8
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSIOLOGY Vol. 224, No. 4, April 1973. Prznted zri U.S.A. Thermosensitivity of medulla oblongata in control of body temperature J. M. LIPTON Psychiatry and Physiology Departments, University of Texas Southwestern Medical School, Dallas, Texas 75235 LIPTON, J. R/I. Thermosensitiuity of medulla oblongata in control of body temperature. Am. J. Physiol. 224(4): 890-897. 1973.-When the temperature of the medulla oblongata (T,) of conscious rats was altered, changes occurred in rectal temperature (T,) and in thermoregulatory behavior that were generally similar to those produced by altering the temperature of the preoptic/anterior hypothalamic (PO/AH) “thermoregulator.” In the majority of rats with thermodes implanted in the lower brainstem, manipu- lating T, for 20-min periods caused changes in T, that were proportional to brain temperature. In other animals AT, was proportional to T, except at high (41-43 C) or low (34-37 C) T, levels. Shivering occurred when T, was lowered to 34-37 C. The T, and shivering responses were unchanged after destruction of the PO/AH region. In behavioral experiments the time spent pressing a pedal to lower ambient temperature was proportional to T,. The influence of T, on this behavior was enhanced by PO/AH destruction. Similarities between effects of altering T, and Tpo/ah together with the lack of dependence of the AT, response on PO/AH mediation, enhancement of T, control over behavioral thermoregulation after PO/AH destruction, and dif- ferences in precision of control exerted by the two brain tempera- tures, suggest that medullary thermosensitivity can mediate a separate secondary control of physiological and behavioral thermoregulatory activities. physiological thermoregulation; behavioral thermoregulation; medulla oblongata; preoptic/anterior hypothalamic region; central thermal sensitivity PREVIOUS EXPERIMENTS HAVE SHOWN that not all of the central controls of body temperature are confined to the thermosensitive “temperature regulator” in the preoptic/ anterior hypothalamic (PO/AH) region. Additional con- trols must exist since a considerable capability for both physiological (2, 30,41) and behavioral (11, 32, 39) thermo- regulation survives the destruction of the PO/AH region. The failure of thermal clamps of this brain region to com- pletely and continuously determine body temperature (24) and thermoregulatory motivation (1, 20) also indicates the existence of antagonistic thermosensitive controls outside the hypothalamus. These findings raise questions about the locus and the functional characteristics of extrahypothala- mic temperature control mechanisms. If it is assumed that the control is brought about primarily by neurons that are especially sensitive to changes in local temperature, then it may be that one or more of several parts of the nervous sys- tem (9, 10, 17, 18,28,40, 44) have a role in the regulation of body temperature. One specific thermosensitive brain re- gion, the medulla oblongata, may be of particular impor- tance since the temperature of this region is known to in- fluence thermoregulatory behavior (33), the most powerful response available to the organism for combatting environ- mental thermal stress (4). The aim of the present experiments was to clarify the role of medullary thermosensitivity in thermoregulatory processes by answering two major questions. First, does the local temperature of the medulla influence the physiological control of deep-body temperature? And, after the first ques- tion was answered affirmitively, does the thermosensitivity of the medulla require mediation by the PO/AH region in order to influence physiological and behavioral thermoregu- lation? MATERIAL AND METHODS The general approach was to manipulate the temperature of the medulla (T,) by means of implanted thermodes and to record correlated changes in either the rectal tempera- ture (T,) or the thermoregulatory behavior of unanesthe- tized rats. Thermodes were placed in the lower brainstem of 72 adult male albino rats (300 g body wt). Thirty-seven of the animals were used in the d which the data described below .efinitive experimen were obtained, the pilot experiments to evaluate the techniques. ts from rest, in Thermodes and Surgery The thermodes were constructed of 18- and Z-gauge stainless steel tubing with the outer tube closed in a hemis- phere by cold welding on a lathe. Thermode temperature was sensed by a small thermistor (0.2-0.3 mm diam) ce- mented onto the exposed portion (1 mm) of the thermode tip. The rest of the thermode shaft was insulated with poly- ethylene tubing. Each rat was anesthetized with an intraperitoneal injec- tion of sodium pentobarbital (50 mg/kg) and placed in a Kopf stereotaxic instrument. Single thermodes were then implanted in the medullary region according to the coordi- nates : 0.3-l .7 mm posterior to the transverse sinus; O.O- rt 1.5 mm lateral to the midline; and 6.5-7.6 mm below the brain surface (de Groot planes (14)). Thermodes were im- planted in the forebrain, adjacent to the PO/AH region, of other rats. Dental acrylic was used to attach each thermode and the electrical connectors for the thermode thermistor to three stainless steel screws which had been driven into the cal- by 10.220.33.4 on April 23, 2017 http://ajplegacy.physiology.org/ Downloaded from

Thermosensitivity of medulla oblongata in control of body ... · medulla oblongata is sensitive to heat (3, 12, 28, 33, 42) and cold (3, 13, 33,43) and indicate that the influence

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Thermosensitivity of medulla oblongata in control of body ... · medulla oblongata is sensitive to heat (3, 12, 28, 33, 42) and cold (3, 13, 33,43) and indicate that the influence

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSIOLOGY Vol. 224, No. 4, April 1973. Prznted zri U.S.A.

