42
j•.,. jW2,•L/c•z• Geological Circular 82-3 SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND EROSION RATES, PALESTINE, KEECHI, AND OAKWOOD SALT DOMES, EAST TEXAS by Edward W. Collins Prepared for the U.S. Department of Energy Under Contract No. DE-AC97-80ET46617 (formerly DE-AC97-79ET44605) Bureau of Economic Geology W. L. Fisher, Director The University of Texas at Austin Austin, Texas 78712 1982 9303110355 930305 PDR WASTE 14l-11 PDR /6ý5ý

SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

j•.,. jW2,•L/c•z•

Geological Circular 82-3

SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND

EROSION RATES, PALESTINE, KEECHI, AND

OAKWOOD SALT DOMES, EAST TEXAS

by

Edward W. Collins

Prepared for the U.S. Department of Energy

Under Contract No. DE-AC97-80ET46617

(formerly DE-AC97-79ET44605)

Bureau of Economic Geology W. L. Fisher, Director

The University of Texas at Austin Austin, Texas 78712

1982

9303110355 930305 PDR WASTE 14l-11 PDR

/6ý5ý

Page 2: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

CONTENTS

ABSTRACT . • ............

INTRODUCTION .............

REGIONAL SETTING

GEOMORPHIC SETTING

TRINITY RIVER TERRACES. . .......

Terrace ages . . •..........

Terraces as indicators of long-term regional uplilt

DOME GEOLOGY AND GEOMORPHOLOGY.

General stratigraphy

Palestine Dome ... .........

Keechi Dome.............

Oakwood Dome ........... ......

Morphologic mapping . . . . .

SEROSIONAL BREACHING OF DOMES

Denudation rates in East Texas

Entrenchment of the Trinity River

SUMMARY

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ..... .........

REFERENCES

* 1

2

3

4

6

7

8 . . .71

. . .81

* 8

10

14

18

. . . 24

S. . 24

28

29

34

35

35

ILLUSTRATIONS

Figures

Location map of study area showing regional structural elements .

Location of topographic cross sections of terraces along the Trinity River...................

iii

1.

2.

3

5

Page 3: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

3. Profile of terrace deposits of the Trinity River..... . . .

-4. Linear regression lines expressing the regional gradient for terrace levels T-2, T-lb, modern floodplain, and the contact between Trinity River alluvium and bedrock ............ .......

5. Stratigraphic column for study area . .....

6. Geologic map of Palestine Dome area .......... .....

7. Topographic map of Palestine Dome area ...... .......

8. North-south and east-west topographic profiles over Palestine Dome.

9. Topographic profiles of terrace surfaces on the western flank of Palestine Dome and adjacent to the dome . . .

10. Geologic map of Keechi Dome area. ... .

11. Topographic map of Keechi Dome area

12. North-south and east-west topographic profiles over Keechi Dome

13. Photograph of tension fracture at Keechi Dome .........

14. Geologic map of Oakwood Dome area .... ........ ..

15. Topographic map of Oakwood Dome area .... .........

16. North-south and east-west topographic profiles over Oakwood Dome.

17. Cross section G-G' of floodplain deposits above Oakwood Dome .

18. Morphologic map of Palestine Dome area .... ........

19. Morphologic map of Keechi Dome area

20. Morphologic map of Oakwood Dome area ........ ... .

21. Location of sampling stations for suspended-sediment-load data .

22. Location of reservoirs for sedimentation resurvey data ........

23. Profile showing Trinity River terraces and depth of incision into bedrock ............... ................

24. Topographic profile of Keechi Creek and its incision into bedrock.

Tables

1.

2.

Denudation rates determined from suspended-sediment load data . . . . 31

Denudation rates determined from sedimentation resurvey data . . . . 31

iv

6

8

9

*11

12

13

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

25

26

27

30

32

33

34

Page 4: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

ABSTRACT

Surficial geologic investigations at Palestine, Keechi, and Oakwood salt domes

have provided information necessary for evaluating these domes as nuclear waste

repositories. Diapir growth uplifted sediments to form domes and created complex

radial faulting. Cretaceous rocks crop out at Palestine and Keechi Domes, whereas

only Eocene Claiborne sediments are exposed over Oakwood Dome. Annular drainage

patterns at Oakwood and Palestine Domes reflect the domal structure. Holocene

deposition is occurring over the center of all three domes in topographic depressions;

these topographic lows suggest that minor subsidence has occurred. At Palestine

Dome, recent sinkholes caused by abandoned brining operations indicate that the dome

is unsuitable as a repository site.

All three diapirs are located within the central Trinity River drainage basin.

Depths to salt at Palestine, Keechi, and Oakwood Domes are 37 m, 133 m, and 351 m,

respectively. Quaternary terraces of the Trinity River reveal no evidence of warping

caused by domal or regional uplift. The average denudation rate in East Texas is

calculated to be 8.85 cm/l,000 yr. Incision by the Trinity River into the bedrock is

S 15 m beneath the present floodplain near the domes. Geomorphic studies of

denudation and river entrenchment in the Trinity River drainage basin indicate that it

is unlikely that Oakwood or Keechi Domes would be breached by erosion during the life

of a potential repository.

INTRODUCTION

Detailed investigations involving both regional and site-specific geology and

geohydrology of the East Texas salt basin have provided information needed for

geologic evaluation of salt domes as potential nuclear waste repositories (Kreitler,

1979; Kreitler and others, 1980; Kreitler and others, 1981).

Investigations of East Texas domes are part of geologic studies of Gulf Coast

salt domes in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi sponsored by the U.S. Department of

Energy. Palestine, Keechi, and Oakwood Domes in East Texas were selected for

I

Page 5: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

detailed investigations. Geomorphic and geologic studies investigated present and

IuLure %LabibiLy ol tic :,all doiin"-s, I lydrologic investigations of the Palestine Dome

area determined that the dome was unsuitable to be a nuclear waste repository. More

recently it has been determined that Keechi Dome is too small to be a repository.

Oakwood Dome is still being considered as a possible repository site, although it is less

suitable than other Gulf Coast salt domes.

Palestine, Keechi, and Oakwood Domes lie within the central Trinity River

drainage basin in Anderson, Freestone, and Leon Counties (fig. 1). These domes are

among 15 shallow domes within the East Texas salt basin. Depth to salt over these

shallow East Texas domes is between 37 m at Palestine Dome and 1,088 m at Brushy

Creek Dome. East Texas domes generally underwent maximum uplift during the early

Cretaceous, reduced growth in the Early Tertiary, and relative stability in the late

Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981).

Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology were

conducted in conjunction with subsurface, remote-sensing, and hydrologic investiga

tions. Site-specific investigations of the three Texas domes are essential to reveal

fractures, warping, and drainage anomalies that might point to dome uplift or

subsidence. Studies of denudation and stream entrenchment in the Trinity River basin

permit evaluation of the potential for erosional breaching of each dome.

REGIONAL SETTING

The East Texas salt basin is bounded by the Mexia-Talco fault zone in the north

and west, the Sabine Uplift in the east, and the Angelina Flexure in the south (fig. 1).

The Mexia-Talco fault zone originated in Middle Jurassic and may have been

associated with the early development of the Gulf of Mexico (Jackson and Wilson, in

press). Initial movement of the Sabine Uplift occurred in pre-Cenomanian (mid

Cretaceous) time, with subsequent rejuvenation continuing until post-Eocene time

(Eaton, 1956). The Angelina Flexure represents a hinge line that marks the southern

limit of the East Texas Basin.

