42

The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

  • Upload
    cissong

  • View
    182

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Progetto “Intervento di emergenza a supporto della popolazione vulnerabile palestinese residente nella Striscia di Gaza”, realizzato da CISS/Cooperazione Internazionale Sud Sud in collaborazione con l'associazione palestinese El Wedad Society for Community Development e finanziato dal Ministero degli Affari Esteri e della Cooperazione Internazionale (MAECI).

Citation preview

Page 1: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip
Page 2: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

1

This publication “The effectiveness of a proposed guidance program in decreasing PTSD reactions among

children in the northern part of the Gaza Strip” has been funded by the Directorate General of the

Development Cooperation, Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation - Emergency

Programme AID 10042 within the project “Emergency intervention for the vulnerable groups affected by

PTSD and psychosocial distress in the Gaza Strip” (10042_GAZA_CISS_5),

The views expressed in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views or policies of the Italian Development Cooperation - Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation. The Italian Development Cooperation - Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation are not responsible for any inaccurate or libellous information, or for the erroneous use of information.

CONTACTS

CISS – Cooperazione Internazionale Sud Sud Local Office Jerusalem: Mafrak Al Dahey, Beit Hanina, Jerusalem Local Office Gaza: Al Mina – al Rashid Street, Abu Ghalion Building 2 Telefax: +972 (0)2 6561012- E-mail: [email protected] Office in Italy: via Marconi n. 2/a, 90141 Palermo TEL. 0039 091-6262004/6262694 FAX 091347048 E-mail: [email protected] – Web site: www.cissong.org EL WEDAD SOCIETY FOR COMMUNITY REHABILITATION Main Office Gaza: Gaza League of Arab States – opposite to Fares Station Telephone: 00970 826 41955 Fax: 00970 826 41957 E-mail: [email protected] Web site: www.elwedad.org ………………………………… Italian Development Cooperation Unit – Jerusalem Mujeer Eddin Street 2 Sheikh Jarrah - Jerusalem http://www.itcoop-jer.org/ Tel: +972(2)532 74 47

September 2014

Cover Photo by: Sergio Cipolla

Page 3: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

2

Action Research

The effectiveness of a proposed guidance program in decreasing

PTSD reactions among children in the northern part of the Gaza

Strip

Realised in the framework of the project:

“Emergency intervention for the vulnerable groups affected by PTSD and

psychosocial distress in the Gaza Strip”

(10042/GAZA/CISS/5)

17th December 2013 – 30th September 2014

Funded By

ITALIAN DEVELOPMENT COOPERATION – ITALIAN

MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS and INTERNATIONAL

COOPERATION

Implemented by:

CISS – Cooperazione Internazionale Sud Sud

In collaboration with:

El Wedad Society for Community Development

Page 4: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

3

PREFACE

The present “action Research” has been made in the framework of the Project “Emergency Intervention in

support of the vulnerable groups affected by PTSD and psychosocial distress in Gaza Strip” Implemented

by CISS in cooperation with El Wedad Society and funded by ITALIAN DEVELOPMENT COOPERATION –

ITALIAN MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS and INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION

The project aims at improving the psychosocial conditions of 519 children at risk and their families in Beit

Lahya, Gaza and Jabalya through the provision of integrated services of psychosocial, educational and

psychological support in 4 Community based Organizations (CBO) and 3 hospitals, as well as at home and

through the creation of playrooms. The beneficiaries are children (8-17 years old) who experienced the loss

or destruction of their houses, and/or the displacement or the death or injury of family members. Most of

them live in areas closed to the border and to the so called “buffer zone”.

The methodology of the Project foreseen three interrelated component:

Playrooms and Psychosocial laboratories: The idea of creating playrooms is based on the need of creating

"safe places" for children and to protect their "right to play". The playroom is set-up by the children

themselves with the support of animators and psychologists by using different techniques (play therapy,

drama therapy and art therapy). From the psychosocial point of view the role of the playrooms is to provide

adequate psychological support to children in suitable and safe places.

Mobile Clinic: The mobile clinic is composed by psychologists and animators who carried out home visits for

the children affected by PTSD. The role of the animator/social workers is to create a friendly environment

where the child and his family can feel comfortable and safe. Each intervention of the mobile clinic has been

structured according to the guidelines identified in the Guidance Program.

Clown therapy service in the hospitals: the Clowns in the hospitals address specifically the psycho-social

needs of the hospitalized children and their parents. The work of the clowns is to apply the techniques of

psychological support already experimented in the playrooms by using the “clown therapy”. In a context

such as the hospital, and considering the specificity of the addressed problems, it is even more difficult to

create a direct contact with the patients because of the limited time (sometimes the children and their

families are in the hospital just for few days) and of the feeling of fear of the minors hospitalized. The

“clown” helps in shortening significantly this time and to deconstruct the classic relationship psychologists /

animators vs patients. In this way the setting that is created, besides of being positive and cheerful, is also

based on trust and empathy. This factor maximizes the potential outcomes of the psychological and

educational support. There is also a positive benefit for the staff of the hospital and the families of the

patients.

The action research is a tool to verify the effectiveness of our work and methodologies in dealing with

children affected by PTSD in the Gaza Strip.

Page 5: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

4

Contents

Research abstract ....................................................................................................................... 5

Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 6

Study problem ............................................................................................................................ 7

Study objectives: ........................................................................................................................ 7

Study importance: ...................................................................................................................... 7

The main terms of the study ...................................................................................................... 8

Theoretical framework ............................................................................................................... 8

First-The concept of psychological trauma ................................................................................ 8

Diagnoses of post-traumatic stress disorder on children: ......................................................... 9

Causes of psychological trauma: .............................................................................................. 10

The most common symptoms of trauma: ................................................................................ 11

Factors related to the intensity of trauma: .............................................................................. 12

Second: The emotional rational treatment .............................................................................. 13

The main steps for cognitive emotional treatment ................................................................. 15

The foundations of the program .............................................................................................. 16

Research Hypothesis ................................................................................................................ 16

Third: Research Methodology and Persuaders: ....................................................................... 16

Samples of the Study: ............................................................................................................... 17

Research Methodology: ........................................................................................................... 17

The validity and Reliability of the Scale .................................................................................... 17

Program objectives: ................................................................................................................. 20

Sub objectives: ......................................................................................................................... 20

Validity of the guidance program: ............................................................................................ 21

Research Outcomes ................................................................................................................. 21

Conclusion and recommendations: ......................................................................................... 24

Thanks to: ................................................................................................................................. 25

Index of Abbreviation: ............................................................................................................. 26

References: ............................................................................................................................... 27

Annexes – description of the sessions and applied test: ......................................................... 28

Page 6: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

5

Research abstract

The main goal of this research is to examine the effectiveness of implementing the proposed guidance

program in decreasing the PTSD reactions among children at the northern part of the Gaza Strip, the

program was implemented on two groups of male and female children, the first group consists of 34

children, their ages range from 13 to 17 years, the second group of 32 male and female children, their ages

range from 8 to 12 years.

The semi-experimental method was used in this research, and its outcomes revealed that there are

statistically significant differences in the mean score of both groups in the pre and post tests on the PTSD

reactions scale and the differences were in favour of the post test, it also revealed that there is an important

effect of the guidance program in decreasing negative PTSD reactions among the targeted groups of

children.

Page 7: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

6

Introduction

The mental health problems and in particular PTSD are widespread phenomena among children in Gaza.

Together to the siege, the Israeli military operations in the past years have deepened this problem. During

the Israeli military operation Cast Lead in 2008/2009, 313 children have died (approximately 23% between

the ages of 5 and 10 years and 62% between 11 and 17 years) and more than 1,400 were injured. The

majority of these (a total of 261 children) lived in densely populated areas of Gaza City and in the North

Governorate. Studies conducted after 3 years from the operation revealed that 56.6% of children showed

moderate reactions to trauma, and 10.6% severe reactions.

The Israeli military operation Pillar of Defence of November 2012 has caused the death of 47 children (16 of

which are under the age of 5 years), as well as the destruction of some 2,000 homes and 136 schools and

the wounding of 516 children and adolescents. The impact of the “Pillar of Defence“ has been dramatic. The

analysis of the World Health Organization in December 2012 revealed a need for psychological support for a

number of citizens between 25,000 and 50,000. Among them children and adolescents are especially at-risk.

The impact of "Pillar of Defense" on the psychosocial health of children has been also assessed directly by

CISS and El Wedad. The result shows that 45.54% of children were affected by PTSD and 99.28% of the

children reported different symptoms such as fear, anxiety, nightmares.

The more recent military operation, Protective Edge in July 2014, had also heavy consequences. According to

OCHA data, more than 2100 Palestinian have been killed (around 80% civilians), among them more than 500

children. Approximately 18,000 homes were either completely destroyed or severely damaged, leaving

about 108,000 people homeless. UNRWA estimates that between 65,000 and 70,000 people will remain as

long-term displaced. The majority of the population of Gaza has lost its economic income increasing the

sense of depression of the adults that will inevitably affect the children. According to data from UNICEF

3,106 children were injured. 51600 children are homeless and according to initial estimates at least 373,000

children are in need of immediate psychological support to cope with the trauma. The data from UNICEF

and OCHA also reported an increase of 91% of sleep disorders, nervousness, aggression and depression

among children, loss of appetite in 85% of adults and a significant increase in the incidence of spontaneous

abortions.

Among the major consequences of the instability determined by the siege imposed on Gaza, various studies

and analyses reveal how psychosocial discomfort and disease are prevalent all over the Gaza Strip.

The trauma can have different reasons, from destroying houses and agricultural roads and land to the siege

that impede the movement of people and goods. All those circumstances have a severe impact on the

Palestinian people physically, mentally, psychologically and socially and there is no doubt that children are

the most affected category because of their lack of cognitive and life experiences and the limited available

coping mechanisms.

There is no doubt that childhood is the most important stage of a person's life, as the experiences children

go through in this stage have a substantial role in forming their personalities, so if these experiences are

painful or shocking, they might negatively affect building a normal personality in the future (Abdel-Rahman,

2006).

