Upload
others
View
4
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
iFlip–FlippingtheClassroominadulteducation2015-2018Project-ID:Erasmus+15-204-012651
1. ExecutiveSummary
1.1. ReportThisreport,writtenbytheArteveldeUniversityCollege(AHS)-projectteam,reflectsthemonitoringandevaluatingofthepilotcoursescreatedwiththeuseoftheFlippingtheClassroom(FTC)methodology.FTCisablendedlearningstrategywiththeaimtoimprovelearnerengagementandoutcomes.Thelearningmethod,amixofindependentlylearningandface-to-faceclassroomteaching,islearneroriented.Thoughitcanbeusedfordifferenttargetgroups,itisverysuitableforadultlearners,especiallybecauseitallowsthemtoacquirethelearningcontentattheirownpace.ThreecourseswerepreparedbythegroupofeducatorswhoweretakingthespecialisedFTC-traininginGhent,taughtbyLutDeJaegherandDriesVanAckerforArteveldeUniversityCollege:
• MasterclassFlippingtheClassroom(PilotBE-01)• Vlogforeducationalpurposes(PilotBE-02)• Socialanddigitalmedialiteracy(PilotBE-03)
14%2019.03.56.png?dl=0
2
Thecourseswereofferedfreeofcharged,andwereannouncedandopenforregistrationduringtheposterpresentationevent(https://www.arteveldehogeschool.be/oso/posterpresentatie/)atArteveldeUniversityCollegeon21/06/2017,with200participantsfromsecondaryandadulteducationschools.
3
Atotalof81peopleappliedforparticipationtothepilotsbyprovidingtheiremailandname.Atwhole60participatedandfinishedandanother21willtakethecoursefromMarchtoJune2018becauseitfitsbetterintheirschedule.Theregistrationfortheonlinepartsstillremainsopenandwillbeleftopeninthefollowingyearsformorelearners.Thecourseswereannouncedaspilots,andeachlearnercouldtakethewholecourseorapartaccordingtohisorherinterestsandpace.Itwasinterestingtoseethatsomeofthelearnerswereworkingontheonlinepartsallbythemselves,whileotherswereworkinginpairstolearnthecontent.SomeofthemwerenotonlyexperiencingthisFTCteachingmethodusingthepilot,butalsostartedexperimentinghowtocreatetheirownF2Fcourse.Theeducatorsdidagoodjob,creatinginteresting,participativeandattractivecoursesthatwerehighlyappreciatedbythelearnersascanbedeductedfromresultsoftheevaluationofthepilotswiththestandardisedquestionnairesdevelopedbytheiFlippartners.
14%2019.03.56.png?dl=0
4
1.2. BackgroundinformationThe3coursesweredevelopedandcreatedbythesameteachersthatfollowedtheFCTtraininginGhentinApril2017.Eachofthemcreatedcoursesaccordingtotheirknowledgeandinterests.Theychoosecontentsthatcanseamlesslybeimplementedforadulteducationinawiderangeoftraininginstitutes.The3coursescanbefoundontheLMSenvironmentoftheArteveldeUniversityCollege(Chamilo)andontheiFlip-website.
Thenamesofthecoursesare:
• iFlippilotBE01:Vloggeninonderwijs• iFlippilotBE02:Socialeendigitalemediageletterdheid• iFlippilotBE03:Masterclassflippingtheclassroom
5
2. CourseintroductionThethreepilotsstartedatdifferenttimes:10thofDecember2017,12thofDecember2017and15thofDecember2017.Theycouldbeaccessedfreelyafterregistrationwithnameande-mailaddress.
14%2019.03.56.png?dl=0
6
2.1. Vloggeninonderwijs26learnersappliedforthiscourseand21pilotsessionswereregistered.Thecoursestartedon15thofDecemberandendedon10thofJanuary.
7
2.2. Socialeendigitalemediageletterdheid24learnersappliedforthiscourseand16pilotsessionswereregistered.Thecoursestartedon12thofDecemberandendedon10thofJanuary.
14%2019.03.56.png?dl=0
8
2.3. iFlipMasterclass31learnersappliedforthiscourseand23pilotsessionswereregistered.Thecoursestartedon12thofDecemberandendedon10thofJanuary.Theonlinecourseisstillopenforaccess.AsteachinginEnglishiscommoninBelgium,thiscoursewasmadeinEnglish,tomakesureawiderrangeofadulteducatorscanuseit.TranslationsinDutchcanbeprovidedifnecessary.