Thermosensitivity of medulla oblongata in

control of body temperature

J. M. LIPTON Psychiatry and Physiology Departments, University of Texas Southwestern Medical School, Dallas, Texas 75235

LIPTON, J. R/I. Thermosensitiuity of medulla oblongata in control of body temperature. Am. J. Physiol. 224(4): 890-897. 1973.-When the temperature of the medulla oblongata (T,) of conscious rats was altered, changes occurred in rectal temperature (T,) and in thermoregulatory behavior that were generally similar to those produced by altering the temperature of the preoptic/anterior hypothalamic (PO/AH) “thermoregulator.” In the majority of rats with thermodes implanted in the lower brainstem, manipu- lating T, for 20-min periods caused changes in T, that were proportional to brain temperature. In other animals AT, was proportional to T, except at high (41-43 C) or low (34-37 C) T, levels. Shivering occurred when T, was lowered to 34-37 C. The T, and shivering responses were unchanged after destruction of the PO/AH region. In behavioral experiments the time spent pressing a pedal to lower ambient temperature was proportional to T,. The influence of T, on this behavior was enhanced by PO/AH destruction. Similarities between effects of altering T, and Tpo/ah together with the lack of dependence of the AT, response on PO/AH mediation, enhancement of T, control over behavioral thermoregulation after PO/AH destruction, and dif- ferences in precision of control exerted by the two brain tempera- tures, suggest that medullary thermosensitivity can mediate a separate secondary control of physiological and behavioral thermoregulatory activities.

physiological thermoregulation; behavioral thermoregulation; medulla oblongata; preoptic/anterior hypothalamic region; central thermal sensitivity

PREVIOUS EXPERIMENTS HAVE SHOWN that not all of the central controls of body temperature are confined to the thermosensitive “temperature regulator” in the preoptic/ anterior hypothalamic (PO/AH) region. Additional con- trols must exist since a considerable capability for both physiological (2, 30,41) and behavioral (11, 32, 39) thermo- regulation survives the destruction of the PO/AH region. The failure of thermal clamps of this brain region to com- pletely and continuously determine body temperature (24) and thermoregulatory motivation (1, 20) also indicates the existence of antagonistic thermosensitive controls outside the hypothalamus. These findings raise questions about the locus and the functional characteristics of extrahypothala- mic temperature control mechanisms. If it is assumed that the control is brought about primarily by neurons that are especially sensitive to changes in local temperature, then it may be that one or more of several parts of the nervous sys- tem (9, 10, 17, 18,28,40, 44) have a role in the regulation of body temperature. One specific thermosensitive brain re-

gion, the medulla oblongata, may be of particular impor- tance since the temperature of this region is known to in- fluence thermoregulatory behavior (33), the most powerful response available to the organism for combatting environ- mental thermal stress (4).

The aim of the present experiments was to clarify the role of medullary thermosensitivity in thermoregulatory processes by answering two major questions. First, does the local temperature of the medulla influence the physiological control of deep-body temperature? And, after the first ques- tion was answered affirmitively, does the thermosensitivity of the medulla require mediation by the PO/AH region in order to influence physiological and behavioral thermoregu- lation?

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The general approach was to manipulate the temperature of the medulla (T,) by means of implanted thermodes and to record correlated changes in either the rectal tempera- ture (T,) or the thermoregulatory behavior of unanesthe- tized rats. Thermodes were placed in the lower brainstem of 72 adult male albino rats (300 g body wt). Thirty-seven of the animals were used in the d which the data described below

.efinitive experimen were obtained, the

pilot experiments to evaluate the techniques.

ts from rest, in

Thermodes and Surgery

The thermodes were constructed of 18- and Z-gauge stainless steel tubing with the outer tube closed in a hemis- phere by cold welding on a lathe. Thermode temperature was sensed by a small thermistor (0.2-0.3 mm diam) ce- mented onto the exposed portion (1 mm) of the thermode tip. The rest of the thermode shaft was insulated with poly- ethylene tubing.

Each rat was anesthetized with an intraperitoneal injec- tion of sodium pentobarbital (50 mg/kg) and placed in a Kopf stereotaxic instrument. Single thermodes were then implanted in the medullary region according to the coordi- nates : 0.3-l .7 mm posterior to the transverse sinus; O.O- rt 1.5 mm lateral to the midline; and 6.5-7.6 mm below the brain surface (de Groot planes (14)). Thermodes were im- planted in the forebrain, adjacent to the PO/AH region, of other rats.

Dental acrylic was used to attach each thermode and the electrical connectors for the thermode thermistor to three stainless steel screws which had been driven into the cal-

by 10.220.33.4 on April 23, 2017

http://ajplegacy.physiology.org/D

ownloaded from

Page 2: Thermosensitivity of medulla oblongata in control of body ... · medulla oblongata is sensitive to heat (3, 12, 28, 33, 42) and cold (3, 13, 33,43) and indicate that the influence

THERMOSENSITIVITY OF MEDULLA OBLONGATA

varia. Benzathine penicillin G (150,000 units, im) was given to each rat immediately after surgery. Wet Purina labora- tory chow was provided during the 6- to 13-day recovery period to offset postoperative loss of body weight. Almost all animals showed an initial disturbance of motor responses and labyrinthine reflexes after surgery. The most typical postoperative symptoms were a clinging to the floor of the cage and unusual head and body orientations. The severity of the symptoms declined over time so that by the end of the recovery period most of the signs of disturbance had disap- peared.