Page 8: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

7

It is well known that the consequences of the military occupation in form of invasion, aggression, siege,

closure and wars lead to a lot of problems, especially for children since they are subjected to greater

psychological pressure, crises and traumas.

The recent researches outcomes have proven that the major factor in determining the reactions of the

human being is not only the traumatic action itself but, also, the ability or inability to face the event. Ability

facing the event means ability to control the situation, which helps the person to control the feelings of

confusion, anxiety, fear and the symptoms that accompany it, like rapid breathing and heartbeat,

hypertension, etc.

Study problem

There is no doubt that wars and aggression have devastating and long term impacts on an individual's

psychological, social and mental health.

The two researchers noted traumatic reactions to the war in the Palestinian people, especially children, such

as lack of sense of security, increase of the sense of helplessness, frustration, together with many other

reactions. Therefore the current search is an attempt by the researchers to prepare a curative and guidance

program to mitigate the effects of trauma in children, by taking a sample of traumatized children.

Accordingly the research problem was formulated in the following basic question:

“How effective is the proposed counselling program to alleviate the severity of the psychological traumas in

children aged from 8 to 17 years?”

Study objectives:

The present study aims at identifying the effectiveness of the proposed counselling program to alleviate the

severity of the psychological traumas in children aged from 8 to 17 years.

Study importance:

The importance of this study can be summarized as follows:

1- The importance of the current applied study is revealed in the fact that it attempts to prepare a

counselling program to alleviate the psychological traumas in children aged 8 to 17 years.

2- Enabling children to overcome the traumatic reactions resulted from the exposure to trauma through the

followings:

- Making the target group aware of their psychological conditions.

- Helping the target group to get rid of the inappropriate thoughts concerning negative expectations

about themselves and about others and the future.

- Helping the target group to get rid of the negative emotions which have a role in the origination and

continuation of frustration and lack of self-efficiency.

3- The researchers hope this study will serve those who are generally interested in psychological health who

will benefit from the results in the preparation of a psychological guidance and counseling program for

children who are in need of assistance in this regard, to face the psychological problems they suffer from.

Page 9: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

8

The main terms of the study:

1-Psychological Trauma:

Psychological trauma is exposing an individual to shocking experience, whether deriving from physical or

psychological threat or from an actual exposure to death or injury.

2- The Guidance Program:

It is defined as a number of counselling and therapeutic techniques designed to help traumatized children to

overcome symptoms and disturbances resulted from a trauma

Theoretical framework

First-The concept of psychological trauma

Freud calls “trauma” the consequences of living a painful and sudden experience that carries with

problematic psychological symptoms , which usually ends up in a person adaptation failure, definitely

leading to incremental disorders in bio-energy, so that over excitement becomes too much for the

respiratory system to handle. Laplanche and Pontalis (1997, 300) define it as an unexpected experience in

someone's life, where the individual finds himself unable to appropriately react, consequently

maladjustments might be shown.

Ursano points out that the traumatic experiences are serious, confusing and surprising events. They cause

fear, anxiety, and withdrawal from social life and avoidance from contacts with others; they are also highly

intensive, unpredictable and non-recurrent. They can affect the individual himself like a car accident, a crime

of violence like sexual exploitation, or they can affect the entire society as in the case of war or earthquake

(Abdel-Khaleq, 1998, 53). There are 2 types of traumatic events:

a) A shocking, non-recurring event that only happens once, as in the case of an accident or catastrophe etc.

b) A shocking event that goes on for a long period of time like sexual exploitation. Those events have more

severe consequences on the individual involved (Deer Grove, 2002, 1-3).

The two researchers see psychological trauma as an unexpected, surprising and external event that scatters

the individual's integration and endangers his life and to whom the individual responds by overwhelmingly

feeling of extreme fear and deficiency. There is no doubt that the frequent exposure of children to crises

causes them more harm than it does to adults, and in addition to physical harm, the psychological impact

may remain for a lifetime.

According to the concept of Individual Differentiation, reactions toward the traumatic experiences vary

between individuals: what forms a severe trauma for someone may just be a painful experience for another.

A psychological trauma in its events and severity does not affect people the same way, it depends on

multiple factors like severity, duration and level of exposure, the individual's perception of the event, his

evaluation and interpretation, his age and maturity, his personality and its degree of structural and

functional cohesion, past experiences and, finally, the social support (UNICEF Regional Offices, 1995, 22)

Page 10: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

9

Diagnoses of post-traumatic stress disorder on children:

There are several diagnostic criteria for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). The fourth Diagnostic and

Statistical manual (DSM-IV) for psychological disorders of the American Psychological Association identified

the diagnostic criteria for the post-traumatic stress disorder, as follows:

a) The individual experienced a traumatic event:

1- The individual witnessed or experienced an event or more that involve the death or the threat of

death to oneself or to someone else, or to one's own or someone else's integrity or safety.

2- The individual responds to this experience with severe fear or terror or disability, in the case of

children they may experience irritation or turbulence.

b) The individual restores the traumatic experience in one or more of the following:

1- Experiencing painful memories in the form of photos, ideas, or sudden perceptions connected to the

traumatic experience; in the case of children they show some type of recurring playing that is

connected to the traumatic experience.

2- The traumatic event or parts of it appear in dreams (nightmares). Specifically for children, their

dreams are frightening and they lack the ability to identify the context in which those dreams take

part and they cannot find a justification for them.

3- A person behaves or feels as if the traumatic event is happening all over again, with regards of

children their behaviours reflect certain parts of the traumatic event

4- The individual experiences the feelings of confusion and disturbance when he is exposed to codes or

internal or external signs that are connected to the traumatic event in general.

5- The individual shows physiological reactions when exposed to those signs.

c) The individual constantly avoids all the stimulants connected to the traumatic event; this appears in at

least three of the following:

1- Exerting efforts to avoid ideas, feelings, and talks connected to the trauma.

2- Making efforts to avoid places, people, and activities related to the trauma.

3- Forgetting certain parts of the traumatic event.

4- Experiencing feelings of isolation and exile from others.

5- Inability to feel love and compassion.

6- Clear lack of attention for major activities or willingness to participate in them.

7- Feeling that the future is unpromising and limited.

d) Appearance of constant symptoms (at least two of the following) after the exposure to trauma: difficulty

in getting asleep or in sleeping itself, susceptibility, arousal and anger and irritation episodes, difficulty in

concentrating, hyperactivity.

Page 11: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

10

e) The symptoms mentioned in (b, c, d) usually last over a month; they are divided into three types

according to the period of exposure to the traumatic event:

1- Severe symptoms: symptoms last for less than three months.

2- Chronic symptoms: they last for more than three months.

3- Late symptoms: symptoms start to appear after six months of exposure to the traumatic event

(DSM-IV, 1994, P427).

Causes of psychological trauma:

1) Physical obstacles: for example being alone in prison, or forbidding an individual from satisfying his need

to socialize with people, or depriving him from water, food or destroying his possessions.

2) Social obstacles: like cruel frustration which arises when dealing with others, thereby inhibits our

determination, hinders our desires and touches our dignity.

3) Economic obstacles: difficult economic conditions, difficulty in accessing work or income and poverty are

a major source of depression because they forbid the most disadvantage people from satisfying their basic

needs and the needs of their families.

In addition, there are many situations that may cause people experiencing severe psychological crises.

If we have a look at the major causes for psychological traumas that occur to children in Gaza, we can

mention:

the destruction of houses: it is known that the feelings of security and stability shape the strongest

needs that a human in general and a child in particular have. Maslow located security at the second

place after satisfying physiological needs. The home of a child is supposed to be the safest

environment for him, and when this home is violated or destroyed, children lose security and

safety, leading, in turn, to feelings of fear and anxiety, that therefore affects the child's personality

in general.

explosions, live shooting towards the population and bombardments, especially late at night, which

targets everybody specially the young,

Frequent cases of injuries or death among families’ members or friends

If this is the state for the community as a whole, children are the most affected by such conditions. But,

again, there is a difference among children in the extent, degree and the way they are affected.

This variation can be attributed to a group of subjective and personal factors, which can be summarized in

the following:

1- the child's perception of the traumatic event plays a major role in specifying the child's personal meaning

of the traumatic event. This means children who watch a certain event are affected by it in different ways,

which depends on the personal characteristics of each child.

2- the psychological stress resulting from hard situations, based on the magnitude and type of variables

come up in the child's life and his ability to control them.

Page 12: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

11

3- the presence of other factors or stress that accompany the traumatic event, which have direct effects on

the child, including: the fact that a crisis is sudden or predicted, the repetition of the stressful event, the fact

that the event is individual or collective, the loss of something or someone, the physical harm, the degree of

threat due to the event on the child’s life, the violent factor whether seen or as personal experience.

The most common symptoms of trauma:

The symptoms of the trauma show up directly or after few months. Trauma can happen to an individual at

any age, including children, some of the symptoms that appear on them are:

1) mental symptoms: lack of concentration, the child is unable to understand what he is reading, mental

distraction, and fast forgetfulness, inability to continue reading, fear of reading, loss or lack of motivation to

read.

2) physical symptoms: pain in the body, pain in the head, stomach and chest, loss of vitality, difficulty in

breathing, weakness in muscles, loss of weight, pain in the muscles, pain in the eyes, trembling limbs (Abu

Hain, 2002, 2 ).

3) disorder in habits: loss of appetite, aggression, introversion, bedwetting, psychological symptoms,

extreme fear, excessive confusion, annoying dreams and nightmares, insomnia, anxiety, excessive grief

(Ministry Of Education, 2001, 2).

Strengthening the parents to help a child with a trauma:

There is no doubt that parents play a crucial role in the recovery of their children from traumatic experience,

or at least to reduce its severity, and then to help them in restoring their well-being. Parents know their

children the most; therefore they are the best ones to provide them with care and protection.

There are many strategies that help parents in providing help to their children who suffer from psychological

traumas, including:

1- providing help and personal support to children whether individually or in groups.

