Click here to load reader

Giampietro Gobo Andrea Molle Doing Ethnography · PDF file But first you need to understand what ethnography is, can be, and most importantly is not. In recent years, ethnography is

  • View

  • Download

Embed Size (px)

Text of Giampietro Gobo Andrea Molle Doing Ethnography · PDF file But first you need to understand...

  • Doing Ethnography

    Giampietro Gobo Andrea Molle

    2nd Edition

    00_Gobo_Molle_Prelims.indd 3 10/20/2016 3:23:43 PM

  • SAGE Publications Ltd 1 Oliver’s Yard 55 City Road London EC1Y 1SP

    SAGE Publications Inc. 2455 Teller Road Thousand Oaks, California 91320

    SAGE Publications India Pvt Ltd B 1/I 1 Mohan Cooperative Industrial Area Mathura Road New Delhi 110 044

    SAGE Publications Asia-Pacific Pte Ltd 3 Church Street #10-04 Samsung Hub Singapore 049483

    Editor: Jai Seaman Assistant editor: Alysha Owen Production editor: Tom Bedford Copyeditor: Gemma Marren Proofreader: Jill Birch Indexer: Adam Pozner Marketing manager: Sally Ransom Cover design: Shaun Mercier Typeset by: C&M Digitals (P) Ltd, Chennai, India Printed in the UK

     Giampietro Gobo and Andrea Molle 2017

    First edition published 2008

    Apart from any fair dealing for the purposes of research or private study, or criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988, this publication may be reproduced, stored or transmitted in any form, or by any means, only with the prior permission in writing of the publishers, or in the case of reprographic reproduction, in accordance with the terms of licences issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside those terms should be sent to the publishers.

    Library of Congress Control Number: 2016941494

    British Library Cataloguing in Publication data

    A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library

    ISBN 978-1-4129-6225-4 ISBN 978-1-4129-6226-1 (pbk)

    At SAGE we take sustainability seriously. Most of our products are printed in the UK using FSC papers and boards. When we print overseas we ensure sustainable papers are used as measured by the PREPS grading system. We undertake an annual audit to monitor our sustainability.

    00_Gobo_Molle_Prelims.indd 4 10/20/2016 3:23:43 PM

  • 1 What Is Ethnography?

    When Hermes took the post of messenger of the gods, he promised Zeus not to

    lie. He did not promise to tell the whole truth. Zeus understood. The ethnographer

    has not.

    Vincent Crapanzano, 1986: 53

    Learning objectives • To gain an understanding of ethnographic methodology. • To grasp the differences between attitude, belief and behavior. • To gain familiarity with the main elements of ethnographic methodology. • To understand the advantages and drawbacks of ethnographic methodology. • To appreciate the historical roots of its development. • To identify the most important methodological differences between doing ethno­

    graphy in sociology and anthropology.

    1.1 Introduction

    Most forms of knowledge are situated and socially constructed. In other words, they arise from people, following specific purposes, in a given historical context whose features they inevitably reflect, including the tendency to perpetuate stereotypes and prejudices. Ethnography is not immune to this tendency.

    As a methodology with more than 100 years of history, ethnography began to develop in the context of the Western world as a form of knowledge investigating distant non-Western cultures, impenetrable to any form of analysis consisting of fleeting contact or brief conversations. Despite good intentions of gaining a deeper understanding, ethnography is still a colonial method that must be, in a sense,

    01_Gobo_Molle_Ch 01_Part I.indd 3 10/20/2016 11:58:49 AM

  • 4 Doing Ethnography

    de-colonialized. And you, students in every part of the world, can make a crucial contribution to that end. But first you need to understand what ethnography is, can be, and most importantly is not.

    In recent years, ethnography is gaining increasing currency in social and applied research, and it may become a mass phenomenon in years to come. Why? Because we now live in what one might call the ‘observation society’ (see Chapter 17).

    The goal of this first introductory chapter is to help to understand the concept of ethnography, to clarify its main advantages and drawbacks, and to identify and outline the more urgent tasks of ethnography in contemporary societies.

    1.2 An overview of ethnography

    Read the following passages from two classical ethnographic works carefully.


