31
HAL Id: inria-00071724 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071724 Submitted on 23 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés. Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models Gilles Celeux, Florence Forbes, Christian Robert, Mike Titterington To cite this version: Gilles Celeux, Florence Forbes, Christian Robert, Mike Titterington. Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models. [Research Report] RR-4859, INRIA. 2003. inria-00071724

Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

HAL Id: inria-00071724https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071724

Submitted on 23 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,émanant des établissements d’enseignement et derecherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou privés.

Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data ModelsGilles Celeux, Florence Forbes, Christian Robert, Mike Titterington

To cite this version:Gilles Celeux, Florence Forbes, Christian Robert, Mike Titterington. Deviance Information Criteriafor Missing Data Models. [Research Report] RR-4859, INRIA. 2003. �inria-00071724�

Page 2: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

ISS

N 0

249-

6399

ISR

N IN

RIA

/RR

--48

59--

FR

+E

NG

ap por t de r ech er ch e

THÈME 4

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Deviance Information Criteria for Missing DataModels

Gilles Celeux — Florence Forbes — Christian Robert — Mike Titterington

N° 4859

Juin 2003

Page 3: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4
Page 4: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France)

Téléphone : +33 4 76 61 52 00 — Télécopie +33 4 76 61 52 52

����������� ������������ �������� ����� �����!�"� �#���%$ �"&�&'�")( �*���+�$ �-,)�/.�&

0�132424576�895:2;57<�=?>A@B2;CED"57F!GH5I@+CED"JK576L>A8NM!DO146"PQ1SRTFVUWCXJK57D�PY>AZ[14\T5] 1;P"P^57DO13F+_�POCEF

`/acb�dfe�gih j:kld9mcnpo#qrklsutfe�qBsuvwqrkld-klxro#qykzsut{ e�x}|7x}qrb"d-e"xB~"sud-vcnle �:e"x

���rs��}e�q�������Bo�vcv�su��q { e��re�~�ace"�}~�ace�tT��g������Yh ��mckltL�����u�h �u�iv�o��ue�x

�������O �¡c¢���£ `/ace { e�¤:klo�tc~�e-kztw¥;su�}d�o#qrklsut�~"�}kzqre"�rkzsut§¦4¨�©�ª/«¬klt�qy�}s { mw~"e {I­ |Ij7vckle��ue"n¯®a�o�nzqre"�Ke�q�o�nS°�¦3���u����«�kzx { kl�re�~�qrnz|Wkltwxrvckz�re {f­ |fnzkltce"o��Ao�t { �ue"tce��yo�nzklx}e { nzkltce"o��Kdfs { e�nlx"±­ mwqAkzq�kzx�tcs�qKx}s�t�o�qymc�ro�nln²| { e�³�tce { ¥;su��d-klx}xrkltw� { o#qyo�d-s { e"nzx"°�©´tWqyawklx�v�o�v�e"��±�µ¶e·�re ®o�xrx}e"xrx�qrace�~��rkzqre"�}klsut¥;su��x}mc~�aWdfs { e"nzx"±�qye"x�qykztc��qyawe ­ e�a�oO¤7klsumc�!s�¥�¤#o��rkzsumcx!e��7qye�tcxrkzsutcxklt)qyace�~"o�xre�xBs#¥�d-k²�7qymw�re�o�t { �yo#t { sud¸e�¹Xe"~�qºd-s { e�nlx�°»L¼�½E¾}¿iÀ  �Á!��£ ¨�e�¤:klo�tc~�e�±+ª¶sud-vcnle�qykzsut±'Ã�Ĭ�!±+Ã�k²�7qymc�}eWÃLs { e"n3±��ºo#t { sudÆÅ�¹Ee�~�qÃLs { e"nlx

Page 5: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

���!�������!�·& ,)� ,����f�"���¶���������·&'���·�)�� ����%,)�·&� �-,��/.��·& � ,������/�·& � �������N���·&

��� ����� � £�� eB~��rk²qyb"�}e { e {�� ¤7klo�tc~"e·¨º©�ª klt�qy�}s { mckzq�v�o��Aj:vckze"�ue�nla�o#nzqye���e�q¶o#nS°�¦3���u����«e"x}q { kz�re"~�qye�dfe�tHqºkltwxrvckz� � v�o��·nle�x·dfs { b"nze"x·nlkzt � o#kl�re�x/e�qºnle�xBd-s { b"nze"x·nlkzt � o�kz�re�x/� � t � ®�yo�nzklx � x"°/©´n+t�� klt { mwkzqºv�o�x { e {�� ³�tckzqrklsut�t�o#qrmc�re�nlnze�v�sumc�Bnle�x�d-s { b�nle�x��fx}qy�}mc~�qrmc�re { e{ sutct � e"x¬dfo�t��Hm�o#tHqre"x�°º¨�o�tcx¬~�e�q�o#�}qykz~"nze�±�tcsumwx�� � klt�qye��rvc� � qrsutcx�~�e9~��rkzqrb"�}e�v�sumc� { eqye"nzx�d-s { b�nle�x�e�qKtwsumcx � ¤�o#nlmcsutwx�nle�~�sud-vXsu��qye�dfe�tHq { e { k²¤ue"�}xre�xAe �7qye"twxrkls�tcx�vXs�xrxrk ­ nle�x{ eB¨�©�ª { o�twx nze/~"sut�qye �7qye { e"xAd � npo�tc��e"x { eBnlsukzx�e�q { e�x d-s { b"nze"x ��e�¹Xe�qyx o�n � o#qrsukl�}e"x"°!�À �Q� ¾ ¢#" � �£ ¨ � ¤:klo�tc~�e�±�~"s�dfvcn � qrklsut±#ÃLÄ��!±#dfs { b"nze { e�d � npo#tc�ue�±�d-s { b�nle ��e�¹Ee�qyxo�n � o#qysukz�re�x

Page 6: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �

. ��W�'�!�-, ��A������

/[ace"t { e�¤ue�nlsuvwkltc� qrace"kz�-qrace"s��}| s�¥�qyawe0*&��������� �1�������������2����3����������������[¦3¨�©�ª/« ±j:vckle��ue"nza�o�n²qye"�·e�q�o�n3°�¦3���u����« { k { tws�q¬�uk²¤ue�dimc~�aY~�sutcxrk { e"�ro#qykzsutLqrs�d-s { e"nlxBsumwqrxrk { eqyace�xr~�suv�e�s�¥��ue"twe"�yo#nlklx}e { nlkztceOo#�/dfs { e"nzx"±�o#nzqyawsumc�ua)qyawe�|�~"s�tc~"nzm { e { qyawe"kl�·x}e"d-klt�o�nv�o�v�e"�/µ·kzqraLo { kzxr~"mwxrxrkzsut�s�¥!qrace�vXs�xrxrk ­ klnzkzqrkle"x s�¥!e��7qye�t { kltw�-qracklx·tcs�qrklsut)qrs-d-s { e"nzxnlk$4#e)dfk¯�7qymc�}e"xWs�¥ { klx�qy�rk ­ mwqrklsutcx�° `/ace�e"tcx}mckltc� { kzxr~"mwxrxrkzsut vXsukzt�qye { sumwqWqrace�vXsux ®xrk ­ nle { k65-~"mwnzqykze"xWs�¥ { e�³�tckztc� ¨�©�ª vc�}e"~�klxre�nz| klt qyace�xreYx}~"e�t�o��rkzsux"° ©´t v�o���qykz~"mcnlo��"±¨�e"©´su�}kls9o�t { �·s ­ e��}q�¦S���u�u�u« { e"xr~��rk ­ e { xrsud-e�v�suxrx}k ­ nzeºkztc~"s�tcxrkzx}qye�tc~"kze"x�kztfqrace { e�³w®tckzqrklsutNs�¥Eo¨�©�ª ¥;su��d-k²�7qymw�re/d-s { e�nlx�±uqyace·d-sux}qAo�vwv�o��re�t�q ­ e"kztc��qyace·s7~"~"mw�r�re�tc~"eBs�¥tce"��o�qykz¤�e { kzdfe�tcxrkzsut v�o��ro�dfe�qye��rx87:9 ±Âµ·acklnzei�·kl~�a�o�� { xrs�t ¦3���u����«Bvc�}e"xre�t�qye { o�tIo�n¯®qye"�}t�o#qrkz¤ue/tws�qykzsutNs�¥X¨�©�ª�±Ho���o#kltikztiqyace·~"s�tHqre��7qAs�¥�dfk¯�7qymc�}e�dfs { e�nlx"°+`/ace { k;5f~�mcnzq´|µ·kzqya�d-su�re���e"tce��yo�n'd-s { e"nlx¶klx/qya�o�q ­ o�xrkz~�tcs�qrklsutcx/nzk$4#e�*&��������� �¶dfoO|�q�o<4�e�xre�¤ue"�ro�ne �Hm�o�nznz| o#~"~"e�vwq�o ­ nle�dfe"o�tckztc�ux"±�µ·k²qya { kl�}e"~�q-~�sutcxre �Hmce"tc~�e"x�¥;s��Wqrace�vc�rs�vXe��}qykze"xWs�¥qyace~"su�}�re�xrv�sut { kztc��¨�©�ª¶x�°º`/awe"�re�klx·qyaHmcx�oftce�e { qrs�e�¤#o�nzm�o#qre9o�t { ~"s�dfv�o#�re�qyace�xrevc�rsuv�e"��qykze"x�¥;su��qrace�dfsux�q·t�o#qrmc�yo�nE~�acsukl~�e"xBs�¥�¨�©�ª¶x"°

`/awe�vc�}e"x}e"t�q�v�o�v�e"�·�}eOo�x}xre"x}xre�x¬qyackzxBvw�rs ­ nze"d kzt��u�re"o#qye�� { e�vwqya o�t { �ue"tce��yo�nzkzq´|¥;su�fd-klx}xrkztc� { o#q�o dfs { e�nlx"° ©´t j:e"~�qykzsut �:±�µ e �}e"~"o�nln/qyawe tcs�qrklsutwx-kzt�qy�rs { mc~�e { kztj:vckle��ue"nza�o�n²qye"��e�q o�nS°c¦S�������u«�°�j:e"~�qykzsut���vc�}e"x}e"t�qyx¶o�q´|7v�sunls���|Ns�¥�qyace·v�suxrx}k ­ nze/e��7qye�t:®xrkls�tcx¶s�¥+¨º©�ª[kzt�d-klxrx}kltc� { o#qyo9dfs { e�nlx"±Hµ·ackznle�j:e"~�qykls�t�gi~"s�tcx}qr�rmc~�qyx·o�t { ~�sud-v�o��re�xqyace�xre e �7qye"twxrkls�tcx�klt �yo#t { sud e�¹Ee�~�q�d-s { e"nzx"±�o#t { j:e�~�qrklsut � { s7e"x-qyace�xyo�d-e�¥;su�dfk¯�:qrmc�re�x�s�¥ { klx}qr�rk ­ mwqykzsutcx�°=/ eY~"s�tc~"nzm { e qrace v�o#vXe���µ·kzqra o { kzxr~"mwxrxrkzsut s�¥¬qrace�re"nze�¤#o�tc~�e�s�¥!qrace�¤#o��rkzsumcx�e �:qre"tcx}klsutwxºkzt j7e"~�qrklsut1>w°

? @ ���i�·&'�"� � �·�&�)�!�·&����[�¶��� �.��8A�� � � ���, B��

CTs���~"sud-v�e�qykztc� v�o��ro�d-e�qy�}kl~Yx�q�o#qrklx�qykl~"o�n�d-s { e"nzx"±�DFEHGJI KML ±Bqrace ~"sutwx}qy�}mc~�qrklsut[s�¥9o�ue"tce��rkz~�d-s { e�n²® ~"sud-v�o��}klxrs�tYqys7sunKklxio { k65-~�mcnzq�vc�rs ­ nle�d µ·k²qya o nlsutw�Lackzx}qrsu�}|�°L©´tv�o��}qrkl~�mcnpo���±�qyaweºkzxrxrmweºs�¥ { e�¤7kzxrkltw�9o�xre�nle"~�qykzsutf~��rk²qye"�}klsutNqra�o#qKµ¶s��N4Hx ­ s�qyafo�x od-eOoQ®xrmc�}e�s�¥�³cqºo�t { o#x�oWdfe"o�xrmw�res�¥�~"s�dfvcnze��:kzq´|�klx �Hmckzqre~�aco�nlnze"tc�ukztc�c°A©´tLqracklxBv�o�v�e"��±µ¶e�e �co#dfkztce�xrsunze"n²|-qrace�~"�}kzqye��rklo { e�¤�e"nzsuvXe { klt�j:vckze"�ue�nla�o#nzqye��¶e�qBo�nS°E¦S�������u«�±:kltc~�nlm { ®kltc�c±Eklt ~"s�tctce"~�qykzsut µ·kzqyaId-s { e"n�~�sud-vcnle �wk²q´|u±Âqrace"kz�¬dfe"o�xrmw�re�±O7:9 ±'s�¥KqyaceWe�¹Xe"~�qyk²¤uet7mwd ­ e��!s#¥cv�o��ro�d-e�qye��rx+klt�oBd-s { e"n3°+`/awklx �7mco�t�qykzq´|�kzx ­ o�xre { sut9oP*&��������� ��± { e�³�tce {­ | Q

E�KMLSRUT!V�W$XMYZD[EH\]I^KL`_aV�W6XMYcb�EH\dL8e

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 7: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

g � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

µ·ace"�}ePbdEH\dL klx/x}sud-e¬¥;mcnln²|fx}vXe�~"k²³�e { x}qyo�t { o�� { k���kltc�iqre"�}d¸µ·ackz~�aLkzx¶¥;mctc~�qykls�t�s#¥+qrace{ o#q�oWo�nzsutce#°�`/ace"t�qyace ��� � ��������'*���F��k#����� 7:9 klx { e�³�tce { o�x

7O9 RQE2KLdT

QE��KL�e ¦��Q«

µ·ace"�}eQE�KML¶kzx�qyace�v�sux}qre"�rkzsu��d-eOo�t { e�¤7kpo�tc~�e�±Q

E�KMLZR������ T V�W6XMYZDFE�\]I^KML�I \�� _ V�W$XMYcb�E�\dL�eµ·ackl~�a ~Oo�t ­ e-�re���o�� { e { o�x9o! �oO|ue�xrklo�t d-eOo�x}mc�re-s�¥ ³cqO±!o�t {"�K�kzxo�t e�x}qykzd�o�qyeNs�¥K { e�vXe�t { kltw�Ysut \A°�`/ace�v�sux}qre"�}klsu�dfe"o�t K R��#� K I \$�ºklxs�¥�qre"t o tco#qymc�ro�nK~�acsukz~"e¥;su�%�K ­ mwq9qrace�v�sux�qye"�}klsu��dfs { e-su�9d-e { kpo�t ~Oo�t o#nlxrs ­ e��}mcx}qrkz³�e { °%&Bs�qye-qya�o#q�7:9klxN~"s�dfvcnze�qre"nz| klt { e"v�e"t { e"t�q-s�¥ºqrace)~�acsukz~"e�s�¥Bqyace)x�q�o�t { o�� { k��"kztc�)b!° ĺxWo�nl�}eOo { |vXsukzt�qye { sumwq�kzt�j:vckze"�ue�nla�o#nzqye��Ke�q·o�n3°X¦S���u�u�u«�±Hqyaceº¥4o�~�q qya�o#q 7:9 dfoO| { e�vXe�t { sut�qrace~�acsukl~�e�s�¥!qrace�e"x�qykldfo#qre'�KNklx/sutce�s�¥+qyawe { k65-~"mcn²qykze"x�s�¥+qyawklxBo�vcvc�}s�o�~�a°

