-line, the periodicity can be
a month or two and the validity can be for an year or so which
can also be fixed based on general agreement.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
"A research is a careful investigation or inquiry especially
through search for new facts in any branch of knowledge; it is
a systematized effort to gain more knowledge"
(A)Types of research
Types of Research selected for this project is
EXPLORATARY .In exploratory research design we focused the
objective of the study, method of data collection and then
select the sample. After collection the data we analyses
and at last interoperate the final result & finds the best
solution of particular problem. In Quantitative research is
based on the measurement of quantity or amount. It is
applicable to phenomena that can be expressed in terms of
quantity
(B) Sampling methodology
Sample Size - 100 respondents.
Sample Unit-Employees were selected among the executives and
staff working in various IT organizations.
Sampling Area- India IT sector
Sampling Technique - Random Sampling technique.
(C)Method of data collection
Primary data has been used in the form of Questionnaire the survey was based on structured questionnaire. The
questionnaire was mainly based on objective type close-ended
question, but few open ended questions were also included. The
pilot survey on ten randomly selected respondents was
undertaken. Then the questionnaire was modified accordingly
Secondary data has been used from various internet sites such
as motorola.com & google.com has been used.
Chapter–5
DATA ANALYSIS
AND
INTERPRETATION
Indian IT sector is contributing a large in employment and
foreign exchange. A developing country like India can ill
afford continued conflict ridden; rigid and litigation
oriented Industrial Relations.
What employees perceive about the emerging HR trends of the IT
organisation has been measured.
To measure the success and failures of emerging HR trends of
Indian IT Industry a structured questionnaire is prepared for
this purpose.
The questionnaire included both open ended and close-ended
questions. The questionnaire used is placed at Appendix "I".
The procedure adopted for data collection was interview
with the employees randomly selected from IT organization to
the extent possible and also through mail. .
The responses given by the respondents were
recorded on the questionnaire. The view expressed by the
respondents has been analyzed in the succeeding paragraphs.
About 100 respondents were selected by convenient random
sampling technique.
RESPONDENTS PROFILE - EDUCATION-WISE
The main features of the employees randomly selected sex-wise,
education-wise and type of functions wise has been provided
here in the succeeding paras.
The 54 per cent of the respondents were Male and 46 per cent
of the respondents were Female
Respondents'
Qualification
Percentage Of
RespondentsNon-Tech Graduate and
Below
11%
Non-Tech Post
Graduate
23%
B.Tech/ BCA etc. 34%M.Tech/MCA Etc. 32%TOTAL 100%
DATA ANALYSIS OF THE RESPONSES OBTAINED FROM
EMPLOYEES .
1. Whether Indian IT Industry needs a trade union or
management's?
Respondents grading with %: No trade union (21%) Single
trade union (13%) Multi trade union (09%) Only welfare
association (57%)
Interpretation –The respondents were asked to comment upon
whether Indian IT Industry needs a trade union or managements
are looking after the employee’s interest in the best possible
manner. The largest 57 percent of the respondent’s view that
there should be only welfare association in Indian IT
industry. 21% need no trade union and 13% like single trade
union only. 9 percent of the respondents opted for multi trade
union.
2. In your view whether excessive competition in Indian IT
sector is harming the overall long term prospects of
employees in this sector?
Respondent’s observations with % - Yes (53%)
No (35%) No comments (12%)
Interpretation: Whether excessive competition in Indian IT
sector is harming the overall long term prospects of employees
in this sector the respondent’s opinion is that 53 percent of
the respondents has replied in Yes to this question. While 35%
has a negative viewpoint & 12% Respondents no reply.
3. Whether IT industry can afford old traditional trade union
methods of agitations like Strike or Gherao etc.?
Respondent’s observations with % - Yes (67%) No
(28%) No comments (05%)
Interpretation: Whether IT industry can afford old traditional
trade union methods of agitations like Strike or Gherao etc.
was also asked from the employees. The question was direct in
nature of Yes or No. 67% of the respondents has given their
reply in No and 28% answered in affirmative. 5% has ticked No
Comments choice. So, it is concluded that old agitational
techniques of trade unions are not desired in IT industry.
