Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Ven
dor
Wor
ksho
p
June
201
2
Bal
tim
ore
MD
Bal
tim
ore,
MD
App
licat
ion
of C
omm
erci
al-G
rade
Ded
icat
ion
Pau
l Pre
scot
tC
QV
B/D
CIP
/NR
O1
CQ
VB
/DC
IP/N
RO
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
de It
em D
edic
atio
nTo
pics
•C
omm
erci
al-G
rade
Ded
icat
ion
Com
mer
cial
Gra
de D
edic
atio
n–
Nec
essa
ry E
lem
ents
Indu
stry
/NR
CG
uida
nce
–In
dust
ry/N
RC
Gui
danc
e•
Exa
mpl
e C
ompo
nent
•S
afet
y C
lass
ifica
tion
•C
omm
erci
al-G
rade
Item
Det
erm
inat
ion
•C
omm
erci
al-G
rade
Ded
icat
ion
Pro
cess
•D
edic
atio
n‘T
raps
’•
Ded
icat
ion
Trap
s2
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
de D
edic
atio
n:
Nec
essa
ry E
lem
ents
•E
ngin
eerin
g In
volv
emen
t
•D
ocum
enta
tion
Et
bli
hd
P•
Est
ablis
hed
Pro
cess
3
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
de D
edic
atio
n:In
dust
ry/N
RC
Gui
danc
e
•E
PR
I NP
-565
2, “G
uide
line
for t
he U
tiliz
atio
n of
,
Com
mer
cial
Gra
de It
ems
in N
ucle
ar S
afet
y R
elat
ed
App
licat
ions
(NC
IG-0
7)”
•G
L 89
-02,
“Act
ions
to Im
prov
e th
e D
etec
tion
of
Cou
nter
feit
and
Frau
dule
ntly
Mar
kete
dP
rodu
cts”
Cou
nter
feit
and
Frau
dule
ntly
Mar
kete
d P
rodu
cts
–C
ondi
tiona
lly e
ndor
sed
EP
RI N
P-5
652
•G
L 91
-05,
“Lic
ense
e C
omm
erci
al-G
rade
Pro
cure
men
t an
d D
edic
atio
n P
rogr
ams”
4
–Id
entif
ied
wea
knes
ses
in li
cens
ee d
edic
atio
n pr
ogra
ms
foun
d du
ring
insp
ectio
ns
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
de D
edic
atio
n:
Glo
be V
alve
Exa
mpl
e
•N
on –
AS
ME
•1
inch
Glo
be
Val
ve
•C
lass
600
5
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
de D
edic
atio
n:
Saf
ety
Cla
ssifi
catio
n
•W
hati
sth
esa
fety
clas
sific
atio
nof
the
valv
e?W
hat i
s th
e sa
fety
cla
ssifi
catio
n of
the
valv
e?Is
the
Val
ve p
art o
fa
safe
ty s
yste
m?
NO
yy
App
endi
x B
, Par
t 21
Not
requ
ired
YES
Doe
s th
e va
lve
perfo
rm a
saf
ety
func
tion?
NO
YES
YES
Pro
cure
safe
ty-r
elat
edP
rocu
reas
CG
I
6
Pro
cure
saf
ety
rela
ted
from
3rd
Par
tyD
edic
atio
n Fa
cilit
yIn
voke
Par
t 21
Pro
cure
as
CG
IP
erfo
rm C
omm
erci
al-
Gra
de D
edic
atio
n(C
GD
)
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
de It
em D
eter
min
atio
n
Doe
sth
eal
em
eett
hecr
iteria
fora
•D
oes
the
valv
e m
eet t
he c
riter
ia fo
r a
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
de It
em (C
GI)?
–N
ot d
esig
ned
and
man
ufac
ture
d as
a b
asic
co
mpo
nent
–C
ritic
al C
hara
cter
istic
s ca
n be
ver
ified
7
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
deD
edic
atio
nP
roce
ssC
omm
erci
alG
rade
Ded
icat
ion
Pro
cess
•W
hat i
s de
dica
tion?
•Te
chni
cal E
valu
atio
n–
Iden
tifie
s te
chni
cal a
nd q
ualit
y re
quire
men
ts•
Dev
elop
tech
nica
l eva
luat
ion
from
:Li
d–
Lice
nsee
doc
umen
ts–
Ven
dor D
esig
n do
cum
ents
Failu
rem
ode
and
effe
ctan
alys
is–
Failu
re m
ode
and
effe
ct a
naly
sis
–E
ngin
eerin
g ju
dgm
ent
8
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
deD
edic
atio
nP
roce
ssC
omm
erci
alG
rade
Ded
icat
ion
Pro
cess
•W
hat i
s th
e pu
rpos
e of
the
tech
nica
l ev
alua
tion?