Ä ~"s��r�re�xrv�sut { kztc� ����������� � ������������������ ������� ���������¦3¨�©�ª/«�¥;su��dfs { e�n�~"sud-v�o�� ®klxrs�t�kzx·o { ¤#o�tc~�e {�­ |Lj:vckle��ue"nza�o�n²qye"� e�qºo�n3°�¦S�������u«A¥;�}sud¸qracklx/~�sutcx}qr�rmc~�qykzsut)(Q+*�,

RQE2KL _ 7:9

RQE��KL _aV�7:9 ¦3�u«

R VQE2KLdT

QE��KML

R T.-������^W$XMYcD[EH\]I^KL I \$�M_aV�W6XMYZDFE�\]I �K<L0/CTs��!d-s { e"nH~"sud-v�o��}klx}sut±Qµ¶e�~"o�tWo�x}xrmcd-e µ·k²qyacsum:q�nzsuxrx!s�¥T�ue"twe"�yo#nlkzq´|�qra�o#q�b�EH\dLSR21�±¥;su�·o�nlnXdfs { e�nlx"±wxrsNµ¶e�q�o<4�e Q

E�KML R T!V�W$XMYcD[EH\]I^KL0/ ¦4��«�K�}s^¤:k { e { qyaco#q

QE2KLEklx'oO¤#o�kznpo ­ nze�kzt~�nlsux}e { ¥;su�}dL±

QE�KMLE~"o�t�e"o�xrkznz| ­ eAo�vwvc�rsO�:kldfo#qye {

mcxrkztc� o�t ÃYª/à ª��}mct ­ | qyo4Hkltc� qrace�xro�dfvwnle�d-eOo#t s�¥/qyawe)xrkld9mcnpo#qre { ¤�o#nlmce�x9s�¥QE2KL�° /[awe"t K R3�#� K I \$��kzxKmcxre { ±

QE KML�~"o�t�o#nlxrs ­ eBo�vcvc�}s^�:kzd�o#qre {-­ |Wvcnlmc���ukltc��kzt

qyaceBxyo�d-vcnzeºd-eOo�tfs�¥Eqrace�x}kldimwnpo#qre { ¤�o#nlmce�x s�¥ K:°�Ä�xAv�suklt�qye { sum:q ­ |�j:vckle��ue"nza�o�n²qye"�e�q)o#nS°B¦S�#�u���u« ± qyawklx�~�awsukl~�e s�¥ �KIe"twxrmc�}e"x�qyaco#q'7O9 klx-v�suxrk²qykz¤�e�µ·awe"t qyawe { e�tcxrk²q´|klxnlsu�#® ~"sutw~OoO¤ue-klt K:± ­ m:q9k²q9kzx�tcs#qio�vwvc�rsuvw�rkpo�qyeWµ·ace"t0K�klx { klx}~"�}e�qye ® ¤#o�nzmce { xrkltw~"e�#� K I \��·mcxrm�o#nlnz|L¥4o�klnzx¬qys)q�o<4�e-sutceWs�¥¶qrace"x}e-¤#o�nzmce"x�°fĺnlx}sc±+o�x��}e�¤�eOo�nze { ­ | ¨ºe"©´su�}klso�t { �Bs ­ e��}qB¦3���u���u« ±�qyawe/e�¹Xe"~�qrkz¤�e { kld-e"tcx}klsut�7:9 d�oO|µ¶e�nln ­ e/tce"�uo#qyk²¤ue/kltiqrace/~Oo#xres�¥�d-k²�7qymc�}e"xºs�¥ { kzx}qy�}k ­ m:qykls�tcx"° / e�µ·klnzn { klx}~"mcx}x�¥;mc�}qrace"�Bqyace�klx}xrmce�s�¥K~�acs7suxrkztc� ¦;su�tcs�q·~�acs7suxrkztc�H« �KNklt)qrace�¥;sunlnzsQµ·kztc�9x}e"~�qykls�tcx"°

4�5Jf64�7

Page 8: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �

� �*��� & ���� � �"&�&'�")( ,����+� � �f,)�/.�&

©´tfqyawklxKxre�~�qykzsut±Hµ¶e { e"x}~"�}k ­ eºv�suxrx}k ­ nze·e��7qye�tcxrkzsutcx¶s#¥'¨�©�ª kztfd-klx}xrkltw� { o#q�o�dfs { e�nlx"±qya�o#q·kzx"±wµ·awe"t

D[EH\]I^KL�R��hD[EH\ce��`I^KL�����e­ |Yo#qrqre"d-vwqykztc��qys�µ·�}kzqreWo�q´|:v�sunzsu��|Ls�¥¶tco#qymc�ro�n�¨º©�ª¶x�kzt xrmc~�a xre�qrqykztc�ux�°NÃLkzxrxrkztc�{ o#q�oºdfs { e"nzx!qra7mwx�klt�¤usun²¤ue�¤#o��}kpo ­ nze"x���µ·ackl~�a-o��}e�tcsut:® s ­ x}e"�}¤�e { ±Hsu�!dfkzxrx}kltc�c±#kltNo { ®{ kzqrklsutNqys�qyaceBs ­ x}e"�}¤�e { ¤#o��rklo ­ nze"xS\A°·¦H/[ace�qyace���su�Atcs�q�iklxAvca�|7xrkz~Oo�nznz|Wd-eOo�tckztc��¥;mcn¥;su�/qyacevc�rs ­ nle�d klxBtcs�qB�re�nle�¤�o#tHqºace��re�° «�`/ace�s ­ xre��}¤�e {Y{ o�q�o-o�xrx}s:~�kpo#qre { µ·k²qya�qyackzxdfs { e"n�µ·kznln ­ e { e"tcs#qye {)­ |�\ R EHG��e /�/�/�e G �ML o�t { qyace�~"su�}�re"x}vXs�t { kltw� � �$# #���&%(* �� �­ |�� R E�� �e�/�/ /+e����ML�°1C�sunlnzs^µ·kltc��qrace�ÅAà qre"�}dfkztcsunls���|u±'qyawefnzk$4�e�nlkzacs:s { D[EH\]I^KL�kzxs�¥�qye�t ~Oo#nlnle { qyace ����#�������N*F, ��� ��, ���O���+*�µ·ackznle D[EH\ce��`I^KL¶klxB~Oo�nznle { qrace1� ����� ,$����� , ��� ���, ���O���+*�°d/ e¬µ·kznln�mcxreo�x/kznlnzmcx}qr�yo#qrklsutcxKs�¥+x}mc~�a d-s { e"nlxAqyace�x}vXe�~"klo�nÂ~Oo#xre"x·s�¥+�ro�t { sude�¹Xe"~�qºo�t { d-k²�7qymw�re¬d-s { e"nlx/kztLj:e"~�qykls�tcx/g�o#t { �:°

����� �! #"�$&%(')$+*-,/.10�"Ä ³��rx�qW~Oo#qre"�usu��| s�¥º¨�©�ª¶x-klxio�xrx}s:~�kpo#qre { µ·kzqra qyace)s ­ xre"��¤ue { nlk64�e�nlklaws:s { ±�D[EH\]I KML�±mct { e��iqyace�o�x}xrmcd-vwqrklsut qra�o#qNk²qi~"o�t ­ e�~�sud-vcmwqye { klt ~�nlsux}e { ¥;su�rd ¦;µ·awkl~�a§klx¥;su�kltcx�q�o�tc~�eYqyace ~"o�xre ¥;su�)d-k²�7qrmc�reYd-s { e"nzx ­ mwq { s7e"x)tws�q�o�nzµ¶oO|7x)acsun { ¥;s��)ack {c{ e"tà o��N4#s^¤�dfs { e"nzx�« °SC�sunlnzsQµ·kztc��¥;�}sud ¦4��«�±wµ·awklnleQ

E�KMLSRUT!V �$�#� W6XMYcDFE�\�I KML�I \��klxB~"nle"o��rn²|�o�t { mwtck �Hmce�nz| { e�³ctce { ±Xe�¤�e"t qyacs�mc�uaYk²qºdfoO|��re �Hmckz�re�¦SÃYª/ÃYª/«Bxrkld9mcnpo�®qykls�t qys ­ e�~�sudfvwmwqye { o�vcvc�}s^�:kzd�o#qre"n²|u±�~�aws:sux}kltc� �KLklx9d-su�}e { e�nlkl~"o#qyefxrsYqra�o#q9qrace{ e�³�twkzqykzsut)s�¥+qyace�x}e"~"s�t { qre"�rd

QE��KL¶klt ¦ �Q«¶kzx/tcs�qBmctck �Hmce�°

©´t�¥4o�~�q"±cµ·kzqracklt�dfkzxrx}kltc� { o#qyo-d-s { e"nzx/nlk$4#e�qyace�d-k²�7qymc�}e�dfs { e"n's#¥Kj:e�~�qykzsut �:° �7±qyace v�o��yo#dfe�qye"�}xdKBo��}e¶tcs�q�o�n²µ�oO|7x8��*&��O��� 2 � �+,$��o�t { qyawe¶v�sux}qre"�rkzsu��dfe"o�t K R3�$��� K I \��~Oo�t�qyace�t ­ e9o-¤�e"�}|�v�s:s��ºe�x}qykzd�o�qysu��° C�su�·kltcx�q�o�tc~�e�±Xklt�qyace�dfk¯�:qrmc�re�~"o�xre#±Ekz¥ ­ s#qyavc�rkzsu�rxNo#t { nzk$4#e"nlkzacs7s { o��re)kztH¤#o��}kpo�t�qiµ·k²qya§�re�xrv�e"~�q-qrs qyace�npo ­ e�nlxis�¥Bqyawe)~"sud-vXs�®tce"t�qyx�±Âo�nzn�vXsux�qye��rkls��ºd-eOo�twx�o��}e9k { e"t�qykz~Oo�n+o�t { qyace�dfk¯�7qymc�}e�~�sunlnlo�vcxre�xBqrs�o-xrkltw�unle ®~"sud-vXs�tce"t�q·d-k²�7qymc�}e-¦Sª¶e�nle"m7��e�qºo�n3°z±T�#�u�u��« °�Ä�xBoN�re�xrmcn²qO±

¨º©�ª�SRUT -��$�#� W6XMYcDFE�\�I KML�I \�� _ V�W$XMYZD[EH\]I �6� � K I \$� L

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 9: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

> � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

klxis�¥�qre"t§tcs�q-oY��s:s { ~�acsukz~"e�°�CTs��ikltcx�q�o�tw~"e�±Aklt qrace)d-k²�7qymc�}e�~Oo#xre�± ¨�©�ª io�nld-sux}qo�nzµ¶oO|:x·nzeOo { x�qrs-o-tce���o#qrkz¤ue¬¤#o�nzmce¬¥;su��7:9 ¦3¨ºe"©´su�}kls-o�t { �·s ­ e��}q"±����u���u« °

Ä�d-su�re��}e"nze�¤#o�t�q·~�acsukz~"e�¥;su�+�KNklx�qrace�vXsux�qye��rkls���dfs { e�su�/d-s { e"x�±�KkEH\dLSR ��� Y�� ���� D[E2K:I \dL�e

xrkltw~"e9qracklx { e"v�e"t { x�s�tYqyaceiv�sux�qye"�}klsu� { klx�qy�}k ­ mwqrklsutLs�¥�qyawe9µ·acsunze9¤ue�~�qys�� K:±Â�ro#qyace��qya�o�t9sut9qyawe¶dfo��r�ukzt�o�n�v�sux}qre"�}klsu� { klx�qy�}k ­ mwqrklsuts�¥Tk²qyx+~"sud-vXs�tce"t�qyx�o�x�kzt�qyawe�dfk¯�7qymc�}e~Oo�x}e�°K`/acklx·nzeOo { x�qrsNqyaceo�n²qye"�}t�o#qrkz¤ue´s ­ x}e"�}¤�e {�� ¨�©�ª

¨�©�ª� 8RUT.- ��� �^W$XMYcD[EH\]I^KL I \$�M_aV�W6XMYZDFE�\]I �K EH\dLNL /�Be�~Oo�nznE¥;su�·kltcx�q�o�tw~"e�qya�o�qO±c¥;su�/qyawe��L® ~"sud-vXs�tce"t�q·d-k²�7qymc�}e�vc�rs ­ nle"d�±wqrace"�}e�e �wkzx}qºodimcnzqrklvcnze�s�¥�����dfo��r�ukzt�o�nuv�sux�qye"�}klsu��d-s { e"x"°�&ºs�qreAqra�o#q"±#µ·ace�t9qyace vc�rkzsu��sut K·klx+mctck¯®¥;su�rd�±#x}s�qyaco#q �K EH\dL�kzx�o#nlxrsBqyace d�oQ�wkzdimcd nzk$4#e"nlkzacs7s { e"x�qykzd�o#qrsu�"±Qqyawe¶~"s��r�re�xrv�sut { kztc�7:9¶±

7O9 RUT!V �$�#� W6XMYcDFE�\]I^KML�I \��M_aV�W$XMYZD[EH\]I �KkE�\�L L�eklx/tce�~"e"x}xyo��}kln²|)vXs�xrkzqrkz¤�e�°

©´t-qyaceBd-k²�7qymc�}e·~Oo�x}e�±:µ·awe"�reºtcsutck { e"t�qrkz³To ­ klnlk²q´|9kzxKe"t { e�dfkz~�±7o�t { ¥;su�Ao�nln�d-s { e"nzxµ·ace"�}e�qyackzx�klxAqyace�~Oo�x}e�±coid-su�}eºt�o�qymc�ro�nE~�acs�kl~"eº¥;su�

QE �KLAklx qrsixre�nle�~�q·o�t�e"x}qrkldfo#qys���D[E�\dLAs�¥'qrace { e�tcxrk²q´| D[EH\]I^KL�±7xrkztc~"e�qracklxA¥;mctc~�qykls�t�klx klt�¤#o��rklo�t�q¶mct { e"��v�e"�}dimwqyo#qykzsut

s�¥�qyace9~"sud-vXs�tce"t�q¬nlo ­ e"nlx�° C�su�ºkltcx�q�o�tc~�e�±Xsutcei~"o�t mcxre�qyaceiv�sux�qye"�}klsu�ºe��:v�e"~�qyo#qykzsut�$� � DFE�\]I^KML�I \��;°/¦ &ºs�qre qra�o#q+qyackzx!kzx�o�nzxrsºklt { e�vXe�t { e�tHq�s�¥cqyawe¶�re�vc�re�xre�tHqyo#qykzsut�¦4��«�° «©´tqye"�}dfx/s#¥!¥;mctw~�qykzsut�o�nEe"x}qrkldfo#qykzsut±Hqyackzx·o�vcvc�}s�o�~�a�vc�rs^¤7k { e"x·x}qyo ­ nle�e�¤#o�nlm�o�qykls�tcx¶qyaco#qo��re�x}mcv�e"�rkzsu�9qrsYqyace�vwnlmc�#® klt e"x}qrkldfo#qye�x D[EH\]I �K<L��Aqyace { e"tcx}kzq´| e�x}qrkldfo#qysu��klxie"o�xrkznz|o�vcvc�}s^�:kzd�o#qre {)­ |�o�tLÃYª/à ª e�¤#o�nzm�o#qykzsut°dCTs���kltcx�q�o�tw~"e�±c¥;s��/o��o�mwxrxrklo�t�dfk¯�7qymc�}eµ·kzqya { e�tcxrk²q´|