2- providing information to children regarding the normal post-traumatic experience responses.

3- clarifying the best ways to deal with psychological and behavioural disorders that occur after the

traumatic experience.

4- fathers talking to their children about the trauma and its causes in an attractive manner far from

intimidation.

Based on the importance of the role parents play, it is necessary to enable the parents to deal with their

psychological traumas and then help their children to overcome the effects of the psychological traumas

they may face, so it is substantial for parents or adults to get involved with their children in learning how to

cope with psychological traumas, this involvement helps in the following:

1) getting rid of painful feeling.

2) individuals develop a sense of empathy and emotional participation.

Page 13: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

12

3) re-evaluating the traumatic event in a factual manner far from fear and stress that accompany the event

when it occurs.

4) thinking of ways to help put things back to normal.

5) attempting to look at things and at the future with hope and optimism.

6) when talking about psychological trauma, whether with parents or with children, you should follow the

following:

a. choose a place that is characterized by calmness and tidiness.

b. taking into account that it is extremely important to determine the right time to talk, and to set

sufficient time for the conversation.

c. it is important to listen carefully to the speakers, whether the speakers are the parents or the

children and encourage them to talk without any coercion or compulsion.

d. the provision of open questions is better than closed ones, it is important not to ask too many

questions.

7) its known that Gaza strip represents a stressful environment for all the residents especially children.

Parents at home, teachers at schools, psychologists and social workers, each one has to do his parts in

helping children who are exposed to traumas, in order to overcome them. Children ought to be helped,

particularly those living in areas with high incidence of armed clashes and constant shelling from tankers and

aircraft, living in areas of continuous danger, on how they can face traumas.

Children living in dangerous zones are affected in a way that appears in their limited activities. Sometimes

those children spend most of their time inside their houses considered the safest place.

Thus, it is important:

1- providing the maximum protection for children, especially if being exposed to danger is unavoidable.

Children must be trained in taking some simple self-protection activities or “tips” like (what do I do if ….).

Through trainings, children will gain new habits they could apply to protect themselves if they find

themselves in dangerous situations.

2- encouraging children to participate in daily life activities, like participating in cleaning, preparing meals

and eating with the group (family, friends), or engaging in artistic activities, singing and drawing, playing.

3- encouraging the participation of children with adults in many simple activities that represent part of the

normal life they were living before getting exposed to the traumatic experience. This will help the child to

have a sense of familiarity and tranquility, and the feeling that he is living in a safe place.

Factors related to the intensity of the trauma:

1) The degree of expectation of the trauma and the preparation for it:

Ask whether the event was: expected or surprising and unexpected,

Ask whether the parents were: prepared or unprepared,

Ask whether the children were: prepared or unprepared.

Page 14: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

13

If the event was expected and people were prepared, they can cope in a better way after the event is over.

It is also important to understand the duration of the traumatic event (minutes, hours, days, months): the

longer the duration of the event is, the greater is the depth of the effects it has on people, the higher is the

risk of developing Post Traumatic Stress Disorder.

2) The degree of exposure of children and parents to the life threatening events:

It is important to know which of the following events were experienced:

- hearing threats of violence toward others,

- hearing the cries of help from others,

- seeing injured people,

- seeing others fall dead,

- direct exposure to injury.

More the children and the parents were affected directly, more painful was their experience.

3) Psychological support:

Priority when dealing with cases.

Psychological support in dealing with the catastrophe is according to two factors:

First: according to the area, you have to deal first with the people that are closer to the catastrophe site,

that is:

- the exact place where the catastrophe occurred (a residential building that was destroyed),

- the area where the catastrophe occurred (the street where the building is located),

- the surrounding area to the location (neighbourhood where the building was located)

- the external areas (the surrounding neighbourhoods).

Second: According to the psychological state, it is important to deal with the ones who have been exposed

to psychological traumas in a way that makes them feel safe and calm.

Third: Group discussion:

If group discussions were held between you and a family which all or most of its members were injured,

short termed psychological support must focus on their ability to cope and adapt to life all over again.

Discussion between survivors might create a feeling of belonging to the human society in each one of them,

and that there are others who share the same pain and injury. The presence of people in one place (a tent or

shelter or a class in school) makes them feel they have become like one family, they care for each other, and

for children who are with them at the same place, even if they are not their children (Syrian Ministry Of

Education, 2011, 4-15).

Second: The emotional rational treatment

Rational emotive therapy (RET) is a psychotherapeutic approach which proposes that unrealistic and

irrational beliefs cause many emotional problems. Ellis proposed that people become unhappy and develop

self-defeating habits because of unrealistic or faulty beliefs.

Page 15: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

14

Albert Ellis, “the founder of the Rational emotive therapy - RET", believes that the reason behind emotions

and behaviours is the individual's thoughts and perceptions about the events; people create psychological

problems for themselves through talking with themselves and their self-assessments and converging their

preferences into urgent needs. for example, there is a difference between the rational phrase that says: I

prefer to have a high income, and the irrational phrase that says: I need to have a high income. Ellis quotes

from Hamlet: “There's nothing either good or bad but thinking makes it so”. Beliefs might be rational, and

leading to emotions with moderate severity, which are considered healthy, or they might be irrational and

leading to severe emotions which, in turn, will also lead to disorder that will hinder the capacity of achieving

goals and feeling happy (Todd & Bohart, 1999),

From Ellis's point of view individuals have two common goals, which are:

A) Sustaining life and experiencing relative happiness and being free of pain. Rationality is shaped in

thinking of ways that contribute to achieving those two goals, but irrationality includes thinking of ways that

prevent or block achieving those goals, individuals also feel upset sometimes when they are trying to

achieve their goals and obstacles or events come in their way and block achieving those goals, or even

prevent them from happening, so individuals start to develop beliefs and ideas that might be positive or

negative, and negative irrational beliefs and ideas develop feelings and behaviours which do not help in

achieving those goals. This indicates that events themselves do not create feelings, it is the beliefs behind

those events that contribute in forming those feelings and presenting them in a specific manner (Ellis, 2004).

The idea of treating the content of thinking and how to think has formed a general starting point to rebuild

the cognitive construction for the client is based on the assumption that the individual's idea about events

and not events themselves are responsible for the change in his moods. This is the basis of the perspective

Ellis adopted in treating the uneven behaviour and the sad thoughts through the following:

1- Doing a cognitive modification in behaviour. This is done by knowing the way of thinking and its

mechanisms and then guiding it toward aimed treatment after developing the new desired concept.

In other words, the modified cognitive construction of an individual is based on modifying and correcting the

erroneous perceptions and negative habits, based on logic and proper mental organizing.

2- Modifying the misperceptions: supporters of the cognitive therapy believe that the problems

experienced by people are caused by the way they think on how to realize themselves and others

around them. Wrong thinking arises due to realizing irrational situations plus the presence of rigid rules

and typical methods, which put behavior on automatic inflexible paths. They all form wrong starts for

thinking and perception

3- Replacing negative thoughts with positive ones: this represents a purpose and a goal to cognitive therapy.

Through it, a process of modification and change occurs to perceptions and personal interpretations and not

just to behaviour, because emotional turmoil is not a sentimental case isolated from personality

components, it is part of an integrated interactive system which starts with the internal behavioural activity

(intellectual) till it reaches the external behavioural activity. (Nassar, 1998, 89)

Ellis's theory in cognitive treatment relies on many basic concepts, including:

1) An individual is born with the willingness to be rational and logical in his thinking and he can be the

opposite.

Page 16: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

15

2) The conceptual, sensory and thought processes play their role in shaping a rational logical behaviour and

an irrational illogical behaviour, he feels, notices, realizes, thinks, and then acts, which means he performs

behaviour in a situation.

3) Rational and irrational thinking can be taught to an individual since childhood through family, peers and

the nature of the culture of the society he lives in.

4) Emotional turmoil arises from the irrational and illogical patterns of thinking; this leads to some kind of

neuroses.

5) External events are not directly responsible for our emotional disorders. The way we think, the way we

perceive and where we go are responsible for this turmoil.

6) Individuals tend to correct their bad or good doings and they see themselves as good or bad based on

their accomplishments, which affects their feelings toward themselves and their actions and others too.

7) Self-esteem (the way an individual perceives himself) and the reasons behind his behaviour form the

major sources behind the emotional turmoil in the future, and these irrational illogical ideas and negative

emotions which are self-defeating must be fought by reforming the mechanisms of thinking, perceptions,

concepts and directions which an individual adopts till he has a logical, rational, organized realistic thinking.

(Al-Saffar, 182, 2002) (Sofyan, 42, 2002)

The main steps for cognitive emotional treatment

Literature points that the steps of a guiding process according to Ellis's theory of emotional cognitive

treatment are based on the following stages:

1- The ideas sensing stage: irrational ideas are put under attention, usually they are filled with violent

emotional feelings which affect the individual and his interaction and compatibility with his inner world

which is represented by ideas, concerns, perceptions, and preferences, and his external world, represented

by the surrounding environment from friends, peers and relatives.

2- The analyzing stage: an internal prolonged conversation about these ideas, and that what he feels from

fear, misery and disorder is a result to these ideas dominating his thoughts and behaviours.

3- The refutation stage: in which, focus is on what Ellis calls “the counsellor’s struggle to reorganize the

client’s perception”, where the client is trained on how he can redo a perceptual organizing and get rid of

the problem, and disengaging his perceptions and illogical ideas and untie all the spatial and temporal chain

events undertaken by emotional abnormal emergency circumstances.

4- The reorganizing stage: the client helps the counsellor gain the ability to reorganize the irrational ideas

according to a new mechanism which relies on logic and high consciousness and the right perception to the

surrounding events.