–D
eter
min
e va
lve’
s sa
fety
func
tion:
•P
rovi
de fl
ow c
ontro
l•
Mai
ntai
n sy
stem
bou
ndar
y•
Pro
vide
sys
tem
isol
atio
nS
il
idti
–S
peci
al c
onsi
dera
tions
:•
Env
ironm
enta
l qua
lific
atio
n•
Sei
smic
qual
ifica
tion
9
•S
eism
ic q
ualif
icat
ion
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
deD
edic
atio
nP
roce
ssC
omm
erci
alG
rade
Ded
icat
ion
Pro
cess
•W
hat i
s th
e pu
rpos
e of
the
tech
nica
l ev
alua
tion?
–D
eter
min
e ac
cept
ance
crit
eria
–D
eter
min
eac
cept
ance
met
hods
Det
erm
ine
acce
ptan
ce m
etho
ds
Det
erm
ine
ifva
lve
isa
like
forl
ike
or•
Det
erm
ine
if va
lve
is a
like
-for-l
ike
or
equi
vale
nt re
plac
emen
t.
10
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
deD
edic
atio
nP
roce
ss
•W
hati
sth
epr
oduc
toft
hete
chni
cal
Com
mer
cial
Gra
de D
edic
atio
n P
roce
ss
Wha
t is
the
prod
uct o
f the
tech
nica
l ev
alua
tion?
Iden
tific
atio
nof
criti
calc
hara
cter
istic
san
d–
Iden
tific
atio
n of
crit
ical
cha
ract
eris
tics
and
acce
ptan
ce m
etho
ds•
safe
tyfu
nctio
nan
dcl
assi
ficat
ion
(act
ive
and
safe
ty fu
nctio
n an
d cl
assi
ficat
ion
(act
ive
and
pass
ive)
•m
ater
ial s
peci
ficat
ion
(form
)•
conf
igur
atio
n (fi
t)•
pres
sure
and
tem
pera
ture
ratin
g (fu
nctio
n)ti
(fti
)•
oper
atio
n (fu
nctio
n)11
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
de D
edic
atio
n P
roce
ssW
ht
thl
’C
itilC
ht
iti
?
Crit
ical
M
easu
rabl
eD
escr
iptio
nof
Crit
ical
Cha
ract
eris
tic
Wha
t are
the
valv
e’s
Crit
ical
Cha
ract
eris
tics?
Cha
ract
eris
ticA
ttrib
ute
Mat
eria
lsM
ater
ial
Valv
em
ater
ial (
chem
ical
& p
hysi
cal p
rope
rties
)
Cfi
tiP
hi
lT
/t
ll
td
bi
ffti
flC
onfig
urat
ion
Phy
sica
lTy
pe/s
tyle
sele
cted
on
basi
s of
func
tion,
flow
re
quire
men
ts a
nd s
huto
ff ca
pabi
lity.
End
co
nnec
tions
may
be
butt
or s
ocke
t wel
d, fl
ange
d, o
r th
read
ed.
Siz
e/D
imen
sion
sD
imen
sion
sD
imen
sion
s,to
lera
nces
and
min
imum
wal
l thi
ckne
ss
may
be
i.a.w
. AN
SI B
16.3
4 or
oth
er s
tand
ards
as
appl
icab
le.
Pre
s/Te
mp
Rat
ing
Func
tion
Sel
ecte
dba
sed
on s
peci
fied
desi
gn p
ress
ure
and
tem
pera
ture
i.a.
w. A
NS
I B16
.34
or o
ther
app
licab
le
td
dst
anda
rds
Sea
t Lea
kage
/O
pera
tion
Func
tion
Sel
ecte
d ba
sed
on s
peci
fied
desi
gn re
quire
men
ts 12
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
de D
edic
atio
n P
roce
ssW
ht
tht
iti
?W
hat a
re th
e ac
cept
ance
crit
eria
?
Crit
ical
Va
lue
Acc
epta
nce
Ran
geVe
rific
atio
nC
hara
cter
istic
pg
Met
hod
Mat
eria
lsD
esig
n S
pecs
Mfr.
Spe
csP
er D
esig
nor
Mfr.
Test
(allo
y an
alyz
er,
chem
ical
, har
dnes
s)p
)
Con
figur
atio
nD
esig
nS
pecs
Mfr.
Spe
csP
er D
esig
n or
Mfr.
Visu
alW
eigh
t
Siz
e/D
imen
sion
sM
fr. S
pecs
Per
Mfr.
M
easu
rem
ent
P/T
Di
SP
St
dd
Mf
Tt(
hd
PM
T)P
res/
Tem
pR
atin
gD
esig
n S
pecs
Sys
.Spe
csM
fr. S
pecs
Per
Sta
ndar
d or
Mfr.
Test
(hyd
ro, P
MT)
Sea
t Lea
kage
/O
pera
tion
Func
tion
Per
Des
ign
or M
fr.O
pen/
Clo
sere
quire
men
tsTe
stO
pera
tion
13
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
deD
edic
atio
nP
roce
ssC
omm
erci
alG
rade
Ded
icat
ion
Pro
cess
•H
owar
eth
eva
lve’
scr
itica
lcha
ract
eris
ticH
ow a
re th
e va
lve
s cr
itica
l cha
ract
eris
tic
verif
ied?