DFEHGJI KML�R �� �� 7

���EHGJI � � e � � L�e

µ¶e�a�oO¤ue�D[E�GkL�R 1

!"� #�

�� �� 7%$

#'&� �E�G I �($

#'&�e � $

#)&�L+* ����� D[E�G I^KL I \$�Me

µ·ace"�}e�E�G I � � e � � L { e�tcs�qye�x)qyace { e�tcxrk²q´| s�¥�qrace tcsu�}d�o�n-, E.� � e � � L { klx}qr�rk ­ mwqykzsut±

K'R0/ 7 e ��e1� 32 µ·kzqra4� R E.���e�/�/�/�e � � L65 ±7� RUE.� e /�/�/1� � L65+o�t { 7 R E 7 �e /�/�/+e27 � L85 ±

4�5Jf64�7

Page 10: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �

o�t { ! { e�tcs�qre"xiqyawe�tHmcd ­ e"�is#¥BÃYª/ÃYª xrkzdimcnpo�qykls�tcx"°�`/ackzx9klx9o�nlx}sLqrace)ÃYª/à ªvc�re { kl~�qykz¤�e { e"twxrkzq´|�±�o�t { qyackzx/nleOo { x�qys-o�tcs#qyace��B~��rk²qye"�}klsut

¨�©�ª�� R T.-���� � W6XMYZD[EH\]I^KL I \�� _aV�W$XMY �D�E�\�L�eµ·ace"�}e �D[EH\dL�R�� �� � �D�EHG � L ° &ºs�qreNqya�o#q�qracklx�kzx�o�nlx}s�qyaceWvc�}suv�suxyo�n�s�¥��·kl~�aco�� { x}sut¦S���u�u�u«¬klt ace"� { klx}~"mcx}xrkls�t s�¥·j7vckle��ue"nza�o�nzqre"��e�q9o�n3°¶¦3���u����«�°�`/ackzx9kzx��Hmck²qyefoLxre�tcxrk¯®­ nle�o�nzqre"�rtco#qyk²¤ue�±�xrkltw~"e�qyawe�vc�re { kl~�qyk²¤ue { kzx}qr�rk ­ mwqykzsut kzx �Hmckzqre�~"e�t�qy�yo#n¶qys% ¶o^|�e"x}kpo�tkltw¥;e��re"tw~"e�°�¦3j:e"e#±'¥;su��kltcx�q�o�tw~"e�±ÂqraceWtcs�qrklsut s�¥# �oO|ue�x¥4o#~�qys��rx"±Âµ·awkl~�a o��reN�ro#qykzsux¬s�¥vc�re { kl~�qykz¤�e"x�±��·s ­ e��}qL¦3���u� �Q« ° « &Bs�qye�o�nzxrsYqra�o#qWqyace��}e"npo�qykz¤�e�¤#o�nlmce�xNs�¥ �DFE�\�L ±�¥;su�{ kz¹Xe"�}e"t�q·dfs { e�nlx"±w~"sutcx�qyk²qymwqre�qrace�vXs�x}qye��rkzsu� �oO|ue�xB¥4o#~�qys��rx·s�¥!Ä�kzqN4Hklt ¦ �O�u� �Q« °����� 0���� � $��1$�,/.10�"`/aceNdfkzxrx}kltc� { o#q�o�x�qy�}mc~�qrmc�reNdfo4�e�x�oO¤�o#klnpo ­ nle�dfo�t�| o�n²qye"�}t�o#qrkz¤ue��re�vc�re�xre"t�qyo#qykzsutcxs�¥Eqrace¬¨�©�ª�± ­ |W�re"o�nlnzs:~"o#qykztc�¬qyaceBv�suxrk²qykls�tcxKs�¥Eqrace!W6XMY9o#t { s�¥Eqyace·¤#o��rkzsumcxKe��:v�e"~�qyo�®qykls�tcx"°c/ e~Oo�t�³��rx�q�tws�qye�qya�o�qO±Tmcxrkztc�Wqyace~"sud-vcnze�qye�nzk$4�e�nlkzacs:s { D[EH\ce��`I KML�±cµ e9~"o�txre�q

QE�KML¬o�x¬qraceWvXs�x}qye��rkzsu��e��:v�e"~�qre { ¤�o#nlmce�¦;sQ¤�e"��qyawe-d-klx}xrkztc� { o#qyo�«�s�¥Aqyace��}sukzt�q

{ e�¤7kpo#tc~"e#± QE2KML R T!V �$�-/���� � W6XMYZD[EH\ce�� I KML�I \ce K �&I \ 2

R T!V ��� /��$� �^W$XYZDFE�\ e�� I^KL I \ e�� �kI \ 2R T!V �$��� � �^W$XMYcD[EH\ce�� I KML�I \���/

©´tIo {c{ k²qykls�t�qrs�qyace { k65-~"mwnzq´|�s�¥K~�acs7suxrkztc� �K�o#x�kltLqyaceivw�re�¤7kzsumcx¬x}e"~�qrklsutE±Xµ eNa�oO¤ueqyace)vc�}s ­ nze"d s�¥ { e�³�twkltc�Yqrace�³w�:e { v�suklt�q { e�¤7kpo�tc~�e�±

QE �KML�°��¬t qyace ­ o�xrkzxis�¥ºo�t

klt�qye��rvc�}e�q�o�qykls�t�s�¥'qrace¬¨�©�ª[o�xAqyace¬e �:vXe�~�q�o�qykls�t�s�¥'qyaweA�}suklt�q¶¨�©�ª s^¤ue"��qrace¬d-klx}xrkltw�{ o#q�o:±�oNt�o#qymw�yo�n'k { eOoNklx�qrsNq�o4#eQ

E �K:I \ce��&L R T!V�W$XMYZD[EH\ce��`I ����� K:I \ce�� � L¨�©�ª EH\ce��&L R T -��$�#� W6XMYcDFE�\ e �`I^KML�I \ce�� �_aV�W6XMYZDFE�\ce��`I ����� K I \ce�� ��L�e

o�t { qyace�t { e�³�tce¨�©�ª�� R ��� � ¨�©�ª EH\ce��cL�I \��

R T -��$��� � � W6XMYZD[EH\ce�� I KML�I \�� _ V ���+�^W$XYZDFE�\ e�� I �$��� K I \ce�� � L I \$� /

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 11: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

� � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

`/acklxB�re �7mwkl�re�xºqrace9~�sudfvwmwq�o#qrklsut�s�¥Ko-vXs�x}qye��rkzsu�·e��:vXe�~�qyo#qykzsutL¥;su�BeOo#~�a ¤#o�nlmces�¥��±­ mwq�qyackzx�klx�mcx}m�o�nln²| tcs�q { k65-~"mcn²qo�x�qyaceW~"s�dfvcnze�qreNdfs { e"n�kzx�s�¥�qye�t ~�awsuxre�t ¥;su��kzqrxxrkld-vcnzkl~"k²q´|u°

Ä�x}e"~"s�t { x}sunlmwqrklsut)kzx/qysW~"sutwxrk { e"� � o#xºo#t o {w{ kzqrklsut�o#nEv�o��ro�d-e�qye��/�yo#qrace"�/qra�o�to�x�o9d-klx}xrkztc�¤#o��}kpo ­ nleBo�t { qrsimcx}e�o�vck²¤us�qyo�n �7mco�t�qykzq´|

QE��KML ­ o�xre { sut�e�x}qykzd�o�qye"xAs�¥

­ s�qra � o#t { K �wqyaco#qBklx"±wkltw¥;su�}d�o#nlnz|�±QE �KMLZR T!V�W$XMYcD[EH\ce � � EH\dL I �KkE�\dLNL /

��tw~"e)o��uo�klt±+µ¶e�dimcx}qix}qy�}e"x}xiqya�o#q"±�klt dfkzxrxrkztc� { o#q�oYvw�rs ­ nze"d-x�nzk$4#efqyawe�dfk¯�7qymc�}edfs { e"n3±�qracei~�acs�kl~"e�x¬¥;su�ºqrace"x}eNe"x�qykldfo#qrsu�rx�o��re��7mwkzqye { e"nzkl~Oo�qyeio#x�qyace9e��:vXe�~�qyo#qykzsutcxs�¥ ��±!�uk²¤ue�t)\A±!o��reWv�s:su��e�x}qykzd�o�qysu�}x"± ­ e�kltc�)¥;su��kztcx}qyo�tc~"efo�nzn�k { e�t�qykl~"o�n�mct { e"��e��H®~�a�o�tc�ue"o ­ nzeivc�rkzsu�rxi¦4x}e"e-j:e�~�qykzsut �:° �u«�°�`/aceNs�tcnz|��re�nle�¤�o#tHq¬e"x}qrkldfo#qys���E ���EH\dL�e �KkE�\�L Lklt qracklx�xre�qrqykztc�LqraHmcxixre�e"d-x9qys ­ e-qyace�������O��ÃLÄ��?e"x}qrkldfo#qys���s�¥¶qyace�vco�kl�FE � e KML ±�ukz¤�e"tF\A±wmwtcnle�xrx�sutwe�klx �re"o { |-qys { e�³�tce�o9vw�rsuv�e"� nlsux}x ¥;mctc~�qykzsut)o�x�kzt)ª¶e�nle"m7��e�q·o�nS°¦S���u����«�°��kz¤�e"t qyaco#q�qyawklx�e�x}qykzd�o�qysu�fklx�tcs#q�o^¤#o�kznpo ­ nle�klt ~�nlsux}e { ¥;su�rd�±/µ¶eI~�acs7sux}eYqysmcxreqyace ­ e�x}qi¦4klt�qye��rd-xºs�¥�qyace�¤#o�nlmce�x�s�¥!qyace�vXs�x}qye��rkzsu� { klx�qy�rk ­ mwqrklsut�vc�rs�vXsu��qykzsut�o�nqys(D[EH\ce��`I^KL D[E2KLr«�v�o�kl� qya�o#q/o��rsux}e { mc�}kltc�iqraceÃYª/ÃYª[kzqye��yo#qrklsutwx"° &Bs�qye¬qra�o#q�qracedfkzxrxrkztc�#® { o#q�o·x}qr�rmc~�qymc�}e·klx�mwxrm�o�nznz|~�acsux}e"t-xrs¬qra�o#q�qrace+�}sukztHq { klx�qy�}k ­ mwqrklsutPDFE�\ce��`I^KLklx o^¤#o�kznpo ­ nle·klt�~�nlsux}e { ¥;s��rd�°�`/aHmcx"±�e�¤ue�t)kz¥Âqrace�ÃLÄ�� e�x}qykzd�o�qyeB~Oo�tctws�q ­ e { e��rkz¤�e {o�t�o�n²|7qrkl~"o�nln²|u±Âqyawef¤#o�nlmwe"x9s#¥]DFE�\ce��`I^KL D[E2KML�o#qqyawe�xrkzdimcnlo#qye { v�o#kl�rxFE��Oe KML~"o�t ­ e~"sud-vcmwqre { °

`/awe9¨�©�ª[~"su�}�re�xrv�sut { kztc�-qrsNqyackzx·o�t�o�n²|:x}klx/kzx�qyace�t¨�©�ª��8RUT.- �$��� � �^W$XY D[EH\ce��!I^KL I \�� _aV�W$XMYZD[EH\ce � � EH\dL�I �K EH\dLNL�e

µ·ackl~�a± ­ o��}�rkztc�BoBv�s:s��+ÃYª/ÃYª o�vcvw�rsO�:kldfo#qykzsut�qys·qyawe�ÃLÄ�� e"x�qykzd�o#qre�±�xracs�mcn { nle"o {qysiovXs�xrkzqrkz¤�eºe�¹Ee�~�qyk²¤ue { kld-e"tcx}klsut 7:9��O±7�uk²¤ue"tfqya�o#q"±Hmct { e��/o��To�q¶vc�}klsu��±�qyaceºxre"~�sut {v�o��}qKs#¥Â¨�©�ª��Aklx�qrace·d�o��:kzdimcd ¦;dfs { mcnzs Vu«�s�¥�qyawe·¥;mwtc~�qrklsutWklt�qre"�u�ro#qye { kztiqyace/³��}x}qv�o��}q�o���o�kztcx}qdK¬o�t { �/°�&ºs�qre�acs^µ¶e�¤ue��"±�qya�o�q�¨�©�ª���klx!xrsud-e�µ·aco#q�kztc~"sutwxrklx�qye�tHq�klt�qraceµ�oO|�kzq¶q�o4#e"x���klt�qrsfo#~"~"s�mct�qO°K`/acevXsux�qye��rkls�� { e�¤7kpo#tc~"e�kltw~"su�}vXsu�ro#qye�x ��o�x·d-klx}xrkltw�¤�o#�rkpo ­ nle�x�µ·acklnze

QE �K<L�o�t { qyace��re�¥;su�re 7:9����re���o�� { x �Yo�x�o�t o {c{ kzqykzsut�o�n+v�o��ro�d-e�qye��

¦4xre�e�j:e"~�qykls�tLgN¥;su�·o�t�kznlnlmwx}qy�ro#qykzsutT« °Äºtcs�qrace"��kzt�qye"�}vc�re�q�o#qrklsutE±uo�t { qyaHmcxKo�tcs#qyace���¨�©�ª�±u~"o�t ­ e { e��rkz¤�e { ¥;�}sud?qyace/ÅAÃ

o�t�o�n²|:x}klxAs�¥'qyawe�d-klxrx}kltc� { o#qyo9d-s { e�nS°��Be�~Oo�nzn�¦4¨�e"d-vcx�qye"�¶e�q/o#nS°²± �O���u�7�7�·s ­ e��}q�o�t {

4�5Jf64�7

Page 12: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �

ª�o�xre�nlnpo:± �^�u���w±�� �7° �w° ��« qra�o#q·qyace�~�su�re¬¥;mctw~�qykzsut�s�¥+qyaceÅAà o�nz�usu�}kzqyawd kzx� E2K I \ce K���LZR���� � W6XMYcDFE�\ce�� I KML I \ce K�� �Ze

µ·ace"�}e'K��·�}e"vc�}e"xre�t�qyx·qyace ~�mc�r�}e"t�q � ¤#o�nzmce¬s�¥ K:±co�t { � E�K I \ e K���L¶klx�dfo��:kld-klx}e { s^¤�e"�Kkztfqyawe �à � x�qye"v)s#¥Eqyawe¬o�nz�usu�rk²qyacd�±�qrs9vc�}sQ¤7k { eBqraceº¥;s�nlnls^µ·kztc� ~"mw�r�re�t�q � ¤#o�nzmce�K �°`/ace�¥;mctc~�qykzsut � kzx9mcx}m�o�nznz| eOo�x}kln²| ~�sud-vcmwq�o ­ nle#±�o�x9¥;s��9kltwx}q�o#tc~"e�kzt qyawe�dfk¯�7qymc�}e~Oo�x}e�°K`/ace"�}e�¥;su�}e�±�o�tcs#qyace��/t�o#qymw�yo�n'~�acs�kl~"e�¥;su�

QE �K<L/kzx�qysNq�o<4�eQ

E��KMLSRUT!V � E �KOE�\dL I \ce � K&E�\�L LZR T!V � � � W6XMYZDFE�\ce�� I �K EH\dL L I \ce � K&E�\�L � eµ·ace"�}e �K EH\dLºkzx¬o�t e�x}qrkldfo#qysu�ºs�¥ K ­ o�x}e { sut D[E2K:I \dL�±Xxrmc~�a o�x¬qraceidfo��r�ukzt�o�n!ÃLÄ��e"x}qrkldfo#qys��"±�su� o³w�:e { vXsukzt�q s#¥ � ±7xrmw~�a�o�x¶o#t)ÅAÃÆd�oQ�wkzdimcd nzk$4#e"nlkzacs7s { e�x}qykzd�o�qye�°`/acklx/~�acs�kl~"e�nzeOo { x/qrsfoN~�su�r�}e"xrv�sut { kltc�f¨�©�ª

¨�©�ª�� R T.-��$��� � �^W$XMYcD[EH\ce��!I^KML�I \�� _ V ��� �^W$XMYZD[EH\ce��!I �K E�\dLNL I \ce �K&EH\dL�� /Ä�xf¥;s���¨�©�ª��Q±�qyawklx�x�qy�ro#qye���| klx�~�sutcx}klx}qre"t�q)kzt qyace�µ�oO| kzqf�re"�uo�� { x �§o�x�d-klx}xrkltw�kltw¥;su�}d�o�qykls�t �yo�qyace��Wqra�o�t o�x-o�t e��7qy�ro v�o��yo#dfe�qye"��± ­ mwq-kzqNkzx-tws�qW�um�o��ro�t�qye�e { qysnleOo { qys¬o �O��#����������e�¹Xe"~�qykz¤�e { kzdfe�tcxrkzsut�7:9��"±�o�x!qrace¶dfo��:kld9mcd?nlk64�e"nzklacs7s { e"x}qrkldfo#qys���ukz¤�e"x/qyace�dfo��:kldimwd¸s�¥

W6XMY�� � � D[EH\ce��!I^KML�I \ce K ��yo#qrace"��qra�o�t�s�¥

��� �^W$XMYZD[EH\ce��!I^KML�I \ce K �qyaceWnpo�qrqye���s�¥Aµ·ackl~�a klx�x}d�o�nznle��¬xrkztc~"e(W$XY�kzxo�~�sutc~"o^¤�e-¥;mwtc~�qrklsut°Wĺt o�n²qye��rt�o#qrkz¤�eqys qyace)dfo��:kld9mcd nzk$4#e"nlkzacs7s { e"x}qrkldfo#qys���µ sumcn {§­ e)qys ~�acs7suxre �KOE�\dLqysIdfo��:kld-klxre� E�K I \ce KL�±wµ·awkl~�a��re"vw�re"x}e"t�qyx�oNdfsu�}e�~�a�o�nznle"tw�ukltc�Nvw�rs ­ nze"d�°

����� 0����*� �� ��� � , .�0�"ħqrackl� { o#vcvc�rsuo�~�a�qrs�¨�©�ª¶x!klt�qyaceA~"s�tHqre��7q�s#¥cd-klxrx}kltc�/¤#o��}kpo ­ nze�d-s { e�nlx�klx'qrsºmcx}eAqrace~"sut { kzqykzsut�o�n+nlk64�e�nlklaws:s { ± DFE�\�I �Oe KML ±Xµ·ace��re ��klx�qrace"tI~"s�tcxrk { e"�}e { o�x�o�t o {c{ k²qykzsut�o�nv�o��yo#dfe�qye"��°�`/ackzx�o�vcvw�rs�o�~�a aco�x¬s ­ ¤7klsumwx¬o�x�|:d-vwqrs�qykz~io�t { ~"suace��re�tc~�| { k65-~"mcn²qykze"x"±o�x { kzxr~�mcxrx}e { klt qyace�vco�x}q9nlkzqre"�ro#qymc�}eL¦Sà o��}�rkzs�qrq�¦ �^�u�u�u«�� �}|�o#tHqNo�t { /[kznlnlklo�d-xrsut¦ �^���#��«�� � k²qrqrnle-o�t { �Bm ­ klt ¦��^�u�u�u«r«�± ­ mwq9kzqklx~"s�dfvcm:q�o#qrklsut�o#nlnz|�¥;eOo#xrk ­ nle-o�t { ~"o�tqyaHmcx ­ e·~"s�dfv�o#�re { µ·k²qyaNqyaceBs�qrace"�Kxrs�nlmwqrklsutcx�o ­ s^¤�e�°B¦ &Bs�qye·kztfo {c{ kzqrklsutiqra�o#qA¨�©�ª��

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 13: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

�^� � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

klx�x}kzqrm�o#qye {N­ e�q´µ¶e�e"tNqyawe�~"sud-vcnze�qye¶o�t { qrace�~"s�t { kzqrklsutco�n7o�vcvc�}s�o�~�ace�x�klt9qra�o#q�k²q�mcx}e"xqyace�~"s�dfvcnze�qre�nlk$4#e"nzklacs7s {f­ mwqBxrkzdfkznpo��}nz|Ne�x}qrkldfo#qye�x���° «

Ä t�o#qymw�yo�n!xrsunzmwqykzsutYkltLqyackzx�¥;�yo�d-e�µ su� 4Lkzx�qys�o�vwvcnz|�qyace9su�rkz�uklt�o#n { e�³�tck²qykzsutYs�¥¨�©�ª[qrs-qrace�~"sut { kzqykzsut�o�n { kzx}qy�}k ­ m:qykls�t±:µ·ackz~�aLnzeOo { x�qys

¨�©�ª��8R T -������ � �^W$XYZDFE�\�I � e KL I \$� _aV�W$XYZDFE�\�I � �:EH\dL�e �KkE�\dLNL�eµ·ace"�}eNo���o�kzt�qrace9vco�kl�'E��Oe KML/klx�e�x}qrkldfo#qye {L­ |�qyace/�}suklt�q¬ÃLĬ� e"x�qykzd�o#qrsu�"±�o�vwvc�rsO�H®kldfo#qye {)­ |Là ª/ÃYª�°X`/awklxBo�vcvc�}s�o�~�aLnleOo { x/qysfoWv�sux}kzqyk²¤ue�e�¹Xe"~�qyk²¤ue { kld-e"tcx}klsut 7:9���±mct { e��ºo �To�qºvw�rkls��¶¥;su� �fo�t { K:±c¥;su��qrace�xyo�d-e��re"o�xrsutwx�o�x�¥;s��·¨�©�ª��^°

ĺt o�n²qye��rt�o#qrkz¤�e�x}sunlm:qykls�t kzxNqys xre"vco��yo#qre"K ¥;�rsud �/±/o�x-klt ¨�©�ª�� �·qya�o�qfkzx"±Aqys~"sut { kzqykzsut�³��}x}qBsut � o�t { qyace�tLkztHqre"�u�ro#qye�s^¤�e"� � ~�sut { k²qykzsut�o�nXsut \ ±w�ukz¤7kltw�

¨�©�ª��8R T -������ � � W6XMYcDFE�\]I � e KML I \�� _ V �����6W$XY D[EH\]I � e � K EH\ce��ZLNL I \�� eµ·ace"�}e �K EH\ce��&LXkzx�o�t�e�x}qrkldfo#qysu�Es�¥ K ­ o�xre { sut D[EH\ce��`I^KL�±^x}mc~�aio�x'qraceKvXsux�qye��rkls��Âdfe"o�t¦;µ·ackz~�a�klxAtcs^µ[o~"su�}�re"~�q¶e�x}qrkldfo#qysu� ­ e"~"o�mcxreºkzqAklx ­ o#xre { sutfqrace��}s�klt�q { klx�qy�rk ­ mwqrklsutT«su��qyaceºÃLÄ�� e"x�qykzd�o#qrsu��s�¥�KW¦4~�sut { k²qykzsut�o�n:sut ­ s�qra \Io�t { �7«�°ºe"�}e � kzx { eOo#nzq�µ·k²qyao�xºd-klx}xrkztc�N¤�o#�rkpo ­ nle�x/�yo#qrace"�·qya�o#tYo�xºo�tLo {c{ k²qykls�t�o�nÂv�o#�yo�d-e�qre"�"°¶`/ace�x}kldimwnpo#qrklsutcxkltNj7e"~�qrklsutN�:° �·klnznlmcx�qy�yo�qye�qya�o�q�¨�©�ª���o�~�qym�o#nlnz| ­ e"aco^¤�e"x { k²¹Ee��re�tHqrnz|�¥;�rs�d�¨�©�ª���µ·ace"te"x}qrkldfo#qykztc�9qrace�~"sud-vcnle �:kzq´|�qrac�rs�mc�ua 7:9¶°

� ��,���� ���I�·� � � �f,)�/.�&

©´t qyawklx-xre"~�qykzsut µ e nzklx}qNqraceL¤#o��}klsumwxf¨º©�ª¶x�klt qyace�~"s�tHqre��7q�s#¥�o x}kld-vcnle��ro�t { sude�¹Xe"~�q¶dfs { e�nS°�j:sud-eºs�¥Xqyace { e�q�o�kznlxKs�¥Âqraceº~"o�nl~�mcnpo�qykls�tcxKo��reBtcs�q �uk²¤ue"tface"�}e ­ m:q�o��}eo^¤#o�kznpo ­ nleN¥;�rsud qrace)o�mwqracsu�}x"° `/ace)d-s { e"nKµ�o�x { klx}~"mcx}xre { kzt§j:vckze"�ue�nla�o�n²qye���e�qWo�nS°¦S���u�u�u«�± ­ mwqface"�}e�µ e x}e�qfkzq-mcv o�xfo d-klx}xrkltw� { o#q�o vc�rs ­ nle"d�±Kµ·kzqya§qyaweL�ro�t { sude�¹Xe"~�qrx/�re���o�� { e { o�x dfkzxrxrkztc��¤#o�nzmce"x�± ­ e"~"o�mcxre�~�sud-vcmwq�o�qykls�tcx�o��}eº¥;e"o�xrk ­ nleºklt�~�nlsux}e {¥;su�rd%¥;su��qyawklx�d-s { e�n�o�t { o�nznls^µ�¥;su��o ­ e�qrqre"��~"s�dfv�o#�rklx}sut s�¥Aqyace { k²¹Ee��re�tHq¨º©�ª¶x"°ÃLsu�reºxrv�e"~�kz³�~"o�nln²|u±�µ¶eº¥;s:~�mcx¶sut-qyaceBµ�oO|-qyace�|�o#~"~"s�mct�q¶¥;su�A~"sud-vcnze��:kzq´|�±:k3° e#°�sutfqrace7:9�x"±�x}kltc~�e�qyace��re�klx/tcs-�re"o�nÂd-s { e"n²® xre�nle"~�qykzsut�klx}xrmce�kzt�qracklx/x}e�q}qykltw�c°

j7mcvcv�suxre�qyace��re�¥;su�re�qyaco#qO±w¥;s����dR 1Me�/�/�/�e�7 eG�R � � _�� � e

4�5Jf64�7

Page 14: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# � �

µ·ace"�}e � ��� , E�K e���� L·o�t { � ��� , E��ke� � �L�e�µ·kzqya o�nln'�ro�t { s�d ¤�o#�rkpo ­ nle�xBkzt { e�vXe�t:®

{ e"t�qºo�t { µ·kzqra�Lo�t { qyace�� � � x]4Htcs^µ·t°K`/ace�tnlsu�(D[EH\ce��`I KML R nzsu�(DFE�\]I �&L�_§nlsu��D[E��`I KML

R TZ7 nzsu��V �F_ 1V � � nzsu� E���� � LdT 1

V � � � � E�G � T � � L T 1V � � � E � � T KML /

à o��r��klt�o�nznz|�±<G��� , E2K&e�� � �

_�� � L � , E2K&e�1�� E���� � LNL ±uµ·ace"�}e�� � R�� � �kE��c_�� � L /�`/aHmcx

nzsu�(D[EH\]I^KL�RUT 7 V nlsu�[V �[_ 1V � � nlsu�1E���� � LdT � V � � � � E�G � T0KML /

©´t�qyawklx/xre�~�qrklsut±cµ e�mcxre�o �To#qBvc�}klsu�¶¥;s��]K:°� ��� �! #"�$&%(')$+*-,/.10�"CTs��¶qyackzx·e��wo�d-vcnle

K:I \� , ��� � � � G �� � � � e 1� � � � ��� e

o�t { qyace��re�¥;s��refqrace-vXsux�qye��rkls���dfe"o�t o#t { d-s { e-s#¥ K:±+�uk²¤ue"t)\A±�o��}e ­ s�qra e �7mco�n�qys�K EH\dLSR � � � � G � � � � � � /c`/aHmcx

¨�©�ª SRV¨�©�ª� 8R 7�nlsu��V �1T � � nzsu�OE���� � L _ � � � � � EHG � T �KkEH\dLNL _ V /

CTmw�}qyawe"�rd-su�}e�±7:9 SR 7O9 R21�/C�su�·¨º©�ª �Bkzq¶qymc�}tcxºs�mwq/qya�o�q

�D�EH\dL R ����� DFE�\]I^KML�I \��R V � �! D[EH\]I �K EH\dLNL�e ¦;gH«

xrsWqya�o#q¨�©�ª�� R ¨�©�ª �T nzsu�[V

o�t { 7:9 �8R21]T nlsu�[V /

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 15: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

�Q� � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

j7mc�rvc�}klx}kltc�un²|u±�qyaceN�}e"npo�qykls�tcxrackzv§¦4g�«ºklx�¤#o�nzk { e�¤ue�t qracsumc�ua ­ s�qra D[E���I �K EH\dLNLºo�t {�D[E�� L�o#�re { e�tcxrk²qykze"x"°©´t { e�e { ±'qracklx¬k { e"t�qrkzq´|Lsutcnz|Lacsun { x�¥;su�ºqyaceNv�o#�}qykz~"mcnlo��·¤�o#nlmceP\~"su�}�re"x}vXs�t { kltw�-qrsWqraces ­ xre��}¤#o#qrklsutcx�°8C�su�/s#qyace��B¤#o�nzmce"x·s�¥ �w± �DFE�� L/klx/tcs�qBe �7mco�n'qysDFE�� I �KkEH\dLNL� � V7° &ºs�qreio�nzxrs-qya�o#q¬kzqºd�o4#e"x¬x}e"tcx}eiqya�o�q87:9 ��kzxºx}d�o�nznle��Bqra�o�tF7:9 �kztqya�o#qAqyawe�vc�}e { kz~�qyk²¤ueºklx¶tws�q¶twe"~"e�xrxro��rkznz|-s�¥'qyawe�xyo#dfeB~"sud-vcnze��:kzq´|-o�xAqyaceºxrmcd s�¥Âqrace{ kld-e"tcx}klsutwx�s�¥!kzqyx/vco��yo�d-e�qre"�}x"°