Later in the experiments the PO/AH region was de- stroyed in selected animals. The stereotaxic coordinates used were 8.0-8.5 mm anterior to the interaural line; just lateral to the superior sagittal sinus; and 7.1-8.0 mm below the brain surface. Bilateral lesions were made by passing d-c current (2 ma) for 15 set between a stainless steel electrode in the forebrain and a steel rod inserted into the rectum.

Physiological Thermoregulation

Brain temperature was altered while the animal rested in a transparent plastic box located inside an environmental chamber controlled at 23 C. Air velocity within the plastic box was negligible. T, was recorded using a thermistor probe inserted 6 cm into the rectum and taped to the tail.

In the routine procedure brain temperature was not altered until T, had become stable (lo-40 min). There- after, brain temperature was held at randomly selected levels between 34 and 43 C for ZO-min periods by controlling the temperature of the water circulated through the ther- mode. After each thermal stimulation period, T, was al- lowed to return to base line before the next stimulation was begun. A written record of visible shivering and changes in general activity was made during each manipulation of brain temperature.

Behavioral Thermoregulation

In these experiments animals with medullary thermodes and others with PO/AH thermodes were trained to control the ambient temperature inside a clear plastic chamber by pressing and releasing a pedal (Fig. 1). The temperature of the air flowing through the chamber was 50 C before the pedal was pressed. When the pedal was operated air tem- perature rapidly dropped to 10 C. The temperature of the thermode, the air temperature inside the animal chamber, and the behavioral responses were recorded on an oscillo- graph. The time spent pressing the pedal for 10 C air was also recorded automatically on an electronic cumulative time meter. The velocity of the air flowing through the chamber, measured at 10 representative points with a heated thermocouple anemometer, averaged 0.52 m/set.

The thermal stimulation experiments were not begun until the proportion of time spent pressing the pedal for 10 C air had become consistent over training sessions for each rat. Thereafter, each thermal stimulation experiment began with an initial 30- to 70-min habituation period, during which the animal responded freely, followed by ZO-min periods in which T, or Tp+h was “clamped” at selected levels between 34 and 43 C.

891

Histblogical Analysis

The anatomical locus of every thermode placement and lesion site was determined by standard histological pro- cedures. An overdose of sodium pentobarbital was adminis- tered, and physiological saline and 10 % Formalin were per- fused through the aorta. The brain was removed and stored in Formalin or Bouin’s fluid. Serial coronal sections 40 p thick were cut from the frozen brain tissue and stained with Luxol fast blue.

The placements were reconstructed on copies of the line drawings in the stereotaxic atlas of Pellegrino and Cushman (34). The thermode tracks and the lesions were traced in by hand in accordance with enlarged images of the brain sec- tions.

RESULTS

Physiological Thermoregulation Experiments

Altering the temperature of the medulla consistently pro- duced changes in T, in 27 of the 34 animals used in these experiments. In the majority of the responsive animals, the AT, over the ZO-min thermal stimulation period was pro- portional to the T, level (Fig. 2A). The T, response to T, manipulation was, therefore, much like that observed when the temperature of the PO/AH region was altered (Fig. 20). The AT,/T,, relations of the other thermoresponsive rats

FIG. 1. Behavioral thermoregulation chamber. Chamber was located in a large temperature-controlled room (10 & 0.5 C). Ni- chrome heater coils (HC) raised temperature of air, drawn through chamber by exhaust fan (EF), to 50 C. When rat pressed response pedal (RP), heaters were turned off and air temperature at sensor (ATS) dropped to 10 C and remained at this low level as long as pedal was held down. When pedal was released, air temperature returned to 50 C.

by 10.220.33.4 on April 23, 2017

http://ajplegacy.physiology.org/D

ownloaded from

Page 3: Thermosensitivity of medulla oblongata in control of body ... · medulla oblongata is sensitive to heat (3, 12, 28, 33, 42) and cold (3, 13, 33,43) and indicate that the influence

892

.8

+.4

0 0 0

ii -.4

= 2 .8

w 1.2

’ z 16 .

2 .8

t: +.4 (r

z 0 -

iii -.4

2 .8

2 1.2

1.6

2.0 ’

A ’

0 0

0

’ 0 a 0 0 0

\ 0

0 0 0

0 0

0

MT-51

Medullary Thermode

SHIVERING v

_ MT-53

Medullary Thermode .

SHIVERING -7 0

Il~ll~lllll Lll1llllll1

34 36 38 40 42 44 34 36 38 40 42 44

THERMODE TEMPERATURE “C

FIG. 2. Changes in rectal temperature produced by altering brain temperature for 20 min in representative animals. A: a proportional relationship between T m and AT, was noted in about 56y0 of the animals with effective thermodes. B: no change in T, with medullary cooling, and a proportional decrease in T, when T, was held at neu- tral and high levels, was seen in approximately 2670 of the animals. C: in 18y0 of the animals, T, changes that were proportional to T, except at high-T, levels were obtained. D: typical proportional rela-

tion between Tpojah and changes in T,. Lines in A and C fitted by using least-squares method; in B and D, by visual inspection.

fell into two categories: those that showed no increase in T, with medullary cooling and a roughly linear decrease when T, was raised above 37-38 C (B type), and those (C type) that showed a linear relation between AT, and Tm except at high thermal stimulation values (41-43 C) where T, dropped precipitously (Fig. 2). The results confirm that the medulla oblongata is sensitive to heat (3, 12, 28, 33, 42) and cold (3, 13, 33,43) and indicate that the influence of medul- lary thermosensitivity on body temperature is similar to that of the PO/AH thermosensitivity. That is, altering the tem- perature of either brain region produces changes in body heat content similar to those which occur or tend to occur when the animal is confronted with environmental thermal stress.

