13
Termination of Operation Standard stages of decommissioning (Note:) Boiling water reactor (BWR) ①        ②          ③          ④           ⑤ Unloading of spent fuel Spent and unused fuel is carried out to reprocessing plants and storage facilities, where it is subject to careful controls and processing. System decontamination - clean-up Chemicals are used to remove as much of the radioactive sub- stances remaining in the facility's piping and container vessels as possible in order to facilitate sub- sequent dismantling work. Safe storage - standby The facility is put into safe stor- age under proper management as long as required and then further dismantling awaits decay of radioactivity to facilitate that work. Site Use The site can be used for a variety of purposes once it goes through legal procedures and its safety is confirmed. Alternatively, one current proposal is for the site to continue to be used effectively as a nuclear power site through coop- eration with the local community. Dismantling (1) - internal demolition To avoid release of radioactive sub- stances to the outside, the equipment inside the building, such as piping and vessels, are first dismantled. Dismantling (2) - building demolition After confirming that the targeted radioactive substances from inside the building have in fact been removed, the building is dismantled in the same way as a normal building. (Note) The operator determines the specific method according to the conditions, and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission confirms the safety. 9 -1-1 Decommissioning Process of Nuclear Power Plant © JAERO

Decommissioning Process of Nuclear Power Plant

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Decommissioning Process of Nuclear Power Plant

Termination of Operation

●Standard stages of decommissioning (Note:) Boiling water reactor (BWR)

①        ②          ③          ④           ⑤

Unloading of spent fuelSpent and unused fuel is carried out to reprocessing plants and storage facilities, where it is subject to careful controls and processing.

System decontamination - clean-upChemicals are used to remove as much of the radioactive sub-stances remaining in the facility's piping and container vessels as possible in order to facilitate sub-sequent dismantling work.

Safe storage - standbyThe facility is put into safe stor-age under proper management as long as required and then further dismantling awaits decay of radioactivity to facilitate that work.

Site UseThe site can be used for a variety of purposes once it goes through legal procedures and its safety is confirmed.Alternatively, one current proposal is for the site to continue to be used effectively as a nuclear power site through coop-eration with the local community.

Dismantling (1) - internal demolitionTo avoid release of radioactive sub-stances to the outside, the equipment inside the building, such as piping and vessels, are first dismantled.

Dismantling (2) - building demolitionAfter confirming that the targeted radioactive substances from inside the building have in fact been removed, the building is dismantled in the same way as a normal building.

(Note) The operator determines the specific method according to the conditions, and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission confirms the safety.

9-1-1

Decommissioning Process of Nuclear Power Plant

©JAERO

Page 2: Decommissioning Process of Nuclear Power Plant

The total amount of waste generated in decommissioning a 1.1 million kW class boiling water reactor (BWR) is approx. 536,000 tons.

Waste that does not emit radioactivity

Approx. 93%(Mostly waste concrete: approx. 495,000 tons)

Building concrete, glass, metal, etc.

(Metal and concrete waste: approx. 28,000 tons)

(Mostly metal waste: approx. 13,000 tons)

Low-level radioactive waste

Materials below clearance level

Approx. 5%

Approx. 2%

Concrete, glass, metal, etc. Materials used

in dismantling

9-1-2 Source: Nuclear and Industrial Safety Agency (at the time), Decommissioning of Nuclear Facilities

Quantity and Types of Waste Generated During Decommissioning

©JAERO

Page 3: Decommissioning Process of Nuclear Power Plant

Pea

cefu

l Use

No

n-p

rolif

erat

ion

Saf

ety

International Agreements

Primary Mechanisms

Safeguards

Physical Protections

●Non-Proliferation Treaties (NPT)●Convention on the Physical Protection of Nuclear Material (PP Convention)●Nuclear Security Recommendations on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities (INFCIRC/225)●London Guidelines / Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG)●Bilateral Nuclear Cooperation Agreements●Convention for the Suppression of Acts of Nuclear Terrorism

Protections from illegal trans-

fers, such as theft of nuclear

materials (non-proliferation)

Protections from sabotage

(radiation safety)

9-2-1

The Peaceful Use of Nuclear Energy and Protection of Nuclear Materials

©JAERO

Page 4: Decommissioning Process of Nuclear Power Plant

International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), etc.