5- The enforcement of perceptual effectiveness where the clients trained to use the right logical thinking

mechanisms in facing the following events without going back to the previous thinking methods. (Al-Naeimy,

2011, 187)

Page 17: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

16

The foundations of the program:

Any program is based on a theoretical basis. In designing the current guidance program the two researchers

followed the logo therapy according to Frankel, as the researchers see it the most convenient for topics like

our current study, ie psychological traumas. Such theory is based on the following theoretical principles:

1) Freedom of will: freedom of will represents the first basis for logo therapy. An individual owns this

freedom and it is what identifies him from other creatures. This freedom is not ultimate, it is limited by a lot

of factors. Frankel points out in this regard that an individual is not free or separate from certain factors,

whether they are biological, social or psychological, but he will remain free to take certain positions toward

these factors and circumstances. (Frankel, 1967, 3)

2) The will of meaning: the will of meaning represents the second basis for logo therapy. When an individual

has the freedom to make his life choices, then he will be able to have the strength and the will to look for

the meaning these choices represent. Frankel points that the will of meaning is always represented in the

individual's attempt to look for meaning, which is a basic strength in his life, and that the frustration of the

will of meaning leads to the existential void which could lead to neurosis. (Frankel, 1988, 29)

3) The meaning of life: it is considered the third basis for logo therapy, it means that life under all

circumstances and factors has a meaning, an individual could explore this meaning through doing a certain

job, or living a certain value, or by suffering when he faces an unavoidable situation, or one he cannot run

from, or a fate he cannot change; this direction he just took toward this fate, or this suffering is what

represents meaning. (Hutzell, 1990, 113)

Research Hypothesis:

The research hypotheses are stated as follows:

1- There is a statistically significant difference at (α ≤ 0.05) between the mean scores of the experimental

group, who ranged in age from (13-17) years, before and after the application of the program for the benefit

of the post application of the PTS scale.

2-There is a statistically significant difference at (α ≤ 0.05) between the mean scores of the experimental

group, who ranged in age from (8-12) years, before and after the application of the program for the benefit

of the post application of the PTS scale.

3- There are no statistically significant differences at (α ≤ 0.05) between mean scores of the experimental

groups, who are between the ages of 8-13 years and aged from 13-17 years, after the implementation of the

program on a scale of PTSD.

Third: Research Methodology and Persuaders:

Target Group of the Study:

The target group of the study includes (213) traumatized male and female children from the north part of

the Gaza Strip; all of them were involved in a project “Emergency intervention for the vulnerable groups

affected by PTSD and psychosocial distress in the Gaza Strip”

Page 18: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

17

Samples of the Study:

Three samples of children included in this study.

The first one is a pilot sample randomly selected from the target community of study in order to examine

the validity and reliability of PTSD scale used in this research; this sample composed of (42) male and female

children, their ages ranging from(8- 17) years.

The second sample is composed of (32) male and female children. Their age is ranging from 8 to 12 years,

systemically and randomly selected from the target community.

The third sample is composed of (34) male and female children. Their age is ranging from (13- 17) years

systemically and randomly selected from the target community.

The following table describe the two samples concerning sex and age:

Table no. (1)

Male Female Total Percent

13-17 22 12 34.00 51.52

8-12 14 18 32.00 48.48

Total 36 30 66.00 100%

Research Methodology:

The semi experimental method was used in this study as it is the most suitable one for such kind of studies,

using the one-group experimental design that is based on pre and post testing.

Two main tools were used in this study are the Child Post-Traumatic Stress Reaction Index and the Guidance

Program:

1-CHILD POST-TRAUMATIC STRESS REACTION INDEX: The instrument tool is composed of 20 items, the

Scores on this tool range from (0-80), the high score means high traumatic reactions and the low score

means low traumatic reactions.

The validity and Reliability of the Scale:

The validity:

That valid test means to what extent the scale measures what is supposed to measure.

The validity of the scale was tested by two means as follows:

(A)The referee validity:

The scale was introduced to a jury of specialists in a mental health and psychometric testing, no

modifications were recommended by the jury.

(B) The internal consistency validity:

Internal consistency validity indicates the correlation degree of each item with the total average of the test.

It also indicates the correlation of the average of each scope with the total average. This validity was

calculated by using Pearson Formula.

According to table (2) the coefficient correlation of each item within its scope is significant at levels (0.01)

and (0.05).

Page 19: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

18

Table (2)

Correlation Coefficient of the scale

Item Pearson

Correlation Sig. Level

1. Is (event/what happened) something that would upset, or

bother, most children your age a lot? 0.347 sig. at 0.05

2. Do you get scared, afraid or upset when you think about

(event)? 0.676 sig. at 0.01

3. Do you go over in your mind what happened- that is; do you

see pictures in your mind or hear sounds in your mind about (the

event)?

0.526 sig. at 0.01

4. Do thoughts about (event) come back to you even when you

do not want them to? 0.732 sig. at 0.01

5. Do you have good or bad dreams about (the event) or other

bad dreams? 0.669 sig. at 0.01

6. Do things sometimes make you think it might happen again? 0.704 sig. at 0.01

7. Do you feel as good about things you liked to do before (the

event like playing with friends, sports, and school activities? -0.464 sig. at 0.01

8. Do you feel more alone inside, or more alone with your

feelings-like other people really do not understand how you feel

about what you went through?

0.712 sig. at 0.01

9. Do you feel scared, upset, or sad that you do not really want

to know how you feel? 0.734 sig. at 0.01

10. Have you felt so scared, upset, or sad that you could not

even talk or cry? 0.754 sig. at 0.01

11. Do you startle more easily or feel more jumpy or nervous

than before (event)? 0.481 sig. at 0.01

12. Do you sleep well? -0.645 sig. at 0.01

13. Do you feel bad/guilty because you didn’t do something you

wish you had done? Or if you did do something you wish you

had not done? For example, to stop something from happening,

help someone else, or because it was not as bad for you as it was

for someone else?

0.628 sig. at 0.01

Page 20: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

19

Item Pearson

Correlation Sig. Level

14. Do thoughts or feelings about what happened get in the way

of remembering things, like what you learned at school or at

home?

0.771 sig. at 0.01

15. Is it as easy to pay attention (concentrate) as before (event)? -0.474 sig. at 0.01

16. Do you want to stay away from things that make you

remember what happened to you? (what you went through) 0.605 sig. at 0.01

17. When something reminds you, or makes you think about

(event) do you get tense or upset? 0.827 sig. at 0.01

18. Since (event) are you doing things again that you had once

stopped doing? Such as wanting to have someone near you,

sleeping with someone, sucking your thumb or fingers, biting

your nails or wetting the bed more often?

0.610 sig. at 0.01

19. Do you have more stomach-aches, headaches, or other sick

feelings since (event) than you did before? 0.464 sig. at 0.01

20. Is it harder for you to keep from doing things you wouldn’t

have done before? For example, getting into fights, disobeying,

more riding your bike more recklessly, taking other kinds of

chances, climbing on things, swearing at someone, not being

careful when you cross the street or during play?

0.716 sig. at 0.01

R table value at df (40) and sig. level (0.05) = 0.393

R table value at df (40) and sig. level (0.01) = 0.304

The results of table (2) show that the values of these items were suitable and highly consistent and valid for

conducting this study.

Reliability of the Questionnaire:

The test is reliable when it gives the same results if it is reapplied in the same conditions.

The reliability of the test was measured by Alpha Cronbach and the Spilt- half techniques.

Table (3)

Reliability coefficient

1- By using Alpha Cronbach Technique

Page 21: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

20

Alpha Cronbach Technique

Scope Total Correlation

Total 20 0.833

From table (3) we can be sure the questionnaire has a good reliability.

2-by using Split half:

Correlation between two parts (even X odd) and modify by Guttmann:

Table (4)

Spilt –half Technique

Total Total Before After

20 0.710 0.830

From table (4) we can be sure the questionnaire has a good reliability.

According to tables (3) and (4), the test is proved to be reliable. Alpha Cronbach coefficient is (0.833) and the

Spilt- half coefficient is (0.830) that indicates that the questionnaire is reliable to be applied in the study.

2- THE GUIDANCE PROGRAM:

The program is formed of (12) sessions, (8) sessions for children and (4) sessions for children and their

families and it relies on the following techniques: lecture, relaxing, practical exercises, and role playing, self-

talk, dialogues. The researchers relied on the Socratic dialogue, where Socrates's goal was moral repairing

for humanity, but not by speeches and sermons, but by people exerting efforts to reform themselves, and

the dialogue takes the shape of a deductive dialogue, and it starts by asking for things that seem known, but

it opens minds for facts that haven't crossed the Interlocutors' minds. Full description of the guidance

program is attached.

Program objectives:

The main objective: to build a guidance program to reduce the severity of the negative PTSD reactions

among the targeted children in Gaza governorates.

Sub objectives:

- To enlighten the individuals of the participating group about their psychological condition, so every

one of them would recognize his weakness areas, because sensing the problem is the first step of

solving it.

- Helping individuals of the participating group to use more positive acquaintances.

Page 22: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

21

- Helping individuals of the participating group to get rid of the inappropriate thoughts concerning

negative expectations about themselves and about others and the future.

- Helping individuals of the participating group to get rid of the negative emotions which have a role

in the origination and continuation of frustration and lack of self-efficiency.

Validity of the guidance program:

The guidance program was introduced to a jury of specialists in a mental health and clinical psychology to

judge the program whether or not it is appropriate technically and scientifically for the purpose of

decreasing the negative reactions of PTSD among the targeted children, two sessions were modified

according to the jury recommendations in addition to the duration of each session.

Research Outcomes

This part presents the findings of the study. The researchers used different statistical techniques using the

Statistical Package for Social Sciences program (SPSS) to show the final collected data results. In addition,

the effect size through (η2) was used to measure the effect size of the implemented guidance program.

Tables were also used to illuminate and present these data with analysis and interpretation.

The first hypothesis is stated as follows:

There is a statistically significant difference at (α ≤ 0.05) between the mean scores of the experimental

group, who ranged in age from 13-17 years, before and after the application of the program for the benefit

of the post application of the PTSD scale.