� ��� 0���� � $��1$�,/.10�"CTs��¶qyace��ro�t { sud e�¹Xe"~�qBd-s { e"nS±Q

E�KML R T!V �$��� � � W$XYZDFE�\ e�� I^KL I \$�R T!V ��� /��$�#�^W$XMYcD[EH\ce�� I KML�I \ce�� �&I \ 2R V�7�nls���V �1T � � nlsu� E���� � L

_ � ��� � � � � EHG � T � � L _ � � � E�� � T��� L _ 1kI \�R T!V ���+�^W$XY D[EH\ce��!I ����� K I \ce�� � L I \$� _ 1Me

xrkltw~"e K I \ e � � , E �ke �� L /�Ä�xBoN�re�xrmcn²qO±7:9�� R21u°ÄB¥�qye��·¥;mw�}qyawe"� { e�qyo�klnze { ~"o�nl~�mcnpo#qrklsutwx µ e�s ­ q�o�kzt

¨º©�ª�� R V�7�nzsu�[V � T � � nlsu� E���� � L _ � � � � � E 1]T � � L+E�G � T �K E�\�L L _ � � � �� � T �M7 �K EH\dL _aV]_ 7

R ¨�©�ª� d_ 7 W$XMYFV �F_ 7P_ � � W6XMY � �� � // eo�nlx}sWs ­ q�o#klt�7:9��8R21c_ 7`eM7:9�� R 1u±

¨�©�ª�� RV¨º©�ª��d_)7`eo�t {

¨�©�ª�� R ¨�©�ª��cT"7 R ¨º©�ª�� /

4�5Jf64�7

Page 16: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �^�

`/awe ¤#o�nlmwe s�¥!7:9��Lklx�tcs�qLxrmw�rvc�}klxrkztc�§xrkztc~"e#±�klt ¨�©�ª��O± � kzx��}e"��o#� { e { o�xLo�te��7qy�roIvco��yo�d-e�qre"�is#¥ { kld-e"tcx}klsut 7° `/ackzxNklxitcs#qiqyace�~"o�xre)kzt§¨�©�ª��-x}kltc~�e�±Aklt qrace~"sud-vcmwqyo#qykzsut)s�¥

QE��KL�± �-klx�qr�reOo�qye { o�x·d-klxrx}kltc�i¤#o��}kpo ­ nle"x�°

� ��� 0����*� �� ��� � , .�0�" � *�����% ����$&% % $ � %�� "¨�©�ª���o�t { ¨º©�ª��klt�¤�sunz¤�e(DFE�\�I �Oe KML °i©´t qyaceW�ro�t { sudÆe�¹Xe"~�q�d-s { e"n3±Eqyackzx �Hm�o�t�qyk²q´|{ s:e�x�tcs�q { e"v�e"t { sut vco��yo�d-e�qre"� K xrs qyaco#q)~"s�dfvcm:qykltw� qyawe 7:9�x)o�t { qyace��re�¥;s��reqyace-¨�©�ª¶x { s7e"x�tcs�q�re"o�nln²| dfo4#e-x}e"tcx}e�°FCTs���kltcx�q�o�tc~�e�±:7:9 ��µ¶sumwn {I­ e-��o�t { 7:9��o�nzqracsumc�ua { kz¹Xe"�}e"t�q�¥;�rs�d¸�:± ­ e"~Oo#mcxre �Nklx¶~"sutcx}k { e��re { o�x·o�t)o {w{ kzqrklsut�o#n�vco��yo�d-e�qre"��±µ¶sumwn { tcs�q·q�o<4�e KNklt�qysWo�~�~"sumwtHqºe"k²qyace��"°

&Bs�qye�acs^µ e�¤�e"�ºqra�o#q¨�©�ª�� R 7Lnlsu��V �1T � � nzsu� � � _ � � � � � E�1�T � � L+EHG � T �K E�\dLNL

_ V � ��� � _ / �

�� � E 1]T � � L 2 � E �

�� � L��2e

µ·ackl~�a o�vcv�eOo#�rx�o#q¬qraceNe"t { s#¥�j7e"~�qrklsut �:° ��s�¥¶j:vckze"�ue�nla�o#nzqye��������,�)¦3���u���u« ±Â~"s��r�re ®xrv�sut { kztc�Nqys-o� ~�a�o#tc�ues�¥!¥;s7~"mwx �²°

`/aweN¨�©�ª¶x-¦3¨º©�ª� � �� � � ��«Bnle"o { kztc�fqrs�qyace�xyo�d-e9d-eOo#xrmc�}eis�¥K~"s�dfvcnze��:kzq´|)qrac�rs�mc�ua7:9aR 1 ­ mwq¬qrs { kz¹Xe"�}e"t�q�v�sux}qre"�}klsu� { e�¤7klo�tc~"e�x�xracs^µ acs^µ qraceinlo#qrqre"�B~Oo�t kztc~"su�}vXs�®�yo#qrefo#t o {w{ kzqrklsut�o#n�v�e"t�o�n²q´| ­ | d-eOo�x}mc�rkztc�)qyacefo�d-sumct�q�s�¥�d-klx}xrkztc�)kltw¥;s��rdfo#qykzsut±~"su�}�re"x}vXs�t { kltw��qys ��±'kltY¨�©�ª �o#t { ¨�©�ª��^°9¨�©�ª���kltw~"su�}vXsu�ro#qye�x�qyaweNdfkzxrxrkztc��kztw¥;su��®d�o#qrklsut9kltiqyaweBv�sux�qye"�}klsu� { e�¤7kpo#tc~"e/µ·ackznled7:9��K�}e"��o�� { x ��o�xAo�tNe��7qy�ro]7:® { kzdfe�tcxrkzsut�o�nv�o��yo#dfe�qye"�i¦ 7:9�� R 1]_ 7�« °�`/ackzx¬klnznlmcx�qy�ro#qye�xºqyaweimctcxro#qykzx}¥4o�~�qysu��|Ykltw~"sutcx}klx�qye"tw~�|Ykztqyace�µ¶o^|)¨�©�ª �·q�o<4�e"x �fklt�qysWo�~�~"sumwtHq"±�o�x·dfe�tHqrklsutwe { klt�j:e�~�qrklsutL�w° �:°

� $ ��Af� ����·&¸��� ,)��&Â�'��� ��)�������&

Ä�x�d-e"t�qrklsutce { klt j:vckle��ue"nza�o�n²qye"�·e�q�o�n3°�¦3���u����«Bo�t { kltLqraceie�tcxrmckztc� { kzxr~�mcxrx}klsut±Eo�to��r~�ace�q´|7vckl~"o�n�e��wo�d-vcnle s�¥�o§d-klx}xrkztc� { o#qyo dfs { e"nºklx�qrace �L®´~�sud-vXsutwe"t�q�tcsu�}d�o�ndfk¯�:qrmc�re�klt)µ·ackl~�a

D[E�G I^KL�R �� � 7

�E�G I � e � L�e ��

� 7 R 1Ze

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 17: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

�Og � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

µ·kzqya�tcs#q�o#qrklsut�o�x { e�³�tce { klt�j7e"~�qrklsutL�w° �u°�`/ace�s ­ x}e"��¤ue { nlk$4#e"nzklacs7s { klx

DFE�\]I^KMLSR�� ��

�� � 7

�EHG�I � e �

L /

`/acklx!dfs { e"nH~"o�t ­ e¶klt�qre"�rvw�re�qre { o�x�oºd-klx}xrkltw�#® { o�q�o·dfs { e"nHvc�}s ­ nze"d?kz¥wµ¶e�kzt�qy�rs { mc~�eqyace�d-e"d ­ e��rxrawklv ¤#o��}kpo ­ nle"x � R E�� �e�/�/�/ne����ML�±�o x}e�qNs#¥ �L® { kzdfe�tcxrkzsut�o�nKklt { kl~"o#qysu�¤ue"~�qysu�}x"± { e�tcs�qre {�­ | � � R / � � �e /�/�/+e�� � � 2�� / �ke�1 2 � ±wx}sNqya�o#q � � R21¬k²¥+o�t { sutwnz|fkz¥G�kzx��ue�tce"�ro#qye { ¥;�rsud�qyace�tcsu�rdfo�n { klx�qy�}k ­ mwqrklsut

�E�/�I � e �

L ±w~�sut { k²qykls�t�o�nTsut � � ±wo�t {DFE �� R21 LSR 7 °K`/ace�~�su�r�}e"xrv�sut { kltc�W~"s�dfvcnze�qre�nlk$4#e"nzklacs7s { klx�qrace"t

D[EH\ce��`I KML R�� ��

�� � �� 7

�E�G

�I � e � L���� ��/ ¦3�u«

� ��� �! #"�$&%(')$+*-,/.10�"j:kltc~�e DFE�\]I^KMLklxWoO¤#o�klnlo ­ nle-klt§~�nlsux}e { ¥;su�rd�±�qyawe�d-klx}xrkztc� { o#qyo � ~"o�t ­ e�kl��tcsu�re {o�t { qrace�e �:vc�re�xrxrkzsutcx�¦3�u«o#t { ¦4��«�¥;su��qyawe { e�¤:klo�tc~�e�o�t { ¨�©�ª ~Oo�t ­ ef~"sud-vcmwqre {mcxrkztc� ! xrkzdimcnpo�qye { ¤#o�nzmce"x�K $

&e�/�/�/ne K $ "

&¥;�}sud o�t ÃYª/ÃYª �}mct° ¦H/ e��}e�¥;e��Wqrace

�reOo { e"�/qys�ª¶e"nze"m:�)e�qºo�nS°'¦S���u����« ¥;su� { e�q�o�kznlx/s�¥+qyacetcs^µ�®´x�q�o�t { o�� { kld-vcnze"d-e"t�q�o#qrklsuts�¥·o�t§Ã ª/ÃYª o#nl�usu�}kzqracd�kzt dfk¯�7qymc�}efx}e�qrqrkltc��x"° « `/ace�³��}x}q�qye"�}d s�¥B¨�©�ª ±�¨�©�ª� o�t { ¨�©�ª �Bkzx/qyace��re�¥;s��re

QE�KML * T V

!"� #� W$XMYcD[E�G I^K $

#'&L

R T V!

"� #�

�� �� W$XMY�

�� � 7%$

#)&

�EHG�I � $

#'& e1� $

#'& L�� /

CTs��¶¨�©�ª �±7qyaceºvXsux�qye��rkls��¶d-eOo�tcx s�¥'qyawe¬v�o��ro�dfe�qye��rx�o#�re�~�sud-vcmwqye { o�x qrace�ÃYª/à ªxyo�d-vcnleKd-eOo�twx!s�¥:qyace xrkzdimcnpo�qye { ¤#o�nzmce"x+s�¥:K7± ­ m:qO±�o�x+d-e"t�qykzsutce { klt9j:e�~�qykzsuti�:° �¶o�t {¥;mc�}qrace"� { klxr~�mcxrx}e { kltWª¶e�nle�m:�Ne�qKo�nS°w¦S�#�u�u��« ±#qyawe"xre·e�x}qykzd�o�qysu�}x�o��}e�tcs�q�dfe"o�tckltw��¥;mcn7kz¥tcs·k { e�tHqrkz³To ­ klnzkzq´|B~"sutwx}qy�ro�klt�q�kzx'kld-vXsux}e { sut�qyaweAd-s { e"nT¦3j7qye�vcace�tcx"±#���u����«�±�o�t { e�¤ue"tqyace�t qyace�|�s�¥�qye�tYnle"o { qrs�tce���o#qyk²¤ue�7:9 � x"°B©´t ¤7kle�µ�s#¥�qyackzxº~�sutcx}k { e��yo ­ nze { �yoOµ ­ o�~ 4T±qyace¨�©�ª ¶~"�rk²qye��rkls�t)klx/tcs�q/qrs ­ e�~"s�tcxrk { e"�}e { ¥;mw�}qyawe"��¥;su��qracklx·vc�}s ­ nle�dL°

4�5Jf64�7

Page 18: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �Q�

� ��� 0���� � $��1$�,/.10�"`/aceA³c�rx}q�qre"�rd-x�s�¥w¨�©�ª��Q±�¨�©�ª��!o�t { ¨�©�ª���o��}eAo�nln#k { e�tHqrkl~"o�nS°�©´t�¤:kze�µ s#¥:qracklx�±�µ e ~"o�tmcxre9qraceixro�dfeiÃYª/ÃYª�o�nl��su�rk²qyacd o#x ­ e�¥;su�}e9qysf~"sud-e9mcvYµ·k²qya o#t o�vcvc�}sO�wkzd�o�qykls�tqys �$��� � � W6XMYcDFE�\ e�� I^KL I \$�4±ce �:~"e"v:qºqra�o#q·µ¶eo�nzxrsWtce�e { qys-xrkld9mcnpo#qreºqrace � � x�°

�·e"~"o�nln+qya�o�q �$��� � � W6XMYcDFE�\ e�� I^KL I \$� R �$� / � � �^W$XY D[EH\ce��!I^KL I \ce K � I \ 2 ¦Sj:e�~�qykzsut�w° ��«�° ��kz¤ue�t qya�o#q"±º¥;su�)d-k²�7qrmc�re d-s { e"nlx�± ��� �^W$XY D[EH\ce��!I^KL I \ce K �¬kzx�o^¤#o�kznpo ­ nle kzt~"nls�xre { ¥;su�}d o�x

��� �^W$XMYcD[EH\ce��!I^KML�I \ce K �:R�� ��

�� � D[E �

� R21 I^K e \�LkW6XMYkE 7

�EHG�I � e �

LNL�e

µ·kzqyaDFE �

� R21kI K eN\dLSR 7

�EHG�I � e �

L� �� � 7 �

�E�G�I �

�e �

�L{ e�¥R �

� EH\ce KML�e

qyackzx·o�vcvc�}s^�:kzd�o#qrklsut�klx/s ­ qyo�kltwe { ¥;�rsud qyace�ÃYª/à ª sumwqrvcmwq�K $ &e�/ /�/ne K $ "

&o�x

1!

"� #�

�� ��

�� � �

� EH\ce K $

#'&LkW6XMY / 7%$

#'&

�E�G�I �($

#'& e � $

#)& L 2 / ¦�>�«

`/ace"t�qyace�x}e"~"s�t { qre"�rd klt�¨�©�ª��^±V ��� �^W$XY D[EH\ce��!I ����� K I \ce�� � I \�� e

~Oo�t ­ e�o#vcvc�rsO�:kldfo#qre {�­ |

V!