Nuclear Regulation Authority (Planning / implementation of safeguards in Japan)

Cooperation

Ministry of Foreign Affairs

Report Evaluation Report Consultation

Organizations toimplement designatedsafeguards inspection, etc.※2

Domestic inspection

Inspection

Additional Protocol Applies to:・ Plants to manufacture and assemble nuclear related materials・ Uranium mines, etc.

Accountancy report

※1 Except supplemental access, such as when arises during a normal inspection※2 The Nuclear Material Control Center is specified according to the Nuclear Reactor Regulation Law as a Designated Organization for Implementing Safeguards and Inspections, as well as a Designated Information Processing Organization.

※1

Nuclear Facilities

Sup

plem

enta

ry A

cces

s

Inte

rnat

iona

l Ins

pect

ion

Acc

ount

ancy

Rep

orts

, etc

.

Act

ivity

Rep

ort,

etc.

Designated informationprocessing organizations※2

9 -2-2

Safeguard System in Japan

Source: Nuclear Regulation Authority

©JAERO

Page 5: Decommissioning Process of Nuclear Power Plant

Voluntary SafeguardsAgreement Countries

(Nuclear-weapon States)

Countries with other safeguard agreements

Parties to the Comprehensive Safeguards Agreements (174 Countries)

Parties to the NPT (191 Countries)(As of February, 2015)

(As of May 21, 2014)

East Asia(4)

★ Korea

  North Korea

★ Japan

★ Mongolia

Southeast Asia(10)

★ Indonesia

★ Cambodia

★ Singapore

★ Thailand ●

★ Philippines

★ Brunei

★ Vietnam

★ Malaysia ●

★ Myanmar ●

★ Laos ●

Oceania(13)

★ Australia

  Kiribati ●

  Samoa

  Solomon

  Tuvalu

  Tonga

  Nauru

★ New Zealand

★ Papua New Guinea

  Vanuatu

★ Palau

★ Marshall Islands

★ Fiji

Middle East & Southeast Asia(18)

★ Afghanistan

★ United Arab Emirates

★ Yemen

★ Iraq

★ Iran ●

★ Oman

★ Qatar

★ Kuwait

★ Saudi Arabia

★ Syria

★ Sri Lanka

★ Nepal

★ Bahrain

★ Bangladesh

  Bhutan

 Maldives

★ Jordan

★ Lebanon

Eastern Europe(27)

★ Azerbaijan

★ Albania

★ Armenia

★ Ukraine

★ Uzbekistan

★ Estonia

★ Kazakhstan

★ Kyrgyzstan

★ Georgia

★ Croatia

★ Slovakia

★ Slovenia

★ Vatican

★ Finland

★ Belgium

★ Portugal

★ Malta

★ Monaco

★ Liechtenstein ●

★ Luxembourg

Africa(44)

★ Algeria

★ Angola

★ Uganda

★ Egypt

★ Ethiopia

★ Ghana

★ Cameroon ●

★ Gabon

  Gambia

★ Kenya

★ Cote d'Ivoire ●

  Comoros

★ Republic of Congo

★ Democratic Republic of Congo

★ Zambia ●

★ Sierra Leone

★ Djibouti

★ Zimbabwe

★ Sudan

★ Swaziland

★ Seychelles

★ Senegal ●

★ Tanzania

Oceania(1)

  Micronesia

Southeast Asia(1)

  East Timor ●

 

Africa(9)

★ Eritrea

  Cape Verde ●

  Guinea ●

  Guinea-Bissau ●

  Sao Tome and Principe

  Equatorial Guinea

  Somalia

★ Benin ●

★ Liberia

 

Middle East & South Asia(1)

  Palestine

★ U.S.A. 