9
3. Referencedocuments
3.1. MoodlecontentofthepilotsThelessoncontentispresentedinavarietyofways,asprovidedintheLMSprogram(Moodle)usedforthedevelopmentofthepilots,andastaughtduringthetraininginGhent.
3.1.1. CoursecontentInthethreecoursestheresourcesarepresentedasbook,file,folder,label,pageorURL.ThewaytheseresourcesareusedcanbeseenwhenopeningthecourseURL’sonthewebsiteofiFlip.Importantforthisreportishowtheeducatorsandeducatorsexperiencedtheuseofthedifferentresources:
TEACHERS
Book:usefulforprovidingahandbookwiththewholecoursecontent,asareferencebook
File:Usefulforfilesthathavetobedownloaded,forexaPowerPoint
Folder:Notusedverymuchduringthepilots,canbeusefultostructure
Notused
Label:ascoursecreatorlabelsareusefultodistinguishtopicsandcontentinthecoursestructure
Page:mostlyusedfortext,images,video’setc,anfrequentlyusedoption
URL:forlinkstowebsites,othertopicsinthecourse,video’s(thecoursewillloadquickerwhenvideo’sarejustlinksinsteadofuploaded)
14%2019.03.56.png?dl=0
10
Examples:• iFlippilotBE01:Vloggeninonderwijs:
Thiscourseislearnsadulteducatorsandlearnershowtocreateandusevlogsandvideolessonsforteachingandlearning.Thecontentcanalsobeveryusefulforteachingandlearningonlineentrepreneurshipandinfopreneurship.
• iFlippilotBE02:Socialeendigitalemediageletterdheid:thiscourseisdevelopedto
makelearnersdigitalandsocialmedianatives.
• iFlippilotBE03:Masterclassflippingtheclassroom:thiscourseisdevelopedto
leteducatorsandlearnerscreateandco-createcontentinaLMS-environment.
3.1.2. MediaThemediausedinthethreecoursesarevideo,pictures,podcastsandPowerPointpresentationswithspokentext.
11
Thevideosaremostlyuploadedtotheteachers’channelonYouTubewithalinkintheLMScourse.Forthevideorecordingtheeducatorsusedasimplestandalonecamera,asmartphoneoraniPad.Tomakesurethesoundisclear,thesoundwascapturedseparatelyfromtheimages,withanexternalmicroorahandyrecorder(H4nPro),whichgaveaperfectsoundwithoutnoise.
EducatorsandlearnerslikedverymuchtheanimationsmadewithIntroLite,averyeasytouseandfreetabletapp.
14%2019.03.56.png?dl=0
12
3.1.3. InteractivityToensureinteractivitytheeducatorsusedseveraltools(forexamplePadlet,discussionforum,andsurvey).ThePadletsareintegratedinalabelorpagewithuseofhtml-code:Theinteractivityisusefulfortheeducatorstohaveanideaofthelearners’thoughts,whereasforthelearnersitisinterestingtofeelpartofalearningcommunity.
3.1.4. Evaluationandfeedback
Feedbackandevaluationtoolsusedinthepilotsare:
• assignment• choice• feedback• forum• quiz• survey
13
4. Curriculaofthetrainingprogrammes
4.1. iFlippilotBE01Thiscourseisdesignedfor16hoursnon-attendede-learningand6hoursattendedF2F-learning.Usingsubjectrelatedvlogsforeducationalpurposes1.Preparingcontent2.Technicalpreparation3.Recordingthecontent4.Editingthecontent5.Publication5.1.Makingachannel5.2.Organizationofachannel5.3.OnlineEnterpreneurship(infopreneurship)
14%2019.03.56.png?dl=0
14
4.2. iFlippilotBE02Thiscourseisdesignedfor20hoursnon-attendede-learningand8hoursattendedF2F-learning.Socialanddigitalmedialiteracy1.Whatismedialiteracy2.Gettinghookedonsocialanddigitalmedia3.Socialanddigitalmediaexplained3.1.TV,radio,movies,series3.2.Google3.3.Facebook3.4.Twitter3.5.Othersocialmedia
4.3. iFlippilotBE03Thiscourseisdesignedfor18hoursnon-attendede-learningand6hoursattendedF2F-learning.MasterclassFTC1.Didactics2.E-learningplatformtools3.Media4.Creation5.Presentation6.Inspiration
15
5. EvaluationTheevaluationofthepilotsisdonebystandardizedquestionnairesforlearnersandtrainers,developedbyAkademiaHumanistyczno-EkonomicznawLodzifortheiFlipproject.Thesequestionnaireswereonlypresentedtolearnerswhoregisteredandparticipatedatthecourse.Theparticipationgradetothecourseswas74%.Peoplewhoregisteredbutdidn’tparticipatewereinterestedbutdroppedoffbecauseoflackoftime.15%ofthemdeclaredthewishtotakethecourseattheirownpaceandatamomentthatfitsbetterintheirtimeschedule.80%fromthelearnerswhoparticipatedatthecourseattendedtheF2Fclasses.27learnersfilledinthequestionnaireattheendofthecourse,9iFlippilotBE01(BE01),8iFlippilotBE02(BE02)and9iFlippilotBE03(BE03).