4. Existing Indian labour Laws/Rules are not strictly applicable to Indian IT Industry as IT sector employees are
quite different from general factory workers and are well
educated and trained. The separate Labour Laws/Rules should be
designed for IT Industry?
Respondent’s observations with % -Strongly agree (57%)
agree (32%) No comments (11%)
Interpretation: Existing Indian labour
Laws/Rules are not strictly applicable to Indian IT Industry
as IT sector employees are quite different from general
factory workers and are well educated and trained. The
separate Labour to whether as Laws/Rules should be designed
for IT Industry: This hypothesis was presented to the
respondents. They were to respond up to which extent they
agree or disagree. The comfortable majorities of respondents
(89%) strongly agree or agree with the hypothesis that Indian
IT sector requires separate labour management system/
regulations. While only minority of 13% has given divergent
views.
5. What the HR managers of Indian IT sector should do to
increase the retentivity rate of its employees?
Respondents' Suggestions with %: Increase wages to international levels (22%), Increase foreign postings (36%),
Increase profit sharing (10%), More promotions (11%), Others
(21%)
Interpretation: A 22% of the respondents has suggested
increasing the wages to international level to increase
employees retentively in Indian IT industry. 36% want more
foreign postings, 10% suggest increase profit sharing and 11%
suggested more promotions. 21% of the other suggestions
included lateral induction from lower the institutes and
better HR management.
6. The most of the employees of Indian IT sector or highly
educated and sensitive in nature. Moreover, the
opportunities outside are very attractive, Whether Indian
IT Industry is able to retain its employees?
Respondent’s observations with % - Yes (61%) No
(23%) No comments (16%)
Interpretation: The most of the employees of IT sector are
highly educated and sensitive in nature. Moreover, the
opportunities outside are very attractive, whether Indian IT
Industry is able to retain its employees was the next opinion
query from the randomly selected IT industry employees. 61% of
the employees view that Indian IT companies are unable to
retain its employees due to most attractive avenues outside.
Only 23% viewed that they are able to retain the employees.
7. What is the state of employee employer relationship in
Your Organisation?
Respondents grading with %: Excellent (14%) Very Good (44%)
Satisfactory (28%) Poor (14%)
Interpretation: Cordial employee employer relationship is very
essential in the upcoming highly competitive economy. The
state of employee employer relationship in Indian IT Industry
was measured through the next question. The state of
employee-employer relationship is not very encouraging. 58
percent of the respondents has graded it very good and above.
While 42 percent consider it satisfactory and below. The
employment of modern technology requires more positive and
effective relationship between management and the employees.
Indian IT Industry has very effective employee employer
relationship.
8. Whether IT Industry has a Positive attitude towards its
employees?
Respondent’s observations with % - Yes (43%) No
(48%) No comments (9%)
Interpretation: It has been found that
in many organisations the management ignores the employee’s
welfare for their profit sake and does not give proper
attention towards employee’s career and prospects. What is the
state of affairs in IT Industry in India was quizzed from our
valued learned respondents. The results are mixed one. While
48% of the respondents' replied in negative and 43% gave a
positive reply. So, there is a profit motive operating more
than employees proper welfare management in Indian IT Industry
9."The grievances of the employees in Indian IT sectors are
handled properly". To what extent do you with this statement.
Respondents' Observation with % : Strongly Agree (12%)Agree (39%) No Comments (14%) Disagree Strongly (26%)
Disagree (09%)
Interpretation: The respondents responses to the status of
grievances handling mechanism was through an indirect
approach. In this Question the respondents
were to comment upon the positive hypothesis that grievance
handling is done properly in the IT organisation. The five
choices provided were strongly agree, agree, no comments,
disagree and strongly disagree. Only 12 respondents strongly
agree to the statement and similarly a small number of 9
respondents strongly disagreed with this. Only 14 percent have
nothing to comment. 39 percent agree that the grievance
handling IN Indian IT industry is done properly and remaining
26 percent disagree with it.
10. Whether new compensating methods being adopted by the various IT companies are positively affecting the employee’s
welfare?