"� #�

�� ��

�� � � $

#'&� W$XY / 7 $

#)&

�EHG�I � $

#)& e � $

#'& L 2 ¦3�u«

µ·ace"�}e K $#'&R KOE�\ e�� $

#'&LcR��#� K I \ce�� $

#)&�S±cµ·awkl~�a ~"o�t ­ e�~"s�dfvcm:qye { e��wo�~�qyn²|u±To�xBxracs^µ·t

­ e�nls^µ�±Emcx}kltc�)x�q�o�t { o�� { �}e"x}mcnzqrx¬klt% ¶o^|�e"x}kpo�tIo�tco�nz|7xrkzxN¦4�Bs ­ e"��qO±E���u� �^«�°¬`/aceNvw�rkls��sut1KWkzx·o�xrx}mcd-e { qys ­ eoNvc�}s { mw~�qBs�¥!~"sut��}mw��o#qye { e�tcxrk²qykze"x"±

D[E2KMLSR DFE 7 L �� � D[E.� e1� L�e

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 19: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

��> � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

µ·ace"�}e D[E 7 L'klx!o�¨�kz�rkz~�acnle�q { e"tcx}kzq´|�� E /�I � �e /�/�/+e�� � L�±MD[E.� I � L�kzx�o�twsu�rdfo�n { e�tcxrk²q´|�E /SI � e �

��� L�o�t { D[E.� Lºklx�o#t klt�¤ue��rxreN�uo�dfdfo { e�tcxrk²q´|���E /SI�� �MV e� �MVL�°�`/ace

�7mco�t�qykzqrkle�x�� e�/�/�/ne�� � ±�� ±�� ±�� o�t { o��}ei³w�:e { a�|:v�e"�}v�o��ro�dfe�qye��rx"°9© q¬¥;sunlnzs^µ·xqya�o#q

�7%$ #'& R �$��� 7 I \ce�� $#)&� R���� _ ! $

#'& ���� ��

� � � �_��

�� $#'& R �$��� � I \ce�� $

#)&� R � � � _ ! $

#'& �� $

#'& ���� E�� _ ! $

#)& L

�� $#'&

R �$��� � I \ce�� $

#'&�:R � _ � $

#'& _ � ! $

#)& � _ ! $

#)& E ��($

#'& T�� L � � E�� _ ! $

#)& T VL�e

µ·kzqya

! $#'& R

�� �� � $

#'&� e �� $

#)& R 1

! $#'&

�� �� � $

#)&� G

�e � $

#)& R

�� �� � $

#'&� EHG

�T �� $

#'& L e

o�t { µ·kzqra�qyace � $#'&R E � $

#'& e�/ /�/+e�� $

#'&� LAxrkld9mcnpo#qre { o�q/qyace���qra�k²qye��yo#qrklsutfs�¥�qyaceÃYª/à ª

o�nl�us��rkzqracd�°© ¥!µ¶e�mcx}e9o#vcvc�rsO�:kldfo#qrklsutI¦�>�«�±:qyace¨�©�ª ~��rk²qye"�}klsut)kzx�qyace�t

¨�©�ª�� * T -!

"� #�

�� ��

�� � �

� E�G e K $

#'&LkW6XMY / 7%$

#'&

�E�G

�I �($

#'& e � $

#)& L 2

_ V!

"� #�

�� ��

�� � � $

#'&� W$XMY7/ 7 $

#'&

�E�G�I � $

#)& e � $

#'& L 2 /

j:kld-klnlo��¶¥;su�}dimcnpo#e�o�vcvcn²|)¥;su��¨º©�ª �^±Tµ·kzqraLqrace9~�e"t�qy�ro�n { e�¤7kpo�tw~"eQE KML ­ e"kltw� ­ o�x}e {

kltcx�qyeOo { s�t�qracef¦ �}sukztHq�«�ÃLÄ�� e"x�qykldfo#qrsu�"°©´t qyacef~Oo�x}e�s�¥·¨�©�ª��^±+qyacef~"e"t�qr�yo�n { e�¤7kpo#tc~"e�o�nlx}s �re �Hmckl�}e"x9nze"x}x9~"s�dfvcm:q�o#qrklsut±

xrkltw~"e)kzqiklx ­ o�x}e { sut o�t§e"x�qykldfo#qre�s�¥!K qya�o#q { s:e�x-tws�q { e"v�e"t { sut ��°�/ e�qrace"t

4�5Jf64�7

Page 20: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �Q�

s ­ q�o#klt

T -!

"� #�

�� ��

�� � �

� E�\ e K $

#)&LkW$XMY E 7 $

#'&

�E�G

�I�� $

#'& e1� $

#'& LNL

_ V�� ��

�� � �

� E�\ce �KLkW6XMY:E �7 � E�G � I �� e ��

L L�e

o�xBo�t�o�vcvc�}s^�:kzd�o#qrklsutfqys-¨�©�ª��^°

� ��� 0����*� �� ��� � , .�0�"j:kltc~�eqrace~"sut { kzqykzsut�o�nEnlk$4#e"nzklacs7s { D[E�G I � e KML�klxBoO¤#o�klnlo ­ nze�±wµ e9~"o�tYo�nzxrs-mcxre~"�}kzqre"�rklo¨�©�ª���o�t { ¨�©�ª��O°W`/aceN³��}x}q�qye��rd*~"o�t ­ e-o�vcvw�rsO�:kldfo#qye { kzt o�x}kld-klnlo��B¥4o#xrackzsut qysqyace�vc�}e�¤7klsumwxBx}e"~�qykls�t±ct�o�d-e"n²|)o�x

QE ��e KML * T V

!"� #�

�� ��

�� � �

� EH\ce K $

#'&LkW6XMY

�EHG�I � $

#'& e1� $

#'& L /

`/ace�x}e"~"s�t { qye��rd s�¥Â¨�©�ª��"± Q E �ke KL�±HklxA�re"o { kznz|Ns ­ q�o�kztce { ±�µ·ackznle/qyaweº~�sudfvwmwq�o#qrklsutwx¥;su�·¨�©�ª��ºs#¥

��� �^W$XY D[EH\]I � e � K EH\ce��ZLNL I \��o��re¬¤�e"�}|�x}kld-klnlo�� qrsWqracsux}evw�rsuv�suxre { o ­ s^¤ue�¥;su��qraceo�vcvc�}sO�wkzd�o�qykls�t�s�¥

Q * ,��°

&Bs�qye�acs^µ e�¤�e"��qra�o#qWqyace�µ e"kl��aHqrx 7 o��re�tcs nlsutw�ue"�Nv�o#�}q-s�¥�qraceL¨�©�ª ¥4o�~�qysu��±e��:~"e�vwqºqrac�rs�mc�ua)qyace�v�sux}qre"�}klsu��µ e"kz�ua�qyx �

� °

� � � � %($ � �� ���" �� $�����$+$ �-,/.10�� ��* ,/.10��/ e�a�oO¤ue

¨�©�ª� 8RUT.- ��� �^W$XMYcD[EH\]I^KL I \$�M_aV�W6XMYZDFE�\]I �K EH\dLNL�eµ·ace"�}e �KkEH\dL { e"tws�qye�x�oNv�sux}qre"�rkzsu��d-s { e�s�¥�K7±To�t {

¨�©�ª�� RUT.- �$��� � � W$XMYZD[EH\ce��!I^KL I \�� _aV ��� � W6XMYZD[EH\ce�� I �$��� K:I \ce�����L�I \�� /

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 21: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

�^� � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

/ e�~Oo#t�µ·�}kzqye

�$��� � � W6XMYcDFE�\ce�� I KML I \�� R ���#� ��� /�W$XY D[EH\ce��!I^KL I \ce K 2 I \��R ���#� ��� /�W$XY D[EH\]I KML I \ce K 2 I \��

_.��� � � � / W$XMYcD[E �!I \ce KML�I \ce K 2 I \�� /`/ace"t

�$��� � �^W$XY D[EH\ce��!I^KL I \��OR3�$� �^W$XYZDFE�\�I KML�I \dL �:T ���#� Å�t�q(/�D[E �!I \ce KL 2 I \��e ¦4��«

µ·ace"�}eqrace�e"t�qy�}suv�|u±

Å�t�q�/ DFE � I \ e KML 2 R T � � / W6XMYZD[E � I \ce KML�I \ce K 2�� �klx¬ofdfe"o�xrmc�}eis�¥Kqyaweidfk¯�7qymc�}e�s^¤ue��rnlo�v° /[ace�tIqraceid-k²�7qymw�re9~�sud-vXsutwe"t�qyx�o#�re9µ e"nznxre"vco��yo#qre { qyackzx�e�tHqr�rsuv�|Iqye��rd kzxtweOo����Lo#t { k²q�kzx�¥4o���¥;�rsud ��µ·ace"t qyace-dfk¯�7qymc�}e~"sud-vXs�tce"t�qyxBo��}e�vXs7su�}nz|fxre"vco��yo#qre { °

© q·¥;sunznls^µ·x¶qra�o#q

Q+*�,� R

Q+*�, d_ -��$�#� �t�q /�DFE � I \ e KML 2 I \��_ V ���+�^W$XMYZD[EH\ce��!I �$��� K I \ e�� � L I \��kT VSW6XMYZD[EH\]I �K EH\dL�e

&Bs^µ�±To�xrx}mcdfkztc�Nqya�o�q

��� � W$XMYZD[EH\ce��!I �#� K I \ e�� � L I \�� * � � � W6XMYcDFE�\ce�� I �KkE�\�L L I \ �`/acklx/x}acsumcn {L­ e�¤�o#nlk { vc�rs^¤7k { e { qra�o#q

�#� K I \ce � � EH\dL�� R �K EH\dLµ·ace"�}e � �:E�\dLcR ��� Y � ���� D[E��`I \dL /

4�5Jf64�7

Page 22: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �^�

`/awe�nlo�x}q�q´µ sfqre"�}dfx/~"o�t ­ e�¥;mc�}qrace"��µ·�}kzq}qye"tLo�xV ��� � W6XMYcDFE�\ e�� I �6��� K:I \ce�� � L I \�� T V�W$XMYZD[EH\]I �KkE�\�L+*

V � � � W6XMYcDFE � I \ce � K EH\dL L I \ � /`/awe"t

�$�#� �t�q /�D[E � I \ce KML 2 I \�� R T ���#� ��� / W$XYZDFE � I \ce KL I \ e K 2 I \��R T ����� � �^W$XMYcD[E � I \ce KML�I \��* T � � � W6XMYZD[E � I \ce �KkE�\dLNL I \ � /

`/ace¬npo#x}q/o#vcvc�rsO�:kldfo#qrklsut-xracs�mcn {�­ e¬�}eOo�x}sut�o ­ nzeºµ·ace�t)qyace¬v�sux�qye"�}klsu�K¥;su�8K9�ukz¤�e"tF\klx/xrm 5f~�kle�tHqrnz|)~�sutc~�e"t�qy�ro#qye { o��}sumct { kzqrx/dfs { e�°

/ e�qyace��re�¥;su�re�a�oO¤ue¨�©�ª�� * ¨º©�ª d_aV �$� � Å�tHq /�D[E �!I \ce KL 2 I \��Me ¦4��«

¥;�rsud µ·ackz~�a k²q�¥;sunznls^µ·x·qya�o#q�¨�©�ª�� � ¨�©�ª� o�t { qra�o#q¬qrace { k²¹Ee��re�tc~"e ­ e�q´µ e"e�t qraceq´µ¶s�~"�}kzqre"�rkloºkzx�q´µ·kl~�e¶qyace/v�sux�qye"�}klsu�!dfe"o�tNs�¥�qrace/dfk¯�7qymc�}e¶e"t�qr�rsuv�|u°�`/awklx�kztce �Hm�o�nzkzq´|~Oo�t ­ e¬¤�e"�}kz³�e { klt�qrace�e��:v�e"�rkzdfe�t�qyx/qya�o�qB¥;s�nlnls^µ�°

`/awe9kld-v�su�}qyo�t�q·vXsukzt�qBqrs�tcs#qye�o ­ s�mwq·qyackzxºkztce �Hm�o�nzkzq´|)kzx/qya�o#q�¨�©�ª���o#t { ¨�©�ª� o��re�s�¥ { k²¹Ee��re"t�qBt�o#qrmc�re�x"±cµ·k²qyaL¨�©�ª���v�e"t�o#nlk���kltc�9vXs7su�rn²|�x}e"v�o#�yo#qre { dfk¯�:qrmc�re�x"°

� �� � � � � $&% ��� �������� )% " ��/[ace"t ~"o�nl~�mcnpo�qykltw��qracef¤#o��}klsumwx9¨�©�ª¶x�¥;su�qrace�������� ����������������tcs^µ�mcxre { klt dfsux�qv�o�v�e"�rxBsut�dfk¯�7qymc�}ee�x}qrkldfo#qykzsut±wµ e9s ­ q�o�kzt�qrace�re"x}mcnzqrxºvw�re"x}e"t�qye { klt�`�o ­ nle �u° Ä�xsutce�~Oo�t§x}e"e�±�¨�©�ª���o�t { ¨º©�ª � { s tcs�q ­ e"a�oO¤�eLxro#qykzx}¥4o�~�qysu�}klnz| (�qrace�¥;su�}dfe��NnleOo { xqysWe��:~"e�xrx}kz¤ue�nz|�nlo��r�ue¬o�t { tcsut:® kltc~��re"o�xrkztc� 7:9 � x"±�vc�}e"x}mcd�o ­ nz| ­ e�~Oo�mcx}e�s�¥�k²qyx/kztc~"sut7®xrklx�qye�tc~�| klt { e"o�nlkztc�)µ·kzqya � o�t { qrs v�s:s��ÃYª/ÃYª o�vcvc�}sO�wkzd�o�qykls�tcx�qys�qyace�ÃLÄ��e"x}qrkldfo#qye�x"°�`/ace��}e"x}mcnzqrx�¥;�rs�d ¨�©�ª �io��re-tcs�q9�re"nzkpo ­ nle ­ e"~Oo#mcxre�s#¥·~"sud-vcmwqyo#qykzsut�o�nvc�rs ­ nle"d-x"°¶¨�©�ª��ºnzeOo { x·qys-npo#�r�ue��Z7O9 � x·qys7sc±�vc�}e"x}mcd�o ­ nz|�o�xºoWxrk { e�e�¹Ee�~�q¬s#¥�kltw~"su� ®vXsu�ro#qykztc� � o#x�o�v�o��ro�dfe�qye��"±Xµ·awe"�re"o�x�¨�©�ª�� ­ e�a�oO¤ue�xxro#qykzx}¥4o�~�qysu�}kln²|)µ·kzqya �}e"x}vXe�~�qqys�7O9¶±w~�sutcxrk { e"�}kltc�qya�o�q¶¥;su� o��L® ~"sud-vXs�tce"t�q�d-k²�7qrmc�re·qyaceºtHmcd ­ e"��s�¥Âv�o��yo#dfe�qye"�}xklx�� � T 1u°�C�klt�o#nlnz|�±Etcs#qyeiqyaco#q�o�nln�¨�©�ª¶x�kzt { kz~Oo#qre���o#x�qrace-o�vcvc�}suvc�}kpo#qreitHmcd ­ e"�

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 23: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

��� � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

s�¥�~�sudfv�sutce�t�qyx"°-©´t o {c{ kzqrklsutE±Âqyace-e�¹Xe"~�qykz¤�e { kld-e"tcx}klsut ¥;su��¨�©�ª���x}q�o ­ klnzklxre�x�o#¥�qye��� R �:±cklt { kl~Oo�qykltw�9qya�o�q�qyace�e �:qr�yoN~"s�dfv�sutce�tHqrx { sWtcs�q/�u�}eOo#qrnz|�~"sut�qy�}k ­ m:qye¬qysiqrace{ e�¤7kpo#tc~"e/s�¥�qrace/d-s { e�nS±Qµ·ackl~�aWdfoO|9tcs#q ­ e¶xrs�o�vcvw�rsuvc�}kpo#qre�°+`/ace/xyo#dfe�kzx�s ­ x}e"��¤ue {¥;su��¨�©�ª���qys�o)nle"x}xre��e �7qye"t�q"°f¨º©�ª �uk²¤ue"x��}eOo�x}sut�o ­ nleW�re�xrmcn²qyx�mct�qykzn+� R -w°i`/acexrm ­ x}e �Hmce�tHq { e��u�yo { o#qykzsut�¥;su� � R � o�t { � R��fd�oO|�~"sud-e�¥;�rsud qyawe9kltwx}q�o ­ klnzkzq´|klt qyace-vcnzmc�#®´kzt e"x�qykldfo#qre[D[EH\]I �KkE�\�L L�°-`/ace�o { e �Hm�o�~�|Is�¥¶qrace-vcnlmc��®´klt e�x}qrkldfo#qye�xkzxxracs^µ·t kzt C�kl��mc�re�x �9o�t { �7°