To answer this first hypothesis, the researchers used T.test paired sample to show the difference between

the children’s responses in the pre and post scores, and Table (5) below displays the results

.Table (5)

T.test paired sample results of differences between pre and post scores on the PTSD scale for experimental

group (ages range from 13-17) in the total degree of the scale

N Mean Std. Deviation t Sig.

value Sig. level

34 36.029 11.671 6.006 0.000 sig. at 0.01

34 20.441 8.027

“t” table value at (33) d f. at (0.05) sig. level equal 2.04

“t” table value at (33) d f. at (0.01) sig. level equal 2.75

Page 23: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

22

Table (5) above shows that there are statistically significant differences between pre and post scale

responses in the whole total degree in favour of the post scale, as the pre mean score of the children of the

experimental group was (36.029) , the post mean score was (20.441).

To calculate the size effect, the researcher used Eta square "η2” by using the following equation (Affana,

2000, 42):

Table (6)

The critical values for effect size levels

Test Effect volume

Small Medium Large

η 2 0.01 0.06 0.14

D 0.2 0.5 0.8

To calculate the size effect, the researchers used Eta square "η2”by using the following equation (Affana,

2000, 42):

t2 = η2

t2 + df

Also the researchers calculated "d" value by using the following equation:

2t = d

df

Table (7)

"t" value, eta square " η 2 " , and "d" for each domain and the total degree

t value η2 d Effect

volume

6.006 0.522 2.091 Large

The results of (η 2) and (D) values shown in table (7) indicate the large effect size of the applied program.

Page 24: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

23

The second hypothesis is stated as follows:

There is a statistically significant difference at (α ≤ 0.05) between the mean scores of pre and post tests of

the experimental group, who ranged in age from (8-13) years, before and after the application of the

program, which were in favour of the post test of PTSD scale.

To answer this first hypothesis, the researchers used T.test paired sample to show the difference between

children's responses in the pre and post scale and Table (8) below displays the results.

Table (8)

T.test paired sample results of differences between pre and post scale for the experimental group in the

total degree of the scale

N Mean Std.

Deviation t

Sig.

value

Sig.

Level

32 37.625 9.377 6.714 0.000

sig. at

0.01 32 23.844 8.061

“t” table value at (31) d f. at (0.05) sig. level equal 2.04

“t” table value at (31) d f. at (0.01) sig. level equal 2.75

Table (8) above shows that there are statistically significant differences between pre and post scale

responses in the whole total degree in favour of the post response scale, as the mean of pre- test score was

(37.62) , and the mean of the post- test score Was (23.844).

Table (9) shows the effect size of applied program on the children

Table (9)

"t" value, eta square " η 2 " , and "d" for each domain and the total degree

t value η2 d Effect

volume

6.714 0.585 2.374 Large

The results of (η 2) and (D) values shown in table (9) indicate the large effect of the applied program.

The third hypothesis is stated as follows

Page 25: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

24

There are no statistically significant differences at (α ≤ 0.05) between mean scores of the experimental

groups who are between the ages of (8-13) years and (13-17) years after the implementation of the program

on a scale of PTSD.

To answer the third hypothesis T.test independent sample was used to measure the significance of

differences and Table (10) shows the results

Table (10)

t.test independent sample of differences between mean scores of the experimental groups who are

between the ages of (8-13) years and (13-17) years after the implementation of the program on a scale of

PTSD

N Mean Std.

Deviation t

Sig.

value

Sig.

level

13-17 34 20.441 8.027 1.718 0.091 not sig

8-12 32 23.844 8.061

“t” table value at (64) d f. at (0.05) sig. level equal 2.00

“t” table value at (64) d f. at (0.01) sig. level equal 2.66

We can see from the previous table that there are no statistically significant differences between the first

group ranging in age from (8-12) and second group ranging in age from (13-17) years, and this result

indicates the feasibility and effectiveness of the program on both groups.

Conclusion and recommendations:

According to the research outcomes the following points can be concluded:

1) There is a significant effectiveness for the guidance program in reducing the PTSD reactions among

the targeted groups of children.

2) The implementation of the guidance program proved big size effectiveness in reducing and releasing

the negative PTSD reactions among the targeted groups.

3) According to the mentioned conclusion, implementing the same guidance program on children who

have about the same demographic characters and are suffering from PTSD is highly recommended.

Page 26: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

25

THANKS TO…

We would like to thank all the people who contributed to this research.

First of all, we thank El Wedad Society, local partner in the Project, for their great commitment and

cooperation in reaching the project goals, for their friendship, professionalism and their daily hard work in

favour of the children of Gaza.

A special thanks to Dr. Osama Saed Hamdouna and Dr. Mohammed Ibrahim Aslea who conducted the

research in a very professional way and who supported technically the psychologists in their daily work with

the mobile clinic.

A special mention to the entire project’s staff, animators, psychologists, field facilitators and tutors whose

great work and team spirit have been essential in improving children’s wellbeing and in ensuring the success

of the project. They conducted the assessment in difficult circumstances and we really appreciated their

efforts, enthusiasm and professionalism in carried out the activities.

We thank also Mohammad Al Sabawi and Amal Khayal who worked hard in collecting and analyzing the

data, in translating from Arabic into English, in editing and making the graphic of the present research. Their

hard work and their commitment are one of the reasons for the quality of this publication.

Thanks to CISS staff in Palestine, Salvo Maraventano – Country Representative, Valentina Venditti – Project

Manager and Yousef Hamdouna – Local Coordinator, who together followed, coordinated and supported

technically all the phases of the project and of the present research.

Thanks to CISS headquarter for the support during the entire duration of the project.

A special mention is given to the Italian Cooperation who funded this project and who made possible the

publication of this research and to the UTL for the synergic work.

Moreover, we would like to thank all the CBOs - Toot el Ardi, Beit Lahya Development, Future Commission,

Ibn Khaldun, Al Salateen and the Hospitals - Al Rantisi, Al Nasser, Kamal Adwan and Al Durra for their

cooperation and commitment to the project’s results.

Finally, our biggest thank goes to all the children who participated in our activities and helped us in

improving our work, who kept teaching us hope, steadfastness and enthusiasm and who push us in going

on.

Page 27: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

26

INDEX OF ABBREVIATIONS

BUFFER ZONE: is a military no-go area that extends within the Occupied Palestinian Territory (OPT) along the

entire Gaza Strip’s border with Israel as well as at sea (Al-Haq organization).

CBO: Community Based Organization

OCHA: Office for the Coordination of the Humanitarian Affairs

PTSD: Post Traumatic Stress Disorders

RET: Rational emotive therapy

SPSS: Statistical Package for Social Sciences

UNICEF: United Nation Children’s Fund

UNRWA: United Nation relief and works agency for Palestine refugees in Near East

Page 28: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

27

References

First: Arabic references:

- Abd Al-Khaleq, Ahmed and others (2000): Disturbances following traumatic events, ideological

study, edition 1, Office of Social Development, Kuwait.

- Abd Al-Rahman, Ali Ismael: (2006) Domestic violence, edition 1, Cairo, The Anglo Egyptian Bookshop.

- Abu Hain, Fadil (2001): Hain: (2001) Participation in the activities of Al-Aqsa Intifada and its

relationship to psychological emotional problems, Children's rush toward martyrdom and its

relationship with some variables, Al-Aqsa University, Gaza, Palestine.

- Al-Naeimi, Mohannad Mohammed (2011): The impact of the guidance program in the mitigation of

the effects of traumatic memory among students, Eighth Arab Scientific Conference for the Gifted

and Talented, Iraq, Diyala University, p 163-190.

- Al-Saffar, Rafah mohammed Ali (2002): Irrational ideas among teachers and their relationship to

sex, specialization and length of service, unpublished Master Thesis, Faculty of Education - Ibn

Rushd, the University of Baghdad.

- Deer Grove, Itly (2002): Reactions that follow the psychologically traumatic experiences and loss,

translation and localization of Zuhair Zakaria, Psychology Crisis Center, Bergen – Norway.

- Laplanche, Jean (1997): Glossary psychoanalysis, edition 1, translated by Mustafa Hijazi, Beirut,

University Corporation for Studies, Publishing and Distribution.

- Nassar, Christine (1998): Contemporary Trends in Psychotherapy, Lebanon, Publications For

Distribution and Publishing Company.

- Sophyan Nabil (2002): Manual in personality and psychological counselling, Taiz University, College

of Education.

- The Ministry of Education (2011): Bulletin for guidance counsellors, psychologists and social

workers, guidance bulletin about trauma, the Directorate of Research, Department of psychological

and social counselling, Syria.

- UNICEF Regional Office in the Middle East and North Africa (1995): Helping a child who is suffering

from psychological trauma a manual for social workers, health workers and pre-school teachers,

translation of Zuhair Zakaria, Amman, Jordan.

Second: Foreign References:

- Ellis, A. (2004): Rational emotive behavior therapy: It works for me, it can work for you. London,

Prometheus Books.

- Frankel, V. E (1988): The Will of Meaning; Foundations and application of logo therapy, New York

American Library, Penguin Inc. - Hutzell, R,R (1990); An Introduction to Logo therapy, In: Keller. P. a, and Ritt. L. g. (EDS) Innovation in

Clinical Practice: a source book, VOL. 9, New York, Professional resource Exchange Inc. - Todd, I. and Bohart, J. (1999): Foundation of clinical and counseling psychology, New York, Longman,

321.

Page 29: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

28

Annexes:

- Annex no. (1)

A table that shows the names of the programmed sessions

Name of the session Session no. Preliminary session 1

Working on the relaxation skill 2

Anger and calmness 3

Self-understanding 4

Control 5

Self-confidence 6

My characteristics 7

Breaking the negative perception 8

Strengthening the positive perception 9

Challenge and resistance 10

Self-talking (group session) 11

My wishes (group session) 12

First session: Preliminary session

Opening meditation, examining emotions, setting the session rules, goals and expectations, getting to know

each other and breaking the ice through the activity “the name and the feeling”.

Goals:

- Getting to know the meaning of psychological trauma.

- Familiarizing the client on the objectives of the sessions.

In this session, which is considered an introductory session (for 15 minutes), the psychologist did the

following:

- He welcomed the participant and he introduced himself, clarified the goal of the program sessions,

which is to alleviate trauma.