Respondent’s observations with % positive effect (46%)
negative affect (19%) no effect (26%) Can’t say (9%)
Interpretation: The IT industry has been devising newer
compensation methods like Profit Sharing/ Stock Options etc.
to increase employee welfare and retentively. Whether these
new compensation techniques are positively effecting or not
was the key point in our next question. 46% of the employees
opined that newer compensation methods has a positive effect
in IT industry while 19% said that it has a negative effect
on employee welfare. 26% view that it has no major effect and
9 percent has replied in CAN NOT SAY. . In the initial stages
when IT Industry was sunrise, the employees and when an IT
industry share price has gone down mostly welcomed it. It has
a negative effect
11. Whether you feel that HR needs of Indian IT sector is
different from old HR practices?
Respondent’s observations with % - Yes (69%) No (23%) no comments (8%)
Interpretation: Through the Question of the questionnaire,
the respondents were asked to comment whether the HR
needs of Indian IT industry are different from traditional HR
Management systems. It was a direct question in Yes/NO/No
comments format and IT professionals selected for survey were
asked to tick one of the choices as mentioned. The majority of
respondents (69%) view that HR needs of IT industry are
different from old economy sector and HR managers in IT
industry has to keep this into mind. Being highly educated
employees are very sensitive in pride and behavior.
Chapter –6
FINDINGS
AND
CONCLUSION
FINDINGS :
As per the survey result Indian IT sector feel different HR
needs.
New compensation techniques in Indian IT Industry are giving
positive effect.
Employees Grievances are not properly handled in these
Industries.
Good relationship between employee and employer in Indian IT
Industry.
Indian IT companies are unable to retain its employees due
to most attractive avenues outside.
Excessive competition in Indian IT sector is harming the
overall long term prospects of employees in this sector.
Shortage of IT workers in India.
More employees say that negative attitude of IT sector
towards its employees.
CONCLUSION:
It can be concluded that Emerging HR trends of Indian It
industry are quite different from the old economy
industry.
India is considered one of Super Power in Information
Technology and allied fields.
Majority of world leaders in IT sector are outsourcing
their requirements from Indian IT Industry and recruiting
Indian IT professionals.
The Indian Government must allow the Industry to meet
international competition and desired environment in
respect of Labour Laws and financial rules must be
liberalized for this Indian IT Industry.
HR managers in Indian IT Industry must keep the sensitive
nature of IT professionals and state of greater
opportunities outside in mind for devising HR policies
for their organization.
China is also entering this area vigorously and
Government of India must help Indian It industry to meet
this challenge.
AND
LIMITATIONS
SUGESSATIONS :
It is found that in these Industries employees grievance
are not properly handled so for retaining the employee
first of all employee grievance are handled.
Indian IT Industry want that they provide the attractive
avenues to its employee for retaining good employee.
Provide the training & development program time to time
to employee for meeting the competition.
The main problem of Indian IT sector is hoe they retain
the employee , so Indian IT sector want that they provide
the job security to employee.
LIMITATIONS:
Employees by and large are reluctant in expressing their
feelings/thoughts in the Questionnaire and tend to be
biased.
The Organization is reluctant to openly share
data/information and tend to keep sensitive
data/information confidential which is understandable.
Some personnel in the Organization, irrespective of their
seniority, cannot pay adequate attention to the requests
of such studies given the constraints of time and the
work pressures prevalent in the Industry today.
Long term perspective
QUESTIONNAIRE FOR PROJECT STUDY ON EMERGING HR
TRENDS IN INDIAN IT INDUSTRY
Dear Sir/Madam,
I am a management student of Fore School of Management. As
part of course I a undertaking this project study. I would a
request you to kindly answer a few questions. This
questionnaire gives you the opportunity to express your
opinion regarding various aspects of emerging HR trends in
Indian a new IT Sector.
As a you are all aware that Information Technology (IT)
industry is achieving a great success in Indian employment
context. As you are to a part of IT industry and must be
observing that the HR trends of IT sector are quite different
from the conventional old economy sectors.
The results shall be submitted to the university in the report
format for the usage of researchers and other concerned
authorities. As is the case for entire study, no individual
will be identified. Only group averages will be reported.
Thanking You
Date.....
Personal Profile of the Respondent
1. (a) Place of survey..................................
(b) Name.............................................
(c) Address...........................................
(d) Male/Female.......................................
(e) Educational qualifications:
(i) Non Tech Graduate or below
(ii) Non-Tech Post-Graduate
(iii) B.Tech/BCA etc.