These results clearly relate the thermosensitivity of the medulla to physiological thermoregulatory processes. In

Cooling Heating .

J. M. LIFTON

previous experiments on cardiovascular and respiratory re- sponses to thermal stimulation of the medulla (3, 12, 13, 28, 42, 43), the significance of the thermosensitivity of the lower brainstem to thermoregulation has been unclear. Reasons for this lack of clarity include 1) the animals used were anes- thetized or decerebrate and therefore unable to make normal thermoregulatory responses, and/or 2) their deep body tem- peratures were controlled by the experimenters. Discrepan- cies in the results of these experiments also confound possible interpretations in terms of thermoregulation.

Since shivering was observed during medullary cooling in animals that showed no change in T, (B type), T, was al- tered for longer durations in these animals to see if the failure to obtain a rise in T, was merely the result of short stimulation periods. Increasing the duration of medullary cooling (34 C) to 40-80 min did not produce consistent and lasting elevations in T, (Fig. 3). It is clear that the rate of heat loss must have increased since the rats shivered inter- mittently throughout the cooling period and yet there was no net gain in body-heat content. On the other hand, long- term heating (43 C) of the medulla produced a marked effect, driving T, down as much as 4 C. Similar decreases with medullary heating were also found in rats with A and C type records, although the rats with C type response generally showed a greater rate of fall. The effects of heating and cool- ing the medulla for longer periods of time confirm the re- sults of the short-term stimulation experiments and provide further evidence for the existence of nonproportional rela- tions between T, and AT,. It is possible that the differences in the types of AT,/T, relations result from differences in the composition of the local thermoreceptor pools stimulated by the thermodes. Guieu and Hardy (22) have listed at least 22 different types of responses of single neurons to changes in local temperature. Slight differences in the thermosensitive characteristics of the population of cells stimulated, or differences in their effector links, thus may account for the different AT,/T, patterns. There was no discernible connec- tion between the type of AT,/T, response and the neuro- anatomical loci of the thermodes.

While the effects of altering T, were, in general, similar to the effects produced by altering Tpo,ah , two major differ- ences were noted between them. First, cooling the medulla to 34-37 C caused shivering in all rats that showed con- sistent changes in T, (A, B, and C types) when T, was raised and lowered. On the other hand, shivering was seen on only one occasion during PO/AH cooling (34 C) even though T, generally rose when the temperature of this brain region was lowered. The latter result is in agreement with previous

k 37-

!ik ? 36- MT- 19 -I 35- +23 OC Ambient g y 34-

/@/WV Shivering

E ’ ’ I . I I

IO 50 100 150 200 TIME (mid

FIG. 3. Effects of long-term heating (43 C) and cooling (34 C) of medulla on rectal temperature and shivering in an animal which showed a B tyfe (Fig. 2) response to short-term (20 min) manipulations of Tm.

by 10.220.33.4 on April 23, 2017

http://ajplegacy.physiology.org/D

ownloaded from

Page 4: Thermosensitivity of medulla oblongata in control of body ... · medulla oblongata is sensitive to heat (3, 12, 28, 33, 42) and cold (3, 13, 33,43) and indicate that the influence

THERMOSENSITIVITY OF MEDULLA OBLONGATA

research on the rat (15) in which cooling of the anterior hy- pothalamus produced an increase in oxygen uptake but did not evoke shivering. Brfick and Wiinnenberg (7) have also suggested that shivering in the guinea pig is almost inde- pendent of hypothalamic temperature. However, shivering has been observed in rats l-5 min after cooling the PO/AH region to approximately 18 C (38). Taken together, the re- sults suggest that moderate cooling of the PO/AH region in the rat may activate nonshivering thermogenesis, as in the guinea pig, and that shivering is evoked only by a greater degree of cooling. It is not clear whether the dissimilarity in effects is the result of differential thresholds for the activation of shivering and nonshivering thermogenesis or whether slight differences in the location of the thermoreceptors which drive them (e.g., the thermoreceptors which influence shivering may be more laterally placed) are responsible. Since moderate cooling of the medulla caused shivering in the present experiment, it seems likely that the thermoreceptors in this brain region are more closely linked with shivering thermogenesis. The difference in the effects of moderate cooling of the medulla and of the PO/AH region in the rat may thus reflect the activation of two separate types of heat production : nonshivering thermogenesis stimulated by PO/AH cooling and shivering influenced by the tempera- ture of the medulla.

The second difference was in the variability of the re- sponse to brain temperature manipulation. While thermal stimulations of the medulla resulted in the same general AT,/T, relation from one test day to the next, the response to a specific level of thermal stimulation was not the same each time. Although this was also true for thermal stimulation of the PO/AH region, the variability in the response over time in the animals with PO/AH thermodes was consider- ably less. This difference in variability may mean that the influence on body temperature exerted by medullary ther- mosensitivity is less precise or compelling than that exerted by the thermosensitive PO/AH region.