    The first thing to note is the prevalence of make-do’s. In every social establish-

    ment participants use available artefacts in a manner and for an end not officially

    intended thereby modifying the conditions of life programmed for these individu-

    als. A physical reworking of the artefact may be involved, or merely an illegitimate

    context of use [...] In Central Hospital many simple make-do’s were tacitly tolerated.

    For example, inmates widely used freestanding radiators to dry personal clothing

    that they had washed, on their own, in the bathroom sink, thus performing a pri-

    vate laundry cycle that was officially only the institution’s concern. On hard-bench

    wards, patients sometimes carried around rolled up newspapers to place between

    their necks and the wooden benches when lying down. Rolled-up coats and towels

    were used in the same way ... Older patients who were disinclined or unable to move

    around sometimes employed strategies to avoid the task of going to the toilet: on

    the ward, the hot steam radiator could be urinated on without leaving too many

    long-lasting signs; during twice-weekly shaving visits to the basement barber shop,

    the bin reserved for used towels was used as a urinal when the attendants were not

    looking ... In Central Hospital, toilet paper was sometimes ‘organized’; neatly torn,

    folded, and carried on one’s person, it was apologetically used as Kleenex by some

    fastidious patients. (Goffman, 1961: 207–9)


    When, in the course of a patient’s illness his condition is considered such that he is

    dying or terminally ill, his name is posted on the critical patients list ... Posting also

    serves as an internally relevant message, notifying certain key hospital personnel

    that a death may be forthcoming and that appropriate preparations for that possi-

    bility are tentatively warranted. In the hospital morgue, scheduling is an important

    requirement. Rough first drafts of the week’s expected work load are made, with

    the number of possible autopsies being a matter which, if possible, is to be antici-

    pated and planned for. In making such estimates the morgue attendant consults

    01_Gobo_Molle_Ch 01_Part I.indd 4 10/20/2016 11:58:49 AM

  • What Is Ethnography? 5

    posted lists from which he makes a guess as to the work load of the coming week.

    The posted list is also consulted by various medical personnel who have some spe-

    cial interest in various anatomical regions. County’s morgue attendant made it a

    practice to alert the ward physician that Doctor S. wanted to get all the eyes he

    could (Doctor S. was a research ophthalmologist). To provide Doctor S. with the

    needed eyes, the morgue attendant habitually checked the posted list and tried,

    in informal talk with the nurses about the patient’s family, to assess his chances of

    getting the family’s permission to relinquish the eyes of the patient for research.

    Apparently, when he felt he had located a likely candidate, a patient whose family

    could be expected to give permission at the time of death, he thus informed the

    pathologist, who made an effort, via the resident physician, to have special atten-

    tion given to the request for an eye donation. (At several places in the hospital:

    on the admission nurse’s desk, in the morgue, in doctors’ lounges, and elsewhere,

    there were periodically placed signs that read ‘Doctor S. needs eyes’, ‘Doctor Y.

    needs kidneys’, etc.). (Sudnow, 1967: 72–3)

    For some of you this may have been your first encounter with an ‘ethnographic account’, a distinctive literary genre which in certain respects resembles a novel.

    Exercise 1.1 Before moving forward, please discuss with your instructor or classmates:

    • Your reactions to the two passages. • Your emotional reactions to them. • Have you ever thought such things could be happening in a hospital?

    1.3 Defining ethnography

    The two above passages were written on the basis of what social scientists call systematic observations. The authors, Erving Goffman and David Sudnow, were physically present at the time that this happened and saw it with their own eyes. The most striking features of these accounts are the precision of the observations, the number of details presented and the vividness of the text. The two authors documented the daily routines of an organization with great acumen and insight, discovering emerging social routines and rituals.

    But, one might ask, couldn’t the same information have been collected in a differ- ent way, for instance by interviewing some of the patients? Perhaps, but this would have required the interviewees to be extremely aware of their actions and possess a great capacity to call to mind every single detail of their lives. Neuroscientists and social researchers would agree that very few people, if any, have these abilities. Couldn’t the details have been gathered by administering a questionnaire to the

    01_Gobo_Molle_Ch 01

Search related