★ U.K.

★ France

★ Russia

★ China

★ Israel

★ India ●

★ Pakistan

★ Chad

★ Central Africa

★ Tunisia ●

★ Togo

★ Nigeria

★ Namibia

★ Niger

★ Burkina Faso

★ Burundi

★ Botswana

★ Madagascar

★ Malawi

★ Mali

★ South Africa

★ Mauritius

★ Mauritania

★ Mozambique

★ Morocco

★ Libya

★ Rwanda

★ Lesotho

North & South America(34)

★ Argentina

  Antigua & Barbados

★ Uruguay

★ Ecuador

★ El Salvador

★ Guyana

★ Canada

★ Guatemala

  Grenada

★ Cuba

★ Costa Rica

★ Columbia

★ Jamaica

  Suriname

  St. Kitts and Nevis

  Saint Vincent and the Grenadines

  Saint Lucia

★ Chile

★ Dominica

★ Dominican Republic

★ Trinidad and Tobago

★ Nicaragua

★ Haiti

★ Panama

★ Bahamas

★ Paraguay

  Barbados

★ Brazil

★ Venezuela

★ Belize

★ Peru

★ Bolivia

★ Honduras ●

★ Mexico

★ Serbia ●

★ Tajikistan

★ Czech Republic

  Turkmenistan

★ Hungary

★ Bulgaria

★ Belarus ●

★ Poland

★ Bosnia-Herzegovina

★ Macedonia

★ Moldova

★ Montenegro

★ Latvia

★ Lithuania

★ Romania

Western Europe(24)

★ Iceland

★ Ireland

  Andorra

★ Italy

★ Austria

★ Netherlands

★ Greece

★ Cyprus

★ San Marino

★ Switzerland

★ Sweden

★ Spain

★ Denmark

★ Germany

★ Turkey

★ Norway

★: IAEA Signatories (164 countries)

■: Additional Protocol Parties (126 countries)

●: Parties that Signed but Failed to Ratify the Additional Protocol (15 of the 21 Parties to the Comprehensive Safeguards Agreements)

〈IAEA Board〉

 35 Countries (2014-15)

〈Other Notes〉

・The IAEA concluded a safeguard agreement with Taiwan as well.

・The IAEA concluded an additional protocol with EURATOM.

9-2-3

Parties to the NPT and IAEA Safeguard Agreements

Source: The Denki Shimbun, Nuclear Pocket Book FY2015

©JAERO

Page 6: Decommissioning Process of Nuclear Power Plant

①Law on Tax for Promotion of Electric Power Development Tax rate Until Sep.2003 JPY 0.445/kWh Oct.2003 - Mar.2005 JPY 0.425/kWh Apr.2005 - Mar.2007 JPY 0.40/kWh Apr.2007 From JPY 0.375/kWh

①,② and ③are called “Electric Power Developmentbased on the Three Laws”. ②Law on Special Accounts

(Consumers)

Electric Power Companies

(Tax for Promotion of Electric Power Development)

General Account

JPY 323 billion

JPY 304.2 billion

Fund for developingsurrounding areas

Surplus fromprevious fiscal year,

etc.

JPY 0.7billion

JPY 27.1billion

JPY 17.3billion

○Development of power supply region ・ Development of infrastructure ・ Industrial development○Emergency preparedness measures for power source region○Promotion of public understanding of long-life fixed generation facilities○Enhancement and strengthening of activities for harmonious coexistence in power supply regions○Enhancement and strengthening of measures for nuclear emergency preparedness, environmental conservation and safety○Measures for enhancement of public understanding of nuclear power generation

Special Accounts for Energy MeasuresAccounts for Promotion of Power Development

JPY 349.5 billion

Measures for Electric Power Plant Location Accounts

Budget by MinistriesCabinet Office JPY 13.9 billion

Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and TechnologyJPY 109.9 billion

Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry JPY 178.9 billionMinistry of Environment JPY 46.6 billion