The effects of thermal stimulation of the medulla on gen- eral activity were similar to those produced by displacing PO/AH temperatue. Raising the temperature of the medulla above normal caused quieting and relaxation much like that seen with PO/AH warming in the present and in previous (19, 27, 36, 37) experiments. Cooling the medulla produced periods of restlessness which were inter- spersed among bouts of shivering. Lowering Tpoiah produced noticeable increases in locomotor activity.

Effects of PO/AH I esions. Lesions were made in the hypo- thalamus of 20 of the rats that had shown consistent re- sponses to thermal stimulation of the medulla. The survi- vors that showed minimum postoperative sequelae and the characteristic 0.2-0.5 C rise in resting deep-body tempera- ture that is associated with destruction of the PO/AH re- gion (32) were then retested 7-10 days later according to the procedure used in the preoperative thermal stimulation tests. None of the animals showed a significant change (P > .3 1 or more) in the negative slope of the AT,/T, relation (Fig. 4) whether the lesions destroyed the PO/AH region

( n= 5), the middle hypothalamic (n = Z), or mid- and pos- terior hypothalamic structures (n = 1). Thus, the influence of T, on deep-body temperature is not mediated through

893

the PO/AH region, nor does it require the integrity of mid- hypothalamic connections.

Behavioral Thermoregulation Experiments

Heating and cooling the medulla produced changes in thermoregulatory behavior that were similar to those ob- served when the temperature of the PO/AH region was altered (Fig. 5). In all rats with effective thermodes the amount of time spent pressing for cold air was proportional to T, . These results confirm previous findings which showed that single warm (42-43 C) and cold (29-30 C) thermal stimulations of the medulla can affect thermoregulatory be- havior (33), and extend them by showing that T, and be- havioral temperature regulation are related in a more quan- titative manner. A result which was not obvious in the earlier research was that the variability in the behavioral response to repetition of a particular brain temperature manipula- tion was greater in animals with medullary thermodes than in rats with PO/AH thermodes. This result suggests that the influence on thermoregulatory motivation exerted by Tpoiah may be more precise than that exerted by T, , a conclusion which parallels the one drawn from the physiological ther- moregulation experiments.

The neuroanatomical sites where thermal stimulation of the medulla was effective in influencing behavior were within the region where local heating and cooling produced changes in T, (Fig. 6). In the rats that were tested in the physiological and in the behavioral thermoregulation ex- periments thermal stimulation of the medulla produced changes in both forms of thermoregulation or had no con- sistent influence on either form.

Efects of PO/AH I esions. Destruction of the PO/AH region by electrolysis produced a significant increase (P < .Ol or better) in the slope of the positive relation between T, and thermoregulatory behavior (Fig. 7) in three out of four rats. On the other hand, destruction posterior to the PO/AH re- gion (n = 3) did not produce changes in the behavior/T, relation (P > .45 or more). The enhancement of the rela- tion between T, and behavioral thermoregulation after PO/AH injury contrasts with the lack of change in the post- surgery A’!lYr/T, relation. This contrast suggests that the effect of the brain injury is not merely to increase the ther- mosensitivity of the medulla but to alter its significance to behavior.

DISCUSSION

The results show that the influence of the medullary thermosensitivity on body temperature and thermoregula- tory behavior is much like the influence exerted by the thermosensitivity of the PO/AH region. Judging from the parallels between these two influences, it may be that the medulla has temperature regulation functions similar to those attributed to the PO/AH thermoregulator. The idea that the medullary region has thermoregulatory capabilities was put forth earlier by researchers who believed that the lower brainstem contained a center for regulation against cold (2 1, 29, 35). It was also suggested that there are centers, located anterior and posterior to the ala cinerea in

by 10.220.33.4 on April 23, 2017

http://ajplegacy.physiology.org/D

ownloaded from

Page 5: Thermosensitivity of medulla oblongata in control of body ... · medulla oblongata is sensitive to heat (3, 12, 28, 33, 42) and cold (3, 13, 33,43) and indicate that the influence

894 J. h/I. LIPTON

MT-45 m Medullary Thermode

1 SHIVERING 1.4 7

I ‘1 ‘1 1 ’ “1 J 34 36 38 40 42 44

MT- 56 MedullaryThermode

FIG. 4. Effects of forebrain lesions on AT,/T, relation. Injury to PO/AH region (left) produced no significant change in slope of the AT,/T, regres- sion line (prelesion b = 0.08, postlesion b = 0.12). Nor did midhypothalamic damage (right) influence relation (pre- lesion b = 0.07, postlesion b = 0.09). Brain sections show site of major injury.

SHIVERING

=v I”“““”

34 36 38 40 42 44

THERMODE TEMPERATURE OC

MT-22 POT-2

MedullaryThermode PO/AH Thermode

0

I+::: . $J ; y’

/

:/

l . 9. -10 - 0

: - t ., - 0 0

5 30- 0

-

- 0 .o 0 .