- The psychologist and the participant agreed on a number of points they have to comply to, which

are:

* Respecting the appointments of the sessions.

* Committing to the ethics of dialogue and discussion..

* Implementing what the psychologist asks you to do during sessions.

* Setting the dates and times for the following meetings.

The psychologist gave the participant a question to think about (for 5 minutes) at home, which is "In your

opinion, what are the reasons that lead to the occurrence of psychological traumas?"

Finally, the psychologist requested the participant to implement a closing meditation (for 5 minutes), where

he asked him to close his eyes and breathe quietly and relax his muscles and feel comfortable and at ease.

Page 30: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

29

Second session: Working on the relaxation skill

Goals:

- To help the child in expressing his feelings freely.

- To enable the child to draw what he believes of himself.

- To energize and entertain.

Tools:

White paper (A4), pens, colours.

1) Warm-up: the psychologist repeats the chant of "if you are happy and you know it" without any music

and asks the child to sing along with him, and says: "if you are happy and you know it clap your hands (and

the child claps his hands). if you are happy and you know it clap your hands (and the child claps his hands)..

if you are happy and you know it and you really want to show it if you are happy and you know it clap your

hands (and the child claps his hands), the flower opened.. the flower closed .. the flower opened.. the flower

closed (3 times) jump 3 jumps.. clap 3 times". (a traditional statement)

2) Relaxation: The psychologist explains what is meant by relaxation and how relaxation gives the child such

big feelings of psychological safety and how focusing and concentrating on something good will make the

child feel relief, lucidity and have a clear vision about life, then starts training as follows:

1- Deep breathing relaxation:

The psychologist asks the child to sit comfortably as he pleases, and tells him to breathe deeply, and to

exhale slowly, which will make the child feel completely relieved.

2- Muscular relaxation:

Sit and lie down comfortably, close your eyes, let your body relax, imagine tension melting away gradually.

3- Optical relaxation:

Sit down comfortably and calmly, breathe slowly and deeply, let thoughts flow in your mind without

concentrating on any of them particularly, just focus on the fact that you are feeling completely calm and

tranquil, listen to your own heartbeats while they are beating quietly, when you feel you are completely

relaxed imagine you are in a beautiful place filled with flowers and singing birds, picture everything around

you completely beautiful, picture the people you love are in this beautiful place with you, spend with them

some happy moments, and now after you've spent these joyful moments with them you can say goodbye to

them and comeback to the place you were in before.

Main activity: (With music) (Turn up the volume game) You tell the child you want to play with him an easy, nice game called turn up the volume: We want to draw two circles on the floor and leave some space between them, we will write in the first circle

(the one on the right) happiness circle, and we'll write on the second circle (the one on the left) grief circle,

while you stand between the two circles we'll play the music and when I say right you'll go to the right circle

which is the happiness circle, and when you enter it you'll say I am happy, I am glad, jump, laugh, do

whatever expresses your happiness, and when I say left, you'll go to the left circle which is the grief circle,

and when you enter it you'll feel sad and sorrowful, you'll make movements that show your sadness, shall we

begin with music? Let's go, the process is repeated many times.

Page 31: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

30

The psychologist should finish up the game with the child's entrance to the happy circle, in every time the

child enters the happy circle, the psychologist should tell him: "I want happiness.. come-on, more

happiness". After the game, the psychologist asks the child how he felt in the grief circle, and in the happiness circle. Ask

the child to conclude the differences between the two states, encourage him to get rid of the sad attitudes

and replace them with happy ones as much as possible.

Third session: Anger and calmness

Goals:

- Warm-up then opening meditation (relaxation) "I want to remind you of our last session, we spoke of grief and happiness, do you remember? Can you

remind me what we did?", After talking, the psychologist says to the child: "there are papers, pens and colors

in front of you, I want you to draw a picture of yourself when you are happy, and then draw yourself when

you are sad, you can begin now",.. and after the child is done, you hold the sad image in your hand and you

ask him to answer your questions.." Can you tell me why he is sad? Can you describe his face features when

he is sad? When someone is sad, what happens to him?"Then the psychologist starts to say:"being sad is not

good, when you are sad you are unable to think or rest, you look angry, stressed and nervous… etc.".

"Now let's look at your happy image, can you tell me why he is happy? Can you describe how he looks when

he is happy? The psychologist comments on that and says happiness is a treasure that protects the person

from anger and tension, being happy makes the individual think better, now let's compare between the two

pictures",… the psychologist wraps up by telling the child the following: "we really need to stay away from

sadness as much as possible and live our lives in happiness because when you are happy you see the whole

world beautiful".

An activity for entertainment: (True or lie)

"I am going to say something about me and you tell me if they are true or they are a lie, do you understand

me? Okay get ready.. (I fought John Cena), (I've never eaten bread), (I was a brave student)".

Fourth session: Self-understanding

Goals:

- Warm-up then opening meditation (relaxation).

"Today we are going to work on something nice and fun, I want you to stand up and look at the floor with

your eyes wide open, I want you to imagine a place, a person, a memory or all three together, when you feel

you are truly safe, remember a place you've lived in, or a place you like to go to… or remember a certain

place or a time or a year or a childhood period, in which you feel you were living in safety and happiness…

think of that place, maybe it is real or maybe it is just your imagination, just think, whether you are thinking

of a person or a place.. if you want you can imagine the picture of this person or this place.. just imagine the

picture.. imagine the colors in this picture, look at the shapes in that place.. remember where you were

standing, or sitting in that tranquil place.. remember the voices of that place.. remember the light..

remember the scent.. remember everything about that place.. I want you, when you are ready, to take the

pens and the colors in front of you and draw that place.. try to draw quietly.. you don’t have to be an artist or

a painter.. I just want you to remember the place with all its events and details.. remember, when you draw a

place that is important and fun for you, drawing could have two faces, a happy face and a sad face, the

emphasis is on the feeling", you should make the child remember what makes him happy and make him

describe it, because by that we make him feel warmth and comfort..

Page 32: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

31

After the child finishes the picture, the psychologist starts to discuss it with him.. "tell me where is this

place? Who were you with? Do you want to go back there? Etc."

Fifth session: Control

Goals:

- Warm-up and then relaxation (opening meditation)

The psychologist starts talking to the child about trauma and says: "We know there are things in life we can't

control and those things have no control over us, but still there are things we can control and things which

can control us, when you wake up you know there are things you are going to have to deal with, and you or

anybody else could be exposed to trauma or to a tough situation at any time, and when you deal with this

trauma you feel like you've lost everything in your life, and the power of control feels like it is far away from

you, life itself seems very far away from you, as if it is happening and going on without having any hand in

shaping it, here you feel like you are about to surrender", in a child's case, he becomes frustrated and he

loses his ability to play and imagine, he loses the ability to have fun, what we are trying to do today is to give

children an experience in resistance, to provide them with an experience so they can be in control over

things.. we let every child tell his story.. tell his own story.. then we use words to describe his feelings.. if we

didn't do so, his fears, losses and lack of hope will continue and grow.. these fears will settle in his body,

that’s why we have to give them a chance to express himself in words so these bad, negative feelings are

out of his system, we have to provide him with the chance to get these feelings out and express them in a

safe way.. he has to practice expressing his feelings without any difficulty.

Main activity of this session: The psychologist says to the child:

"Now I want you to tell me a story in which you have experienced a psychological trauma, I want to hear the

story from you…" we try to encourage the child to talk, we tell him: "you know each one of us stores trauma

in his body not in his mind.. of course the mind remembers the pain, but we don't want to remember the pain

or even think about it, because this way, the effects of those thoughts on the body stay, the body can't

dispose them, psychological trauma affects digestion, joints, stomach, sleep, drinking habits, our

relationships with others.., now after you've told us about a psychological trauma you've been through, we

want to do an athletic activity, because sports is a good way to dispose psychological trauma, you should

practice some sports like praying, singing, dancing, walking with friends and drinking lots of water, because

water cleanses your body from trauma", here the psychologist will have to perform an activity that makes

the child feel safe, feeling safe will relieve the child.. if the child is not comfortable he won't do anything

based on his own will and this tires the body.

The activity: (with music)

"I want you to sleep on your belly.. learn to stand up.. stand up.. now that you are standing, I want you to

clap your hands .. and say (1,2,3,4).. extend your hands.. rest on the floor.. relax.. look up.. look at the sky..

look at the stars.. look around you.. extend your hands.. hit the floor.. lift your hands to the sky.. higher.. get

down on the floor.. hit the floor hard.. standup.. sit down.. extend your legs.. and your arms.. move your

fingers.. hit the floor with your legs (4 times).. left your hands up.. swing to the right and then to the left...

right.. left.. move your hands in a circular motion.. move them faster.. faster.. now slowly.. let's go faster

now.. faster.. even faster.. now slowdown.. open your arms.. swing right and left.. move your hands now

vastly in a circular motion and say (1,2,3,4) really slow, and say (1,2,3,4) then stand up".

Page 33: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

32

Sixth session: Self-confidence

Goals:

- To clarify the importance of self-confidence in facing the changing events and circumstances in life.

- To increase the child's self-confidence.

- Warm-up then relaxation.

Tools:

Pencils, colours, white papers (A4).

Activity: Pictures

The psychologist shows a number of pictures to the child, these pictures refer to self-confidence, the child is

asked to choose a picture for himself, after he chooses it, the psychologist asks him: "Why did you choose

this particular picture? What did you like about this picture? Would you like to be like the person in this

picture? Why? What is stopping you from being like this person in the picture?", The psychologist then

comments: "of course this is a picture of someone who has a great position, he enjoys a lot of self-confidence

because he is brave, educated, he is not afraid of any circumstances, he can control the situations he

experiences,… etc.".