Electric Power Generation Diversification Accounts○Promotion of development of power generating facilities etc.○Measures for smoother power supply○Nuclear safety measures○Promotion of research and development concerning the nuclear fuel cycle○Promotion of advanced nuclear science and technology○Securing safety, and others

③Law on the Development of Areas Adjacent to Power Generating Facilities

Grant to supportpower supply regions

Financial support to smoothenconstruction and operation of

power generation facilitiesGrants based on location

of electric power plants

Subsidy for supportingindustrial development

in power supplyregions

Subsidy fordevelopment of power

supply regions

and others

※ “Special Accounts for Promotion of Electric Power Development Acceleration Measures” and “Special Accounts for Petroleum and Sophisticated Structure of Energy Supply and Demand” were  merged into “Special Accounts for Energy Measures” in FY2007. Among this, “Accounts for Promotion of Electric Power Development” took over operation of the “Special Account for Promotion of  Electric Power Development Acceleration Measures”.※ Since FY2007, the revenue from “Promotion of Power-resources Development Tax” has transferred to the annual revenue of the general account. The necessary amount has been transferred from the  general account to “Special Accounts for Energy Measures” each year.※ In addition, approximately 8.8071 billion yen is set aside as a nuclear damages compensation support account.※ Revenue of Power-Resources Development Tax is the estimated amount for the 2015 fiscal year.

Miscellaneous income

Nuclear Safety Regulation Measures○Ensuring the safety of nuclear power facilities, etc.○Disaster prevention measures around nuclear facilities○Health management for victims of nuclear accidents

from draft budget for fiscal 2015

9-3-1

Electric Power Development based on the Three Laws

Source: The Denki Shimbun, Nuclear Pocket Book FY2015

©JAERO

Page 7: Decommissioning Process of Nuclear Power Plant

Filled in bulkheadE.L.+10m

E.L.+5.5m

E.L.-7m

W.L.

Intake15mφ

About 0.2m/s

Surface water intake system (Tomari Nuclear Power Station, Units 1, 2)

Intake pipe-type deep water intake system(Yanai Power Plant, Units 1, 2)

About -7.0m

3.0m

About 0.2m/s

Intake pipe

Curtain wall Intake

Intake tower

About 24m

T.M.S.L.-8.0m

T.M.S.L.-13.0m

T.M.S.L. -4.2m

About 0.2m/s

Curtain wall-type deep water intake system(Tomari Nuclear Power Station, Units 1 to 4)

T.M.S.L. -6.0m

About 0.5m/s

Intake tower-type deep water intake system (Hamaoka Nuclear Power Station, Unit 4)

Porous dike-type deep water intake system (Shika Nuclear Power Plant, Unit 1)

Intake about 60m Intake channel (tunnel) about 430m (extended to 480m)

About 0.3m/s T.M.S.L.+3.5m

Abou

t 40m

Abou

t 50m

Abo

ut 7

0m

Prefectural road

Bar screen

9-4-1

Overview of Water Intake Systems

Source: The Denki Shimbun, Nuclear Pocket Book FY2015

©JAERO

Page 8: Decommissioning Process of Nuclear Power Plant

Temperature monitoring point

Wave dissipation dike

T.M.S.L. +3.0m

L.W.L. T.M.S.L. -0.02m

T.M.S.L. -4.0m About 0.7m/s

Surface water discharge system (Tomari Nuclear Power Station, Units 1-4)

T.P. -8.5m

M.W.L T.P. +0.09m

Water discharge rate: 4m/s    T.P. -14.3m

Drainpipe-type submerged water discharge system (Genkai Nuclear Power Plant, Units 3 , 4 )

Continuous monitoring of free chlorine concentration

(0.02ppm or less)

Porous dike-type submerged water discharge system (Tomari Nuclear Power Station, Units 1 , 2 )

About 0.4m/s

4.5m

Multi-stage discharge water system (Higashi Niigata Thermal Power Plant, Units 1-3)

Riprap Wave dissipation blockRandom masonry E.L -4.5m

Asphalt mat

Temperature monitoring

E.L. +11m

E.L.-7.5m

E.L. +6m

E.L. -9m

Submerged water discharge opening D=2.5m v=4m/s

E.L. +5.5m

Kita Bohatei seawall

E.L. +4.5m

W.L.