= 50-

l 0

s - l

70 -

LlllllllllJ II II 11 IllI 1 34 36 38 40 42 44 34 36 38 40 42 44

THERMODE TEMPERATURE “C

FIG. 5. Comparison of effects of altering T, and Tpoiah on amount of time spent responding for cold air. Scores are changes in percent of time spent responding relative to neutral thermal stimulation (38 C). Lines fitted by using method of least squares.

the medulla, wkrose local temperature influences body tem- perature and sweating (26). Observations of shivering in re- sponse to low ambient temperature in rabbits with sections of the brainstem led Dworkin (16) to propose that

the medulla contains a subsidiary center for thermoregula- tion.

If, as the data indicate, the medullary thermosensitivity has a capability for influencing body temperature and ther- moregulatory behavior, then what is the nature of its role in overall thermoregulation? One possibility is that the medul- lary thermoreceptors normally provide subsidiary informa- tion about local temperature to the PO/AH region where it is integrated with thermal signals from other body regions to bring about the regulation of temperature within very narrow limits (24, 25). It has been suggested that the ther- moreceptors of two other extrahypothalamic regions, the mesencephalon (8), and spinal cord (23, 3 1, 45) provide such subsidiary temperature information to the PO/AH re- gion. Another possibility, not mutually exclusive with the first but perhaps more explanatory of the present results, is that the capability of the medulla to influence regulatory responses makes up a secondary temperature control. Bligh (5, 6) h as reviewed evidence for a secondary or “broad band” type of thermoregulation in modern homeotherms which is based on central thermosensitive structures in- herited from evolutionary ancestors, although it is not necessarily dependent on the thermoreceptive PO/AH re- gion. In this view the thermoresponsiveness of the medulla might play a major role in physiological and behavioral

by 10.220.33.4 on April 23, 2017

http://ajplegacy.physiology.org/D

ownloaded from

Page 6: Thermosensitivity of medulla oblongata in control of body ... · medulla oblongata is sensitive to heat (3, 12, 28, 33, 42) and cold (3, 13, 33,43) and indicate that the influence

THERMOSEl’$3ITIVITY OF MEDULLA OBLONGATA

FIG. 6. Cross-sectional drawings of lower brainstem of rat showing points where thermal stimulation produced consistent changes in T, and behavioral thermoregulation. Sites where thermal stimulation

temperature regulation when deep-body temperature de- viates beyond usual levels (in fever, heat and cold stress, and in exercise). Two findings of the present experiments, the appropriateness of medullary thermoresponsiveness to temperature homeostasis (e.g., raising T, produced de- creases in T,) and the relatively less precise influence on thermoregulatory processes exerted by T, as compared with that exerted by the Tpo,&h, might be expected if the medulla contains a secondary thermosensitive mechanism for the control of body temperature.

The persistence of the influence of medullary temperature on T, after PO/AH injury suggests that the thermorespon- siveness of the medulla has considerable survival value. It is possible that the physiological capacity to prevent deviations in body temperature which remains after PO/AH injury is mediated by the medullary temperature receptors and their extrahypothalamic links with effecters. Since the tem- perature of the medulla oblongata has been shown to in- fluence cardiovascular and respiratory responses in anes- thetized and decerebrate animals (3, 12, 13, 28, 42, 43), it may be established in future experiments that the changes in body temperature produced by altering T, in conscious

was effective were found to lie below floor of fourth ventricle between level of caudal edge of inferior colliculus and a point slightly posterior to radix nervi abducentis.

animals result from more direct links betwen the thermosen- sitive cells and the cardiovascular and respiratory centers located within this brain region. The shivering response to local cooling of the medulla was also observed after the PO/AH region was destroyed and may, therefore, depend on connections with the spinal cord rather than with dien- cephalic structures. In behavioral thermoregulation, the influence of T, does not require mediation by the PO/AH region but appears to be normally inhibited by it. It is inter- esting to note, in light of the proposal of a primitive tempera- ture regulation based on inherited central thermosensitivity (5, 6), that injury to the forebrain did not change the sig- nificance of T, to physiological thermoregulation but did enhance its significance to behavioral thermoregulation, the form of temperature control that was the most important to the precursors of the modern homeotherms.

In summary, the results indicate that the medullary thermosensitivity is capable of exerting a secondary control of body temperature that is independent of the hypothala- mic thermoregulator. It is now appropriate to ask how the thermosensitive cells in other parts of the nervous system (8,40,44) relate to the thermoresponsiveness of the medulla.

by 10.220.33.4 on April 23, 2017

http://ajplegacy.physiology.org/D

ownloaded from

Page 7: Thermosensitivity of medulla oblongata in control of body ... · medulla oblongata is sensitive to heat (3, 12, 28, 33, 42) and cold (3, 13, 33,43) and indicate that the influence

896 J. M. LIPTON

1000

2 900 v)

- nz <c 800

c3

6 700 0

z - + 600 z w e v, 500

ki t 400

MT-32 Medullary Thermode FIG. 7. Effects of forebrain lesions on

relation between medullary temperature and amount of time spent pressing a pedal for cold air. Destruction of PO/AH region (left) produced an en- hancement of slope of behavior/T, regression line (prelesion b = 30.0; postlesion b = 66.0; P < .OOl). Injury posterior to PO/AH region (right) did not cause a change in behavioral re- sponse to medullary thermal stimula- tion (prelesion b = 27.0; postlesion b = 23.2). Brain sections show sites of major injury.

