UY BAN NHAN DAN CONG HOA XA HOI CHU NGHlA VIET NAMTHI XA DONG XOAI Boc lap - Tir do - Hanh phi'ic

S6^4^_/JIB-U-B-Np Dong Xoai, ngayoLi thdng 11 nam 2013

t6c!L^@@' THONG BAO

Ket luan cua D/c Vuong Due Lam - Pho Chu tjch UBND thi xa

tai cuoc hop ngay 21/11/2013

Ngay 21/11/2013, tai phong hop C-UBND thi xa, D/c Virang Dire Lam-Pho Chiitich UBND thi xa chu tri nghe UBND phirong Tan Binh bao cao ket qua xet duyet ho so1dh nghi cap GCNQSDD cua ong Mai Quang Huy, ngu tai t6 1, khu ph6 Thanh Binh,

phirang Tan Binli va ket qua xac minh don cua mot so ho dan ngii tai to 2b, khu pho TanBinh, phuang Tan Binli phan anli ho ba Le Thi Thuan xay dung cong trinh nha Ian chiemduong di chung.

Thanh phan dy hop: Lanh dao cac don vi: Ban QLDA So Xay dung, Phong TNMT,Van phong DKQSD dat, Chi cue Thue, Phong QLDT, Doi QLTTDT; Chu tich UBNDphuong Tan Binli; Lanh dao va chuyen vien Van phong HDND&UBND thi xa.

Tai cuoc hop, sau khi nghe UBND phuong Tan Binh bao cao, qua y kien phat bieucua cac thanJi phan dir hop, D/c Vuang Due Lam - Pho Chii tich UBND thi xa ket luan ^nhtr sau: /s^.*

1. Ket qua duyet ho so' nghi cap GCNQSDD ciia ong Mai Quang Huy, ngu taji.*'@'#?to 1, Idiu pho Thanh Binh, phuong Tan Binli: 1' -i'. \ ^

V"A :Qua xem xet ho sa de nghi cap GCNQSDD cua ong Mai Quang Huy do UBNDV^.?11-

plurong Tan Binh trinh UBND thi xa tai To trinh sd 06/TTr -UBND ngay 30/01/2012, con '(nhieu sai sot, khong dam bao ve tinli phap ly, cu the: """

-Thu nhat, tliai gian xac dinh viec sir dung dat on dinh co mau thuan: Theo xac nhan ciiaCong an thi xa Tuyen Quang ngay 31/5/2005 thi tur ngay 17/11/2004 fro vg hxtoc ho ong Huydang l<y ho lchau thirang tru tai to 8, phuong Tan Quang, thi xa Tuyen Quang; tie sau ngay17/11/2004 ong Huy vang mat tai dia phuong, Cong an thi xa Tuyen Quang da xoa ten trong s6ho khiu g6c; Tir ngay 16/11/2001 den ht ngay 30/12/2004, ong Huy dang Icy tarn tru co thai

han tai ap Dale Xuyen, xa Dale Nhau, huyen Bu Dang; tir ngay 30/4/2004 den ngay 30/6/2005,ong Huy dang Icy tam tru co thdi han tai to 1, khu pho Thanh Binh, phuong Tan Binh; d6n ngay07/7/2005 ong Huy nhap lchau thuong tru tai to 1, ldiu pho ThanlT Binh, phuong Tan Binli (chuho khdu la ba Phgm Thi Ha - vp- ong Huy). Nhu1 vay, viec UBND phuong xac nhan ho ong Huy

nhan sang nhutmg va sir dung dat on dinli tir nam 2003 la chua chinh xac.-Thu 2, h6 so de nghi clp GCNQSDD co tay xoa.

Tir nhfrng ly do tren, UBND thi xa giao UBND phirong Tan Binh phSi hop PhongTN&MT thi xa, Van phong DKQSDD thi xa va cac ca quan co lien quan xem xet lai toanbo trinh tu, thu rue h6 so cap mai GCNQSDD ciia ho ong Huy, tham muu UBND thi xa capGCNQSDD cho ong Huy theo diing quy dinli ciia phap luat. Dong thdi to chuc kiem diemtrach nhiem doi voi cac ca nhan co lien quan trong viec de xay ra sai sot frong qua trinh xetduyet h6 so cap moi GCNQSDD cua ong Huy nhu da neu tren.