9-4-2

Overview of Water Discharge Systems

Source: The Denki Shimbun, Nuclear Pocket Book FY2015

©JAERO

Page 9: Decommissioning Process of Nuclear Power Plant

BusinessWater Intake Source

Main Fish SpeciesPower Plant

Shizuoka Thermal Effluent

Utilization Research Center

Chubu Electric Power Co.

Hamaoka Nuclear Power Plant

Unit 3--110.0

Unit 4--113.7

Unit 5--126.7

(Hatchlings)

Red sea bream, flounder, swimming crab,

mud crab, abalone, Japan tiger prawn,

grouper, tiger globefish

Ishikawa Prefectural

Fisheries Research Center,

Production Department Shiga Plant

Hokuriku Electric Power Co.

Shika Nuclear Power Plant

Unit 1--54.0

Unit 2--120.6 Abalone, flounder, turban shell

Kansai Electric Power Co., Ltd.

Takahama Nuclear Power Plant

Kansai Electric Power Co., Ltd.

Takahama Nuclear Power Plant

Units 1,2--82.6 each

Units 3,4--87.0 each Abalone, turban shell

Capacity (10,000kW)

9-4-3

Table of Fish Breeders Using Hot Water from Power Plants (Nuclear-Power Related)

Source: The Denki Shimbun, Nuclear Pocket Book FY2015

©JAERO

Page 10: Decommissioning Process of Nuclear Power Plant

(As of September 2020)

Established Currently

Year Established Tax Rate Tax Rate Valid Notes

Fukui

Ibaraki*2

Ehime

Saga

Shimane

Shizuoka

Kagoshima

Miyagi

Niigata

Hokkaido

Ishikawa

Aomori*4

1976

1978

1979

1979

1980

1980

1983

1983

1984

1988

1992

2004

8th update

8th update

8th update

8th update

8th update

8th update

7th update

7th update

7th update

6th update

5th update

4th update

5%

5%

5%

5%

5%

5%

7%

7%

7%

7%

7%

10%

17%

17%

17%

17%

17%

17%

17%

15%

17%

17%

17%

17%

Nov. 2016 to Nov. 2021

Apr. 2019 to Mar. 2024

Jan. 2019 to Jan. 2024

Apr. 2019 to Mar. 2024

Apr. 2020 to Mar. 2025

Apr. 2020 to Mar. 2025

Jun. 2018 to May. 2023

Jun. 2018 to Jun. 2023

Nov. 2019 to Nov. 2024

Sep. 2018 to Aug. 2023

Oct. 2017 to Oct. 2022

Apr. 2019 to Mar. 2024

*1, 5

*1

*1, 5

*1

*4

*1

*1

*1, 6

*1, 5

*1, 5

*1

*3, 5

(Currently 12%)

*1:The tax rate of 17% breaks down to 8.5% of the cost and 8.5% of the output (the output percentage is a conversion of the tax amount/heat output into a percentage - the notes below also apply this rule).*2:The nuclear fuel taxes for Ibaraki Prefecture have been taxed since April 1999 as a "Nuclear Fuel Handling Tax". *3:The tax rate at 15% breaks down to 12% of the cost and 3% of the output. *4:The nuclear fuel taxes for Aomori Prefecture are taxed from April 2004 as a "Nuclear Fuel Materials Handling Tax". The tax rate at 17% breaks down to 8.5% of the cost and 8.5% of the output.*5:For Fukui Prefecture (from November 2016), Shimane Prefecture (from April 2017), Saga Prefecture (from April 2017), Ehime Prefecture (from August 2017) and Miyagi Prefecture (from March 2020), output tax is

levied even during decommissioning.*6:The tax rate at 17% breaks down to 4.5% of the cost and 12.5% of the output.