Post lesion0 1-1

THERMODE TEMPERATURE “C

ADDENDUM to W. G. Clark and S. M. McCann for their comments on the manu-

While this paper was in press, Chai and Lin (J. Physiol. London 225 : 297-308, 1972) independently reported that thermal stimulation of the medulla oblongata can influence physiological thermoregula- tion in unanesthetized macaques. Their data and inferences are in agreement with several of the major ideas of the present report.

script, to W. E. Romans for bioengineering services, and to P. D. Ward of Grant Instruments Development Ltd., Cambridge, U. K., for fitting the thermistors.

This research was supported by Public Health Service Research Grant I-ROl-NS-10046-01 from the National Institute of Neuro- logical Diseases and Stroke.

The author is indebted to Patrick Dwyer for his expert assistance, Received for publication 5 September 1972.

REFERENCES

1. ADAIR, E. R., J. U. CASBY, AND J. A. J. STOLWIJK. Behavioral effector systems : temperature regulation in the squirrel monkey: changes induced

nonshivering and shivering thermogenesis. In : Physiological and Behavioral Temperature Regulation, edited by

by shifts in hypothalamic temperature. J. Camp. Physiol. Psychol. 72: 12-27, 1970.

J. D. Hardy, A. P. Gagge, and J. A. J. Stolwijk. Springfield, Ill.: Thomas, 1970, p. 562-580.

2. ANDERSSON, B., C. C. GALE, B. H~KFELT, AND B. LARSSON. Acute and chronic effects of preoptic lesions. Acta Physiol. &and. 65: 45-60, 1965.

3. BARBOUR, H. G., AND F. JELSMA. Vasomotor changes induced by the direct application of heat or cold to the medulla. Am. J.

Physiol. 97 : 503, 193 1. 4. BENZINGER, T. H. Heat regulation: homeostasis of central tem-

perature in man. Physiol. Rev. 49 : 671-759, 1969. 5. BLIGH, J. Thermosensitivity of the hypothalamus and thermo-

regulation in mammals. BioZ. Rev. Cambridge Phil. SOL 41: 3 17- 367, 1966.

8. CABANAC, M. Interaction of cold and warm temperature signals in the brainstem. In: Physiological and Behavioral Temperature Regzc- Zation, edited by J. D. Hardy, A. P. Gagge, and J. A. J. Stolwijk. Springfield, Ill. : Thomas, 1970, p. 549-561.

9. CABANAC, M., AND J. D. HARDY. RCponses unitaire et thermo- rtgulatrices lors de rechauffements et refroidissements localises de la region preoptique et du mesencephale chez le lapin. J. Physiol. Paris 6 1: 33 l-347, 1969.

6. BLIGH, J. Temperature Regulatzon in Mammals and Other Vertebrates. Amsterdam : North-Holland. In press.

7. BR~~cK, K., AND W. W~~NNENBERG. “Meshed” control of two

10. CABANAC, M., J. A. J. STOLWIJK, AND J. D. HARDY. Effect of temperature and pyrogens on single-unit activity in the rabbit’s brain stem. J. ApPZ. Physiol. 24: 645-652, 1968.

11. CARLISLE, H. Effect of preoptic and anterior hypothalamic lesions on behavioral thermoregulation in the cold. J. Comj. Physiol. Psychol. 69 : 391-402, 1969.

by 10.220.33.4 on April 23, 2017

http://ajplegacy.physiology.org/D

ownloaded from

Page 8: Thermosensitivity of medulla oblongata in control of body ... · medulla oblongata is sensitive to heat (3, 12, 28, 33, 42) and cold (3, 13, 33,43) and indicate that the influence

THERMOSENSITIVITY OF MEDULLA OBLONGATA 897

12. CHAI, C. Y., J. Y. Mu, AND J. R. BROBECK. Cardiovascular and respiratory responses from local heating of the medulla oblongata. Am. J. Physiol. 209 : 301-306, 1965.

13. CHAI, C. Y., AND S. C. WANG. Cardiovascular and respiratory responses to cooling of the medulla oblongata of the cat. Proc. Sot. ExptZ. BioZ. Med. 134: 763-767, 1970.

14. DE GROOT, J. The rat forebrain in stereotaxic coordinates. Verhandel. Koninkl. Ned. Akad. Wetenschap. Afdel. Natuurk. Sect. II:

50: l-40, 1959. 15. DONHOFFER, S., M. FARKAS, A. HAUG-LAszIA, I. JARAL, AND G.

SZEGVARI. Das Verhatten der Wtimeproduktion und der Korper- temperatur der Ratte bei lokaler Erw%rmung und Kiihling des Gehirnes. Arch. Ges. Physiol. 286 : 273-280, 1959.

16. DWORKIN, S. Observations on the central control of shivering and of heat regulation in the rabbit. Am. J. Physiol. 93 : 227-244, 1930.

17. EDINGER, H. M., AND J. S. EISENMAN. Thermosensitive neurons in tuberal and posterior hypothalamus of cats. Am. J. Physiol. 219: 1098-l 103, 1970.

18. EISENMAN, J. S., AND D. C. JACKSON. Thermal response patterns of septal and preoptic neurons in cats. Exptl. Neural. 19: 33-45, 1967.

19. FREEMAN, W. J., AND D. D. DAVIS. Effects on cats of conductive hypothalamic cooling. Am. J. Physiol. 197: 145-148, 1959.