-_ UBND thi xa bieu duong Chi cue Thue thi xa da phat hien nhung sai sot trong quatrinh Idem tra ho so de nghi cap GCNQSDD cua ong Mai Quang Huy, de nghi Chi cue Thuethi xa tiep tuc phat huy trong thai gian tai.

2. Ket qua xac minh don ciia mot so ho dan ngu tai to 2b, khu pho Tan Binh,phuo'ng Tan Binh, phan anli ho ba Le Thi Thuan (ciing dia chi) xay dung congtrinh nha Ian chiem diro'ng di chung:

Qua xem xet Bao cao s6 744/BC-UBND ngay 19/11/2013 ciia UBND phirang Tan

Binh va phat bieu cua cac thanh phan du hop, D/c Vuang Due Lam - Pho Chu tichUBND thi xa co y kien nhu sau:

Tai Cong van s6 924/UBND-TD ngay 17/7/2013, UBND thi xa da giao UBNDphirang Tan Binh chii cong phoi hop Phong Quan ly do thi thi xa, Doi Quan ly trat tir dothi, phong TN&MT thi xa xem xet, giai quyet don kien nghi ciia cac ho dan (kern theodon), cu the gom 03 noi dung sau:

1.Xac minh viec cap GCNQSDD cho ba Le Thi Thuan.

2.Xu ly viec ho ba Tluian xay dung cong trinh ngan dirong thoat nuoc gay ngap ung.

3.Do dac, tra lai dirong di cho cac ho dan trong xom.

Tuy nhien, den nay UBND phuong Tan Binh bao cao thue hien xong noi dung thu 2:yeu ciu ho ba Thuan thao da phan cong trinh xay dung Ian chiem ngan dong thoat nude.Doi vai 02 noi dung con lai UBND phuong Tan Binh va cac ca quan co lien quan chiratham miru giai quyet dirt diem.

-Doi vai viec UBND phuong Tan Binh kien ngh| UBND thi xa thuan chu truong .'" :.hop thue hoa dien tich dat dirang hem theo dan ciia ba Thuan la chira co co so giai quySt. ..@ %Ly do: Nguon goc va qua trinh su dung dien tich dat dirong hem nay ciia cac ho dan chira '*@ }duoc xac minh, lam ro, mat ldiac noi dung don neu tren cua cac ho dan chua duoc giai "'quylt dut diem. @:S ,--

-De giai quyet dirt diem vu viec neu tren, UBND thi xa thong nJiat giao Thanli tra thi ^S^xa chii cong ph6i hop UBND phirang Tan Binh, Phong TN&MT thi xa, Phong QLDT thi xava Doi QLTTDT thi xa tham tra, xac minh tham miru UBND thi xa giai quyet don ghi ngay09/7/2013 cua ho ong Hoang, ong Tap, ong Hoc, ong Tuyen, ong Thiec; dong thai de xuatUBND thi xa phuong an quan ly, su dung dien tich dat dirong hem neu tren. Hoan thanhtrong thefi han 30 ngay ke tir ngay nltan dieffc don va ho sff lien quan.

-Giao UBND phuong Tan Binh chuyen toan bp ho sa lien quan cho Thanh tra thi xa

tru&c ngay 05/12/2013.

3. Ve dffn gia tliu tien su- dung dat doi vffi ho ba Nguyen Thi Nga (chdng la dngNguyln Thanh Trung) thuoc du an Quy lioach khu dan cu1 phia dong bac duong Hung

Vinnig:

Tai cuoc hop ngay 09/01/2013, do dong chi Tran Van Chung - Chu tich UBND thixa chii tri nghe UBND phuong Tin Binh bao cao ket qua xac minh dan de nghi ciia cac hodan tren dia ban, UBND phuong Tan Binh da bao cao ket qua xac minh don ciia ongNguyln Danh Phuong, thuoc dir an Quy hoach khu dan cu phia Dong Bac duong HimgVuang tai Bao cao s6 91/BC-UBND ngay 30/11/2012. Ngoai truong hap ong NguyenDanh Phuong, Chii tich UBND thi xa yeu can UBND phirang Tan Binh bao cao themnhung tnrdng hap con vuang mac, do do UBND phuong Tan Binh da bao cao them 02

truong hop (khong co van ban) g6m:Jio ba Nguyln Thi Hong Lien va ho ong NguyenThanh Trung (tuc chdng cua ba Nguyln Thi Nga) .