The Mount Enterprise-Elkhart graben system occurs north of the Angelina

Flexure. It consists of contemporaneous down- and up-to-the-basin normal faults with

dips of 350 to 600 that steepen toward the surface. Initial movement on the Mount

Enterprise faults was during the Cretaceous; the most pronounced activity was during

2

Page 6: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

OKLA

I ' , • /SABINE LA

" 0 /s 4' Tyler sUPLIFT

/ KeecI . esi W eons o"/ ok-ood, • ''ka:'

R'iOT' RIVER

EBA IN .

O 5Onsr

0O 80 km

EXPLANATION

-I, Fault

Sail dome

Figure 1. Location map of study area showing regional structural elements.

Eocene time (Eaton, 1956). Recent studies indicate that this fault system was active

duringthe Quaternary (Collins and others, 1980; Pennington and others, 1981).

Basement in the East Texas Basin is probably folded and faulted Paleozoic rocks

of Ordovician to Early Pennsylvanian age. Overlying Mesozoic and Cenozoic strata

record a series of transgressive to regressive depositional events (Nichols and others,

1968). A rapidly subsiding north-trending low, the Tyler Basin, received thick

accumulations of Mesozoic and Early Tertiary sediments. Post-Eocene sediments were

deposited beyond the southern basin margin in the younger part of the Gulf Basin.

GEOMORPHIC SETTING

The East Texas Basin underlies the Rolling Hills and Prairie physiographic

subprovince of the East Texas Timber Belt (Fenneman, 1938). Dense vegetation,

dominated by oak and pine forests, limits field studies in the region. Soils are

predominantly acidic sands or sandy loams of low organic content, and they are easily

eroded when vegetation is cleared. Normal annual precipitation varies eastward from

3

Page 7: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

75 cm to more than 130 cm, and the average annual temperature ranges between 160

and 200 C (Orton, 1969).

East Texas is drained by the Trinity, Neches, and Sabine Rivers. Palestine,

< - Keechi, and Oakwood Domes are within the Trinity River drainage system, which

encompasses an area of about 48,000 km 2 (fig. 1). The river flows southeastward for

about 650 km from its headwaters north of Dallas to the Gulf of Mexico. Elevation at

the headwaters reaches 400 m above sea level, although in the study area elevation

ranges from 60 to 150 m above sea level. The northern part of the basin is a slightly

rolling area of treeless prairies and rolling, timbered hills. Heavily forested rolling

hills characterize the study area in the central part of the basin, whereas the southern

part of the basin is a relatively flat coastal prairie (Leifeste and Hughes, 1967).

Several terrace levels and a broad floodplain, commonly 8 km wide, are

developed along the Trinity River valley. Meanderbelts may be as wide as the

floodplain, and oxbow lakes are common. Along the upper Trinity River, five terrace

levels have been recognized by Slaughter and others (1962), although near the mouth of

the river on the Gulf Coastal Plain, Failing (1969) observed only four terrace levels. In

the study area four terrace levels exist, and poorly exposed remnants of gravel are

common at high elevations. These poorly exposed gravel deposits are designated

"upland gravels" and may represent older terraces (Stenzel, 1938). Terraces along the

Trinity River result from the river's response to base-level changes associated with

Pleistocene sea-level fluctuations and climatic variations.

TRINITY RIVER TERRACES

In the study area, four terrace levels are identified according to their heights

above the river floodplain (figs. 2 and 3):

T-3 27.5 to 36.5 m

T-2 15 to 21 m

T-lb 4.5 to 9 m

T-la 1 to 3 m

The lower terraces are normally better defined than the highest terrace, and outcrops

exposing terrace sediments are rare. The lithology within the terraces varies

considerably. In general, the upper two terrace levels, T-3 and T-2, have a similar

composition consisting of clay, sand, and subangular to rounded pebbles of vein quartz,

chert, quartzite, silicified wood, and ironstone; occurrence of bone is rare. Thurmond

4

Page 8: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

A I

N

Tzý EXASI

0 20 40mi i I I 1 II 1 I1 1 I I

0 20 40 60 km

w E Elevation (

S1 60

0 4000ff

0 -1

Keechi Dome

• PALESTINE

>"-Rtlestine Dome

Ookwood Dome

w E9

Elevation ft f

400--- 2

300 90

200 70 T-2 T-to IT-lb T-3 A

0 f200.

0 4000ff

EFevofieo n r

200 60

40 100

F. loponTI T-fb Frneoon SAY

Figure 2. Location of topographic cross sections of terraces along the Trinity River. From Kreitler and others (1981).

-5

P

Page 9: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

It A

+ IC

100t+ @ Mesquite and

300+ Forney North

-50 @ogLk - 7 8 and Oakwood EXPLANATION

oor Quadrangles x T-3 ST

T-lb

010Trinity River floodplain T-io

00 0 Libery 0 50M

Quadrangle +n T- I 0 80km

Figure 3. Profile of terrace deposits of the Trinity River. From Kreitler and others (1981).

(1967) determined in terrace studies of the northern part of the Trinity River valley

that gravels of a terrace 28 to 37 m above the floodplain consist largely of exotic

sediments such as red quartzites, dark cherts, and vein quartz. Gravels of this

composition, however, are also abundant in the T-2 terrace and less common in the

T-lb terrace, although outcrops of T-lb are poor. No exposures of the T-la terrace

were accessible. Gravels of the T-3 and T-2 terraces, as well as the older upland

gravels, are commonly cemented by iron oxides. The upland gravels are also composed

mainly of cobble-size sediment.

Soils developed on the upper two terraces vary from a clayey loam to sand. Soils

on terrace T-lb are composed of clay to clayey loam, and soils on the T-la terrace

and the river floodplain are predominantly clay (Coffee, 1975). The lower rivet

terraces, T-lb and T-la, are characterized by oxbow lakes and scrolls.

Terrace Ages

Absolute ages of the Trinity River terraces have not been determined, but tý

terraces may correlate with Pleistocene formations of the Texas Gulf Coastal Plai

The upper terrace level, T-3, appears to be related to the Pleistocene Montgome

6

AIA

Page 10: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

Formation, whereas the T-2 terrace level corresponds to the Pleistocene Beaumont

Formation. Terrace levels T-lb and T-la are related to the late Pleistocene or

Holocene Deweyville Formation (figs. 2 and 3). The Beaumont (T-2) and Deweyville

terraces (T-lb and T-la) are well developed along the section of the Trinity River

flowing through East Texas.

Montgomery alluviation, related to the highest terrace, probably occurred

between 170,000 and 300,000 years B.P. (Bernard and LeBlanc, 1965, p. 146). Verte

brate and invertebrate fauna from a T-2 terrace located in the northern part of the

Trinity River drainage basin have been determined to be of Sangamon Age (Slaughter,

1969). The Sangamon Interglacial lasted from 128,000 to 73,000 years B.P. (Suggate,

1974). Figure 2 shows that terrace T-2 correlates with the late Pleistocene Beaumont

Formation, a widespread accumulation related to early Wisconsin interstadials;

Beaumont alluviation occurred from 70,000 to 100,000 years B.P. (Bernard and

LeBlanc, 1965, p. 146). Radiocarbon age dates of wood fragments from Deweyville

terraces (T-lb and T-la) on the Trinity, Neches, and Sabine Rivers range from 17,000

to more than 30,000 years B.P. (Bernard and LeBlanc, 1965).