Supportive activity: The ant and the rabbit:

The psychologist tells the child the ant and the rabbit story.. the psychologist says: "I want to tell you a funny

story, which is the story of the ant and the rabbit, once upon a time, there was an ant and its friend the

rabbit, the ant was very active, it goes every day to look for its livelihood, the ant would eat a little bit from it

and keep a little bit from it for home.. the rabbit, the ant's friend, would just eat it all, it is too lazy to keep

some food for home.. when winter came by, it was too cold for the rabbit to go out, though it was very

hungry, but it couldn't.. when it became starved.. it (the rabbit) thought and thought and then said: "oh, why

wouldn't I go to my friend the ant, I'll surely find some food over there", so it went to its friend the ant and

knocked on the door... the ant said: "who is it?", the rabbit replied "it's me, your friend, the rabbit", the ant

asked: "what do you want?", the rabbit said: "please I want some food", the ant said: "I'll give you food for

one condition, while you eat I'll see your dance, rabbit".

After telling the story, the psychologist asks the child the following questions:

"Who were the main characters of the story? What did you understand from the story? Who was right and

who was wrong? Why? If you were the ant, how would you act with the rabbit? Why?".

Page 34: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

33

Seventh session: My characteristics

Goals:

- Warm-up then relaxation.

Tools:

Pencils, colors, white papers (A4).

"I want you to draw on the paper your right hand and draw your five fingers clearly, after you finish drawing,

I want you in each finger to write a good characteristic about yourself, this means you'll write down five

characteristics, each one in each finger, then draw your left hand on the second page, and write in each

finger five characteristics you don't like about yourself, this means you'll write down five characteristics, each

one in each finger, but these are characteristics that you don’t like about yourself".

After the child finishes the activity, the psychologist starts to ask him about every detail of these

characteristics: "why do you like this characteristic? What's the most liked characteristic of your own

characteristic? Etc."

The psychologist starts to talk to the child in an understandable language and tells him: "after every hard

event you go through and every person goes through, sometimes you and anyone might be controlled by

states where you find yourself agitated, angry, sad, or nervous, you just feel you can't stop yourself from

thinking about what has happened or imagining it, but you can simply face all of that, you can get rid of

these states by drawing your attention to the outside world, to people, to trees, to everything surrounding

you, instead of focusing on these ideas, let's do this following activity together"

Supportive activity:

"I want you to sit comfortably.. relax your hands and legs, don’t sit with your hands and legs stiffed.. breathe

deeply and slowly.. inhale.. exhale.. think of what's around you, then mention five voices you can hear

around you, you can say I hear my brother talking, I hear my breaths, I hear a door closing…etc., and again

breathe deeply and slowly.. inhale.. exhale.. think of what's around you, then mention five things you can feel

with your hands, you can say I am touching the chair with my hand, I am touching my clothes… etc.".

"Breathe deeply and slowly.. inhale.. exhale.. I know you have been through some really difficult situations,

maybe it would be good for you to talk about them, so you'd feel better.. you know the voices you just heard

were out of your control.. even the things you've touched and have touched your body were out of your

control too.. so is the case of what is called trauma.. trauma itself is out of your control.. it is important to

talk about it.. to get what's inside of you out is a good thing.. to throw the things you are suffering from out

of you.. so let's talk about some of the things that make us feel pain and upset, let's talk about where you

were during the war on Gaza, were you injured or hurt? Did you see anyone in front of you get hurt? How

scared were you? With which point from the ones I just have mentioned would you like to start talking?".

The psychologist starts to encourage the child to talk about the point he just chose for himself and discusses

it with him. At the end of the session, the psychologist should finish the session with a fun activity and doesn't end it by

talking about pain and sadness. Activity:

The psychologist writes on a small paper (5 small papers) the names of five animals and birds, on each paper

a name.. then he folds the paper and tells the child: "on each paper there is a name of an animal or a bird, I

want you to imitate the voice of the animal or the bird that comes out with you".. and the child begins to

open the paper and starts imitating the voices, the psychologist must encourage him.. after every time the

psychologist must tell him how great he is and how good he is in imitation.. etc., you can play and laugh, the

Page 35: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

34

state of laughing and fun must continue.. on the paper you would write the names of (rooster, sheep, cow,

cat, bird).

eighth session: Breaking the negative perception

Goals:

- The child recognizes what's meant by the negative perception

- The child recognizes how to break the negative perception

- Opening meditation and relaxation

The psychologist asks the child to close his eyes and tells him:"if you were sitting on a chair comfortably,

breathing calmly, relaxing your muscles, all your muscles, focus on your foot and thigh muscles, focus on

your stomach and thoracic cavity, focus on your shoulders and neck muscles, relax all your muscles, breathe

calmly, feel safe, comfort and tranquility, you are in a safe place", then the psychologist performs the

following activity:

He gives the child a paper, a pencil and colors, he asks him: "Can you draw me a triangle?", if the child

answers "No", then the psychologist draws the triangle, if the child answers "Yes", the psychologist tells him

to start drawing the triangle on the paper.. after he draws it, the psychologist tells him:"I have a fun game I

want to play with you.. I want you to name the sides of the triangle, lets name the first side (I can't), and the

second side (I don’t deserve) and the third side (I don't have to change), and I made you stand up between

those three sides and I asked you to stand on the first side, which is (I can't), what would you feel? Of course

you'll be affected, you'll lose your self-confidence, and you will really feel that you can't.. what do you think?

Am I right or wrong? so since you've said you can't, you'll feel you are unable and you'll replace the second

side, where you become a helpless person who can't do anything.. am I right or wrong? Therefore, the final

result is that you'll replace the third side, you'll judge yourself, you don’t have to change, okay, now let's

discuss this calmly while you are sitting with me, breathing calmly, relaxing your muscles, feeling safe and

secured, imagine yourself sitting comfortably and there is a person right in front of you that you don't like,

you don’t want to deal with him, he has negative attitudes with you in your life, just concentrate with

yourself for a few minutes, and I'll help you with words, the person you are imagining right now is someone

you don't like, you don’t want to deal with him and has negative attitudes in your life, when you remember

him, you feel upset… etc., I think now you are feeling upset, you are not comfortable, your feelings are

negative, therefore notice the ideas that flow on your mind, your feelings, the longer you keep them, the

more you lose, for example, if there was a certain teacher in your school who you don't like, you can't stand

to see him, what could happen?", You listen to the child, you will reply to his words with "yes, you are right,

if you hate the teacher, you'll hate the subject he is teaching you, it is even possible that you'll hate the whole

school because of him, and this is exactly what will happen to you when you experience a psychological

trauma, and you keep on remembering this trauma.. when you remember trauma you'll get affected by it so

much that you won't think about what you should study, you won't concentrate, you'll lose your health, your

weight, sleep, food, your relationships with family and friends, so from here you better make some effort in

overcoming trauma and what it could cause from negative feelings.. and this is what we are going to do in

our next session".

Ninth session: Strengthening the positive perception

Goals:

- The child recognizes what's meant by the positive perception

- The child recognizes how to strengthen the positive perception

- Opening meditation and relaxation

Page 36: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

35

The psychologist asks the child to close his eyes and tells him:"if you were sitting on a chair comfortably,

breathing calmly, relaxing your muscles, all your muscles: focus on your foot and thigh muscles, focus on

your stomach and thoracic cavity, focus on your shoulders and neck muscles, relax all your muscles, breathe

calmly, feel safe, comfort and tranquillity, you are in a safe place", then the psychologist performs the

following activity:

He gives the child a paper, a pencil and colors, he asks him: "Can you draw me a triangle?", if the child

answers "No", then the psychologist draws the triangle, if the child answers "Yes", the psychologist tells him

to start drawing the triangle on the paper.. after he draws it, the psychologist tells him:"I have a fun game I

want to play with you.. I want you to name the sides of the triangle, lets name the first side (I can), and the

second side (I deserve) and the third side (I have to change), and I made you stand up between those three

sides and I asked you to stand on the first side, which is I can, what would you feel? Of course you'll be

affected, you'll feel more self-confidence, and you will really feel that you can.. what do you think? Am I right

or wrong? so since you've said you can, you'll feel you are able and you'll replace the second side, where you

become a strong, confident person who can do anything.. am I right or wrong? Therefore, the final result is

that you'll replace the third side, you have to change, okay, now let's discuss this calmly while you are sitting

with me, breathing calmly, relaxing your muscles, feeling safe and secured, imagine yourself sitting

comfortably and there is a person right in front of you that you like, you like dealing with him, he has positive

attitudes with you in your life, just concentrate with yourself for a few minutes, and I'll help you with words,

the person you are imagining right now is someone you like, you want to deal with him and he has positive

attitudes in your life, when you remember him, you feel relieved, a bright smile shines on your face… etc., I

think now you are feeling kind of fun, comfort, your feelings are positive, therefore if we assumed you have a

lack of self-confidence problem due to a psychological trauma or an event that has occurred to you or to

someone in front of you, in order to think positively, you need to ask yourself these questions: why do I have

this problem? Who is the cause of this problem? How much did this problem cause me to lose in health,

thought, time, social relationships, in my studies… etc., for example, if there was a certain teacher in your

school who you really like, you'll love his subjects, you'll get the highest marks, you'll be very happy and you'll

love school, this is exactly what will happen to you when you experience a psychological trauma, always

think of people you love and who loves you back.. always think that you are not suffering alone, there are

people who are standing with you and who love you, that’s when you kick out negative feelings and replace

them with positive ones".

Tenth session: Challenge and resistance

Mohammed is a sixth grade student, he lives in Al-Salam neighbourhood east of Jabalya city, while he is at

school, he and his friends heard planes bombing, so they hurried to his house, and when they arrived,

Mohammed sat with his family, he saw his brother Ahmed and his sister Sua'ad crying from fear.