10 15 20 25 30 35

0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

0.25

C�kl�umw�re � ( �o#npo��7| { o�q�o�x}e�q!s�¥�� V/s ­ x}e"�}¤#o#qrklsutwx+µ·k²qya � R V·~"sud-vXs�tce"t�qyx�³cq}qye { (�oO¤�®e"�yo#�ue { e�tcxrk²q´| ¦��� � �No�t { ¥;mcnzn�« ±7vwnlmc�#® klt { e"twxrkzq´|-µ·kzqra)oO¤ue��yo��ue�v�o��yo#dfe�qye"�}x�¦ ���� ����o�t { { s#qyx�« ±�vcnzmc�#®´kzt { e"tcx}kzq´| µ·kzqya d�o#�r�ukzt�o�nAÃLÄ�� v�o#�yo�d-e�qre"�rx�¦� ���� ��������� �����Lo�t {{ s�qyx ® o�t { ® { o#xrace�x�«�±+o�t { vwnlmc�#® klt { e"tcx}kzq´|Yµ·k²qya��}sukztHq�ÃLĬ� v�o��yo#dfe�qye"�}x-¦���������� ������o�t {){ o�x}ace"xy«�°K`/ace�tHmcd ­ e"�¶s�¥+kzqye��yo#qrklsutwx kzx �^�w± �u�u��¦ ­ mc�}t:®´kztT«Avwnlmcx �O�w± ���u�)¦4dfo�kztT«�°

4�5Jf64�7

Page 24: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# � �

10 15 20 25 30 35

0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

0.25

10 15 20 25 30 35

0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

0.25

10 15 20 25 30 35

0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

0.25

10 15 20 25 30 35

0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

0.25

C�kl�umw�re�� ( ��o�npo��7| { o�q�o�x}e�qis#¥ � V�s ­ xre"��¤#o#qykzsutcx�µ·k²qya � R � e - e � e ��~�sudfv�sutce�t�qyx³cqrqre { (9o^¤�e"�ro��ue { e"tcx}kzq´| ¦ �� �� o#t { ¥;mcnzn�« ±+vwnlmc�#® klt { e�tcxrk²q´| µ·k²qya oO¤ue"�ro��uefv�o��yo#dfe ®qye"�}x¬¦ ���� ����9o�t {�{ s�qyxy«�±7vcnlmc��®´klt { e�tcxrk²q´|Nµ·kzqra�dfo��r�ukzt�o�nTÃ�Ĭ� v�o��ro�d-e�qye��rx�¦� ���� � ������ � � �)o#t { { s�qyx ® o�t { ® { o�x}ace"xy«�±�o�t { vcnlmc��®´klt { e"tcx}kzq´| µ·kzqra��}suklt�q�ÃLÄ�� v�o��yo#dfe�qye"�}x¦�������� � ������Io�t { { o�xrawe"x�« °�`/aceIt7mwd ­ e���s�¥9k²qye��yo#qrklsutcxfklx%�^�:± �u��� ¦ ­ mc�}t:®´kztT«fvcnzmcx�^�w± �u�u��¦4dfo�kztT«�°

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 25: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

�u� � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

−2 0 2 4 6 8

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

−2 0 2 4 6 8

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

−2 0 2 4 6 8

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

−2 0 2 4 6 8

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

−2 0 2 4 6 8

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

−2 0 2 4 6 8

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

C�kl�umw�re�� (¬j7kldimcnlo#qye { { o�q�o�x}e�q�s�¥ 1 -���s ­ x}e"��¤�o�qykls�tcxºµ·k²qya � R V e �ke - e � e � e � ~�sudN®vXsutwe"t�qyx9³wqrqye { (fo^¤�e"�ro��ue { e�tcxrk²q´| ¦��� � � o�t { ¥;mcnzn�« ±�vcnzmc�#®´kzt { e"tcx}kzq´| µ·kzqya o^¤�e"�ro��uev�o��yo#dfe�qye"�}x·¦ ���� �����o�t {N{ s#qyx�« ±�vcnlmw�#®´kzt { e"twxrkzq´|�µ·kzqraNd�o��}�ukltco�n:ÃLĬ� v�o��yo#dfe�qye"�}x¦� ���� � ��� ��� ������o#t {9{ s#qyx�®´o�t { ® { o�x}ace"xy«�±Ho�t { vcnlmw�#®´kzt { e�tcxrk²q´|�µ·k²qya/�}suklt�q�ÃLĬ� v�o��ro�dN®e�qye��rxº¦���������� ������·o�t {W{ o#xrace�x�«�°�`/aweBtHmcd ­ e��As#¥Xk²qye��yo#qrklsutcx�klx �^�w± �u�u�W¦ ­ mc�}t:®´kztT«!vcnzmcx�^�w± �u�u��¦4dfo�kztT«�°

4�5Jf64�7

Page 26: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# ���

¨º©�ª ¨�©�ª�� ¨º©�ª�� ¨º©�ª � ¨�©�ª�� ¨�©�ª�� ¨º©�ª���� gH��� gH� � ����� ���u� ��� � g �Q� g �O�

�:° �> �w°->> �:° ��� �����:° �u� gc° gu� � ��° ��� gc° �u�� gug�� g��M> g > � >���� gH� � ����� �����

�w° ��� gc° �#g >w° g�� ��>��:° ��� �^�:° ��� �^�:° ��� �:° g��g gug > g��u� gH��� >�gu� g���� �u�u� �u�u�

� �u° ��� �:° g � �:° �u� �^�u�w° g�� ��>w° ��� �Q�7° gH� � �u° ���� gugH� gugH� g���� >��#� � � � �u��� �u���

�^�w° �u� �:° gu� �:° ��� �^�u�w° ��� ���w° �#� ���:° �u� �Q�:° �Q�> gug�� gugug g���g >��<> ����� g���� �u���

� �u° �> �:° gu� �w° g�� �^� �u° �^� gM>w° ��� ���:° ��� �^�w° ��g� g >u� gug > ���u� ����� �u� � gH�u� g����

�^�w° �> �:° ��� �w° �u� ���u�w° ��� ���u° �<> g��:° � � �#gc° �u�

`�o ­ nle!� (-�Be�xrmcn²qyx�¥;s��qrace ������� ��������� ��� ��o�t { ���w± �u�u�Yà ª/ÃYª xrkld9mcnpo#qrklsutwx (9s ­ ®xre"��¤ue { ±w~�sudfvwnle�qre·o�t { ~"sut { kzqrklsut�o#n�¨�©�ª¶x�o#t { ~�su�r�}e"x}vXsut { kltc�e�¹Xe"~�qyk²¤ue { kld-e"tcx}klsutwx7:9¶°

7 7� 7 � 7 � � � � � � � � � � � � �`!�}mce ° �> ° ��� ° �Q� ° ��� ® ��° � � �:° � �w° � ° �u� ° ��g � �u° > ° �u�à o�v ° �u� ° �u� ° ��� ° ���u� ® �u° �u� ®�° �^� �:° �u� �:° ��� ° �u� ° �^� ° ��� �u° >�gÃLeOo�t ° ��� ° ��� ° ��� ° �M> � ® �u° �u� ®�° ��� �:° �^� >w° �u� ° �Q� ° �Og ° �> �:° �u�ÃLd�o#v ° � � ° ��g ° �Og ° � � ® �u° ��� ®�° �u� �:° �Q� �w° g > ° �^� ° � � �:° �#g ° �u�

`�o ­ nle-� (Å�x}qrkldfo#qykzsutY�re�xrmcn²qyx�¥;su�¬qraceWxrkld9mcnpo#qre {I{ o#qyo�xre�q�µ·kzqya �OgM>�s ­ xre��}¤#o#qykzsutcx�±� R --o�t { 1 � e � � �WÃYª/à ª xrkzdimcnpo�qykls�tcx"°

/ e�o�nzxrsWo�t�o#nz|7xre { o { o#q�o�x}e�q·s�¥ 1�-�is ­ xre��}¤#o#qrklsutcx/x}kldimwnpo#qre { ¥;�}sud¸qrace�tcsu�}d�o�ndfk¯�:qrmc�re� / V ��3, E��ke�/-V L _ � /-V � ��, E T 1 / � e�/ � L _ � / 1 � 11, E�V�/ V e � / - L _ � / V � 11, E � / �ke�/ � L /`/acefx}kldimwnpo#qrklsutY�}e"x}mcnzqrx9o��}e-o^¤#o�kznpo ­ nleikzt `!o ­ nze-�w°FC!kl�umc�}eW���}e"vc�}e"x}e"t�qyx9qraceW~"su� ®�re"x}vXs�t { kltw� e"x�qykzd�o#qre"x�o#¥�qye�� V � e � � ��kzqre"�yo�qykls�tcx�¥;su��� R V:°1C�su��qyackzx�tHmcd ­ e��9s�¥

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 27: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

�#g � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

¨�©�ª ¨�©�ª�� ¨º©�ª�� ¨�©�ª � ¨º©�ª � ¨�©�ª�� ¨�©�ª���� ��� � �#��� ���u� �u��� >u�u� g��u� ���u�

�7° �^� >w° �u� �:° �Q� ® �^�w° g�� �w° ��� �^�:° �#� gc° �^�� �u�#g ���u� �>u� g�� � ���#g � �Q� � �^�

���u° g�g �Q�:° �u� >w° �> ®´� �u° >�� � �u° �> �7° ��� �w° gH�g ���u� �#��g �u�u� �u�u� �#g � �>u� �����

�^�:° � � ��° g �w° � ® �Q���w° � ®����u° � g��:°-> �^�:° �� �#g�� ����� > �^� g���� >���� ���u� ���^�

���u°-> � ��° � �Q�:° � ® ��>��:° � ���w° � ��gc° � �^�:° g> ����� ���u� >���� g��M> ����� �u� � ���Q�

�O�w°-> �^�:° � ��>w° g ® �Q���w° � �u�w° � ���:° � ��>:° �� ����g ���> >u��� �u��� ����� �#g�� ���^�

�^�:° �> �w° ��g ���w° ��� ® � ��>w° >�� �u�:° ��� �#�w° ��g ���w° �Q�

`�o ­ nlei� (��·e"x}mcnzqrx�¥;su��qraceixrkzdimcnlo#qye {Y{ o#qyo�xre�q¬µ·kzqra �Og >�s ­ xre��}¤#o#qykzsutcx�o#t { V �ke � � �ÃYª/ÃYª x}kldimcnlo#qykzsutcx(�s ­ x}e"��¤ue { ±X~�sudfvwnle�qre�o�t { ~"s�t { kzqrklsutco�n¨�©�ª¶x9¦;³c�rx}qºnlkztce^« o�t {~"su�}�re"x}vXs�t { kltw�-e�¹Ee�~�qrkz¤ue { kzdfe�tcxrkzsutcxd7:9 ¦4x}e"~�sut { nlkltwe^«�°

~"sud-vXs�tce"t�qyx�±�qyawe { k²¹Ee��re"tw~"e"x ­ e�q´µ¶e�e"t qyawe�e"x�qykldfo#qre"x�o��reftce"�unzkl�uk ­ nle#°�`/ace�xyo�d-eo�vcvcnzkle"xBqys C!kl�umc�}ei�w±X¥;su� � R �w°�`/ace { k²¹Ee��re"tw~"e"x�x�q�o���q¬qys�o�vcv�eOo���¥;s�� � R2-)kztC�kl�umw�ref�w°Ij:kztc~"e�qrace�~�su�r�}e"~�qit7mwd ­ e��is�¥·~�sudfv�sutce�t�qyxikzx9klt { e"e { -c±�µ e�~"sud-v�o��}eqyaceN¤#o��rkzsumcx�e�x}qykzd�o�qye"x¬µ·k²qya qyaweWqr�rmceN¤#o�nzmce"x�kzt `!o ­ nzef�:°(C�kl��mc�reW�)xrawsQµ·xnpo#�r�ue��{ kz¹Xe"�}e"tc~�e"x·¥;su� � R � ± � R �fo#t { � R � °#&ºs�qre�qya�o#q"±�o#¥�qye��� R -w±cqyacevc�re { kl~ ®qykz¤�e { e�tcxrk²q´|�aco�� { n²|-~�a�o�tc�ue�x"°K`/ace¬xro�d-e�vcace�tcsud-e"tcs�t)s:~�~"mc�}x�klt C!kl�umc�}e¬��¥;su�Aqrace�o�nlo��7| { o#q�o�x}e�q"°

¨º©�ª ¶o�t { ¨�©�ª�� ­ e"a�oO¤ue�xrkld-klnlo��rn²|�o�x�¥;su�AqraceB��o�npoQ�:| { o#q�o#xre�q"°�¨�©�ª��/o�t { ¨�©�ª��o��reAtcs�q�xyo#qrklx}¥4o#~�qys��}|�vc�}s { mw~"kltw��tce���o#qyk²¤ueJ7:9 � x"±�µ·ackz~�a9¥;su��¨�©�ª���klx+tcs�q�kltc~�sutcxrkzx}qre"t�qµ·kzqya)qrace��re�d�o�� 4�sut�k²qyx/v�suxrk²qykz¤7k²q´|fkztLj:e"~�qykls�tL�:° �9x}kltc~�e�¥;s��¶qyace�d-k²�7qymw�re¬e �co#dfvcnzeqyaceBvc�rkzsu�KklxKtcs�q �To�qO°K¨�©�ª�� vw�rs { mc~"e�x¶tcs�t:®´kztc~"�}eOo�x}kltc� 7:9 � x"°�¬tcn²|W¨�©�ª��/o#t { ¨�©�ª���ukz¤�e"x+�reOo#xrsut�o ­ nle 7:9 � x!µ·k²qyai¨º©�ª���xre"nze"~�qykltw� � R -ºµ·ackznleA¨�©�ª���kzx!x}e"nle�~�qrkltc� � R � °&ºs�qre�qra�o#qº¨�©�ª��¬o#t { ¨º©�ª �ºxre�nle"~�qºqrace�rkl��aHq·tHmcd ­ e��ºs�¥!~"s�dfv�sutce�tHqrx�� C�su� �O�w± ���u�dfsu�}e�ÃYª/ÃYª?kzqye��yo#qrklsutwx"±cµ e9s ­ x}e"��¤ue { qra�o#q�¨�©�ª���o�t { ¨º©�ª �Bµ¶e��reix�qykznln'xre�nle�~�qykztc�

4�5Jf64�7

Page 28: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �u�

� R -Wµ·kzqraLtce���o#qrkz¤ue 7:9 � x�±T¨�©�ª���µ¶o�xºx}e"nze"~�qrkltc��� R --qrs:s-o�t { qyawes#qyace��rx·µ¶e��rexre"nze"~�qykltw� � R � °