20. GALE, C. C., M. MATHEWS, AND J. YOUNG. Behavioral thermo- regulatory responses to hypothalamic cooling and warming in baboons. Physiol. Behau. 5 : l-6, 1970.

21. GOLTZ, F. Uber die Functioner des Lendenmarks des Hundes. Arch. Ges. Physiol. 8 : 460-498, 1874.

22. GUIEU, J. D., AND J. D. HARDY. Integrative activity of preoptic units I: response to local and peripheral temperature changes. J. Physiol., Paris. 63 : 253-256, 1971.

23. GUIEU, J. D., AND J. D. HARDY. Effects of preoptic and spinal cord temperature in control of thermal polypnea. J. AppZ. Physiol. 28: 540-542, 1970.

24. HAMMEL, H. T. Regulation of internal body temperature. Ann. Rev. Physiol. 30: 641-710, 1968.

25. HARDY, J. D. Peripheral inputs into the central regulator for body

temperature. In: Advances in Climatic Physiology, edited by S. Ito, K. Ogata, and H. Yoshimura. Tokyo: Igaku Shoin, 1972, p.

3-21. 26. HASAMA, B. Pharmakologische und physiologische Studien tiber

die Schweibzentren. III Mitteilung : zur frage nach der Beein- flussung der Schweibsekretion und der Korpertemperatur durch die Medulla Oblongata. Arch. ExptZ. Pathol. Pharmakol. 153 : 257-290, 1930. ’

27. HEMINGWAY, A., T. RASMUSSEN, H. WIKOFF, AND A. T. RASMUSSEN. Effects of heating hypothalamus of dogs by diathermy. J. Neuro-

physiol. 3 : 329-338, 1940. 28. HOLMES, R. L., P. P. NEWMAN, AND J. H. WOLSTENCROFT. A heat

sensitive region in the medulla. J. Physiol, London 152 : 93-98, 1960.

29. JELSMA, F. The antagonism between the carotid and vertebral circulations with respect to the control of the heat regulating centers. Am. J. Physiol. 93 : 661, 1930.

30. KELLER, A. D., AND E. B. MCCLASKEY. Localization by the brain slicing method of the level or levels of the cephalic brainstem upon which effective heat dissipation is dependent. Am. J. Phys. Med. 43: 181-211, 1964.

31. KOSAKA, M., E. SIMON, R. THAUER, AND O.-E. WALTHER. Effect of thermal stimulation of spinal cord on respiratory and cortical activity. Am. J. Physiol. 217: 858-863, 1969.

32. LIPTON, J. M. Effects of preoptic lesions on heat escape responding and colonic temperature in the rat. Physiol. Behav. 3 : 165-169, 1968.

33. LIPTON, J. M. Behavioral temperature regulation in the rat: effects of thermal stimulation of the medulla. J. Physiol., Paris 63:

325-328, 1971. 34. PELLEGRINO, L. J., AND A. J. CUSHMAN. A Stereotaxzc Atlas of the

Rat Brain. New York : Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1967.

35. RICHET, C. Frisson comme appareil de rCgulation thermique. Mem. Sot. BioZ. 44: 896-899, 1892.

36. ROBERTS, W. W., E. H. BERGQUIST, AND T. C. L. ROBINSON. Thermoregulatory grooming and sleep-like relaxation induced by local warming of preoptic area and anterior hypothalamus in opossum. J. Camp. Physiol. Psychol. 67 : 182-l 88, 1969.

37. ROBERTS, W. W., AND T. C. L. ROBINSON. Relaxation and sleep induced by warming of preoptic region and anterior hypothalamus in cats. Exptl. Neural. 25: 282-294, 1969.

38. SATINOFF, E. Behavioral thermoregulation in response to local cooling of the rat brain. Am. J. Physiol. 206: 1389-1394, 1964.

39. SATINOFF, E., AND J. RUTSTEIN. Behavioral thermoregulation in rats with anterior hypothalamic lesions. J. Camp. Physiol. Psychol. 71: 77-82, 1970.

40. SIMON, E. Le r81e de la moelle tpiniere dans la thermoregulation. Arch. Sci. Physiol. 2 1 : 215-233, 1967.

41. SQUIRES, R. D., AND F. H. JACOBSON. Chronic deficits of tempera- ture regulation produced in cats by preoptic lesions. Am. J. Physiol. 214: 549-560, 1968.

42. TABATABAI, M. Respiratory and cardiovascular responses result- ing from heating the medulla oblongata in cats. Am. J. Physiol. 222: 1558-1564, 1972.

43. TABATABAI, M. Respiratory and cardiovascular responses resulting from cooling the medulla oblongata in cats. Am. J. Physiol. 223:

8-12, 1972. 44. THAUER, R. Thermosensitivity of the spinal cord. In : Physiological

and BehavioTaZ Temperature Regulation, edited by J. D. Hardy, A. P. Gagge, and J. A. J. Stolwijk. Springfield, Ill. : Thomas, 1970, p. 472-492.

45. W~NNENBERG, W., AND K. BR~~cK. Studies on the ascending path- ways from the thermosensitive region of the spinal cord. Arch. Ges. Physiol. 24 1 : 233-241, 1970.

by 10.220.33.4 on April 23, 2017

http://ajplegacy.physiology.org/D

ownloaded from