Terraces as Indicators of Long-Term Regional Uplift

Terrace level gradients from the headwaters of the Trinity River to the Gulf

Coastal Plain show that Pleistocene deposits have not been affected by major regional

or local uplift except at the Elkhart Graben where minor displacement was caused by

faulting (Collins and others, 1980). In analyses of Quaternary coastal plain elevations,

Bernard and LeBlanc (1965) showed that the landward part of the Texas Coastal Plain

was uplifted while the offshore zone subsided. This differential vertical movement

resulted from isostatic adjustment caused by sedimentary loading and by greater

compaction rates offshore. Gradients of Quaternary terraces updip of the Coastal

Plain do not reveal uplift, probably because of the distance from the hingeline

separating the uplifted coastal plain and the subsided offshore zone.

Figure 4 shows lines of linear regression for terrace levels T-2 and T-lb, the

present floodplain, and the base of incision into bedrock. These slopes are similar,

suggesting that no pronounced uplift has occurred. A terrace level near the Elkhart

Graben system (location 9, fig. 4) appears to vary slightly in elevation above the

floodplain, possibly due to displacements from faulting (Collins and others, 1980),

although terraces at other locations also display slight variations in elevation.

7

Page 11: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

Elevohon

fl M +

400 120

0s

200 60 T-2,terrace BeG... .-Io 7

T- lb terrace ® ©

STrinity River floodplai s =slope 0 3 .0kin

all uviumn and bedrock

0 (D-lcotio (D 0 T @ SL@ @

Figure 4. Linear regression lines expressing the regional gradient for terrace levels

T-2 and T-lb, the modern floodplain, and the contact between Trinity River alluvium

and bedrock. The study area is the central Trinity River basin. Locations refer to

figure 2.

DOME GEOLOGY AND GEOMORPHOLOGY

Surface geology and geomorphology at Palestine, Keechi, and Oakwood Domes

document different strata and drainage patterns. Morphological and structural

elements of the three domes are similar, however.

General Stratigraphy

In the study area, sediments of the Claiborne Group crop out except where

overlain by Quaternary sediments deposited by local rivers and streams and where salt

diapirs have uplifted older rocks ranging from the Tertiary Wilcox Group to the

Cretaceous Washita Group. Outcrops of these older strata are typically very poor.

The oldest stratigraphic unit exposed at the surface of Palestine Dome is the

Cretaceous Buda Limestone (Hightower, 1958). At Keechi Dome the oldest units

8

Page 12: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

exposed are the Cretaceous Taylor and Navarro Groups (Ebanks, 1965). Tertiary

Claiborne sediments crop out at Oakwood Dome. The stratigraphic succession in the

study area is shown in figure 5.

Figure 5. Stratigraphic column for study area.

The Buda Limestone is a medium- to massive-bedded, slightly glauconitic and

fossiliferous, microcrystalline limestone (Hightower, 1958). It is overlain by Woodbine

strata. The massive to poorly bedded, very fine to fine-grained quartz sands of the

Woodbine are overlain by the interbedded, very fine grained sandstones and shales of

the Eagle Ford Group. Overlying the Eagle Ford shales are glauconitic, fossiliferous,

chalky limestones of the Austin Group. Younger Taylor Group and Navarro Group

strata are undifferentiated at both Palestine and Keechi Domes. These groups

comprise sequences of massive to poorly bedded, fossiliferous marls, and clays

(Hightower, 1958).

The Paleocene Midway Group consists dominantly of calcareous to non-calcare

ous marine shales interbedded with sandstones in the upper part. Overlying the

Midway Group are sandstones and mudstones of the Paleocene-Eocene Wilcox Group

9

Page 13: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

that formed by fluvial-deltaic deposition (Fisher and McGowen, 1967). Cyclic

deposition continued in the Eocene with deposition of the Eocene Claiborne Carrizo,

Reklaw, and Queen City Formations. These Claiborne units are exposed throughout

the entire domal area. Sands in the lower part of the Carrizo Formation are

interpreted to be stream deposits of either coarse-grained meanderbelt (McGowen and

Garner, 1970) or braided alluvial origin, whereas the finer grained upper part reflects a

lower alluvial plain environment having extensive floodbasins. The Newby Member of

the overlying Reklaw Formation contains abundant glauconite and an open shelf fauna,

although a trace fossil assemblage is prevalent in shallow water. The Marquez

Member of the Reklaw Formation represents restricted marginal marine conditions.

Crevasse splays and small bayhead deltas were sites of coarser grained clastic

sedimentation (Collins, 1980). The Queen City Formation comprises upward

coarsening, shoal-water, delta sequences and polymodally cross-bedded marginal

marine sand shoals (Hobday and others, 1979).

Quaternary terrace deposits of the Trinity River also occur in the study area.

Four terrace levels and an additional gravel unit that occurs at higher elevations,

termed "upland gravels" by Stenzel (1938), have been identified.

Palestine Dome

Strata cropping out over Palestine Dome range from the Cretaceous Washita

Group to Pleistocene terrace deposits (fig. 6). Cretaceous and Tertiary units have

been uplifted to develop a typical domal outcrop having dips up to 50°. Pleistocene

sediments unconformably overlie older stratigraphic units on the western flank of the

dome. Patches of terrace sediments may occur as erosional remnants in other areas

over the dome, although this is difficult to determine. Well-developed radial faults

were mapped by Hightower (1958). The depths to salt and cap rock are 37 m and

36.5 m, respectively (Halbouty, 1980).

The unique topography at Palestine Dome was first recognized in early studies by

Hopkins (1917) and Powers (1926). A man-made lake fills a central depression over the

dome, and is enclosed by a ring of hills (figs. 7 and 8). The dome is encircled by

annular drainage, and intermittent streams in a centripetal pattern flow into the lake

in the central topographic depression over the dome. Powers (1926) observed gas

seeps, mud springs, mud volcanoes, and "craters" or collapse holes that have resulted

from early salt brining operations. In recent studies, 15 of these collapse features

were mapped by Fogg (in Kreitler and others, 1980, p. 46-54). Because of the

Page 14: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

... .... ... - - - - - -

CONTQUR ON TOP OF SALT

-75000FT.

... .........

............. ............ ...

................. ..... ..............

.................

..........

... ........... .................

0 ............

I-

II ml

0 Ikm

EXPLANATION

>ElMODERN ALLUVIUM

z '1TRINITY RIVER TERRACE Ujfl DEPOSIT

CyL UPLAND TERRACE DEPO~ { :QUEEN CITY FM REKLAW FM

CARRIZO FM

HWILCOX GROUP

L .MIDWAY GROUP

E- AYLOR a NAVARRO GRO

E AUSTIN CHALK WOOD BIN E a EAGLE FOI

GROUPS B UDA LIMESTONE

U/-D FAULT -- INFERRED OR

SIT

UPS

COVERED

Figure 6. Geologic map of Palestine Dome area. Modified from Hightower (1958).