� � �9��¶. �&'����

`/acklx�v�o�v�e"�9aco�x9x}acs^µ·t qya�o#q�qyace { e�¤7klo�tc~"e�kltw¥;su�}d�o�qykls�t ~"�rk²qye��rkls�t s�¥Bj7vckle��ue"nza�o�n²®qye"�9e�q-o�n3°�¦3���u���u«o�t { qrace)~"su�}�re�xrv�sut { kztc� e�¹Xe"~�qykz¤�e { kld-e"twxrkls�t o�nlnzs^µ ¥;su�No µ·k { e�yo�tc��e�s#¥�kztHqre"�}vc�re�q�o#qrklsutcxWo#t { e �7qye"twxrkls�tcxfs�mwqyx}k { e�e��:v�sutce�tHqrkpo�n�¥4o#dfkznlkle�x"±Ko�xNµ¶o�xo�nl�}eOo { | o�vcvco��re�tHq�¥;�}sudÆqraceNvcm ­ nzklx}ace {I{ kzxr~"mwxrxrkzsut s�¥KqyaceWv�o�v�e"��°P/[a�o#q�µ e-a�oO¤ue¥;sumct { kltfo {c{ k²qykzsutiqyac�}sumc�uaWqyawe"su�}e�qykz~Oo�n�o�t { e �wv�e"�}kld-e"t�q�o#n�x}qym { kle�x kzxKqra�o#qAxrs�dfe·s�¥qyace�xre�e��7qre"tcx}klsutcx�±wµ·ackznleºo�x tco#qymc�ro�n � o�x qrace¬s�qrace"�}x"±�o#�re�x}kld-vcnz|-tcs#q/o { e �Hm�o#qyeº¥;su�e�¤#o�nlmco#qykztc��qyace-~"s�dfvcnze��:kzq´|Yo�t { ³cqs�¥/o�dfs { e�nS±'e"k²qyace�� ­ e�~Oo�mcx}e-qrace�| �uk²¤ue ���% � ��2�����e�¹Xe"~�qrkz¤�e { kld-e"tcx}klsutcx�s�� ­ e"~"o�mcx}eBqrace�|We �wawk ­ k²q�qys7sd9mc~�a-¤#o��}kpo ­ klnlk²q´|�¥;�rsud s�tcedfs { e"nÂqrs-qracetce��7qO° /[awklnle�j:vwkle"��e"nlaco�nzqre"��e�q¬o�n3°+¦S�������u«�o��}�umce�qya�o#qºtce���o#qyk²¤ue 7:9 � xo��re)kzt { kl~"o#qyk²¤uefs�¥ºoIv�sux}xrk ­ nz| vXs7su�9³cq ­ e�q´µ e"e�t qrace)dfs { e�n�o�t { qrace { o#qyow±�qyace��reklx�tcs�e��:vcnlo�t�o#qrklsutIs�¥Aqyaco#q 4Hklt { klt sumw�~"o�xre�x (�¥;su�¬qyawe-xro�d-e { o#q�o�o�t { qraceWxyo�d-edfs { e"n3±wx}sudfe�¨º©�ª¶x�o��}eo�xrx}s:~�kpo#qre { µ·kzqra�v�sux}kzqyk²¤ue 7:9!xºo#t { s#qyace��rxBo��re�tws�qO°

ĺdfs�tc�)qyaceW¤#o��rkzsumcx�~"�}kzqre"�rklow±�¨�©�ª���o�t { ¨�©�ª ��x}qyo�t { sumwqo�x ­ e�kltc�)qraceWdfsux�q�re"nzkpo ­ nle)s�¥ºqyace ¨�©�ª¶xfµ e x�qym { kze { (Lqyace�| o#�re�dfsu�}e��re"x}klx�q�o�t�q�qrs v�s7su�We"x}qrkldfo#qye�xklt qra�o#q�¨º©�ª � { s:e�x�tcs�q { e"v�e"t { sut e�x}qykzd�o�qye"xi¦4kzt qyace9~"npo#xrxrkz~Oo�n+xre�tcxreO«�o�t { ¨�©�ª���re"nzkle�x�sut o�~�sut { k²qykls�t�o�n�e�x}qrkldfo#qyeiqra�o#q��ue�qyxoO¤ue"�ro��ue { s^¤ue���k²qye"�ro#qykzsutcx�° ºs^µ e�¤ue��"±qyace ­ e"a�oO¤7kls�mc�is�¥º¨�©�ª��Wklt qre"�rd-xis�¥·qrace)~"su�}�re�xrv�sut { kztc� 7:9?klx��Hmce�x}qrklsut�o ­ nle#° © ¥sutce�s�¥�qrace"x}eLq´µ s ¨�©�ª¶xftce"e { xWqys ­ e�vckl~ 4#e { sumwq�o�x � �O�N¨�©�ª¸¥;su�Wdfkzxrx}kltc� { o�q�odfs { e"nzx"± kzq-klx-mct { s�m ­ qye { nz| ¨�©�ª��Q±/o#xfk²q ­ mwkln { x-s�t qyawe d-klxrx}kltc� { o#qyo x�qy�rmw~�qymw�re�yo#qrace"��t�o#qrmc�yo#nlnz|�±ºx�q�o���qykztc� ¥;�}sud qrace ~"sud-vcnle�qyeI¨�©�ª*o#t { kzt�qye"���yo#qrkltc� s^¤ue���qracedfkzxrxrkztc�L¤#o��}kpo ­ nle"x�° BsQµ e�¤�e"��±¶¨�©�ª��Wkzx9tcs�qiklt�¤#o��rklo�t�q�qrs qyace)~�awsukl~�e�s�¥ �¸¦�µ·acklnze¨�©�ª��¶klxy«�°�`/awklx ¨�©�ª q�o4#e"x klt�qys9o�~"~�sumct�q qrace�d-klx}xrkztc� { o#q�ox}qr�rmc~�qymc�}e ­ mwq kzqK¥4oO¤us��rxdfs { e"nzx�dfkztckld-k���kltc�·qyaweºd-klx}xrkltw�kztw¥;su�}d�o#qrklsut)¦3o�xKxrawsQµ·t�kltfj:e"~�qykzsut��7° gH« °d/[ackznle·oxre"twxrk ­ nle/~�acsukz~"e#±H¨�©�ª�� { s:e�x�tcs�qKtce�~"e"x}xyo��}kln²|inle"o { qys¬qrace/d-sux}q�x}mckzqyo ­ nze�dfs { e�nS° CTs��kltcx�q�o�tc~�e�±+kltIqyacefdfk¯�7qymc�}e-~"o�xre#±�k²q�~�aws:sux}e"xqyace-dfk¯�7qymc�}e-d-s { e"n�µ·k²qyaIqyacef~"nlmwx}qye��x}qy�}mc~�qrmc�re�µ·kzqra�qrace��u�re"o#qye�x}qºe�¤7k { e"tc~�e9o�t { qracklx·d-s { e�nÂ~Oo#t ­ e { kz¹Xe"�}e"t�qº¥;�}sud¸qracedfsux�qB�re"nze�¤#o�t�qBdfs { e�nS° &Bsutce�qyace�nle"x}x"±X¨�©�ª¶x�~"o�t ­ exre"e�t o�xºo+ �oO|�e"xrklo�tL¤�e"�}xrkls�t s�¥Ä�©�ª?o�t { ±Eo�x¬v�suklt�qre { s�mwq ­ | x}e�¤�e"�yo#n { klx}~"mcx}xyo�t�qrx�kltIj:vwkle"��e"nlaco�nzqre"�·e�q�o#nS°!¦S�������u«�±

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 29: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

�> � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

qyace�|fdfoO|Wmct { e��rv�e"t�o#nlk���e·dfs { e"nT~�sudfvwnle��:k²q´| (�¨�©�ª���~"o�t�qyawe"�re�¥;su�re ­ eºe �wv�e"~�qye { qys�re { mc~"e�qyackzx�qye�t { e"tw~�|�klt�oNxre�tcxrk ­ nle�µ¶oO|u°

`/awe¶¥4o�~�q!qya�o�q�¨�©�ª���vc�}s { mc~"e�x�kltc~��re"o�xrkztc� 7:9!x!¥;su�+kltc~��re"o�xrkztc��~�sudfvwnle��:k²q´|�kzx!tws�q¤ue"��|ix}mc�rvc�}klx}kltc�c± ­ mwqKkzq�vXs�klt�qyx�s�mwqKo { �ro^µ ­ o�~ 49µ·kzqraiqyackzx�4Hklt { s#¥X~��rk²qye"�}kpow± ­ e�~Oo�mwxre~"sutcx}k { e��rkztc� �Vo�x�o�t o {c{ k²qykzsut�o�n+v�o��ro�dfe�qye���d�o4#e"x¬qraceL¦4~"s�t { kzqrklsutco�n�«/dfs { e�n�qys7so { o�vwqrkz¤�e�qrs ­ e�µ¶e�nln¯® { kzxr~"�}kld-klt�o�qykltw�c°�j7kld-klnpo#�rnz|�±7¨�©�ª��ºkzxBtws�q·¤ue"��| { klx}~"�}kld-klt�o#qrkltc�­ mwq�k²qAd�oO|Nµ¶o��r�ro�t�q¶¥;mc��qyace��¶klt�¤�e"x}qrkl��o�qykls�t)(�© q klxA�yo#qrace"� x}qyo ­ nle·¥;su�K¤#o��}|7kltw���:x¶o�t {kzq/nzeOo { x/qrs 7O9 ¤#o�nzmce"x·~�nlsux}e¬qysNqyace�tHmcd ­ e"�·s�¥!v�o��ro�d-e�qye��rx·klt)qrace�dfs { e"n3°

�/�#���!�·��¶�·&

à °KÄ�kzqN4Hklt° �!sux�qye"�}klsu� ­ oO|�e"x�¥4o�~�qysu�}xY¦�µ·kzqra { kzxr~�mcxrx}klsutT« °��O� � �� �,!� � � �O� ���M�,� ����2�$#������N�, � ����������� � � ������� #�·±���� ( � � �� �"gH�:± �^�u� �u°

�!° ¶�}|uo�t�q�o�t { �w°XÄ�° /[kznlnzkpo�d-xrsutE° ĺx}|7dfv:qys�qrkl~ ­ e�a�oO¤:kzsumc�Bs�¥�nlo�xrx}kz³�~"o#qykzsutLdfo��:k²®dimwd nlk64�e"nzklacs7s { e"x�qykzd�o#qre"x�°��]�����F���2�������±k>�� ( �u��� w�#� �u± �O�����w°

�W°Hª¶e�nle�m:�X±cà ° Bmc�rtE±:o#t { ª�°7�+°H�Bs ­ e"��qO°Eª¶sud-vcmwq�o�qykls�t�o�nco#t { kztw¥;e"�}e"t�qyklo�n { k;5-~"mcn¯®qrkle"x+µ·kzqraidfk¯�7qymc�}e v�sux}qre"�}klsu� { klx�qy�}k ­ mwqrklsutwx"°��O� � �� �, � � � �O���!�F�������N� � ������$#��2���N�,�!# #���������2�����±c���c¦3�u«0( ���u��:�u���w±w���u�u�w°

à °�¨�e"©´su�}kls�o�t { ª�°#�!°��·s ­ e"�}q"°7¨�klx}~"mcx}xrkls�tis�¥Tj7vckle��ue"nza�o�nzqre"��e�q�o�n3° � x�v�o�v�e"�"°��O� � �� �,� � � �O� ���M�, � ������$#��2���N�, � ����������� � #�������� #�/±O>�g ( >���� &>u�u�w±c���u���:°Ä9° �!°+¨�e"d-vcx�qye"��± &° à ° � o�kl� { ±+o�t { ¨9° º°!�·m ­ kzt°�à oQ�wkzdimcd*nzk$4#e"nlkzacs7s { ¥;�}sud*klt7®

~�sudfvwnle�qre { o#q�o¬¤7kpo�qyaweºÅAÃ%o�nl�us��rkzqracd ¦;µ·kzqra { klxr~�mcxrx}klsut�«�°��O� � �� �, � �]� �O� ���M�,� ����2�$#������N�, � ����������� � #�������� #�·±c�u� ( ��:�u�w± �^���u�7°

�°H�N° Ä9° � kzq}qynze/o�t { ¨9° �°u�Bm ­ klt° �¬t��}suklt�qyn²|9e�x}qrkldfo#qykztc�¬v�o��ro�d-e�qye��rxKo�t { d-klx}xrkltw�{ o�q�o ­ |§dfo��:kld-k���kltc��qyace�~�sudfvwnle�qre�® { o#q�o nzk$4�e�nlkzacs:s { °��!�F�������N� � � ����$#�����������±����( � �O� w�u���:± �^�u���w°

C¶° �°Xª�°ÂÃLo��r�}kls�q}qO°/j7e"v�o��ro#qykztc��d-k²�7qrmc�re�xBs#¥�dfk¯�7qymc�}e { klx}qr�rk ­ mwqykzsutcx�°��]�����F��������� #�±� ��( �>u��w�>u�:± �^�����:°

jX°��Bkz~�a�o�� { xrsut°7¨�kzxr~�mcxrx}klsut�s�¥Tj:vwkle"��e"nlaco�nzqre"�'e�q�o�n3°��:� � �� �,:� � � �O� ����, � ������$#��2���N�,� ����������� � #�������� #�/±O>�g ( >u� �u±����u���:°

4�5Jf64�7

Page 30: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �u�

ª�°T�!°T�·s ­ e��}q"° �&�O���� � � #������ �O����� � � #�� � �� * �N*�����������°Kj:vw�rkltw�ue"���Ke��rnpo#�c±T���u� �u°ª�°#�+°��·s ­ e"��q�o#t { �N°#ª�o�xre�nlnpo:°O )��O��� �Z���,$� � � ����$#������N�, )��� �O�+*�#�°:j:vw�rkltw�ue"���Ke"�}npo��c±&Be�µ��Asu� 4T±)�^�u�u�:°

¨9°+�w°+j:vckze"�ue�nla�o�n²qye��"±6&° �N°6 ¶e�x}qO±�ª�o��}nlklt º° �+°z±!o�t { Ä9°Â¤#o�t { e�� � kzt { e�° ¶o^|�e"x}kpo�td-eOo�x}mc�re�x�s�¥�d-s { e"n�~"sud-vcnle �:kzq´|-o�t { ³wqO° �:� � �� �, � �!� �O� ���M�, � � ����$#������N�, � ����� ������ � #�������� #�·± >�g ( ���u� >#g��w±w���u���:°

à °Xj7qye�vcace"twx"°·¨�e"o�nlkztc�-µ·k²qya�npo ­ e"n'x�µ·kzqr~�ackltc�-klt�d-k²�7qymc�}e�dfs { e"nzx"° �:� � �� �,d� � � �O� ����, � � ����$#��2���N�, � ����������� � #�������� #�·±:>�� ( ����� :�u�u�w±w���u���w°

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 31: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes655, avenue de l’Europe - 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Lorraine : LORIA, Technopôle de Nancy-Brabois - Campus scientifique615, rue du Jardin Botanique - BP 101 - 54602 Villers-lès-Nancy Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France)Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt : Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt - BP 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis : 2004, route des Lucioles - BP 93 - 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France)

ÉditeurINRIA - Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt, BP 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)��������� ���� ���������� ��� ���

ISSN 0249-6399