Usually at night there isn o electricity, all he hears are planes and tanks bombing around, and every now and

then, he hears his neighbours and the surrounding residents screaming, so Mohammed feels really scared,

but still, he was holding it together so he would calm his brother and sister, he would keep on hugging

them.. in the morning he found lots of destruction and demolished houses, he would ask about his friends in

these houses through his mother and father, he heard his mother saying to his father that they had to leave

their house and escape, but his father replied by saying: "what's meant to happen will happen if god

intended it to happen, it's all about fate", the mother agreed with him, but the next day their house was

shelled, that’s when the father made up his mind to leave the house, and that’s what they did, they went to

a relative's house thinking it would be safer.. but it wasn’t, they were surprised how close the bombing was,

Page 37: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

36

but they still stayed there hearing the screaming, the bombing, the ambulances.. day and night, till the

aggression on Gaza was over, the family returned to their home and found the destruction, the father

thanked god they weren't in it and that they are all okay, Mohammed then started to laugh at his brother

Ahmed and his sister Sua'ad, saying they were scared, but I wasn't so his father told him:"yes Mohammed,

you are really brave", so Mohammed said: "I heard my father saying everything happens by god's well, and I

believe in God".

After displaying the story, the psychologist asked these questions: "1) What do you think of Mohammed's

attitude? 2) What do you think of Ahmed and Sua'ad? 3) If we asked you to be one of three, Mohammed,

Ahmed or Sua'ad, who would you choose? And why? 4) Why do you think Mohammed didn't feel scared like

his brothers? 5) Can you draw me a picture of the three brothers revealing their states like you've heard the

story? 6) If we asked to advise each one of the three brothers an advice or more, what would you tell them?".

After the discussion, the psychologist comments and says: "indeed, everything is in God's hand, when

someone is scared of something, he gets tired, his concentration decreases, his thinking is not proper, his

health crashes, he could die.., but when you are strong, brave, cohesive, you know how to behave properly,

that’s why when you have a problem or you are exposed to trauma, whatever it is, you have to pray to God..

you have to believe in God's well.. death and life are in god's hand.. that’s when you can overcome trauma

and its negative emotions.. you have to pray when times are dark.. nothing does good to an individual except

his closeness to god and his prayers".

The psychologist continues: "I know you are tired of talking about war and destruction, but you have to

know that fear is essential when it is moderate, because fear helps us in protecting our selves.. let's end the

session in a fun activity".

The activity:

The psychologist prepares a set of balloons, say 5, and prepares 5 small papers and writes on each paper a

phrase of the following: (I am strong) (I believe in God) (I am not afraid to die) (My well is hard as steel) (I am

against all traumas whatever they are).

The psychologist folds the papers and puts each paper in a balloon, then blows the balloons and tells the

child to run behind the balloons and pop them, every balloon he pops, he opens the inside folded paper and

reads the written phrase loudly 3 times.. and so on till he pops all the balloons and the psychologist finishes

up the session with a relaxing meditation.

Eleventh session: Self-talking (group session)

Title of the session: Wishes and dreams

Goals:

- To let the participants know which negative thoughts cause them pain

- To let the participants know which positive thoughts cause them happiness and pleasure "Today, we are going to talk about the mind and explain to you that there is a conscious part and an

unconscious part of the mind in other words, there is something called the subconscious … this subconscious

is considered a warehouse, where we store our thoughts, especially if they are painful thoughts or feelings

we always try to escape from by forgetting them, but between every now and then, they appear.. in dreams ,

in the slip of a tongue, it causes us great pain and distress, therefore, we are going to perform the following

activity.

Page 38: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

37

Activity:

"You will take a paper and a pin and will write down (5) negative letters which have bad effects on you, I'll

help you, for example, I am a shy person, I have a bad memory, I can't concentrate, I am an anxious person, I

became a person with bad temper… etc.".

After the activity, the psychologist says: "it's nice that you've performed the activity, now please tear the

paper.. tear it vastly.. faster.. faster.. throw the paper quickly.. quickly.. get rid of all the negative thoughts

and feelings immediately".

Activity:

"Each one of you will take a paper and a pin and will write down (5) positive letters which have good effects

on him, I'll help you for, example, I am a brave person, I have a strong memory, I am not afraid of traumas, I

am a calm person, I am a patient person.. etc.".

After the activity, the psychologist says: "it's nice that you've performed the activity, now please write those

positive letters in a private notebook of your own and keep them with you.. start again by reading the first

letter, take a deep breath.. breathe calmly.. relax your muscles.. feel comfortable.. feel you are in a safe

place.. a place where you are happy and secured…. Repeat reading the first letter (10) times with feelings..

then close your eyes and imagine yourself in a new look.. then open your eye".

"Please from this day on, if you notice a negative letter, throw it immediately.. make sure you have the

power to do so.. you can be whatever you want.. thank you and this is the end of our session".

Twelfth session: My wishes (group session)

Goals:

- Acquisition of the participants the ability to plan for the future

- Helping the participants in specifying their wishes

- Encouraging the participants to make an effort to achieve their wishes

- Warm-up and relaxation

Activity: with soothing music (the pond of wishes and dreams)

The psychologist draws a big circle and asks the participants to stand around the circle, then tells them the

following:"imagine that there is a pool of water in front of you filled with dreams and wishes, every

individual is allowed to take from the pond whatever wishes he dreams and wants to achieve, the

psychologist reaches out his hand as if he is taking water from the pond and mops his body with the water,

he closes his eyes, wanders a little bit and then opens his eyes and says I just made my first wish, now I want

every one of you to do the same".

Then he tells them to say what they wished for and asks them why this wish is not coming true? For

example:"I wished for … what's stopping me from achieving it? Of course nothing if I made an effort and

placed my trust in the hands of god".

Finally, the psychologist says:"at the end of these sessions, I want to thank you for the effort you have made,

you were very cooperative and brave ,I love you so much and it was a pleasure meeting you guys, you are the

Page 39: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

38

men of the future, protectors of our homeland, but before I leave you I want to implement a fun activity with

you, and whoever wins the competition will win the prize of…… okay let's begin":

The psychologist divides the group into two parts: the father with group…., The mother with the other

group…..

1- A hen lays white eggs, what is the color of the eggs a rooster lays? A rooster doesn't lay eggs

2- "Safar elbaidabyadon aw abyaden? Al-SaffarAsfrmshabyad"(traditional statement).

3- In which country does rainbow exist? It is not in a country, it is in the sky.

4- A snake walks on the floor, then how many legs does it have? It doesn't have any legs.

5- Where do the fields of macaroni exist in Palestine or Egypt? They don't, they don’t plant it.

6- a house with black residents, red floor, green walls, what is the name of this house? A watermelon.

7- Something with big teeth and doesn't eat? A comb.

8- Where does the sea that has no water exist? On the map.

9- How many eggs does a cat lay? It doesn't lay eggs.

10- "Ashra w ashramsheshreen, wen? Essaa'aashra w ashra"(traditional statement).

11- How many ears do your mother, your father's wife and your uncle's sister have? 2 ears.

Of course the psychologist will spread an atmosphere of joy, happiness and laughter, and after every answer

he says to the participants: "well done, clap your hands for this team,…."

A closing activity:

"Now let's all stand up and form a circle, everybody hold the hand of the person standing right next to you,

get closer to each other, you are a beautiful family, you love each other.. you live in a beautiful, comforting,

safe house.. move around in the circle with your hands held together,, (soothing music) repeat with me: "if

you are happy and you know it clap your hands (and they clap their hands).. if you are happy and you know

it clap your hands (and they clap their hands).. if you are happy and you know it and you really want to show

it if you are happy and you know it clap your hands (and they clap their hands), the flower opened.. the

flower closed .. the flower opened.. the flower closed (3 times) jump 3 jumps. clap 3 times (traditional

statement)", thank you and till we meet again".

Notes:

- The sessions included some activities which may not seem appropriate for all ages, so the

psychologist has the ability to replace them with whatever activities he believes are more

appropriate for his targeted group. - The psychologists who implemented the sessions were given a special training in accordance to the

needs of the sessions.

Page 40: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

39

- Annex no. (2)

CHILD POST-TRAUMATIC STRESS REACTION INDEX

NAME _________________________________________________ AGE _______

Answer each question by placing a check mark under which describes the subject’s feelings. For the (event), be specific to the child’s experience; e.g. replace (event) with what happened to him/her. PLEASE BE SURE TO ANSWER ALL QUESTIONS

Event NONE LITTLE SOME (of the time)

MUCH MOST

1. Is (event/what happened) something that would upset, or bother, most children your age a lot?

2. Do you get scared, afraid or upset when you think about (event)?

3. Do you go over in your mind what happened- that is; do you see pictures in your mind or hear sounds in your mind about (the event)?

4. Do thoughts about (event) come back to you even when you do not want them to?

5. Do you have a good or bad dreams about (the event) or other bad dreams)?

6. Do things sometimes make you think it might happen again?

7. Do you feel as good about things you liked to do before (the event like playing with friends, sports, and school activities?

4 3 2 1 0

8. Do you feel more alone inside, or more alone with your feelings-like other people really do not understand how you feel about what you went through?

9. Do you feel scared, upset, or sad that you do not really want to know how you feel?

10. Have you felt so scared, upset, or sad that you could not even talk or cry?

11. Do you startle more easily or feel more jumpy or nervous than before (event)?

12. Do you sleep well? 4 3 2 1 0

13. Do you feel bad/guilty because you didn’t do something you wish you had done? Or if you did do something you wish you had not done? For example, to stop something from

Page 41: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip

40

happening, help someone else, or because it was not as bad for you as it was for someone else?

14. Do thoughts or feelings about what happened get in the way of remembering things, like what you learned at school or at home?

15. Is it as easy to pay attention (concentrate) as before (event)?

4 3 2 1 0

16. Do you want to stay away from things that make you remember what happened to you? (what you went through)

17. When something reminds you, or makes you think about (event) do you get tense or upset?

18. Since (event) are you doing things again that you had once stopped doing? Such as wanting to have someone near you, sleeping with someone, sucking your thumb or fingers, biting your nails or wetting the bed more often?

19. Do you have more stomach-aches, headaches, or other sick feelings since (event) than you did before?

20. Is it harder for you to keep from doing things you wouldn’t have done before? For example, getting into fights, disobeying, more riding your bike more recklessly, taking other kinds of chances, climbing on things, swearing at someone, not being careful when you cross the street or during play?

Page 42: The Effectiveness of a Proposed Guidance Program in Decreasing PTSD Reactions Among Children in the Northern Part of the Gaza Strip