11

RD

Page 15: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

0 '~~ ~ .........~ ' 0 0

.0,00• '.° • a° 0,, a'• 0

I ao 0

* o4o 0 'o -' a

3000

o o a 'o ' 0 % , * 0', . 0

000*0oo .. 0o *• .°o

o o o *oo a

o 0 0 o o- o ... 0 0 0 0 0 30 • o0.000000

o a 30 33 0 0 :oaa0,,

300000 aoo° o0o 0 ~ o 00

° °o~o0,o 00a ,•0 0~

'o 'o 30 o .. ~ ~

0 Imi

0 1 kmLake

4 Swamp

Elevation (above msl) • -350 ft 250-300ft

(>107m) (76- 92m)

300-350ft F <250ft

(92- 107m) 76 (<7Gm)

-1 0 1000 ft contour on top F 7r00ofP t i of Soal

Figure 7. Topographic map of Palestine Domeaa.ro eterndohs(91)

12

Page 16: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

Elevation ft m

400- N $

-110 1350

100

300 90 Duggey's Lake

80 250

70

200- < 0 2000ft Salt at-IO00 ft (-305 rn) l- I

0 1 km

Elevation ft m WE

350- 1 W I00

300 90 Duggey's 80 j Lke

25070

200-I 0 2000ft

I • •Salt at -100ft (-305 m) 0 Ikm

Figure 8. North-south and east-west topographic profiles over Palestine Dome. Width of dome at the -305-m contour of salt is shown below the profile. From Kreitler and others (1981).

potential for additional collapses caused by inactive brining operations and the

uncertainty of long-term hydrologic stability at the dome, Palestine Dome was

eliminated as a potential site for a nuclear waste repository (Kreitler and others, 1980,

p. 46-54).

Palestine Dome is one of the few salt domes in East Texas that is overlain by

well-developed Quaternary terrace deposits. The stability of East Texas salt domes

during the Quaternary is an important criterion when evaluating domes as nuclear

waste repository sites. Topographic profiles of the terrace surface over and near the

dome do not indicate warping of Quaternary deposits. At Palestine Dome, the T-3

terrace level overlies the western flank of the dome (fig. 6). A topographic profile of

the T-3 terrace surface on the west flank of the dome matches profiles of the same

13

Page 17: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

terrace surface north and south of the dome (figs. 6 and 9). This suggests that no

dome growth has occurred since deposition of the terrace deposits, although this

assumption is based on the idea that the terrace surface has not been leveled by

' . erosion.

Keechi Dome

Strata cropping out at Keechi Dome are of Cretaceous, Tertiary, and Quaternary

age (fig. 10). Rocks within the Taylor and Navarro Groups are the oldest sediments

exposed. Strata exhibit dips up to 450, and radial faults exist (Ebanks, 1965).

Quaternary terrace deposits occur in the domal area, but exposures are poor. Brief

investigations of these Quaternary deposits indicate no evidence of warping or

faulting. The depths to salt and cap rock are 133 m and 38 m, respectively (Halbouty,

1980).

The topographic expression at Keechi Dome is not as conspicuous as at other

interior salt domes. However, Keechi Creek flows north-south across the dome,

through a slight topographic low over the center of the dome (figs. II and 12). The

drainage pattern in the area is subdendritic, and relief of about 30 m occurs between

the central topographic low occupied by Keechi Creek and surrounding peripheral hills.

Powers (1926) reported that the only evidence of salt at the surface is a small salt lick

located on the Keechi Creek floodplain.

Two unusual cracks or fissures (fig. 13) were observed at Keechi Dome in

November, 1979 (Kreitler and others, 1981). A landowner reported that the cracks

were first discovered in the spring of 1978. By May 1980 the cracks had been filled by

slumping and soil erosion. These fractures display trends of N. 70 E. and N. 670 W. and

are located along a southeastern extension of an inferred fault mapped near the dome

center by Ebanks (1965) (fig. 10). The relation of the fractures to the inferred fault is

speculative. When first observed in November 1979, these fractores appeared to be

nearly vertical and were 30 m and 12 m long. The larger fracture was 3.5 cm wide.

Exact depth of the cracks is unknown, but the base of the larger crack was deeper than

I m. An approximate depth of 4 m was measured by landowners in the spring of 1978,

but this has not been documented. The upper meter of soil cover is composed of 50 cm

of slightly clayey sand above 20 cm of red to yellow mottled clay and 30 cm of silty

clay. Although the mechanism that produced the fractures is unknown, the fractures

appear to be tensional rather than shear fractures because they were dilated and

because no offset was observed.

14

Page 18: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

(

ELEV It m

350- I00

300 -90

-80

250 -70

200 60

ELEV ft m

350

I00

300 90

-80

250" _70

200 -60

-50

150

T-3

7 CLAIBORNE GROUP

(

ELEV ft m 400- 120

350 -00

300 90

-80 250

-0SALT AT IOOTMt

0C

C /

T-3

T-I / CLAIBORNE GROUP

0 "'2 I ni

0 "2 1 km

Figure 9. Topographic profiles of terrace surfaces on the western flank of Palestine Dome and adjacent to the dome.

From Kreitler and others (1981).

(

8

B

ELEV ft m

350

-I0

300 -9C

C-8

250-7C

200 -6

-5(

150i

• _ ~T-3

CLAIBORNE GROUP

Page 19: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

QUATERNARY TERTIARY CRETACEOUS

V Io I ya

Modern "Upland gravel" Queen City Reklaw Corrizo Wilcox Midway Taylor a Navarro

alluvium terrace Formation Formation Formation Group Group Groups (undiff.)

0 Fault, dashed where /4 Strike and dip "•-5Oo,./. Contour on lop of m Location of tension

"t -covered or inferred salt I fractures

Figure 10. Geologic map of Keechi Dome area. Modif ied from Ebanks (1965).

16

.. ... ... ... ..........! : • ............ ..i i ... .... . .... :..-.-.

. . . . . . . . .. . . . . . .... . . ...

::. \... .. ... ..... : . .......