Met
hod
1:S
peci
alte
sts
and
insp
ectio
ns–
Met
hod
1: S
peci
al te
sts
and
insp
ectio
ns–
Met
hod
2: C
omm
erci
al-g
rade
sur
vey
Met
hod
3:S
ourc
eve
rific
atio
n–
Met
hod
3: S
ourc
e ve
rific
atio
n–
Met
hod
4: A
ccep
tabl
e su
pplie
r/ite
m
perfo
rman
cere
cord
perfo
rman
ce re
cord
14
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
de D
edic
atio
n P
roce
ssH
ow d
o I u
se M
etho
d 1?
Iti
*T
t*
Insp
ectio
ns*
•R
ecei
ptIn
stal
latio
n
Test
s*•
Pre
-Inst
alla
tion
Ben
ch•
Inst
alla
tion
•P
ost I
nsta
llatio
n•
Doc
umen
tRev
iew
–B
ench
–A
ging
–D
estru
ctiv
e•
Doc
umen
t Rev
iew
–N
on-D
estru
ctiv
e•
Pos
t Ins
talla
tion
*Crit
ical
Cha
ract
eris
tics
(CC
s)
–P
ost M
aint
enan
ce
Test
–S
urve
illanc
e/Te
st
15P
roce
dure
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
de D
edic
atio
n P
roce
ssH
ow d
o I u
se M
etho
d 2?
•Ve
rify
com
mer
cial
supp
lier’s
qual
ityco
ntro
lsTy
pica
l•
Verif
y co
mm
erci
al s
uppl
iers
qua
lity
cont
rols
. Typ
ical
ar
eas
of c
onsi
dera
tion
incl
ude:
•P
rocu
rem
ent
•M
ater
ial C
ontro
l•
Fabr
icat
ion
•A
ssem
bly
•A
ssem
bly
•C
alib
ratio
n•
Test
•In
spec
tion
In
voke
qua
lity
cont
rols
in p
urch
ase
orde
r. Av
oid
nucl
ear-
uniq
ue
16
requ
irem
ents
. Hav
e a
certi
ficat
e of
con
form
ance
.
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
de D
edic
atio
n P
roce
ss
How
do
I use
Met
hod
3?
•M
ayw
antt
ous
eso
urce
verif
icat
ion
fora
nM
ay w
ant t
o us
e so
urce
ver
ifica
tion
for a
n in
frequ
ently
use
d su
pplie
r or e
xped
ited
need
need
.•
The
criti
cal c
hara
cter
istic
s m
ay b
e ve
rifie
d by
witn
essi
ng:
by w
itnes
sing
:–
Fabr
icat
ion
proc
ess
Abl
–A
ssem
bly
proc
ess
–N
onde
stru
ctiv
e ex
amin
atio
n te
st–
Per
form
ance
test
17
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
de D
edic
atio
n P
roce
ss
•S
uppl
ier/I
tem
perfo
rman
ceco
uld
beba
sed
How
do
I use
Met
hod
4?
Sup
plie
r/Ite
m p
erfo
rman
ce c
ould
be
base
d on
his
toric
al v
erifi
catio
n of
:A
udit
sche
dulin
g–
Aud
it sc
hedu
ling
–S
ampl
ing
plan
dev
elop
men
t
•E
nsur
e th
at th
e da
ta is
dire
ctly
app
licab
le
to a
crit
ical
cha
ract
eris
tic
18
Com
mer
cial
-Gra
de D
edic
atio
n P
roce
ss
How
do
I use
Met
hod
4?
•P
rovi
de s
peci
fic in
form
atio
n on
acc
epta
nce
activ
ities
. Don
’t st
ate
“test
val
ve to
AS
TM
B1b
34”R
athe
rst
ate
“per
form
ance
hydr
osta
ticB
1b.3
4. R
athe
r, st
ate
perfo
rman
ce h
ydro
stat
ic
test
of t
he v
alve
bod
y to
xxx
psi
.” H
old
the
pres
sure
for X
X m
inut
es, t
hen
insp
ect f
or
p,
ple
akag
e•
Don
’t ad
apt E
PR
I JU
TG C
GI e
valu
atio
ns w
ithou
t l
tili
bilit
eval
uatin
g ap
plic
abili
ty•
Ens
ure
“buy
-in” b
y th
e lic
ense
e th
at d
edic
atio
n pa
ckag
eis
appr
opria
teto
thei
rpla
ntsp
ecifi
c19
pack
age
is a
ppro
pria
te to
thei
r pla
nt s
peci
fic
need
s.
Que
stio
nsor
Com
men
ts?
Que
stio
ns o
r Com
men
ts?
Paul
Pre
scot
tP
aulP
resc
ott@
nrc
gov
20
Pau
l.Pre
scot
t@nr
c.go
v