(IV) M.Tech/MCA/MBA
(f) Your Nature of Job:
(i) Computer Hardware
(ii) Computer Software
(iii) Marketing Services of IT
(iv) HR/ Personnel management
2. Whether do you feel there is any roll of trade union in the
IT Industry?
(i) No Trade Union
(ii) Single Union
(iii) Multi Union
(iv) Only welfare association
(iv) Can not say
3. In your view whether excessive competition in Indian IT
sector is harming the overall long term prospects of employees
in this sector.
(i) Yes
(ii) No
(iii) No Comments
4. Whether old methods of employee’s association/trade union
like strike or Gherao etc. are desirable in Indian IT Sector
(Please Tick)
(i) Yes
(ii) No
(iii) No Comments
5. "Existing Indian labour Laws/Rules are not strictly
applicable to Indian IT Industry as IT sector employees are
quite different from general factory workers and are well
educated and trained. The separate Labour Laws/Rules should be
designed for IT Industry:. Do you agree with this proposition?
(i) Strongly Agree
(ii) Agree
iii) No Comments
(iv) Disagree
(v) Strongly Disagree
6. "Existing Indian labour Laws/Rules are not strictly
applicable to Indian IT Industry as IT sector employees are
quite different from general factory workers and are well
educated and trained. The separate Labour Laws/Rules should be
designed for IT Industry:. Do you agree with this proposition?
(i) Strongly Agree
(ii) Agree
iii) No Comments
(iv) Disagree
(v) Strongly Disagree
7. What is the state of employee employer relationship in Your
Organisation
(i) Excellent
(ii) Very Good
(iii) Satisfactory
(iv) Poor
8. "An Indian IT sector company has a positive attitude
towards its employees and is not neglecting their welfare and
prospects for their profit sake." Do you agree with the
statement?
(i) Yes
(ii) No
(iii) No Comments
9. "The grievances of the employees in Indian IT sectors are
handled properly". To what extent do you with this statement.
(i) Strongly Agree
(ii) Agree
(iii)No Comments
(iv) Disagree
(v) Strongly Disagree
10. Whether new compensating methods being adopted by the
various IT companies are positively effecting the employees’
welfare?
(i) Positive Effect
(ii) Negative Effect
(iii) No Effect
(iv) Can Not Say
11. Whether you feel that HR needs of Indian IT sector are
different from old HR practices.(Please Tick)
(i) Yes
(ii) No
(iii) Can Not Say
12. Please give your comments and suggestions to bring further
improvement in HR Management in Indian IT Industry.
Thank You,
BOOKS REFERENCE:
Burack, E.R. & Mc. Nicholos, T.J. Human Research
Planning: Technology, Policy and & Change, The
Comparative Administration Research Institute of the
Centre for Business and Economic Research, College of
Business Administration, Kent State University, 1973.
Edwards, John et.al., "Manpower Planning", John Wiley,
New York..,1983
Gelden, P Stevan," Report Writing for Business and
Industry", Business Communication Service.
Kothari, CR." research Methodology Methods and tech-
niques", Wiley Eastern Limited.
Lawler III, Edward E., "Control Systems in
Organizations," In Handbook of Industrial and
Organizational Psychology, (Rand-Menally, 1976).
Mustafi, CK 1981. "Statistical Methods in Managerial
Decisions, Macmillon New Delhi.
Pareek, U and T.V.Rao, 1981, "Designing and Managing
Human Resource Systems", Oxford and IBH Publishing Co.,
New Delhi.
Ramaswamy, E.A. & Uma Ramaswam. "Industry and Labour",
Oxford Press: New Delhi, 1981.
Rao, T.V. and Pereira, D.F., Recent Experiences in HRD,
New Delhi, Oxford & IBH, 1985.
Rao, T.V. and Abraham, E.A.," A Survey of HRD Practices
in Indian Industry, in Rao, T.V. and Pereira, D.F.,
Recent Experiences in HRD, New Delhi, Oxford & IBH, 1985
13. Silvera, D.M., "Human Resource Development", 1988,
The Indian Experience.Higher Education and IT:
Websites Reference
www.google.com
www.wikipedia.com
www.investopedia.com
www.kml.com
www.businesslink.gov.com
www.altavista.com
www.yagoohoogle.com
www.beemadeals.com