...............................

~~~~~. . .'." " ...": : : ' • : " " " . . . . . . W

~~~~. . . . .. . . . . . .. .. . . .* ° " Q

S..... .... ... .. ..... . •.. .. !i..... .... ii ~~. . . . ....... . . . . .

~~~~~~~~~.. . ..........i~ i~ i~ i ii i i ii i~ i i

(• ; m .i ii~ i ii~ i iiii i~ ii ii~ i iii. .A.E . .. ,...... ...... ::

Page 20: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

I mi

km Lake

Swamp

-•1000 - I( conlour

-/oooft '•• on top of salt

Elevation (above mslO

50Oft ~( ::,- 152m)

=475 - 500 ft

0145 -152 m)

.150 -4175f I

M337- 145m I

4 25 - 4 50 f t

(130-137m')

r7- 400-425ft

375 -400fl (114-122m)

350 -375 ft

(107- 114m)

325 - 350f.i

(99 -107 m)

300-325ft

t 92-99m)

Z 300 ft

-9 2 m)

Figure 11. Topographic map of Keechi Dome area. From Kreitler and others (1981).

17

0

0

N

Page 21: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

Elevation ft m

550 160 N S

500--150

-140 450

-130

4005 1020

-110 350

-100

300 -90 Salt at -1000 ft (-305m) -80 0 km

250 1 , , _ -70 0 200Oft

Elevation

ft m 550

160 W E

500 150

-140 450

_130

400- 120

-110 350 _ too- oII 300-90 I

0 1km Salt at -l00ft (-305m) S i I I

0 2000 ft

Figure 12. North-south and east-west topographic profiles over Keechi Dome. Width of dome at the -305-m contour of salt is shown below the profile. From Kreitler and others (1981).

Oakwood Dome

Eocene Claiborne strata crop out in domal configuration over Oakwood Dome

(fig. 14) (Collins and others, 1981). Claiborne strata compose the Carrizo, Reklaw, and

Queen City Formations. These stratigraphic units dip up to 200. Quaternary terrace

18

Page 22: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

Figure 13. Photograph of tension fracture at Keechi Dome. Scale is in 10-cm increments. Width of fracture is 3.5 cm. Photograph was taken in November 1979.

deposits exist over the southern half of Oakwood Dome and appear unaffected by

domal uplift and faults. Four normal faults visible in outcrop cut only Claiborne strata

downthrown away from the dome. Additional fracture zones are common, and a

lineament pattern visible on aerial photographs is probably fault-controlled. None of

the faults can be shown to displace Quaternary strata, but because of poor exposures

19

Page 23: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

........................ .............: .............................................................: .............ii i i i i i

: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : .. ...... ... ... ..= = •: i i~ i~

. .. . ....... ... . . .... . . . . Q . . . . . . . . . . . . .: : : : . . . . . .. .. . .. .. . .. .. . .. . . .. ...R . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . .... .

. ._ _ , ,, ,.o . ,, ..... .,......... ........... ......~i~ i ! ! !i i ' :: ! ! ;i ! !~ i : i.. .... . ...... .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~:: : : ............ii i i i i i~ ii i i i ii i i i !!i i ;; i i• " . . . .. . . .

....... ...................

oK ,o • ao eh~ ei : •: : : : : : : : S .. .. .. .. . . . . . . .. . . . . . .. .. .. . . .. . . .. .... .. . .

. . . . .. .. .. .. ..... . .... . . . .. ..k .. . ..-.. . . ......00 l( 05 )c no ¢ ntpo s l . . .. • . •. :: : : : :

Figure......... ... Ge l.cma..aw odD m.r..F o olisa dohes( 1...

......... erosion .. .he ..rc uf •dslc m n ano eetrl ic utd h ............ .......... sa t a d.a.o.ae.-1 m a d 1 •r sp c i e y

The....... ........h .b v a w o o e i h rctrz d b o t -e ta depression.... suro.de ..... _1rsetsapdrdeao14h etr, oten n

eastern~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~_ ....... ........is.15ad 6.Tta eie vrth oeis75m .......... ....... su d ndZi ove the .en.e o5te d me h ra a n lrdria e

presen. ....... ...... we.r...asen5a k. oo e e •lo pani l tdi h topograph...... deresi..boe.hedoe

20

Page 24: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

0

0 lkm

N

I mi

N)Lake ' Swamp

• .• ,j.-1000 ft contour

on top of salt

Elevation

00 50Oft (>152m)

(137 - 152 m)

S400-450ftI

(122-137m)

(above MSL}

Fý-350-400ft

Lj (107- 122m)

300-350f, (92 - I07m)

< 3500 ft (ý- 92m )

Figure 15. Topographic map of Oakwood Dome area. From Kreitler and others (1981).

21

Page 25: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

•- Elevation

ft1 m

Elevation

ft, m

SN

-- SaIt at - i000 ft (-305 m)-A

0 6000 ft

0 2 km

W

-150

-130

400

300I--Salt at -Q000 ft (-:305 m)----

O 6000 it

0 I 2km

Figure 16. North-south and east-west topographic profiles over Oakwood Dome.

Width of dome at the -305-m contour of salt is shown below the profile. From

Kreitler and others (1981).

22

E

Page 26: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

INCISION INTO BEDROCK GI Q.

20

50 -. X. . :i:iii!!::i:::.... .. .....

OK 0(4O

201 OK OK10 IOO0f 202 OK O

S V E . = 2 = I . ... ... ..... . . . .

.20

DOME CENTER SOUTHERN MARGIN OF SALT

"• MODERN ALLUVIUM- Ranges from fine to coarse :17 CLAIBORNE GROUP - Ranges from fine sand

sand, clayey fine sand, and silty clay to and inlerloyered clayey sand to

pebble-sized ironstone gravel silly cloy, burrowed, corbonaceous

QUATERNARY TERTIARY

Figure 17. Cross section G-G' of floodplain deposits above Oakwood Dome. Location

of section G-G' shown on figure 14. From Collins and others (1981).

Ten shallow boreholes were drilled into floodplain deposits to determine and

compare the thickness variations of these Holocene deposits over and adjacent to the

dome (fig. 17). Floodplain deposits consist of a persistent basal gravel (10 to 40 cm)

composed of subrounded to subangular ironstone pebbles and coarse- to medium

grained sand. Medium- to fine-grained sand and silty clay overlie the gravel. Over the

dome these Holocene floodplain deposits are consistently 8 to I I m thick, but flanking

the dome they thin to 4 m (fig. 17). At the center of the dome, 200 m north of the

well-developed floodplain, the intermittent streams are incising bedrock. Variations in

the thickness of Holocene deposits suggest that subsidence may have occurred before

or during deposition of the floodplain deposits, resulting in accumulation of thicker

sediment above the dome (Collins and others, 1981).

Evidence of subsidence has been noticed at other salt domes. Natural collapse

has been reported I km west of Butler Dome's center, where Lake Port is now (Powers,

1926). Significant post-Pleistocene dissolution and subsidence with contemporary

Holocene deposition were confirmed at Jefferson Island salt dome in Louisiana. After

man-induced collapse of a salt mine drained Lake Peigneur, several hundred feet of

soft lake sediment were identified over the dome. The lake had previously filled a

central depression over the dome (Martinez and others, 1981). Subsidence may result

23

NF"P(")AI T IC}N

Page 27: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

from volume loss created by salt dissolution, or cap rock dissolution, or by ground

water, although this has not yet been established at Oakwood Dome.

Morphologic Mapping

Morphologic mapping of Palestine, Keechi, and Oakwood Domes (figs. 18, 19,

and 20) shows that hillside slopes at Oakwood are steeper than at the other domes. All

three domes display central topographic depressions in which modern sediments are

being deposited. Morphologic maps of the domes distinguish between slopes formed by

erosional processes and slopes formed by depositional processes. U.S. Geological

Survey topographic maps (scale 1:24,000) were used to determine degree of slope over

the domes.

Erosional slopes at Oakwood Dome are steeper than slopes at Keechi and

Palestine Domes. At Oakwood Dome approximately 50 percent of the surface has

slopes from 5 to 15 , whereas over Keechi Dome greater than 95 percent of the area has slopes from 00 to 50. Over Palestine Dome, hillsides having gradients from 0 to 50 comprise approximately 65 percent of the area. Above Oakwood and Palestine