5.1. Personalinformationparticipants(ageandgender)
0
5
10
25-3031-40
41-5051-60
>60
Participants
25-30 31-40 41-50 51-60 >60BE01 9 0 0
BE02 4 3 1
BE03 6 2 1
Ageoflearnersperpilot
BE01
BE02
BE03
010
2030
femalemale
female malegender 21 5
Genderofparticipants
14%2019.03.56.png?dl=0
16
5.2. Adultlearnersevaluation:results
verynegnegneutralposverypos0
123456789
Learners
Usableindailylife
Learningcorrespondinterest
Trainingtimeaprropriate
Trainerabletoanswerquestions
Methodhelpslearningandunderstandin
g
Trainertakestimeforexpaining
Methodeasytouse
Methodhelpfulinlearning
Clearinstructions
Numberoflearners
appropriate
Equipmentappropriate
Recommendcoursetrainintoothers
veryneg
neg 1 1 1
neutral 2 1 1 1 1 1 1
pos 5 4 3 3 2 3 2 3 4 1
verypos 1 4 4 9 5 9 5 6 6 6 4 8
AdultlearnerevaluationpilotBE01
17
verynegnegneutralposverypos0
0,5
1
1,5
2
2,5
3
3,5
4
4,5
5
learners
Usableindailylife
Learningcorrespondinterest
Trainingtimeaprropriate
Trainerabletoanswerquestions
Methodhelpslearningandunderstandin
g
Trainertakestimeforexpaining
Methodeasytouse
Methodhelpfulinlearning
Clearinstructions
Numberoflearners
appropriate
Equipmentappropriate
Recommendcoursetrainintoothers
veryneg
neg 2 1
neutral 2 1 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1
pos 3 4 3 3 1 4 5 3 1 5 1 2
verypos 3 3 2 5 5 3 1 4 5 2 4 5
AdultlearnerevaluationpilotBE02
14%2019.03.56.png?dl=0
18
verynegnegneutralposverypos0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Learners
Usableindailylife
Learningcorrespondinterest
Trainingtimeaprropriate
Trainerabletoanswerquestions
Methodhelpslearningandunderstandin
g
Trainertakestimeforexpaining
Methodeasytouse
Methodhelpfulinlearning
Clearinstructions
Numberoflearners
appropriate
Equipmentappropriate
Recommendcoursetrainintoothers
veryneg
neg 1 1
neutral 5 1 1 1 1 2 1 1
pos 3 4 2 5 1 3 2 2 4 1
verypos 4 6 9 4 9 7 6 6 4 4 7
9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9
AdultlearnerevaluationpilotBE03
19
5.3. Adultlearnersevaluation:conclusions
5.3.1. iFlippilotBE01Learnersevaluatethispilotpositively.Thefactthatthere’sapositivetoverypositivescorefor“methodhelpslearningandunderstanding”and“helpfulinlearning”provesthatFTCisasuccessfulteachingandlearningmethod.Attentionshouldbepaidto“trainingtime”(1negative).Aslearnershaveavarietyofbackgrounds,noteverylearnerlearnsatthesamepace.Differentiationshouldbepossibleatanytime.Exceptfor1learner,allothersfindthepilotcontentusableindailylife.Thewrittencommentfromthislearnerwas:“Iwouldverymuchliketousethis,butIcan’timaginefindingthetimetodoso”.Writtencomments:
ü “Veryinteresting”ü “Nicetoworkthisway”ü “goodtrainer”ü “Iwouldverymuchliketousethis,butIcan’timaginefindingthetimetodoso”
5.3.2. iFlippilotBE02Learnersevaluatethispilotpositivetoverypositive,aswellasconcerningthemethod,thecontentandtheF2Flessons.Learnersfindthemethodeasytouseandhelpfulinlearningandwereunanimouslypositiveaboutthetrainers’support.Attentionshouldbepaidtothetrainingtimeandtheequipment.Theeducatorsexperiencedthisindeed.Thoughthelessoncontentispreparedinawaytomakeitpossibleforeverylearnertofolloweverysubject,forsomethiswasn’teasybecausetheydidn’thaveanypre-knowledgeaboutsomeofthesubjects.Learnerswouldrecommendthecoursetoothers.Writtencomments:
ü “Iwillverymuchrecommendotherstousethiscourse”ü “Ilearnedalot”ü “Ididn’thaveenoughtimetothroughallthecontentandassignments”ü “Ishouldhavehadmoreforeknowledge”ü “Iwouldsurelyliketousethiscourseinthefuture”
14%2019.03.56.png?dl=0
20
5.3.3. iFlippilotBE03Thiscoursewasverymuchappreciatedbythelearners.Impressiveisthehighscoreforthe2questionsconcerningtheteacheroreducator.Thiscouldleadtotheconclusionthatcoursesorhighlyappreciatedwhentheteacheroreducatorisverymuchconcernedandreadytosupportandanswerquestionsatanytime.Thefactthatthere’s1learnerwhofindstheinstructionsjustclearenough(neutral),whereasalltheothersfindtheinstructionsclear(good,verygood)pointsoutapointofattention.Learnersshouldalwaysmakesurethateveryoneunderstandstheinstructions.Writtencomments:
ü “greattrainer”ü “nice”ü “Ididn’tunderstandsomeoftheinstructions”ü “thetrainerdidagoodjob”ü “interesting,thanksalot”ü “Ifeelinspired”
5.4. Educators’evaluationFromthepointofviewoftheeducators,thethreetrainedteacherswhompreparedthepilotsgavethisfeedback:
ü Ittakesmuchtimetodevelopthematerialbutitisinterestingtoexplorethepossibilitiesofthemethodandtheusedapplications
ü EducatorsneedasolidbasicICT-knowledgeü Thematerialcaneasilybedevelopedwithfreesoftwareandbasichardware,but
themoreyouarerecognizingandappreciatingthestrengths,themoreyouexperiencetheneedofforexamplehigherqualityvideoandsoundcapturehardwareandsoftware
ü Theapproachandtheusedtechniquesisinnovativeandgivesanewdrivetoteachinganddevelopingeducationalmaterial
ü Aseducator,youneedtobeaccessibleforhelptothelearnersü Thereshouldbeacertificationsystemthatmakessurepeoplewhosubscribetoa
pilotreallytakepartofthecourseü TheLMSprovidesaninterestingopportunitytofollowthecoursecontent
completionbythelearnersü Interestingmethodfordifferentiationandstudentcenteredteaching
21
5.5. ConclusionandrecommendationsTheFTCmethodishighlyappreciatedbyeducatorsandlearners.Theresources,inawidevariety(video,PowerPointwithspokentext,text,pictures,linkstowebsitesandonlinematerial,podcastsetc)givelearnerstheopportunitytolearnattheirownpace.Whilepreparingthepilots,theeducatorsdiscoveredmoreandmorepossibilitiestouseinteractivity,givefeedback,organisethecontent.Itinspiredthemtobecomemoreandmorecreativeindevelopingandpresentingthecontentandtoinstallfeedback,discussionandworksessions.Foradultlearners,FTCandthevariationofmediaandotherresourcesusedmadethecontentattractiveandinterestingtolearnandgavethepossibilitytorecapture,rewind,getandgivefeedback,discusswithpeersandeducatorsandtoaskquestions.TheF2Fmomentswereexperiencedasintenseandinteresting,bothforthelearnersandtheeducators,becausethelearnerscametoclasswithalotoffeedback,questions,ideas.AlllefttheF2Fmomentswithalotofinspiration.NowthatthepilotsarerealizedandtheknowhowtodevelopcoursecontentwiththeFTCmethod,thetechniquewillbeinstalledinthecurriculumoftheteachertraininginArteveldehogeschool.With1500studentsstudyingtobecomeateacherinsecondaryeducationandalargeamountofteachers,alsofromadulteducation,attendingtheArteveldehogeschoolforatrainingorcompletioncourse,manyfutureeducatorscanbeinstructedandguidedintheuseofFTC.TheteachereducatorsfromtheArteveldehogeschoolwillalsogetnumerousofopportunitiestobetrainedintheFTCmethod.ThematerialdevelopedforiFlipwillbeveryusefultorealizethis.
14%2019.03.56.png?dl=0
22
6. Pictures