Theo bao cao ciia UBND phuang Tan Binh tat cuoc hop ngay 09/01/2013 neu tren thiho ong Nguyen Thanh Trung (ba Nguy in Thi Nga) bi giai toa toan bo dien tich dat de thychien dir an khu dan cir phi'a Dong Bac duong Hung Vurang, dat co GCNQSDD, tren dltco nha, gia dinh ong Trung kho khan v< dat a. Tren ca sa bao cao ciia UBND phuangTan Binh va y kien cua cac thanh phan dir hop, d/c Tran Van Chung - Chu tich UBNDthi xa da thong nhat ban cho ho ong Trung (ba Nga) 14 16 dat TDC tai cho theo dan giachinh sach cua dir an tai Thong bao so 16/TB-UBND ngay 11/01/2013 cua UBND thi xa.Thuc hien ket luan neu tren, UBND phuang Tan Binh da ph6i hap voi Van phongHDND&UBND thi xa tham mun UBND thi xa ban hanh Quylt dinh so 2963/QD-UBNDngay 26/9/2013 giao dat TDC cho ho ba Nguyen Thi Nga.

Tuy nliien, tai cuoc hop nay (ngay 21/11/2013), qua xem xet bien ban xac dinh giatri den bu ngay 12/3/2009 doi voi ho ong Trung va y kien ciia dai dien lanh dao BQLDASo Xay dung (chu ddu tie) thi ho ong Trung (ba Nga) co 300m2 dat nong nghiep, dat coGCNQSDD bi giai toa thuoc dir an Quy hoach Ichu dan cu phia dong bac duong HiingVirang, tai tho'i diem lap bien ban xac dinh gia tri den bu, hien trang tren dlt lchong conha nen khong the hien trong ho so den bu. Nhu vay, viec UBND phuang Tan Binli baocao ho ong Nguyen Thanh Trung bj giai toa toan bo dien tich dat de thirc hien dir an khudan cir phia Dong Bac duong Hung Virang, dat co GCNQSDD, tren dat co nha tai cuochop ngay 09/01/2013 la khong chinh xac va ho ong Trung (ba Nga) khong du dieu kiend8 du'oc giao dk TDC theo dien chinh sach dir an. Vi vay, UBND thi xa thong nhathhutign sir dung dlt ho ong Trung (ba Nga) theo don gia hien hanh tai thoi diem nop tien^s&-dung dat. ;_-.|

-Giao Van phong HDND va UBND thi xa ph6i hop vai cac ca quan lien quan thaiiimuii UBND thi xa ban hanh quyet dinh dieu chinh Khoan 4, Dieu 1, Quyet dinljXo2963/QD-UBND ngay 26/9/2013 v6 viec giao dat TDC cho ho ba Nguyln Th| Nga, trongdo quy dinh ho ba Nga nop tien sir dung dat theo don gia hien hanh tai thai diem nop tidn

sir dung dat.

-Yeu cau UBND phuang Tan Binh nghiem tuc rut kinli nghiem trong viec thammuu xet giao dat TDC cac du an tren dia ban phuang.

Tren day la ket luan ciia D/c Vurang Dire Lam - Pho Chu tich UBND thi xa taicuoc hop neu tren, UBND thi xa thong bao d6n cac co quan, dan vi lien quan bik va thyc

hien./.

Noinhan: TL.CHU TICHTTThjlly. KT. CHANH VAN PHONG

-CT, cac PCT HDND-UBND TX; ^^fUp CHANH VAN PHONG-Thanh phan dir hop; /@^-'@ 'ntus- ''\ \

Thanh tra thj xa; /@ ?/ -l^fe^A /] I-LDVP, CV: TD, NC, KT, CCHC; I:@@?; % #i W\ V/ /)\ ^^~~~

Y-U@ \ :\ J^^Ji^/ il] I / 1 1 1 /

yCeaiig (&/um %'u