Domes (but not at Keechi), erosional slopes are steeper than those near the dome.

Despite the variations in erosional slope at the different domes, all three domes

display depositional slopes commonly in a central topographic depression. In the

central area over Palestine Dome a man-made lake is surrounded by a ring of hills

(fig. 18). At Keechi Dome the floodplain of Keechi Creek in the central dome area is

approximately three times as wide as the floodplain upstream and downstream

marginal to the dome (fig. 19). In the south-central part of Oakwood Dome, a

relatively large floodplain has developed (fig. 20). Drilling at Oakwood has revealed

that the modern floodplain alluvium is twice as thick over the dome as in adjacent

areas. Topographic lows are also prominent above Louisiana salt domes (Kolb, 1976),

which may indicate subsidence over domes, possibly due to dissolution of cap rock or

salt by ground water.

EROSIONAL BREACHING OF DOMES

A critical factor in evaluating a salt dome as a nuclear waste repository is the

possibility of breaching of the dome by erosion. Not only could erosion cause actual

exposure of a repository, but salt dome breachment could also reactivate dome

24

Page 28: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

km Imi

Slopes resulting from erosional processes

0-20

W 2-5o

5-15o

Slopes resulting from depositional processes

I0-2

Stream

" .... '" Intermittent stream

Swamp

Pond

" -/o00 --- Contour on top of salt (- 305m)

Figure 18. Morphologic map of Palestine Dome area. From Kreitler and others (1981).

25

Page 29: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

0 1. .

Slopes resulting from erosional processes Streom

S0-2° ' Intermittent stream

2-5°

Swamp

• 5-15' "Pond

Slopes resulting from depositional processes Contour on top o0 salt

CF7 71 0 -2 - oDf r30 5 m )

Figure 19. Morphologic map of Keechi Dome area. From Kreitier and others (1981).

26

Page 30: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

Slopes resulting from erosional processes

0O-2o

W. w2-5

M 5-155

Slopes resulting from depositional processes

M 0-2o

S- Stream

"- Intermittent stream

Swamp

Pond

0 Contour on top of salt (-305mJ

Figure 20. Morphologic map of Oakwood Dome area. From Kreitler and others (1981).

27

Page 31: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

growth. Erosional breaching could also release radionuclides into the biosphere.

Growth history studies of Hainesville Dome in East Texas show that a significant

amount of salt was extruded through the eroded top of the salt pillow (Loocke, 1978).

To evaluate the potential for erosion and exhumation of an East Texas salt dome, two

studies were made to estimate the regional denudation rates in the East Texas salt

basin and to examine the previous incision of the Trinity River.

Denudation Rates in East Texas

Recent denudation rates appear low enough to pose no threat of breaching the

East Texas salt domes. The East Texas salt basin receives an average rainfall of 100

to 130 cm and is drained by the Trinity, Neches, and Sabine Rivers and their

tributaries. The region is characterized by heavy vegetation, and land cover varies

from cropland and pastureland to dense forested areas. Oakwood and Keechi salt

domes both underlie the Trinity River drainage basin.

In East Texas, sediment is removed from drainage basins primarily by rivers or

streams. Rates of denudation were computed using suspended-sediment-load data of

rivers (fig. 21 and table i) and data from sedimentation resurveys of East Texas

reservoirs (fig. 22 and table 2). The equations used for these computations are as

follows:

(1) Denudation from suspended-sediment-load data: S+B SA+-B sDs + Dc = DT

where A = net drainage area

S = suspended-sediment-load data (average per yr)

B = bed load (estimate per yr)

Ds = denudation from suspended-sediment (per yr) Dc chemical denudation (per yr)

D = total denudation (per yr)

(2) Denudation from sedimentation resurvey data:

d A = DT

where A = net drainage area

d = average annual deposition (per yr)

DT = total denudation (per yr)

Using suspended-sediment-load data, an average denudation rate for East Texas

is estimated to be 8.85 cm/l,000 yr. Rates computed for the Trinity, Neches, and

28

Page 32: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

Sabine River basins are 11.45, 8.16, and 6.95 cm/l,000 yr, respectively (fig. 21 and

table 1). Computations of the modern denudation rates are probably relatively

accurate even though bed-load and dissolved-load values were estimated. Suspended

sediment-load data were collected for periods ranging from 7 to 36 yr at 10 recording

stations maintained by the Texas Department of Water Resources. Bed-load values

were calculated to be 10 percent of the suspended load (Fisk and others, 1954), and the

chemical denudation for the western Gulf region is estimated at 0.037 mm/yr

(Livingstone, 1963). Sedimentation resurvey data from four reservoirs in East Texas

were used to compute an average denudation rate of 16.8 cm/1,000 yr (fig. 22 and

table 2). This value is close to denudation rates computed using suspended-load data

and helps to verify the accuracy of the modern denudation values.

Extrapolation of recent denudation rates to the future is uncertain. Winker

(1979), however, calculated Pleistocene rates of denudation along the Texas Gulf

Coast that compare relatively well with the modern values. He determined that late

Pleistocene denudation rates ranged from 3 to 10 cm/l,000 yr. Recent denudation

rates in East Texas appear low enough to prevent erosional breaching of the salt

domes; however, to predict possible breaching of a dome requires consideration of

future climatic conditions.

Entrenchment of the Trinity River

Another factor in evaluating the possible breaching of salt domes is the response

of rivers to climatic and associated sea-level fluctuations. During a glacial stage,

river incision and sediment aggradation will occur because of changes in base level

created by fall and rise of sea level, respectively. With each fall in sea level the

nickpoint moves farther upstream because of the rapid removal of unconsolidated

alluvium of the preceding aggradational episode. This investigation concerns previous

incision of the Trinity River during sea-level fluctuations and suggests that potential

breaching of Oakwood, Keechi, and Palestine Domes is not of major concern. To evaluate possible breaching of the salt domes, it is necessary to understand

the relation between glacial cycles and river incision and formation of terrace levels.

The Trinity River terraces and terrace ages have been discussed. During glacial

cycles, river incision and sediment aggradation occur with the lowering and rising of

sea level, respectively. The gradient of the Gulf Coast continental shelf is considered

important because it decreases from the headwaters of the Trinity River onto the

continental shelf. Thus, as sea level falls, the maximum depth of river incision will be

much less than the sea-level drop. Estimates of the maximum fall of sea level during

29

Page 33: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

To/edo

tSTATIONS

I Rosser 2 Corsicana 3 Crockell 4 Romayor 5 Diboll 6 Nacogdoches 7 Rockland 8 Zovalla 9 Tatum 10 Loganspor t, La.

0 50 mi.

0 80 km.

Figure 21. Location of sampling stations for suspended-sediment-load data. From

Kreitler and others (1981).

30

Page 34: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

( /r determ• , East Texas from suspended-sediment-load data.a

Derived from Stout and others (1961); Adey and Cook (1964): Cook (1970); Mirabal (1974); Dougherty (1979) 6From Fisk and others (1954)

cFrom Livingstone (1963)