Prefecture

9-4-4 Source: Federation of Electric Power Companies of Japan, Electricity Utilities and Taxes 2020

Changes in Nuclear Fuel Tax Rates

©JAERO

Page 11: Decommissioning Process of Nuclear Power Plant

Principle of Fusion

Heavy water (deuterium)

Neutron Neutron

Fission Products

Neutron

Energy

Uranium 235

Fission

FusionTritium

Energy

Neutron

Helium

Principle of Fission

9-4-5

Nuclear Fusion and Fission

©JAERO

Page 12: Decommissioning Process of Nuclear Power Plant

9-4-6 Source: Power Generation Cost Analysis Working Group, Report on Analysis of Generation Costs, Etc. for Subcommittee on Long-term Energy Supply/Demand Outlook (May 2015)

Generation Cost Per Kilowatt Hour (kWh)

50

40

30

20

10

0

(Yen/kWh)

Nuclear Coal-fired

LNG-fired

Oil-firedLand

Wind Solar Hydro Biomass

Offshoreembedded

GeothermalMega-solar Residential Normal Small-hydro

(800,000 yen/kW)Small-hydro(One million yen/kW)

Wood-fired Coal co-fired

Capacity Factor 70%

40 years

70%

40 years

70%

40 years

30%

40 years

10%

40 years

20%

20 years

30%

20 years

83%

40 years

12%

20 years(30 years)

12%

20 years(30 years)

45%

40 years

60%

40 years

60%

40 years

87%

40 years

70%

40 yearsLifespan(2030 Model)

《Legend》

2014Model

Max

Min

Max

Min

2030Model

12.9⬆

12.3

10.3~⬆

10.1~

13.7⬇

13.4

30.6⬇

28.9

43.4⬇

41.7

21.6⬇

13.6~21.5

30.3~34.7(2030)

16.9⬇

16.8

24.2⬇

12.7~15.6

29.4⬇

12.5~16.4

11.0(2014=

2030)

23.3(2014=

2030)

27.1(2014=

2030)

29.7(2014=

2030)

13.2⬆

12.6

©JAERO

Page 13: Decommissioning Process of Nuclear Power Plant

9-4-7 Source: Energy and Environment Council, Cost Verification Committee Report (May 2015)

Nuclear Fuel Cycle Costs

2.5

2.0

1.5

1.0

0.5

0.00%

(Yen/kWh) (Yen/kWh) (Yen/kWh)

Discount rate

(Note) Totals may not add up due to rounding.

1% 3% 5%

2.1 2.0 2.0 2.02.5

2.0

1.5

1.0

0.5

0.00%

Discount rate1% 3% 5%

2.5

2.0

1.5

1.0

0.5

0.00%

Discount rate1% 3% 5%

1.3-1.4 1.1-1.2 1.0 1.02.3 1.9 1.5 1.4

0.7

0.2

1.1

0.3

0.8

0.1

0.8

0.1

0.9

0.1

0.5

0.1

0.1

0.1

1.0

0.0

0.3

0.0

0.0

0.0

(2011 report) (2015 report) (2011 report)

■ Uranium fuel  ■ MOX fuel  ■ Reprocessing, etc.  ■ Interim storage, etc.  ■ High-level waste disposal  ■ Direct disposal

Reprocessing ModelReprocess all spent fuel and recycle

Current ModelPut all spent fuel into safe storage

and reprocess

Direct Disposal ModelDirect disposal after interim

storage of all spent fuel

0.6

0.2

1.1

0.2

0.7

0.2

1.1

0.2

0.7

0.2

1.0

0.1

0.8

0.1

1.0

0.0

Fron

t end

Bac

k en

d

Fron

t end

Bac

k en

d

0.7

0.1

0.4-0.5 0.2

-0.3 0.1

0.9

0.10.1

0.8

0.1

0.8

0.1

Fron

t end

Bac

k en

d

©JAERO