Table 2. Denudation rates determined from sedimentation resurvey data.a

Average

Date and annual

duration Drainage deposition Denudation Denudation

Reservoir Stream of survey area (km2) (mi) (cm/yr) (cm/1.000 yr)

Wolf Creek Wolf Creek 1919 to 66 1 446xtO' 2 19x10' 21 9 Apr. 1939

20 yr

Grand Saline Simons Branch Feb. 1925 to 55 2.143x10' 3.89xt0 2 38.9 Apr. 1938 13.25 yr

Dam B Neches River 1951 to 19.614 2 39x10' 1 18910 ' 1.18

(Steinhagen) Feb. 1960 8.83 yr

Lake Cherokee Sabine River Oct 1948 to 440 2 87x0l' 528xtO 5.28

Apr. 1960 11 5 yr

aEvans and Bramblett, 1960: U. S. Army Corps of Engineers. 1960: Sedimentation Committee of Water Resources Council. 1975; from Kreimier and others. 1981

Table 1. Denudation rates(i

Page 35: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

,' U EDALLAS 2CI

• TYLER

S•c•.•T KEECH I /

OAKWOOD DOME

I Wolf Creek 2 Grand Saline 3 Dam B 4 Lake Cherokee

Figure 22. others (198.

Location of reservoirs for sedimentation resurvey data. From Kreitier and

1).

32

Page 36: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

fl

600 0--1

500- -50

".~- ~ 400--fod li

_100A

300

200-EXLNTO

- 0 3

100 T-o

0 Caelod be•leta T-lty Rive

TrTO/ 0 -00 -1 004,0C

0 8Or

Figure 23. Profile showing Trinity River terraces and depth of incision into bedrock. Depths of incision into bedrock are determined from borehole data obtained from Texas Highway Department files, Dowell and Petty (1973), Rehkemper (1969), and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (1962). Locations 1, 10, and 16 are Liberty Quadrangle, Long Lake and Oakwood Quadrangles, and Mesquite and Forney North Quadrangles, respectively (see fig. 2 for locations).

Pleistocene glacial intervals vary from 80 to 140 m (Bloom, 1978). Sea-level estimates

for the Wisconsin glaciation indicate that sea level was between 100 and 135 m below

the present level (Andrews, 1975). Since cycles of incision followed by aggradation

occur with the fall and subsequent rise of sea level, maximum incision should occur

during the greatest fall in sea level, and incision to a greater depth should not occur

unless uplift of the area creates renewed incision.

Along the Trinity River, borehole data provided by the Texas Highway Depart

ment and the Texas Department of Water Resources were used to establish the depth

of river incision into bedrock (fig. 23). Figure 23 shows in the study area an average

alluvium thickness of 15 m from the modern floodplain to the contact between the

alluvium and bedrock. Because of the gradual headward retreat of nickpoints and

incision, actual incision of the streams over the domes is much less than the

entrenchment by the Trinity River. Less than 5 m of incision by Keechi Creek into

bedrock has occurred over Keechi Dome (fig. 24). Consequently, erosional breaching

of the domes is of only minor concern.

33

Page 37: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

Si-, eecr Come Keechi Creek floodplain•

uu0 iUt• , V It'

0 t'r

20 1i Confluence with Trirnity River ---. ..-- -- - - - - - -- - - - - - E C ID M -00100 KEECHI DOME (schematic) rock at 38 m -50 Cop rc l3

- - ncision into bedrock -ORIZONTAL SCALE below surface, Ic0i Sit bedrmock solt at 133 m 0*00 i- Data point for incision into bedrock hi below surboce

0

0

Figure 24. Topographic profile of Keechi Creek and its incision into bedrock. Depths of incision into bedrock are determined from borehole data obtained from the Texas Highway Department files.

SUMMARY

Palestine, Keechi, and Oakwood Domes are located in the Trinity River drainage

basin. Four terrace levels have been identified along the Trinity River valley in the

central part of the drainage basin where the domes occur. The regional gradient of

these terraces provides no indication of significant regional or domal uplift. Quatern

ary terrace deposits at Palestine Dome show no indication of warping due to dome

uplift.

Although Palestine, Keechi, and Oakwood Domes display different types of

drainage patterns, central topographic depressions share similar characteristics over

all three domes. Deposition occurs within these central depressions. Thickness

variations of floodplain deposits over Oakwood Dome may indicate that subsidence has

occurred over the dome.

For evaluation of possible breaching of a salt dome, the regional denudation rate

in East Texas and the effects of future climatic conditions are also major factors.

Average denudation rates computed from suspended-sediment-load data and sedimen

tation resurvey data are 8.85 cm/I,000 yr and 16.8 cm/l,000 yr, respectively. Incision

by the Trinity River into bedrock is 15 m beneath the middle of the present floodplain

of the Trinity River valley in the vicinity of the domes.

34

Page 38: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

This research was funded by the U.S. Department of Energy, Contract No. DE

AC97-80ET46617 (formerly DE-AC97-79ET44605). The manuscript was reviewed by

T. C. Gustavson, M. P. A. Jackson, S. J. Seni, L. F. Brown, Jr., and D. A. Smith. C. W.

Kreitler, principal investigator for the East Texas Waste Isolation studies, also

provided constructive comments. The text was word processed by Charlotte J. Frere,

and edited by Amanda R. Masterson. Figures were drafted by John T. Ames,

Thomas M. Byrd, Micheline R. Davis, Margaret Evans, Byron P. Holbert, Jeffrey

Horowitz, and Jamie McClelland, under the supervision of Dan F. Scranton. Cover

design and text layout and assembly were by Micheline Davis.

REFERENCES

Adey, E. A., and Cook, H. M., 1964, Suspended-sediment load of Texas streams: Texas

Water Commission Bulletin 6410, 49 p.

Andrews, J. T., 1975, Glacial systems: an approach to glaciers and their environments:

Massachusetts, Duxbury Press, 191 p.

Bernard, H. A., and LeBlanc, R., 1965, Resum6 of the Quaternary geology of the

northwestern Gulf of Mexico Province, in Wright, H. E., Jr., and Frey, D. G.,

eds., The Quaternary of the United States: Princeton University Press, p. 137

187.

Bloom, A. L., 1978, Geomorphology--a systematic analysis of Late Cenozoic land

forms: Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey, Prentice-Hall, 510 p.

Coffee, D. R., 1975, Soil survey of Anderson County, Texas: U. S. Department of

Agriculture, Soil Conservation Service, 92 p.

Collins, E. W., 1980, The Reklaw Formation of East Texas, in Perkins, B. F., and

Hobday, D. K., eds., Middle Eocene coastal plain and nearshore deposits of East

Texas, a field guide to the Queen City Formation and related papers: Gulf Coast

Section, Society of Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists Field Trip

Guidebook, p. 67-70.

Collins, E. W., Dix, 0. R., and Hobday, D. K., 1981, Oakwood Salt Dome, East Texas,

surface geology and drainage analysis: The University of Texas at Austin,

Bureau of Economic Geology Geological Circular 81-6, 22 p.

Collins, E. W., Hobday, D. K., and Kreitler, C. W., 1980, Quaternary faulting in East

Texas: The University of Texas at Austin, Bureau of Economic Geology

Geological Circular 80-1, 20 p.

35

Page 39: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

Cook, H. M., 1970, Suspended-sediment load of Texas streams, compilation report,

October 1963-September 1965: Texas Water Development Board Report 106, 61 p.

Dougherty, J. P., 1979, Suspended-sediment load of Texas streams, compilation report, -x__ . October 1971-September 1975: Texas Department of Water Resources Report

233, 82 p.

Dowell, C. L., and Petty, R. G., 1973, Engineering data on dams and reservoirs in Texas, Part 11: Texas Water Development Board Report 126, p. 0801.0 AF0827.0 AC.

Eaton, R. W., 1956, Resum6 of subsurface geology of northeast Texas with emphasis on salt structures: Gulf Coast Association of Geological Societies Transactions, v. 6, p. 79-84.

Ebanks, G. K., 1965, Structural geology of Keechi salt dome, Anderson County, Texas: The University of Texas at Austin, Master's thesis, 85 p.

Evans, J. C., and Bramblett, H. L., 1960, Report on sedimentation of Lake Cherokee, Gregg and Rusk Counties, Texas: U.S. Department of Agriculture, Soil Conservation Service, 12 p.

Failing, M. S., 1969, Comparison of Trinity River terraces and gradients with other Texas Gulf Coast rivers, in Lankford, R. R., and Rogers, J. 3. W., eds., Holocene geology of the Galveston Bay area: Houston Geological Society, p. 85-92.

Fenneman, N. M., 1938, Physiography of eastern United States: New York, McGrawHill, 714 p.

Fisher, W. L., and McGowen, J. H., 1967, Depositional systems in the Wilcox Group of Texas and their relationship to occurrence of oil and gas: Gulf Coast Association of Geological Societies Transactions, v. 17, p. 105-125. Reprinted as The University of Texas at Austin, Bureau of Economic Geology Geological Circular 67-4, 21 p.

Fisk, H. N., McFarlan, E., Jr., Kolb, C. R., and Wilbert, L. J., Jr., 1954, Sedimentary framework of the modern Mississippi delta: Journal of Sedimentary Petrology, v. 24, no. 2, p. 76-99.

Halbouty, M. T., 1980, Salt domes: Gulf region, United States and Mexico: Houston, Gulf Publishing Company, 425 p.

Hightower, M. L., 1958, Structural geology of the Palestine Salt Dome, Anderson County, Texas: The University of Texas at Austin, Master's thesis, 83 p.

Hobday, D. K., Morton, R. A., and Collins, E. W., 1979, The Queen City Formation in the East Texas Embayment: a depositional record of riverine, tidal and wave interaction: Gulf Coast Association of Geological Societies Transactions, v. 29, p. 136-146. Reprinted as The University of Texas at Austin, Bureau of Economic Geology Geological Circular 80-4, 11 p.

36

Page 40: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

Hopkins, 0. B., 1917, The Palestine salt dome, Anderson County, Texas: United States

Geological Survey Bulletin 661, p. 253-270.

Jackson, M. P. A., and Wilson, B. D, in press, Fault tectonics of the East Texas Basin:

The University of Texas in Austin, Bureau of Economic Geology Geological

Circular.

Kolb, C. R., 1976, Topographic lows above domes, in Martinez, 3. D., Thoms, R. L.,

Kupfer, D. H., Smith, C. R., Jr., Kolb, C. R., Newchurch, E. 3., Wilcox, R. E.,

Manning, T. A., Jr., Romberg, M., Lewis, A. J., and Rovik, J. E., eds., An

investigation of the utility of Gulf Coast salt domes for the storage or disposal

of radioactive waste: Louisiana State University, Institute for Environmental

Studies, ORNL-SUB-4112-25, p. 407-414.

Kreitler, C. W., 1979, Studies of the suitability of salt domes in East Texas Basin for

geological isolation of nuclear wastes: Gulf Coast Association of Geological

Societies Transactions, v. 29, p. 157-163.

Kreitler, C. W., Agagu, 0. K., Basciano, J. M., Collins, E. W., Dix, 0., Dutton, S. P.,

Fogg, G. E., Giles, A. B., Guevara, E. H., Harris, D. W., Hobday, D. K.,

McGowen, M. K., Pass, D., and Wood, D. H., 1980, Geology and geohydrology of

the East Texas Basin, a report on the progress of nuclear waste isolation

feasibility studies (1979): The University of Texas at Austin, Bureau of

Economic Geology Geological Circular 80-12, 112 p.

Kreitler, C. W., Collins, E. W., Davidson, E. D., Jr., Dix, 0. R., Donaldson, G. A.,

Dutton, S. P., Fogg, G. E., Giles, A. B., Harris, D. W., Jackson, M. P. A., Lopez,

C. M., McGowen, M. K., Muehlberger, W. D., Pennington, W. D., Seni, S. 3.,

Wood, D. H., and Wuerch, H. V., 1981, Geology and geohydrology of the East

Texas.Basin, a report on the progress of nuclear waste isolation feasibility

studies (1980): The University of Texas at Austin, Bureau of Economic Geology

Geological Circular 81-7, 210 p.

Lankford, R. R., and Rogers, 3. J. W., eds., 1969, Holocene geology of the Galveston

Bay area: Houston Geological Society, 141 p.

Leifeste, D. K., and Hughes, L. S., 1967, Reconnaissance of the chemical quality of

surface waters of the Trinity River basin, Texas: Texas Water Development

Board Report 67, 65 p.

Livingstone, D. A., 1963, Chemical composition of rivers and lakes: U. S. Geological

Survey Professional Paper 440-G, 64 p.

Loocke, J. E., 1978, Growth history of the Hainesville salt dome, Wood County, Texas:

The University of Texas at Austin, Master's thesis, 95 p.

Martinez, 3. D., Kumar, M. B., Kolb, C. R., and Coleman, J. M., 1981, Catastrophic

drawdown shapes flood: Geotimes, v. 26, no. 3, p. 14-16.

McGowen, 3. H., and Garner, L. E., 1970, Physiographic features and stratification

types of coarse-grained point bars: modern and ancient environments: Sedimen

tology, v. 14, no. 1/2, p. 77-111.

37

Page 41: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

Mirabal, John, 1974, Suspended-sediment load of Texas streams, compilation report,

October 1965-September 1971: Texas Water Development Board Report 184,

[17 p.

Murry, G. E., 1961, Geology of the Atlantic and Gulf Coast Province of North

America: New York, Harper's, 692 p.

Nichols, P. H., Peterson, G. E., and Wuestner, C. E., 1968, Summary of subsurface

geology of northeast Texas: American Association of Petroleum Geologists

Memoir 9, v. 2, p. 982-1004.

Orton, R. B., 1969, The climate of Texas and the adjacent Gulf waters: U. S.

Department ol Commrnerce, Weather Bureau, 195 p.

Pennington, W. D., Kreitler, C. W., and Collins, E. W., 1981, Seismicity near Rusk,

East Texas (abs.): Geological Society of America, Abstracts with Programs,

v. 13, no. 5, p. 260.

Powers, Sidney, 1926, Interior salt domes of Texas: American Association of

Petroleum Geologists Bulletin, v. 10, no. 1, p. 1-60.

Rehkemper, L. J., 1969, Sedimentology of Holocene estuarine deposits, Galveston Bay, in Lankford, R. R., and Rogers, J. J. W., eds., Holocene geology of the Galveston Bay area: Houston Geological Society, p. 12-52.

Sedimentation Committee of Water Resources Council, 1975, Supplement to: sedi

ment deposition in U.S. reservoirs, summary of data reported through 1975: U.S. Department of Agriculture Miscellaneous Publication 1362.

Slaughter, B. H., 1969, Age of the second terrace of the upper Trinity River, Texas

(abs.): Geological Society of America Special Paper 121, p. 412.

Slaughter, B. H., Crook, W. W., Jr., Harris, R. K., Allen, D. C., and Seifert, Martin,

1962, The Hill-Schuler local faunas of the upper Trinity River, Dallas and Denton

Counties, Texas: The University of Texas at Austin, Bureau of Economic Geology Report of Investigations No. 48, 75 p.

Stenzel, H. B., 1938, The geology of Leon County, Texas: University of Texas, Austin, Bureau of Economic Geology Publication 3818, 295 p.

Stout, I. M., Bentz, L. C., and Ingram, H. W., 1961, Silt load of Texas streams, a

compilation report, June 1889-September 1959: Texas Board of Water Engineers

Bulletin 6108, 236 p.

Suggate, R. P., 1974, When did the last interglacial end?: Quaternary Research, v. 4, no. 3, p. 246-252.

Thurmond, 3. T., 1967, Quaternary deposits of the East Fork of the Trinity River, North-Central Texas: Southern Methodist University, Master's thesis, 74 p.

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, 1960, Report of sedimentation resurvey, Dam B

Reservoir, Neches River, Texas: U. S. Army Engineer District, Fort Worth, 21 p.

38

Page 42: SURFICIAL EVIDENCE OF TECTONIC ACTIVITY AND · Tertiary and Quaternary (M.P.A. Jackson, personal communication, 1981). Surficial studies concentrating on surface geology and geomorphology

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, 1962, Comprehensive survey report on Trinity River and tributaries, Texas: U. S. Army Engineering Districts, Fort Worth and Galveston, v. 4, appendix VI, p. 113-155.

•__Wjnker, C. D., 1979, Late Pleistocene fluvial-deltaic deposition, Texas coastal plain and shelf: The University of Texas at Austin, Master's thesis, 187 p.

39